Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0604125 · Physical Review A

Comment on “Quantum direct communication with authentication”

Zhanjun Zhang, Jun Liu, Dong Wang, Shi Shou-Hua

Published Feb 23, 2007• 118 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Two protocols of quantum direct communication with authentication [Phys. Rev. A 73, 042305 (2006)] were recently proposed by Lee, Lim, and Yang. In this paper we will show that in the two protocols the authenticator Trent should be prevented from knowing the secret message. The first protocol can be eavesdropped on by Trent using the intercept-measure-resend attack, while the second protocol can be eavesdropped on by Trent using a simple single-qubit measurement. To fix these leaks, we revise the original versions of the protocols by using the Pauli $Z$ operation ${\ensuremath{\sigma}}_{z}$ instead of the original bit-flip operation $X$. As a consequence, the attacks we present can be prevented and accordingly the protocol securities are improved.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.75.026301

Related papers

Revisiting Quantum Secure Direct Communication with W State

Jun Liu, Liu Yi-Min, Hai-Jing Cao +2 more

The quantum secure direct communication protocol recently proposed by Cao and Song [Chin. Phys. Lett. 23 (2006) 290] (i.e., the C-S QSDC protocol) is revisited. A security leak is pointed out. Taking advantage of this leak, an eavesdropper may adopt the intercept–measure–resend strategy to attack the quantum channel such that in the C-S QSDC protocol the secret message can be completely eavesdropped. To fix the leak, the original version of the C-S QSDC protocol is revised. As a consequence, the security is improved and assured at least in the case of an ideal quantum channel.

Chinese Physics Letters•Sep 27, 2006•42 citations

High Efficiency of Two Efficient QSDC with Authentication Is at the Cost of Their Security

Qin Su-Juan, Wen Qiao-yan, Luoming Meng +1 more

Two efficient protocols of quantum secure direct communication with authentication [Chin. Phys. Lett. 25 (2008) 2354] were recently proposed by Liu et al. to improve the efficiency of two protocols presented in [Phys. Rev. A 75 (2007) 026301] by four Pauli operations. We show that the high efficiency of the two protocols is at the expense of their security. The authenticator Trent can reach half the secret by a particular attack strategy in the first protocol. In the second protocol, not only Trent but also an eavesdropper outside can elicit half-information about the secret from the public declaration.

Chinese Physics Letters•Feb 1, 2009•13 citations

Efficient quantum secure direct communication with authentication

Wen Liu, Hanwu Chen, Zhi-giang Li +2 more

Two protocols of quantum direct communication with authentication [Phys. Rev. A 73, 042305(2006)], proposed by Lee, Lim and Yang, recently were indicated to be insecure against the authenticator Trentpsilas attacks [Phys. Rev. A 75, 026301(2007)]. In this paper, two novel efficient protocols of quantum direct communication with authentication are presented by utilizing four kinds of Pauli operations (I, sigmax, isigmay, sigmaz). These new protocols can transmit two bits message every GHZ state, instead of one bit in the aforementioned protocols. Analysis shows that they are secure against the inner participantpsilas attacks (such as Trentpsilas attacks) as well as the outer Evepsilas attacks. Finally, we generalize them to multiparty quantum direction communication.

IEEE Congress on Evolutionary Computation (CEC)•Jun 1, 2008•12 citations

Efficient Quantum Secure Direct Communication with Authentication

Wenjie Liu, Hanwu Chen, Zhiqiang Li +1 more

Two protocols of quantum direct communication with authentication [Phys. Rev. A 73 (2006) 042305] were recently indicated to be insecure against the authenticator Trent attacks [Phys. Rev. A 75 (2007) 026301]. We present two efficient protocols by using four Pauli operations, which are secure against inner Trent attacks as well as outer Eve attacks. Finally we generalize them to multiparty quantum direction communication.

arXiv:0711.3502•Chinese Physics Letters•Jul 1, 2008•40 citations

Improvement of Security of Three-Party Quantum Secure Direct Communication Based on GHZ States

Man Zhong-Xiao, Yun‐Jie Xia

A protocol for three-party quantum secure direct communication based on Greenberger–Horne–Zeilinger (GHZ) states was recently proposed by Jin et al. [Phys. Lett. A 354 (2006) 67] By analysing the protocol we find some security loopholes, e.g. one bit of secret messages of a party (Alice in the original paper) can always be leaked straight to the public without any eavesdropping. These problems suggested previously are discussed and possible solutions are presented to improve the security of the original protocol.

Chinese Physics Letters•Jan 1, 2007•75 citations

Revised Quantum Direct Communication Scheme with Mutual Authentication

Wenjie Liu, Hanwu Chen, Juan Xu +1 more

Based on mutual authentication and dense coding, a novel revised efficient quantum direct communication scheme is proposed. It is composed of two phases: the quantum state distribution process and the direct communication process. The purpose of the former is to authenticate Trent and users to each other, and let the two legitimate users (Alice and Bob) safely share the Bell states. While the latter aims to make direct communication to transmit a secret message between Alice and Bob. In order to prevent from Eve's eavesdropping as well as to authenticate each other simultaneously, a decoy photon checking technique is applied. Compared with other analogous protocols, the quantum state distribution process is more simple and feasible and the proposed scheme is more efficient; i.e., the total efficiency is almost 100%. Security analysis shows that the proposed scheme is secure against the eavesdropping attacks, the impersonation attacks, and some special Trent's attacks, including the attacks by using different initial states.

Journal of Southeast University•Dec 30, 2010•1 citation
Two protocols of quantum direct communication with authentication [Phys. Rev. A 73, 042305 (2006)] were recently proposed by Lee, Lim, and Yang. In this paper we will show that in the two protocols the authenticator Trent should be prevented from knowing the secret message. The first protocol can be eavesdropped on by Trent using the intercept-measure-resend attack, while the second protocol can be eavesdropped on by Trent using a simple single-qubit measurement. To fix these leaks, we revise the original versions of the protocols by using the Pauli ZZZ operation \ensuremathσz{\ensuremath{\sigma}}_{z}\ensuremathσz​ instead of the original bit-flip operation XXX. As a consequence, the attacks we present can be prevented and accordingly the protocol securities are improved.
The quantum secure direct communication protocol recently proposed by Cao and Song [Chin. Phys. Lett. 23 (2006) 290] (i.e., the C-S QSDC protocol) is revisited. A security leak is pointed out. Taking advantage of this leak, an eavesdropper may adopt the intercept–measure–resend strategy to attack the quantum channel such that in the C-S QSDC protocol the secret message can be completely eavesdropped. To fix the leak, the original version of the C-S QSDC protocol is revised. As a consequence, the security is improved and assured at least in the case of an ideal quantum channel.
Two efficient protocols of quantum secure direct communication with authentication [Chin. Phys. Lett. 25 (2008) 2354] were recently proposed by Liu et al. to improve the efficiency of two protocols presented in [Phys. Rev. A 75 (2007) 026301] by four Pauli operations. We show that the high efficiency of the two protocols is at the expense of their security. The authenticator Trent can reach half the secret by a particular attack strategy in the first protocol. In the second protocol, not only Trent but also an eavesdropper outside can elicit half-information about the secret from the public declaration.
Two protocols of quantum direct communication with authentication [Phys. Rev. A 73, 042305(2006)], proposed by Lee, Lim and Yang, recently were indicated to be insecure against the authenticator Trentpsilas attacks [Phys. Rev. A 75, 026301(2007)]. In this paper, two novel efficient protocols of quantum direct communication with authentication are presented by utilizing four kinds of Pauli operations (I, sigmax, isigmay, sigmaz). These new protocols can transmit two bits message every GHZ state, instead of one bit in the aforementioned protocols. Analysis shows that they are secure against the inner participantpsilas attacks (such as Trentpsilas attacks) as well as the outer Evepsilas attacks. Finally, we generalize them to multiparty quantum direction communication.
A protocol for three-party quantum secure direct communication based on Greenberger–Horne–Zeilinger (GHZ) states was recently proposed by Jin et al. [Phys. Lett. A 354 (2006) 67] By analysing the protocol we find some security loopholes, e.g. one bit of secret messages of a party (Alice in the original paper) can always be leaked straight to the public without any eavesdropping. These problems suggested previously are discussed and possible solutions are presented to improve the security of the original protocol.
Based on mutual authentication and dense coding, a novel revised efficient quantum direct communication scheme is proposed. It is composed of two phases: the quantum state distribution process and the direct communication process. The purpose of the former is to authenticate Trent and users to each other, and let the two legitimate users (Alice and Bob) safely share the Bell states. While the latter aims to make direct communication to transmit a secret message between Alice and Bob. In order to prevent from Eve's eavesdropping as well as to authenticate each other simultaneously, a decoy photon checking technique is applied. Compared with other analogous protocols, the quantum state distribution process is more simple and feasible and the proposed scheme is more efficient; i.e., the total efficiency is almost 100%. Security analysis shows that the proposed scheme is secure against the eavesdropping attacks, the impersonation attacks, and some special Trent's attacks, including the attacks by using different initial states.