Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2112.08457 · IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity

Mutual and Self-Inductance in Planarized Multilayered Superconductor Integrated Circuits: Microstrips, Striplines, Bends, Meanders, Ground Plane Perforations

Sergey K. Tolpygo, Evan B. Golden, Terence J. Weir, Vladimir Bolkhovsky

Published Mar 28, 2022• 23 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Data are presented on mutual and self-inductance of various inductors used in multilayered superconductor integrated circuits: microstrips and striplines with widths from 250 nm to a few micrometers, located on the same layer at various distances from each other, from 250 nm to a few micrometers, and/or on different layers spaced vertically; effect of long slits in the ground plane(s) along the inductors on their mutual inductance; inductance of right-angled bends; and inductance of meanders. Measurements were done using circuits fabricated in the SFQ5ee and the SC1 fully planarized fabrication processes with eight niobium layers and Nb/Al-AlOx/Nb Josephson junctions, developed at MIT Lincoln Laboratory for superconductor electronics. Simple analytical expressions for mutual and self-inductance of the basic inductors are given, describing experimental data with accuracy better than 2% over a very wide range of parameters. Mutual coupling between microstrips is long-ranged and decreases as a second power of distance between them, making microstrips unsuitable for very large scale integrated circuits. Mutual inductance of striplines decreases exponentially with distance between them on a scale of$({\boldsymbol{H}} + 2{\boldsymbol{\lambda }})/{\boldsymbol{\pi }}$∼ 0.3 μm, where${\boldsymbol{H}}$and${\boldsymbol{\lambda }}$are, respectively, the distance between and magnetic field penetration depth in superconducting ground planes, whereas superconducting properties of the signal traces are practically irrelevant. This decay distance determines the scale of integration above which adjacent inductors in a circuit become strongly coupled. Dependence of mutual inductance on the linewidth of wires is weak. As a result, the area of flux transformers—an essential component of all superconductor digital circuits using ac power, qubits, and sensor arrays—scales poorly with the linewidth, potentially restricting scalability of the circuits.

DOI
10.1109/tasc.2022.3162758

Related papers

Self- and Mutual Inductance of NbN and Bilayer NbN/Nb Inductors in a Planarized Fabrication Process With Nb Ground Planes

Sergey K. Tolpygo, Evan B. Golden, Terence J. Weir +2 more

We present measurements of the self- and mutual inductance of NbN and NbN/Nb bilayer inductors (microstrips, striplines, serpentines, etc.) with Nb ground plane(s) fabricated in an advanced process for superconductor electronics developed at MIT Lincoln Laboratory. In this process, the signal traces of logic cell inductors are made either of a 200-nm NbN layer with${{\bm{T}}}_{\bm{c}} \approx $15.5 K or an in-situ deposited NbN/Nb bilayer, replacing a 200-nm Nb layer M6 in the standard SFQ5ee process with nine superconducting layers on 200-mm wafers. Nb ground planes are preserved to maintain a high level of interlayer shielding and low intralayer mutual coupling. A two-step patterning of the top Nb and the bottom NbN layers of the NbN/Nb bilayer allows the creation of inductors with a very wide range of inductances, from low values ∼0.4 pH/μm typical for Nb geometrical inductors to ∼35 pH/μm typical for thin-film kinetic inductors. The mutual inductance of various combinations of NbN, Nb, and NbN/Nb inductors does not depend on superconducting properties of the signal traces in the studied range of linewidths,${\bm{w}}$; it equals the mutual inductance of the Nb inductors with the equivalent geometry and placement between the ground planes. The measured magnetic field penetration depth in NbN films deposited by reactive sputtering at 200 °C isλNbN= 491 ± 5 nm. The measured kinetic inductance of the films with thicknesses${\bm{t}}\ = {\bm{\ }}$200 nm and 150 nm, respectively 1.51 pH/sq and 2.06 pH/sq, is larger than that expected for conventional superconductors with short mean free path, corresponding to about 25% lower superfluid density. We also measured kinetic inductance of the right-angle bends of NbN striplines and found it to be negligible at${\bm{w}} < {\bm{\lambda }}_{{\bm{NbN}}}^2/{\bm{t}}$, indicating an insignificant effect of current crowding in the presence of superconducting ground plane(s). Implementing NbN and NbN/Nb kinetic inductors enables a significant increase in the integration scale of superconductor digital electronics.

arXiv:2210.10705•IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity•Feb 14, 2023•12 citations

Inductance of superconductor integrated circuit features with sizes down to 120 nm

Sergey K. Tolpygo, Evan B. Golden, Terence J. Weir +1 more

Abstract Data are presented on the inductance of various features used in superconductor digital integrated circuits: microstrip and stripline inductors with linewidths down to 120 nm and different combinations of ground plane layers, effect of perforations of various sizes in the ground planes and their distance to the inductors on inductance, inductance of vias of various sizes between adjacent layers, inductance of composite vias between distant superconducting layers. Test circuits used for the measurements were fabricated in a new 150 nm node of a fully planarized process with eight niobium layers developed at MIT Lincoln Laboratory for superconductor electronics as well as in our standard SFQ5ee and SC1 fabrication processes with 250 nm minimum feature size. The new SC2 process utilizes 193 nm photolithography in combination with plasma etching and chemical mechanical planarization of interlayer dielectrics to define inductors with linewidth down to about 100 nm on critical layers. The standard processes use 248 nm photolithography. The measured data are compared with the results of inductance extraction using software packages InductEx and wxLC. Variations of circuit inductors caused by the fabrication processes are discussed. Magnetic flux trapping in ground plane moats and its coupling to nearby inductors are discussed for circuit cooling in a residual field of several configurations.

arXiv:2101.07457•Superconductor Science and Technology•May 25, 2021•47 citations

Inductance of Circuit Structures for MIT LL Superconductor Electronics Fabrication Process With 8 Niobium Layers

Sergey K. Tolpygo, Vladimir Bolkhovsky, Terence J. Weir +4 more

Inductance of superconducting thin-film inductors and structures with linewidth down to 250 nm has been experimentally evaluated. The inductors include various striplines and microstrips, their 90° bends and meanders, interlayer vias, etc., typically used in superconducting digital circuits. The circuits have been fabricated by a fully planarized process with 8 niobium layers, developed at MIT Lincoln Laboratory for very-large-scale superconducting integrated circuits. Excellent run-to-run reproducibility and inductance uniformity of better than 1% across 200-mm wafers have been found. It has been found that the inductance per unit length of stripline and microstrip line inductors continues to grow as the inductor linewidth is reduced deep into the submicron range to the widths comparable to the film thickness and magnetic field penetration depth. It is shown that the linewidth reduction does not lead to widening of the parameter spread due to diminishing sensitivity of the inductance to the linewidth and dielectric thickness. The experimental results were compared with numeric inductance extraction using commercial software and freeware, and a good agreement was found for 3-D inductance extractors. Methods of further miniaturization of circuit inductors for achieving circuit densities> 106Josephson junctions per cm2are discussed.

arXiv:1408.5828•IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity•Nov 24, 2014•96 citations

Developments toward a 250-nm, Fully Planarized Fabrication Process with Ten Superconducting Layers and Self-Shunted Josephson Junctions

Sergey K. Tolpygo, Vladimir Bolkhovsky, Ravi Rastogi +5 more

We are developing a superconductor electronics fabrication process with up to nine planarized superconducting layers, stackable stud vias, self-shunted Nb/AlOx-Al/Nb Josephson junctions, and one layer of MoNx kinetic inductors. The minimum feature size of resistors and inductors in the process is 250 nm. We present data on the mutual inductance of Nb stripline and microstrip inductors with linewidth and spacing from 250 nm to 1 μm made on the same or adjacent Nb layers, as well as the data on the linewidth and resistance uniformity.

arXiv:1704.07683•IEEE International Superconductive Electronics Conference (ISEC)•Jun 1, 2017•15 citations

Scalability of Superconductor Electronics: Limitations Imposed by AC Clock and Flux Bias Transformers

Sergey K. Tolpygo

Flux transformers are the necessary component of all superconductor digital integrated circuits utilizing flux biasing and ac power excitation and clocking of logic cells, e.g., adiabatic quantum flux parametron (AQFP), reciprocal quantum logic (RQL), superconducting sensor arrays, qubits, etc. On average, one transformer is required per one Josephson junction. We consider limitations to the integration scale (device number density) imposed by the critical current of the ac power transmission lines (primary of the transformers) and cross-coupling between the adjacent transformers. The former sets the minimum linewidth and the mutual coupling length in the transformer, whereas the latter sets the minimum spacing between the transformers. Decreasing linewidth of superconducting (Nb) wires increases kinetic inductance of the transformer's secondary, decreasing its length and mutual coupling to the primary. This limits the minimum size. As a result, there is a minimum linewidth${{\boldsymbol{w}}}_{\mathbf{min}}\sim $100 nm, which determines the maximum achievable scale of integration. Using AQFP circuits as an example, we calculate dependences of the AQFP number density on linewidth for various types of microstrip-based and stripline-based transformers and inductors available in the SFQ5ee fabrication process developed at MIT Lincoln Laboratory, and estimate the maximum circuit density as a few million AQFPs per cm2. We propose an advanced fabrication process for a 10× increase in the density of AQFP and other ac-powered circuits. In this process, inductors are formed from a patterned bilayer of a geometrical inductance material, Nb, deposited over a layer of high kinetic inductance material, e.g., NbN. Individual pattering of the bilayer layers allows to create stripline inductors in a wide range of inductances, from the low values typical to Nb striplines to the high values typical for NbN thin films, and preserve sufficient mutual coupling in stripline transformers with extremely low cross-talk. Energy efficiency of ac-powered circuits is limited by dielectric losses in the ac power transmissions lines. Problems of scaling associated with multiphase ac power distribution are discussed.

arXiv:2210.02632•IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity•Dec 19, 2022•11 citations

Layout Strategies for Connecting Multiple Superconducting Ground Planes with Ground Pillars

Kyle Jackman, Coenrad Johann Fourie

Several advances have been made towards increasing the number of Niobium layers for superconductor integrated circuits. Fabrication processes, such as the MIT Lincoln Laboratory SFQ5ee process and the CRAVITY-AIST process, now provide eight or more Niobium layers. The additional superconducting layers significantly increase the space available for routing between and within cells. However, striplines must now be routed through multiple ground planes to efficiently utilize all available metal layers. This can lead to large mutual inductance between signal lines, especially when ground pillars are used to connect ground planes. The placement of these ground pillars become crucial. In this work, we use numerical software to analyze the effects of striplines transitioning through multiple ground planes and how the location of ground pillars influence the mutual inductance between lines and show that careful layout considerations are required for modern circuits with dense layouts. We also present layout improvement strategies to mitigate or lessen the negative effects of these mutual inductance on circuit operation.

IEEE International Superconductive Electronics Conference (ISEC)•Jul 1, 2019•0 citations
Data are presented on mutual and self-inductance of various inductors used in multilayered superconductor integrated circuits: microstrips and striplines with widths from 250 nm to a few micrometers, located on the same layer at various distances from each other, from 250 nm to a few micrometers, and/or on different layers spaced vertically; effect of long slits in the ground plane(s) along the inductors on their mutual inductance; inductance of right-angled bends; and inductance of meanders. Measurements were done using circuits fabricated in the SFQ5ee and the SC1 fully planarized fabrication processes with eight niobium layers and Nb/Al-AlOx/Nb Josephson junctions, developed at MIT Lincoln Laboratory for superconductor electronics. Simple analytical expressions for mutual and self-inductance of the basic inductors are given, describing experimental data with accuracy better than 2% over a very wide range of parameters. Mutual coupling between microstrips is long-ranged and decreases as a second power of distance between them, making microstrips unsuitable for very large scale integrated circuits. Mutual inductance of striplines decreases exponentially with distance between them on a scale of(H+2λ)/π({\boldsymbol{H}} + 2{\boldsymbol{\lambda }})/{\boldsymbol{\pi }}(H+2λ)/π∼ 0.3 μm, whereH{\boldsymbol{H}}Handλ{\boldsymbol{\lambda }}λare, respectively, the distance between and magnetic field penetration depth in superconducting ground planes, whereas superconducting properties of the signal traces are practically irrelevant. This decay distance determines the scale of integration above which adjacent inductors in a circuit become strongly coupled. Dependence of mutual inductance on the linewidth of wires is weak. As a result, the area of flux transformers—an essential component of all superconductor digital circuits using ac power, qubits, and sensor arrays—scales poorly with the linewidth, potentially restricting scalability of the circuits.
We present measurements of the self- and mutual inductance of NbN and NbN/Nb bilayer inductors (microstrips, striplines, serpentines, etc.) with Nb ground plane(s) fabricated in an advanced process for superconductor electronics developed at MIT Lincoln Laboratory. In this process, the signal traces of logic cell inductors are made either of a 200-nm NbN layer with${{\bm{T}}}_{\bm{c}} \approx 15.5Koranin−situdepositedNbN/Nbbilayer,replacinga200−nmNblayerM6inthestandardSFQ5eeprocesswithninesuperconductinglayerson200−mmwafers.Nbgroundplanesarepreservedtomaintainahighlevelofinterlayershieldingandlowintralayermutualcoupling.Atwo−steppatterningofthetopNbandthebottomNbNlayersoftheNbN/Nbbilayerallowsthecreationofinductorswithaverywiderangeofinductances,fromlowvalues∼0.4pH/μmtypicalforNbgeometricalinductorsto∼35pH/μmtypicalforthin−filmkineticinductors.ThemutualinductanceofvariouscombinationsofNbN,Nb,andNbN/Nbinductorsdoesnotdependonsuperconductingpropertiesofthesignaltracesinthestudiedrangeoflinewidths,15.5 K or an in-situ deposited NbN/Nb bilayer, replacing a 200-nm Nb layer M6 in the standard SFQ5ee process with nine superconducting layers on 200-mm wafers. Nb ground planes are preserved to maintain a high level of interlayer shielding and low intralayer mutual coupling. A two-step patterning of the top Nb and the bottom NbN layers of the NbN/Nb bilayer allows the creation of inductors with a very wide range of inductances, from low values ∼0.4 pH/μm typical for Nb geometrical inductors to ∼35 pH/μm typical for thin-film kinetic inductors. The mutual inductance of various combinations of NbN, Nb, and NbN/Nb inductors does not depend on superconducting properties of the signal traces in the studied range of linewidths,15.5Koranin−situdepositedNbN/Nbbilayer,replacinga200−nmNblayerM6inthestandardSFQ5eeprocesswithninesuperconductinglayerson200−mmwafers.Nbgroundplanesarepreservedtomaintainahighlevelofinterlayershieldingandlowintralayermutualcoupling.Atwo−steppatterningofthetopNbandthebottomNbNlayersoftheNbN/Nbbilayerallowsthecreationofinductorswithaverywiderangeofinductances,fromlowvalues∼0.4pH/μmtypicalforNbgeometricalinductorsto∼35pH/μmtypicalforthin−filmkineticinductors.ThemutualinductanceofvariouscombinationsofNbN,Nb,andNbN/Nbinductorsdoesnotdependonsuperconductingpropertiesofthesignaltracesinthestudiedrangeoflinewidths,{\bm{w}};itequalsthemutualinductanceoftheNbinductorswiththeequivalentgeometryandplacementbetweenthegroundplanes.ThemeasuredmagneticfieldpenetrationdepthinNbNfilmsdepositedbyreactivesputteringat200°CisλNbN=491±5nm.Themeasuredkineticinductanceofthefilmswiththicknesses; it equals the mutual inductance of the Nb inductors with the equivalent geometry and placement between the ground planes. The measured magnetic field penetration depth in NbN films deposited by reactive sputtering at 200 °C isλNbN= 491 ± 5 nm. The measured kinetic inductance of the films with thicknesses;itequalsthemutualinductanceoftheNbinductorswiththeequivalentgeometryandplacementbetweenthegroundplanes.ThemeasuredmagneticfieldpenetrationdepthinNbNfilmsdepositedbyreactivesputteringat200°CisλNbN=491±5nm.Themeasuredkineticinductanceofthefilmswiththicknesses{\bm{t}}\ = {\bm{\ }}200nmand150nm,respectively1.51pH/sqand2.06pH/sq,islargerthanthatexpectedforconventionalsuperconductorswithshortmeanfreepath,correspondingtoabout25200 nm and 150 nm, respectively 1.51 pH/sq and 2.06 pH/sq, is larger than that expected for conventional superconductors with short mean free path, corresponding to about 25% lower superfluid density. We also measured kinetic inductance of the right-angle bends of NbN striplines and found it to be negligible at200nmand150nm,respectively1.51pH/sqand2.06pH/sq,islargerthanthatexpectedforconventionalsuperconductorswithshortmeanfreepath,correspondingtoabout25{\bm{w}} < {\bm{\lambda }}_{{\bm{NbN}}}^2/{\bm{t}}$, indicating an insignificant effect of current crowding in the presence of superconducting ground plane(s). Implementing NbN and NbN/Nb kinetic inductors enables a significant increase in the integration scale of superconductor digital electronics.
Abstract Data are presented on the inductance of various features used in superconductor digital integrated circuits: microstrip and stripline inductors with linewidths down to 120 nm and different combinations of ground plane layers, effect of perforations of various sizes in the ground planes and their distance to the inductors on inductance, inductance of vias of various sizes between adjacent layers, inductance of composite vias between distant superconducting layers. Test circuits used for the measurements were fabricated in a new 150 nm node of a fully planarized process with eight niobium layers developed at MIT Lincoln Laboratory for superconductor electronics as well as in our standard SFQ5ee and SC1 fabrication processes with 250 nm minimum feature size. The new SC2 process utilizes 193 nm photolithography in combination with plasma etching and chemical mechanical planarization of interlayer dielectrics to define inductors with linewidth down to about 100 nm on critical layers. The standard processes use 248 nm photolithography. The measured data are compared with the results of inductance extraction using software packages InductEx and wxLC. Variations of circuit inductors caused by the fabrication processes are discussed. Magnetic flux trapping in ground plane moats and its coupling to nearby inductors are discussed for circuit cooling in a residual field of several configurations.
Inductance of superconducting thin-film inductors and structures with linewidth down to 250 nm has been experimentally evaluated. The inductors include various striplines and microstrips, their 90° bends and meanders, interlayer vias, etc., typically used in superconducting digital circuits. The circuits have been fabricated by a fully planarized process with 8 niobium layers, developed at MIT Lincoln Laboratory for very-large-scale superconducting integrated circuits. Excellent run-to-run reproducibility and inductance uniformity of better than 1% across 200-mm wafers have been found. It has been found that the inductance per unit length of stripline and microstrip line inductors continues to grow as the inductor linewidth is reduced deep into the submicron range to the widths comparable to the film thickness and magnetic field penetration depth. It is shown that the linewidth reduction does not lead to widening of the parameter spread due to diminishing sensitivity of the inductance to the linewidth and dielectric thickness. The experimental results were compared with numeric inductance extraction using commercial software and freeware, and a good agreement was found for 3-D inductance extractors. Methods of further miniaturization of circuit inductors for achieving circuit densities> 106Josephson junctions per cm2are discussed.
We are developing a superconductor electronics fabrication process with up to nine planarized superconducting layers, stackable stud vias, self-shunted Nb/AlOx-Al/Nb Josephson junctions, and one layer of MoNx kinetic inductors. The minimum feature size of resistors and inductors in the process is 250 nm. We present data on the mutual inductance of Nb stripline and microstrip inductors with linewidth and spacing from 250 nm to 1 μm made on the same or adjacent Nb layers, as well as the data on the linewidth and resistance uniformity.
Flux transformers are the necessary component of all superconductor digital integrated circuits utilizing flux biasing and ac power excitation and clocking of logic cells, e.g., adiabatic quantum flux parametron (AQFP), reciprocal quantum logic (RQL), superconducting sensor arrays, qubits, etc. On average, one transformer is required per one Josephson junction. We consider limitations to the integration scale (device number density) imposed by the critical current of the ac power transmission lines (primary of the transformers) and cross-coupling between the adjacent transformers. The former sets the minimum linewidth and the mutual coupling length in the transformer, whereas the latter sets the minimum spacing between the transformers. Decreasing linewidth of superconducting (Nb) wires increases kinetic inductance of the transformer's secondary, decreasing its length and mutual coupling to the primary. This limits the minimum size. As a result, there is a minimum linewidth${{\boldsymbol{w}}}_{\mathbf{min}}\sim $100 nm, which determines the maximum achievable scale of integration. Using AQFP circuits as an example, we calculate dependences of the AQFP number density on linewidth for various types of microstrip-based and stripline-based transformers and inductors available in the SFQ5ee fabrication process developed at MIT Lincoln Laboratory, and estimate the maximum circuit density as a few million AQFPs per cm2. We propose an advanced fabrication process for a 10× increase in the density of AQFP and other ac-powered circuits. In this process, inductors are formed from a patterned bilayer of a geometrical inductance material, Nb, deposited over a layer of high kinetic inductance material, e.g., NbN. Individual pattering of the bilayer layers allows to create stripline inductors in a wide range of inductances, from the low values typical to Nb striplines to the high values typical for NbN thin films, and preserve sufficient mutual coupling in stripline transformers with extremely low cross-talk. Energy efficiency of ac-powered circuits is limited by dielectric losses in the ac power transmissions lines. Problems of scaling associated with multiphase ac power distribution are discussed.
Several advances have been made towards increasing the number of Niobium layers for superconductor integrated circuits. Fabrication processes, such as the MIT Lincoln Laboratory SFQ5ee process and the CRAVITY-AIST process, now provide eight or more Niobium layers. The additional superconducting layers significantly increase the space available for routing between and within cells. However, striplines must now be routed through multiple ground planes to efficiently utilize all available metal layers. This can lead to large mutual inductance between signal lines, especially when ground pillars are used to connect ground planes. The placement of these ground pillars become crucial. In this work, we use numerical software to analyze the effects of striplines transitioning through multiple ground planes and how the location of ground pillars influence the mutual inductance between lines and show that careful layout considerations are required for modern circuits with dense layouts. We also present layout improvement strategies to mitigate or lessen the negative effects of these mutual inductance on circuit operation.