Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:cond-mat/0003020 · Physical Review A

Spectral equivalence of bosons and fermions in one-dimensional harmonic potentials

Michael Crescimanno, Adam Scott Landsberg

Published Feb 5, 2001• 14 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Recently, Schmidt and Schnack [Physica A 260, 479 (1998)], following earlier references, reiterate that the specific heat of N noninteracting bosons in a one-dimensional harmonic well equals that of N noninteracting fermions in the same potential. We show that this peculiar relationship between heat capacities results from a more dramatic equivalence between Bose and Fermi systems. Namely, we prove that the excitations of such Bose and Fermi systems are spectrally equivalent. Two complementary proofs of this equivalence are provided; one based on a combinatoric argument, the other from analysis of the underlying dynamical symmetry group.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.63.035601

Related papers

Bosons and fermions in a one‐dimensional harmonic oscillator potential

B. G. Wybourne

Abstract The symmetry properties of bosons and fermions in a one‐dimensional harmonic oscillator are explored. It is shown that there is a one‐to‐one correspondence between the counts of the maximal spin states states formed by N‐noninteracting bosons and fermions in a one‐dimensional harmonic oscillator. © 2002 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem, 2002

International Journal of Quantum Chemistry•Jan 1, 2002•1 citation

Virial coefficients from unified statistical thermodynamics of quantum gases trapped under generic power law potential in $d$ dimension and the equivalence of trapped quantum gases

Mir Mehedi Faruk, Shah Mohammad Bahauddin

From the unified statistical thermodynamics of quantum gases, the virial coefficients of ideal Bose and Fermi gases which are trapped under generic power law potential are derived systematically. From the general result of virial coefficients, one can produce the known results in $d=3$ and $d=2$. But more importantly we found that, the virial coefficients of bosons and fermions become equal (except the the second virial coefficient, where the sign is different) when we trap the gases under harmonic potential in $d=1$. This result suggests the equivalence between Bose and Fermi gases which is already established for $d=1$ by M M Faruk (J Stat Phys, DOI 10.1007/s10955-015-1344-4). Surprisingly our investigation also shows that the virial coefficients of two dimensional free quantum gases are identical to the virial coefficients of one dimensional harmonically trapped quantum gases.

arXiv:1601.07946•Jan 28, 2016•0 citations

A soluble one dimensional model of an interacting Fermi gas. I

Eleonora M. Witteles, Gideon Carmi

The authors study a one dimensional model system of fermions which proves to be exactly soluble in the thermodynamic limit. It is shown that the thermodynamic functions for the model system are the same as for a system of noninteracting fermions in a harmonic oscillator well. As a special case of the model system, with a particular choice for the coupling constant, it reduces to a particular two-species system of fermions interacting via pairwise harmonic forces. For this case of the two-species system the free energy per particle, the pressure the specific heat at constant volume, and the isothermal compressibility are calculated in the canonical ensemble in closed form. It is shown that this system does not undergo a phase transition.

Journal of physics. A, Proceedings of the Physical Society. General•May 1, 1972•1 citation

Dimensionality effects in restricted bosonic and fermionic systems

Dragoş-Victor Anghel

The phenomenon of Bose-like condensation, the continuous change of the dimensionality of the particle distribution as a consequence of freezing out of one or more degrees of freedom in the limit of low particle density, is investigated theoretically in the case of closed systems of massive bosons and fermions, described by general single-particle Hamiltonians. This phenomenon is similar for both types of particles and, for some energy spectra, exhibits features specific to multiple-step Bose-Einstein condensation, for instance, the appearance of maxima in the specific heat. In the case of fermions, as the particle density increases, another phenomenon is also observed. For certain types of single particle Hamiltonians, the specific heat is approaching asymptotically a divergent behavior at zero temperature, as the Fermi energy epsilon(F) is converging towards any value from an infinite discrete set of energies epsilon(i)(i>/=1). If epsilon(F)=epsilon(i), for any i, the specific heat is divergent at T=0 just in infinite systems, whereas for any finite system the specific heat approaches zero at low enough temperatures. The results are particularized for particles trapped inside parallelepipedic boxes and harmonic potentials.

arXiv:cond-mat/0006430•Physical review. E, Statistical physics, plasmas, fluids, and related interdisciplinary topics•Dec 1, 2000•4 citations

Relationship between Systems of Impenetrable Bosons and Fermions in One Dimension

Marvin D. Girardeau

A rigorous one-one correspondence is established between one-dimensional systems of bosons and of spinless fermions. This correspondence holds irrespective of the nature of the interparticle interactions, subject only to the restriction that the interaction have an impenetrable core. It is shown that the Bose and Fermi eigenfunctions are related by ψB=ψFA, where A(x1 … xn) is +1 or −1 according as the order pq … r, when the particle coordinates xj are arranged in the order xp<xq< … <xr, is an even or an odd permutation of 1 … n. The energy spectra of the two systems are identical, as are all configurational probability distributions, but the momentum distributions are quite different. The general theory is illustrated by application to the special case of impenetrable point particles; the one-one correspondence between bosons with this particular interaction and completely noninteracting fermions leads to a rigorous solution of this many-boson problem.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Nov 1, 1960•1,743 citations

Thermodynamic Properties of a q-Boson Gas Trapped in an n-Dimensional Harmonic Potential

Guozhen Su, Lixuan Chen, Jincan Chen

The thermodynamic properties of an ideal q-boson gas trapped in an n-dimensional harmonic potential are studied, based on the distribution function of q-bosons. The critical temperature Tc,q of Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC) and the heat capacity C of the system are derived analytically. It is shown that for the q-boson gas trapped in a harmonic potential, BEC may occur in any dimension when q ≠ 1, the critical temperature is always higher than that of an ordinary Bose gas (q = 1), and the heat capacity is continuous at Tc,q for a one-dimensional system but discontinuous at Tc,q for a two- or multi-dimensional system.

Open Systems & Information Dynamics•Jun 1, 2003•5 citations
Recently, Schmidt and Schnack [Physica A 260, 479 (1998)], following earlier references, reiterate that the specific heat of N noninteracting bosons in a one-dimensional harmonic well equals that of N noninteracting fermions in the same potential. We show that this peculiar relationship between heat capacities results from a more dramatic equivalence between Bose and Fermi systems. Namely, we prove that the excitations of such Bose and Fermi systems are spectrally equivalent. Two complementary proofs of this equivalence are provided; one based on a combinatoric argument, the other from analysis of the underlying dynamical symmetry group.
Virial coefficients from unified statistical thermodynamics of quantum gases trapped under generic power law potential in ddd dimension and the equivalence of trapped quantum gases
From the unified statistical thermodynamics of quantum gases, the virial coefficients of ideal Bose and Fermi gases which are trapped under generic power law potential are derived systematically. From the general result of virial coefficients, one can produce the known results in d=3d=3d=3 and d=2d=2d=2. But more importantly we found that, the virial coefficients of bosons and fermions become equal (except the the second virial coefficient, where the sign is different) when we trap the gases under harmonic potential in d=1d=1d=1. This result suggests the equivalence between Bose and Fermi gases which is already established for d=1d=1d=1 by M M Faruk (J Stat Phys, DOI 10.1007/s10955-015-1344-4). Surprisingly our investigation also shows that the virial coefficients of two dimensional free quantum gases are identical to the virial coefficients of one dimensional harmonically trapped quantum gases.
The authors study a one dimensional model system of fermions which proves to be exactly soluble in the thermodynamic limit. It is shown that the thermodynamic functions for the model system are the same as for a system of noninteracting fermions in a harmonic oscillator well. As a special case of the model system, with a particular choice for the coupling constant, it reduces to a particular two-species system of fermions interacting via pairwise harmonic forces. For this case of the two-species system the free energy per particle, the pressure the specific heat at constant volume, and the isothermal compressibility are calculated in the canonical ensemble in closed form. It is shown that this system does not undergo a phase transition.
The phenomenon of Bose-like condensation, the continuous change of the dimensionality of the particle distribution as a consequence of freezing out of one or more degrees of freedom in the limit of low particle density, is investigated theoretically in the case of closed systems of massive bosons and fermions, described by general single-particle Hamiltonians. This phenomenon is similar for both types of particles and, for some energy spectra, exhibits features specific to multiple-step Bose-Einstein condensation, for instance, the appearance of maxima in the specific heat. In the case of fermions, as the particle density increases, another phenomenon is also observed. For certain types of single particle Hamiltonians, the specific heat is approaching asymptotically a divergent behavior at zero temperature, as the Fermi energy epsilon(F) is converging towards any value from an infinite discrete set of energies epsilon(i)(i>/=1). If epsilon(F)=epsilon(i), for any i, the specific heat is divergent at T=0 just in infinite systems, whereas for any finite system the specific heat approaches zero at low enough temperatures. The results are particularized for particles trapped inside parallelepipedic boxes and harmonic potentials.
A rigorous one-one correspondence is established between one-dimensional systems of bosons and of spinless fermions. This correspondence holds irrespective of the nature of the interparticle interactions, subject only to the restriction that the interaction have an impenetrable core. It is shown that the Bose and Fermi eigenfunctions are related by ψB=ψFA, where A(x1 … xn) is +1 or −1 according as the order pq … r, when the particle coordinates xj are arranged in the order xp<xq< … <xr, is an even or an odd permutation of 1 … n. The energy spectra of the two systems are identical, as are all configurational probability distributions, but the momentum distributions are quite different. The general theory is illustrated by application to the special case of impenetrable point particles; the one-one correspondence between bosons with this particular interaction and completely noninteracting fermions leads to a rigorous solution of this many-boson problem.
The thermodynamic properties of an ideal q-boson gas trapped in an n-dimensional harmonic potential are studied, based on the distribution function of q-bosons. The critical temperature Tc,q of Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC) and the heat capacity C of the system are derived analytically. It is shown that for the q-boson gas trapped in a harmonic potential, BEC may occur in any dimension when q ≠ 1, the critical temperature is always higher than that of an ordinary Bose gas (q = 1), and the heat capacity is continuous at Tc,q for a one-dimensional system but discontinuous at Tc,q for a two- or multi-dimensional system.