Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Annual Methodological Archive Research Review

Optimizing RF/DC Electrode Layouts in Ion Traps: Minimizing Micromotion Through Geometric Configuration for Enhanced Confinement and Laser Cooling Access

Kaz Bano

Published Jan 30, 2026• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Ion traps are a foundational technology in quantum information processing, precision spectroscopy and foundational physics tests. At the heart of their performance is the inhibition of micromotion, an oscillation of ions through imperfect trapping potentials, that restricts the laser cooling efficiency, coherence times, and the accuracy of measurements. The paper provides a systematic computational analysis of four different electrode geometries (Linear Paul, Segmented, Surface and Ring) in 24 different RF / DC configurations (C01-C24) and 13 performance parameters that comprise trap depth (0.62 1.48 eV), radial secular frequency (1,100 1 Multi-objective optimization with weighted scoring of these metrics indicates that Ring trap geometry scores the highest total (80.2/100), followed by Linear Paul (72.0), Segmented (67.0) and Surface (55.1) configurations. ANOVA (one-way) statistically verified the presence of statistically significant inter-geometry differences in micro-motions amplitude (F = 18.43, p < .001) and cooling efficiency (F = 22.17, p < .001), with Tukey HSD post-hoc revealed that the most significant difference was between the Ring and the Surface. The Pearson correlation analysis shows that RF drive voltage and micromotion amplitude (r = -0.94 to -0.99) and cooling efficiency and micromotion (r = -1.00) have near-perfect inverse correlations, which prove that the quality of confinement is regulated by electrode geometry, RF amplitude, and spacing. These results give quantitative design principles of next-generation ion traps in quantum computing and atomic clock. Keywords: ion trap, micromotion minimization, RF/DC electrode optimization, laser cooling, Mathieu stability, secular frequency, quantum computing

Related papers

Session II / Quantum Information & Computing Trapped and cooled 88Sr+ ions in a cylindrical potential provided by a micro-fabricated ring trap

Peng Zhao, Chuan Seng Tan, Seit, Wei +5 more

Laser-cooled trapped ions platform is one of the best candidates for the development of future quantum computing. This has generated a major worldwide research effort aimed at scaling and integrating trapping devices. As part of this effort, we are developing miniature atomic ion traps in the laboratory: Paul linear surface traps manufactured in collaboration with Nanyang Technology University and the Microelectronics Institute of Singapore. An original feature of the manufacturing process is that all the electrical contacts of the trap electrodes are made through the Silicon substrate (TSV: through silicon vias). In this way, the wire-bondings usually soldered directly to the electrodes can be offset or completely eliminated [1]. This opens the way to complex architectures, in particular cylindrically symmetrical ring traps, which cannot be made with surface connections that would break the desired symmetry. The trapping and laser cooling of ions in cylindrically symmetrical linear Paul traps (called "ion storage rings" in their macroscopic version, diameters of around 100 mm) was demonstrated in pioneering work at Garching [2] and subsequently extended to microfabricated traps (multilayer technology) at Sandia National Labs (diameter 2.5 mm) [3] and Berkeley (diameter 95 μm) [4]. These devices are of interest because, in the absence of defects, they enable rotational symmetry for the trapped ions and thus periodic boundary conditions for the confined cold ion system (Coulomb crystal). They are also candidates for observing and manipulating the rotational quantum state of trapped ion ensembles [4]. We will present our latest results concerning the performance of TSV surface ring traps (diameters between 150 and 210 μm) manufactured in Singapore. In particular, we loaded these traps with Dopplercooled 88Sr+ ions (from a single ion to several hundreds). Laser cooling and image acquisition enable us to estimate the defects of the trapping potential with respect to perfect rotational symmetry. The application of DC voltages to a set of segmented electrodes then makes it possible to compensate for most of these defects, which nevertheless remain the major problem to be solved in order to achieve sub milikelvin free motion.

•Jul 7, 2024•0 citations

Optimized Surface Ion Trap Design for Tight Confinement and Separation of Ion Chains

Ilya Gerasin, Nikita O. Zhadnov, K. S. Kudeyarov +3 more

Qubit systems based on trapped ultracold ions win one of the leading positions in the quantum computing field, demonstrating quantum algorithms with the highest complexity to date. Surface Paul traps for ion confinement open the opportunity to scale quantum processors to hundreds of qubits and enable high-connectivity manipulations on ions. To fabricate such a system with certain characteristics, the special design of a surface electrode structure is required. The depth of the trapping potential, the stability parameter, the secular frequency and the distance between an ion and the trap surface should be optimized for better performance. Here, we present the optimized design of a relatively simple surface trap that allows several important high-fidelity primitives: tight ion confinement, laser cooling, and wide optical access. The suggested trap design also allows us to perform an important basic operation, namely, splitting an ion chain into two parts.

arXiv:2407.14195•Quantum Reports•Aug 23, 2024•4 citations

Ion-trajectory analysis for micromotion minimization and the measurement of small forces

Timm F. Gloger, Peter Kaufmann, Delia Kaufmann +4 more

For experiments with ions confined in a Paul trap, minimization of micromotion is often essential. In order to diagnose and compensate micromotion we have implemented a method that allows for finding the position of the radio-frequency (rf) null reliably and efficiently, in principle, without any variation of direct current (dc) voltages. We apply a trap modulation technique and focus-scanning imaging to extract three-dimensional ion positions for various rf drive powers and analyze the power dependence of the equilibrium position of the trapped ion. In contrast to commonly used methods, the search algorithm directly makes use of a physical effect as opposed to efficient numerical minimization in a high-dimensional parameter space. Using this method we achieve a compensation of the residual electric field that causes excess micromotion in the radial plane of a linear Paul trap down to $0.09\phantom{\rule{4pt}{0ex}}\text{V}\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}{\text{m}}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$. Additionally, the precise position determination of a single harmonically trapped ion employed here can also be utilized for the detection of small forces. This is demonstrated by determining light pressure forces with a precision of 135 yN. As the method is based on imaging only, it can be applied to several ions simultaneously and is independent of laser direction and thus well suited to be used with, for example, surface-electrode traps.

arXiv:1503.07031•Physical Review A•Oct 27, 2015•39 citations

The Effect of Trap Design on the Scalability of Trapped-Ion Quantum Technologies

Le Minh Anh Nguyen, Brant Bowers, Sara Mouradian

To increase the power of a trapped-ion quantum information processor, the qubit number, gate speed, and gate fidelity must all increase. All three of these parameters are influenced by the trapping field, which, in turn, depends on the electrode geometry. Here, we consider how the electrode geometry affects the following radial trapping parameters: trap height, harmonicity, depth, and trap frequency. We introduce a simple multi-wafer geometry comprising a ground plane above a surface trap and compare the performance of this trap to a surface trap and a multi-wafer trap that is a miniaturized version of a linear Paul trap. We compare the voltage and frequency requirements needed to reach a desired radial trap frequency and find that the two multi-wafer trap designs provide significant improvements in expected power dissipation over the surface trap design in large part due to increased harmonicity. Finally, we consider the fabrication requirements and the path towards the integration of the necessary optical control. This work provides a basis to optimize future trap designs with scalability in mind.

arXiv:2503.00218•Entropy•May 29, 2025•3 citations

Multi-Wafer Surface Ion Traps: Enhanced Trap Depth, Vertical Confinement, and Ion Lifetime Through Increased Wafer Separation

Kaz Bano

Surface ion traps are a cornerstone technology for scalable quantum information processing, yet their shallow trap depths and limited ion lifetimes remain fundamental engineering bottlenecks. This study presents a systematic experimental and statistical comparison between standard single-wafer surface traps and a novel multi-wafer surface trap architecture in which two parallel wafers with integrated radio-frequency (RF) electrodes are separated by a controllable vertical gap. Seventeen trap configurations were characterized (N = 5 standard, N = 12 multi-wafer), with wafer separations ranging from 50 to 500 µm. Welch’s independent-samples t-tests revealed that the multi-wafer geometry produced a mean trap depth of 23.53 meV compared with 8.50 meV in standard traps (d = 2.71, p < .001), extended ion lifetimes from 120 s to 620.75 s (d = 2.72, p < .001), and reduced anomalous heating rates from 857 to 153 quanta/s (d = −14.75, p < .001). Pearson correlations showed an exceptionally strong positive relationship between wafer separation and trap depth (r = .999, p < .001), and between trap depth and ion lifetime (r = .997, p < .001). A linear regression model explained 99.4% of the variance in ion lifetime from trap depth alone (R² = .995). Qubit coherence time (T₂*) scaled with trap depth, reaching 18.2 ms in the deepest configuration. Results demonstrate that multi-wafer architectures overcome the characteristic depth saturation (∼5.5 meV) of standard designs and produce deeper, more stable, and longer-lived ion traps suitable for scalable quantum computing. Keywords: surface ion trap, multi-wafer architecture, trap depth, ion lifetime, quantum computing, anomalous heating, vertical confinement

Annual Methodological Archive Research Review•Feb 21, 2026•0 citations

Surface trap with dc-tunable ion-electrode distance

Da An, Clemens Matthiesen, Ahmed Abdelrahman +5 more

We describe the design, fabrication, and operation of a novel surface-electrode Paul trap that produces a radio-frequency-null along the axis perpendicular to the trap surface. This arrangement enables control of the vertical trapping potential and consequentially the ion-electrode distance via dc-electrodes only. We demonstrate the confinement of single 40Ca+ ions at heights between 50 μm and 300 μm above planar copper-coated aluminum electrodes. Laser-cooling and coherent operations are performed on both the planar and vertical motional modes. This architecture provides a platform for precision electric-field noise detection and trapping of vertical ion strings without excess micromotion and may have applications for scalable quantum computers with surface ion traps.

arXiv:1807.06043•Review of Scientific Instruments•Sep 1, 2018•13 citations
Ion traps are a foundational technology in quantum information processing, precision spectroscopy and foundational physics tests. At the heart of their performance is the inhibition of micromotion, an oscillation of ions through imperfect trapping potentials, that restricts the laser cooling efficiency, coherence times, and the accuracy of measurements. The paper provides a systematic computational analysis of four different electrode geometries (Linear Paul, Segmented, Surface and Ring) in 24 different RF / DC configurations (C01-C24) and 13 performance parameters that comprise trap depth (0.62 1.48 eV), radial secular frequency (1,100 1 Multi-objective optimization with weighted scoring of these metrics indicates that Ring trap geometry scores the highest total (80.2/100), followed by Linear Paul (72.0), Segmented (67.0) and Surface (55.1) configurations. ANOVA (one-way) statistically verified the presence of statistically significant inter-geometry differences in micro-motions amplitude (F = 18.43, p < .001) and cooling efficiency (F = 22.17, p < .001), with Tukey HSD post-hoc revealed that the most significant difference was between the Ring and the Surface. The Pearson correlation analysis shows that RF drive voltage and micromotion amplitude (r = -0.94 to -0.99) and cooling efficiency and micromotion (r = -1.00) have near-perfect inverse correlations, which prove that the quality of confinement is regulated by electrode geometry, RF amplitude, and spacing. These results give quantitative design principles of next-generation ion traps in quantum computing and atomic clock. Keywords: ion trap, micromotion minimization, RF/DC electrode optimization, laser cooling, Mathieu stability, secular frequency, quantum computing
Laser-cooled trapped ions platform is one of the best candidates for the development of future quantum computing. This has generated a major worldwide research effort aimed at scaling and integrating trapping devices. As part of this effort, we are developing miniature atomic ion traps in the laboratory: Paul linear surface traps manufactured in collaboration with Nanyang Technology University and the Microelectronics Institute of Singapore. An original feature of the manufacturing process is that all the electrical contacts of the trap electrodes are made through the Silicon substrate (TSV: through silicon vias). In this way, the wire-bondings usually soldered directly to the electrodes can be offset or completely eliminated [1]. This opens the way to complex architectures, in particular cylindrically symmetrical ring traps, which cannot be made with surface connections that would break the desired symmetry. The trapping and laser cooling of ions in cylindrically symmetrical linear Paul traps (called "ion storage rings" in their macroscopic version, diameters of around 100 mm) was demonstrated in pioneering work at Garching [2] and subsequently extended to microfabricated traps (multilayer technology) at Sandia National Labs (diameter 2.5 mm) [3] and Berkeley (diameter 95 μm) [4]. These devices are of interest because, in the absence of defects, they enable rotational symmetry for the trapped ions and thus periodic boundary conditions for the confined cold ion system (Coulomb crystal). They are also candidates for observing and manipulating the rotational quantum state of trapped ion ensembles [4]. We will present our latest results concerning the performance of TSV surface ring traps (diameters between 150 and 210 μm) manufactured in Singapore. In particular, we loaded these traps with Dopplercooled 88Sr+ ions (from a single ion to several hundreds). Laser cooling and image acquisition enable us to estimate the defects of the trapping potential with respect to perfect rotational symmetry. The application of DC voltages to a set of segmented electrodes then makes it possible to compensate for most of these defects, which nevertheless remain the major problem to be solved in order to achieve sub milikelvin free motion.
Qubit systems based on trapped ultracold ions win one of the leading positions in the quantum computing field, demonstrating quantum algorithms with the highest complexity to date. Surface Paul traps for ion confinement open the opportunity to scale quantum processors to hundreds of qubits and enable high-connectivity manipulations on ions. To fabricate such a system with certain characteristics, the special design of a surface electrode structure is required. The depth of the trapping potential, the stability parameter, the secular frequency and the distance between an ion and the trap surface should be optimized for better performance. Here, we present the optimized design of a relatively simple surface trap that allows several important high-fidelity primitives: tight ion confinement, laser cooling, and wide optical access. The suggested trap design also allows us to perform an important basic operation, namely, splitting an ion chain into two parts.
For experiments with ions confined in a Paul trap, minimization of micromotion is often essential. In order to diagnose and compensate micromotion we have implemented a method that allows for finding the position of the radio-frequency (rf) null reliably and efficiently, in principle, without any variation of direct current (dc) voltages. We apply a trap modulation technique and focus-scanning imaging to extract three-dimensional ion positions for various rf drive powers and analyze the power dependence of the equilibrium position of the trapped ion. In contrast to commonly used methods, the search algorithm directly makes use of a physical effect as opposed to efficient numerical minimization in a high-dimensional parameter space. Using this method we achieve a compensation of the residual electric field that causes excess micromotion in the radial plane of a linear Paul trap down to $0.09\phantom{\rule{4pt}{0ex}}\text{V}\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}{\text{m}}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$. Additionally, the precise position determination of a single harmonically trapped ion employed here can also be utilized for the detection of small forces. This is demonstrated by determining light pressure forces with a precision of 135 yN. As the method is based on imaging only, it can be applied to several ions simultaneously and is independent of laser direction and thus well suited to be used with, for example, surface-electrode traps.
To increase the power of a trapped-ion quantum information processor, the qubit number, gate speed, and gate fidelity must all increase. All three of these parameters are influenced by the trapping field, which, in turn, depends on the electrode geometry. Here, we consider how the electrode geometry affects the following radial trapping parameters: trap height, harmonicity, depth, and trap frequency. We introduce a simple multi-wafer geometry comprising a ground plane above a surface trap and compare the performance of this trap to a surface trap and a multi-wafer trap that is a miniaturized version of a linear Paul trap. We compare the voltage and frequency requirements needed to reach a desired radial trap frequency and find that the two multi-wafer trap designs provide significant improvements in expected power dissipation over the surface trap design in large part due to increased harmonicity. Finally, we consider the fabrication requirements and the path towards the integration of the necessary optical control. This work provides a basis to optimize future trap designs with scalability in mind.
Surface ion traps are a cornerstone technology for scalable quantum information processing, yet their shallow trap depths and limited ion lifetimes remain fundamental engineering bottlenecks. This study presents a systematic experimental and statistical comparison between standard single-wafer surface traps and a novel multi-wafer surface trap architecture in which two parallel wafers with integrated radio-frequency (RF) electrodes are separated by a controllable vertical gap. Seventeen trap configurations were characterized (N = 5 standard, N = 12 multi-wafer), with wafer separations ranging from 50 to 500 µm. Welch’s independent-samples t-tests revealed that the multi-wafer geometry produced a mean trap depth of 23.53 meV compared with 8.50 meV in standard traps (d = 2.71, p < .001), extended ion lifetimes from 120 s to 620.75 s (d = 2.72, p < .001), and reduced anomalous heating rates from 857 to 153 quanta/s (d = −14.75, p < .001). Pearson correlations showed an exceptionally strong positive relationship between wafer separation and trap depth (r = .999, p < .001), and between trap depth and ion lifetime (r = .997, p < .001). A linear regression model explained 99.4% of the variance in ion lifetime from trap depth alone (R² = .995). Qubit coherence time (T₂*) scaled with trap depth, reaching 18.2 ms in the deepest configuration. Results demonstrate that multi-wafer architectures overcome the characteristic depth saturation (∼5.5 meV) of standard designs and produce deeper, more stable, and longer-lived ion traps suitable for scalable quantum computing. Keywords: surface ion trap, multi-wafer architecture, trap depth, ion lifetime, quantum computing, anomalous heating, vertical confinement
We describe the design, fabrication, and operation of a novel surface-electrode Paul trap that produces a radio-frequency-null along the axis perpendicular to the trap surface. This arrangement enables control of the vertical trapping potential and consequentially the ion-electrode distance via dc-electrodes only. We demonstrate the confinement of single 40Ca+ ions at heights between 50 μm and 300 μm above planar copper-coated aluminum electrodes. Laser-cooling and coherent operations are performed on both the planar and vertical motional modes. This architecture provides a platform for precision electric-field noise detection and trapping of vertical ion strings without excess micromotion and may have applications for scalable quantum computers with surface ion traps.