Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

APL Photonics

Free-space secure optical communication based on the nonseparability of vectorial structured light

Mingze Cai, Zhenyu Wan, Yuzhuo Cao, Runshi Wang, Yu Zhang, Jing Du, Jian Wang

Published May 1, 2026• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

Free-space optical (FSO) communication offers high capacity, license-free spectrum, and immunity to electromagnetic interference, making it a promising solution for future wireless links. However, practical deployment of FSO systems remains challenged by issues of link security and reliable transmission under atmospheric turbulence. In this work, we investigate the use of nonseparability encoding based on vectorial structured light as a turbulence-resilient and secure transmission approach. Through simulations and experiments, we compare multi-level nonseparability encoding with conventional amplitude modulation under various turbulence strengths and eavesdropping scenarios. The results demonstrate that vectorial structured light exhibits inherent security advantages, imposing higher optical signal-to-noise ratio penalties on eavesdroppers and making information recovery from partial interception significantly more difficult. These findings confirm the potential of nonseparability-based encoding for enhancing both security and robustness in FSO communication systems.

DOI
10.1063/5.0327437

Related papers

Secure and Reliable Communications over Free-space Optical Channels

Xiaole Sun

Free-space optical (FSO) communication provides a promising alternative solution to the traditional radio frequency (RF) communications. Compared to the RF technology, there are many advantages of FSO communications, such as ultra-high bandwidth, license-free spectrum, low inter-channel interference, and energy-efficient transmission. The potential applications for FSO communication include the last-one-mile access link from the fiber-based backbone network, low earth orbit (LEO) satellite communications, high-altitude base station platforms or vehicles, deep-space communications, and in-building automation connections. As the FSO technology becomes mature and increasingly involved, the security and reliability requirements of such applications also become crucial. Regarding the security issues, although the FSO communication is inherently more secure than the RF counterpart due to high directivity of its line-of-sight (LOS) link, it can still suffer from optical wire-tapping attack. There are many different application schemes that an eavesdropper can still probe the FSO link. Traditionally, to protect the communication, many works have been done on encryption layer and upper network layer, such as computationally intensive cryptographic algorithms and message exchanging protocols. In recent years, physical-layer security (PLS) has been getting more attentions as it provides an extra layer of security against eavesdropping. The PLS schemes, in general can be categorized into two main categories: classical PLS and quantum key distribution (QKD) protocols. The classical PLS is based on the information theoretic security analysis, while the QKD security is guaranteed by the quantum mechanics laws. Both techniques have been studied for FSO channels. In the first half of this dissertation, we study the PLS in a LOS FSO channel using orbital angular momentum (OAM) multiplexing and show that higher secrecy capacity can be achieved using OAM multiplexing technology in the presence of atmospheric turbulence effects. Then, we proposed an adaptation scheme for QKD system over FSO channel with different QKD protocols, i.e. BB84 and decoy state protocols. By adapting the source brightness based on the channel condition, we optimized the secret key rate (SKR) of the QKD system. Furthermore, we proposed a multiple spatial modes-based QKD system with backpropagation method to increase the total SKR through parallel channels. Regarding the reliability of an optical communication system as well as information reconciliation for both PLS and QKD schemes, the forward error correction (FEC) becomes an essential technique to enable high-speed transmission. The FEC with low-density parity-check (LDPC) codes has been studied for decades from LDPC block codes to the most recent spatially-coupled (SC) LDPC codes. For FSO communications, due to the time-varying nature of FSO channels, the capability of rate adaptation is important to achieve a consistent reliable transmission. In the second half of this dissertation, we proposed unified FPGA-based architecture to implement both quasi-cyclic (QC) LDPC codes and SC-LDPC codes with rate adaptation capability. The performance is verified through FPGA emulation to show good error floor properties. To further validate the rate adaptation capability, we have built a spatial light modulator (SLM)-based FSO channel emulator to test the adaptive coding scheme. Furthermore, we have conducted a fiber-based experiment with our rate adaptative coding scheme to show that the proposed adaptive coding scheme can be also used in dynamic fiber-based networks.

•Jan 1, 2019•0 citations

Enhancing the Security of Free-Space Optical Communications With Secret Sharing and Key Agreement

Ning Wang, Xuegui Song, Julian Cheng +1 more

Security issues of free-space optical (FSO) communications are discussed. Based on a subcarrier intensity-modulated air-to-ground FSO system model, we first analyze the coherence time of the air-to-ground FSO link and show that under practical assumptions, scintillation reciprocity holds in the FSO communication system. A private secret-key-based cryptosystem with key management is introduced to enhance FSO security, and a key agreement approach is proposed based on statistics of the random atmospheric-turbulence-induced fading channel measurements. The secret key rate of the key agreement scheme is investigated for the gamma–gamma turbulence model. Practical key agreement protocols based on bidirectional channel identification are designed for different FSO communication scenarios. Our numerical results reveal that the key rate is not sensitive to the strength of the atmospheric turbulence; the per-symbol signal-to-noise ratio and the training sequence length are the dominating factors.

Journal of Optical Communications and Networking•Nov 5, 2014•48 citations

Secrecy analysis of a free-space laser communication system with a coherent main channel

Manuel Prasanna Kalaimani, Harishankar Ramachandran

Physical layer security of a free-space optical (FSO) communication link is investigated for certain eavesdropping scenarios in which the eavesdropper exploits the divergence of the transmitted laser beam, which is subject to atmospheric turbulence, to compromise the security of the transmission link. A solution for physical layer security in which the legitimate receiver is positioned to receive only the coherent component of the transmitted laser beam is proposed. The irradiance fluctuations are modeled with separate distributions for the coherent and non-coherent components of the transmitted beam, corresponding to the main channel and the eavesdropper’s channel, respectively. Complete secrecy analysis of this setup is presented, and closed form expressions of the probability of strictly positive secrecy capacity, average secrecy capacity, and secrecy outage probability are derived. The analytical results are verified by Monte-Carlo simulations. Secrecy performance for worst-case scenarios corresponding to an adversary with powerful resources to capture all of the leaked information is explored. Results are analyzed for different turbulence regimes, and it was found that secure communication is possible even in the region of strong turbulence.

Optical Engineering•Jun 2, 2023•2 citations

Low probability of intercept (LPI) free-space optical communication with wavelength diversity in strong atmospheric turbulence regime

Vijay Nafria, Ivan B. Djordjević

In physical-layer security and cryptography we are concerned with the security of the transmitted data, while in low probability of intercept (LPI) communication with protecting the privacy of the end users. In our recent publications related to LPI communications and radars over free-space optical (FSO) links we proposed to hide the constant-amplitude modulated data, imposed on thermal source beam, in ambient solar radiation to protect the end users privacy and at the same time improve the reliability and security, while reducing the detectability of transmitted signal by the adversary Willie. In order to study both LPI and covert communication concepts we have developed an FSO communication testbed at the University of Arizona campus with a 1.5 km-long FSO link. Here we present results of our FSO experiments, where we conducted both LPI and covert communications at data rates ranging from 125 Mb/s to 10 Gb/s, wherein the information beam is kept completely hidden under the ambient solar radiations as random thermal noise. To improve the system reliability to atmospheric turbulence effects we make use of wavelength diversity method as a low-cost, easy to implement and far more practical alternative to conventional adaptive optics systems.

Optics Express•Nov 28, 2024•7 citations

Secrecy Outage Performance in Free Space Optical Communication Links

Aanchal Gupta, Divya Dhawan, Neena Gupta

Free space optical (FSO) communication is widely used wireless type of communication, which is highly advantageous as it offers huge capacity, immunity to electromagnetic interference, and low deployment cost. FSO systems are vulnerable to eavesdropping attacks due to the miniaturization and lightweight of optical devices used for detection. Therefore, secure communication of FSO systems remains a challenging task. In order to overcome this problem, secrecy outage probability (SOP) is analyzed in this study. A system model is presented comprising a transmitter and receiver, Alice and Bob and a malicious eavesdropper, Eve. Simulation results are demonstrated which reveal that for a fixed value of Eve’s signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), the SOP decreases with increasing values of Bob’s SNR. In addition, it is shown that increasing the values of coupling parameter deteriorates the SOP performance.

CRC Press eBooks•May 28, 2024•0 citations

On Secure Communications for FSO Systems Over Generalized Turbulence Channels

Wafaa Mohammed Ridha Shakir, Ruwaida A. A. Abdul Kareem

With the continued development of optical wireless communications, the security performance of free space optical (FSO) communications is the most crucial aspect that should receive significant attention. Despite the fact that FSO communications are considered more secure than radio frequency systems, their link performance degrades due to some environmental factors such as atmospheric turbulence, fog, and non-zero boresight pointing errors. The combined effect of these factors on the secrecy performance of FSO communication systems over the generalized Malaga- M fading channel is investigated in this paper. This work assumes a more realistic eavesdropping scenario in which both legitimate and unauthorized receivers are located on the same receiving plane. Secrecy outage probability and strictly positive secrecy capacity are expressed in exact closed-form expressions in this work. The results show that the FSO system has acceptable secrecy performance in moderate and light fog, with potential reach distances ranging from hundreds of meters to a few kilometers. Monte-Carlo simulations are used to verify the numerical results.

IEEE International Symposium on Measurements & Networking (M&N)•Jul 18, 2022•10 citations
Free-space optical (FSO) communication offers high capacity, license-free spectrum, and immunity to electromagnetic interference, making it a promising solution for future wireless links. However, practical deployment of FSO systems remains challenged by issues of link security and reliable transmission under atmospheric turbulence. In this work, we investigate the use of nonseparability encoding based on vectorial structured light as a turbulence-resilient and secure transmission approach. Through simulations and experiments, we compare multi-level nonseparability encoding with conventional amplitude modulation under various turbulence strengths and eavesdropping scenarios. The results demonstrate that vectorial structured light exhibits inherent security advantages, imposing higher optical signal-to-noise ratio penalties on eavesdroppers and making information recovery from partial interception significantly more difficult. These findings confirm the potential of nonseparability-based encoding for enhancing both security and robustness in FSO communication systems.
Free-space optical (FSO) communication provides a promising alternative solution to the traditional radio frequency (RF) communications. Compared to the RF technology, there are many advantages of FSO communications, such as ultra-high bandwidth, license-free spectrum, low inter-channel interference, and energy-efficient transmission. The potential applications for FSO communication include the last-one-mile access link from the fiber-based backbone network, low earth orbit (LEO) satellite communications, high-altitude base station platforms or vehicles, deep-space communications, and in-building automation connections. As the FSO technology becomes mature and increasingly involved, the security and reliability requirements of such applications also become crucial. Regarding the security issues, although the FSO communication is inherently more secure than the RF counterpart due to high directivity of its line-of-sight (LOS) link, it can still suffer from optical wire-tapping attack. There are many different application schemes that an eavesdropper can still probe the FSO link. Traditionally, to protect the communication, many works have been done on encryption layer and upper network layer, such as computationally intensive cryptographic algorithms and message exchanging protocols. In recent years, physical-layer security (PLS) has been getting more attentions as it provides an extra layer of security against eavesdropping. The PLS schemes, in general can be categorized into two main categories: classical PLS and quantum key distribution (QKD) protocols. The classical PLS is based on the information theoretic security analysis, while the QKD security is guaranteed by the quantum mechanics laws. Both techniques have been studied for FSO channels. In the first half of this dissertation, we study the PLS in a LOS FSO channel using orbital angular momentum (OAM) multiplexing and show that higher secrecy capacity can be achieved using OAM multiplexing technology in the presence of atmospheric turbulence effects. Then, we proposed an adaptation scheme for QKD system over FSO channel with different QKD protocols, i.e. BB84 and decoy state protocols. By adapting the source brightness based on the channel condition, we optimized the secret key rate (SKR) of the QKD system. Furthermore, we proposed a multiple spatial modes-based QKD system with backpropagation method to increase the total SKR through parallel channels. Regarding the reliability of an optical communication system as well as information reconciliation for both PLS and QKD schemes, the forward error correction (FEC) becomes an essential technique to enable high-speed transmission. The FEC with low-density parity-check (LDPC) codes has been studied for decades from LDPC block codes to the most recent spatially-coupled (SC) LDPC codes. For FSO communications, due to the time-varying nature of FSO channels, the capability of rate adaptation is important to achieve a consistent reliable transmission. In the second half of this dissertation, we proposed unified FPGA-based architecture to implement both quasi-cyclic (QC) LDPC codes and SC-LDPC codes with rate adaptation capability. The performance is verified through FPGA emulation to show good error floor properties. To further validate the rate adaptation capability, we have built a spatial light modulator (SLM)-based FSO channel emulator to test the adaptive coding scheme. Furthermore, we have conducted a fiber-based experiment with our rate adaptative coding scheme to show that the proposed adaptive coding scheme can be also used in dynamic fiber-based networks.
Security issues of free-space optical (FSO) communications are discussed. Based on a subcarrier intensity-modulated air-to-ground FSO system model, we first analyze the coherence time of the air-to-ground FSO link and show that under practical assumptions, scintillation reciprocity holds in the FSO communication system. A private secret-key-based cryptosystem with key management is introduced to enhance FSO security, and a key agreement approach is proposed based on statistics of the random atmospheric-turbulence-induced fading channel measurements. The secret key rate of the key agreement scheme is investigated for the gamma–gamma turbulence model. Practical key agreement protocols based on bidirectional channel identification are designed for different FSO communication scenarios. Our numerical results reveal that the key rate is not sensitive to the strength of the atmospheric turbulence; the per-symbol signal-to-noise ratio and the training sequence length are the dominating factors.
Physical layer security of a free-space optical (FSO) communication link is investigated for certain eavesdropping scenarios in which the eavesdropper exploits the divergence of the transmitted laser beam, which is subject to atmospheric turbulence, to compromise the security of the transmission link. A solution for physical layer security in which the legitimate receiver is positioned to receive only the coherent component of the transmitted laser beam is proposed. The irradiance fluctuations are modeled with separate distributions for the coherent and non-coherent components of the transmitted beam, corresponding to the main channel and the eavesdropper’s channel, respectively. Complete secrecy analysis of this setup is presented, and closed form expressions of the probability of strictly positive secrecy capacity, average secrecy capacity, and secrecy outage probability are derived. The analytical results are verified by Monte-Carlo simulations. Secrecy performance for worst-case scenarios corresponding to an adversary with powerful resources to capture all of the leaked information is explored. Results are analyzed for different turbulence regimes, and it was found that secure communication is possible even in the region of strong turbulence.
In physical-layer security and cryptography we are concerned with the security of the transmitted data, while in low probability of intercept (LPI) communication with protecting the privacy of the end users. In our recent publications related to LPI communications and radars over free-space optical (FSO) links we proposed to hide the constant-amplitude modulated data, imposed on thermal source beam, in ambient solar radiation to protect the end users privacy and at the same time improve the reliability and security, while reducing the detectability of transmitted signal by the adversary Willie. In order to study both LPI and covert communication concepts we have developed an FSO communication testbed at the University of Arizona campus with a 1.5 km-long FSO link. Here we present results of our FSO experiments, where we conducted both LPI and covert communications at data rates ranging from 125 Mb/s to 10 Gb/s, wherein the information beam is kept completely hidden under the ambient solar radiations as random thermal noise. To improve the system reliability to atmospheric turbulence effects we make use of wavelength diversity method as a low-cost, easy to implement and far more practical alternative to conventional adaptive optics systems.
Free space optical (FSO) communication is widely used wireless type of communication, which is highly advantageous as it offers huge capacity, immunity to electromagnetic interference, and low deployment cost. FSO systems are vulnerable to eavesdropping attacks due to the miniaturization and lightweight of optical devices used for detection. Therefore, secure communication of FSO systems remains a challenging task. In order to overcome this problem, secrecy outage probability (SOP) is analyzed in this study. A system model is presented comprising a transmitter and receiver, Alice and Bob and a malicious eavesdropper, Eve. Simulation results are demonstrated which reveal that for a fixed value of Eve’s signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), the SOP decreases with increasing values of Bob’s SNR. In addition, it is shown that increasing the values of coupling parameter deteriorates the SOP performance.
With the continued development of optical wireless communications, the security performance of free space optical (FSO) communications is the most crucial aspect that should receive significant attention. Despite the fact that FSO communications are considered more secure than radio frequency systems, their link performance degrades due to some environmental factors such as atmospheric turbulence, fog, and non-zero boresight pointing errors. The combined effect of these factors on the secrecy performance of FSO communication systems over the generalized Malaga- M fading channel is investigated in this paper. This work assumes a more realistic eavesdropping scenario in which both legitimate and unauthorized receivers are located on the same receiving plane. Secrecy outage probability and strictly positive secrecy capacity are expressed in exact closed-form expressions in this work. The results show that the FSO system has acceptable secrecy performance in moderate and light fog, with potential reach distances ranging from hundreds of meters to a few kilometers. Monte-Carlo simulations are used to verify the numerical results.