Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity

Simulation Framework for Thermal Quasi-Particle Microwave Loss in Multimaterial Superconducting Quantum Circuit Elements

Haoran Duan, Ritika Dhundhwal, Gabriel Cadilha Marques, D. Fuchs, Ioan M. Pop, Thomas J.G. Reisinger, Jasmin Aghassi‐Hagmann

Published Aug 29, 2025• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Superconducting quantum circuits constitute one of the most advanced and promising platforms for building faulttolerant quantum computers. However, the associated relatively short coherence times remain a major challenge. Therefore quantifying the various responsible loss mechanisms is key, which can be achieved effectively by refined loss modeling. An important source of dissipation is thermal quasi-particles, for which many simulation tools exist. Here we improve on these by integrating two of them in a self-consistent manner into an automated workflow for a circuit composed of two materials. Namely, the workflow consists of a numerical simulation of the Mattis-Bardeen surface impedance and electromagnetic finite element simulation using Ansys HFSS to predict temperature-dependent quasi-particle loss from normal state material properties. As a test, we use it to simulate the quality factors as a function of the temperature of superconducting resonators composed of tantalum. Tantalum resonators are often found to be dominated by quasi-particle loss at a significantly lower temperature (less than 1 K) than what would be expected from the bulk critical temperature (4.4 K) observed to good approximation in DC transport measurements. A likely cause is a defect phase with a low critical temperature, potentially associated with the tantalum beta phase. By fitting the temperature-dependent loss data to the workflow results, we estimate the concentration of the defect phase. This is an important step forward in correlating materials design and microwave loss.

DOI
10.1109/tasc.2025.3604329

Related papers

On-Chip Microwave Sensing of Nonequilibrium Quasiparticles in α-Tantalum Superconducting Circuits on Silicon for Scalable Quantum Technologies

Shima Poorgholam-Khanjari, Paniz Foshat, Mingqi Zhang +3 more

High Resolution Image Download MS PowerPoint Slide The performance and scalability of superconducting quantum circuits are fundamentally constrained by nonequilibrium quasiparticles, which induce microwave losses that limit resonator quality factors and qubit coherence times. Understanding and mitigating these excitations is therefore central to advancing scalable quantum technologies. Here, we demonstrate on-chip microwave sensing of quasiparticles in high- Q α -tantalum coplanar waveguide resonators on silicon, operated in the single-photon regime. Temperature-dependent measurements reveal persistent nonequilibrium quasiparticles at millikelvin temperatures, producing a measurable suppression of the internal quality factor ( Q i ) relative to theoretical expectations. By benchmarking across materials, we find that the quasiparticle density in α-Ta is approximately one-third that of NbN at equivalent normalized temperatures ( T / T c ), directly correlating with reduced microwave loss. Our methodology establishes a scalable platform for probing quasiparticle dynamics and points toward new routes for engineering superconducting circuits with improved coherence, with impact on qubit readout resonators, kinetic-inductance detectors, and emerging quantum processors and sensors.

arXiv:2509.07669•ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces•Jan 5, 2026•3 citations

Disentangling Losses in Tantalum Superconducting Circuits

Kevin D. Crowley, Russell A. McLellan, Aveek Dutta +19 more

Superconducting qubits are a leading system for realizing large-scale quantum processors, but overall gate fidelities suffer from coherence times limited by microwave dielectric loss.Recently discovered tantalum-based qubits exhibit record lifetimes exceeding 0.3 ms.Here, we perform systematic, detailed measurements of superconducting tantalum resonators in order to disentangle sources of loss that limit state-of-the-art tantalum devices.By studying the dependence of loss on temperature, microwave photon number, and device geometry, we quantify materials-related losses and observe that the losses are dominated by several types of saturable two-level systems (TLSs), with evidence that both surface and bulk related TLSs contribute to loss.Moreover, we show that surface TLSs can be altered with chemical processing.With four different surface conditions, we quantitatively extract the linear absorption associated with different surface TLS sources.Finally, we quantify the impact of the chemical processing at singlephoton powers, the relevant conditions for qubit device performance.In this regime, we measure resonators with internal quality factors ranging from 5 to 15 × 10 6 , comparable to the best qubits reported.In these devices, the surface and bulk TLS contributions to loss are comparable, showing that systematic improvements in materials on both fronts are necessary to improve qubit coherence further.

arXiv:2301.07848•Physical Review X•Oct 6, 2023•108 citations

High-quality superconducting tantalum resonators with beta phase defects

Ritika Dhundhwal, Haoran Duan, Lucas Brauch +16 more

For practical superconducting quantum processors, orders of magnitude improvement in coherence is required, motivating efforts to optimize hardware design and explore new materials. Among the latter, the coherence of superconducting transmon qubits has been shown to improve by forming the qubit capacitor pads from α-tantalum, avoiding the metastable β-phase that forms when depositing tantalum at room temperature, and has been previously identified to be a source of microwave losses. In this work, we show lumped element resonators containing β-phase tantalum in the form of inclusions near the metal–substrate interface with internal quality factors (Qi) up to 5.0 ± 2.5×106 in the single photon regime. They perform at least as good as resonators with no sign of the β-phase in x-ray diffraction and thermal quasi-particle loss. Our results indicate that small concentrations of β-phase can be beneficial, enhancing critical magnetic fields and potentially, for improving coherence in tantalum-based superconducting circuits.

arXiv:2502.17247•Applied Physics Letters•Nov 24, 2025•13 citations

Quasiparticle quality factors in superconducting resonators: effects of bath temperature and readout power

Zhenyuan Sun, S. Withington, Songyuan Zhao

Abstract The performance of superconducting resonators underpins a wide range of modern quantum technologies, yet their quality factor often deviates at low temperatures from standard Mattis–Bardeen predictions. This discrepancy is often attributed to nonthermal quasiparticles generated by microwave readout power, which limits the sensitivity of superconducting devices. We present a macroscopic model based on modified Rothwarf–Taylor equations that incorporates a power-dependent phonon generation term, providing an explicit relationship between quality factor, bath temperature and readout power. The model shows excellent agreement with temperature sweep measurements of NbN microstrip resonators with β -Ta terminations over a wide dynamic range of readout power levels, accurately capturing the transition between thermally-dominated and microwave-induced loss regimes. This framework provides a predictive tool for optimising superconducting resonators and advancing the design of high- Q devices for quantum sensing and quantum information processing.

arXiv:2605.08591•Superconductor Science and Technology•Oct 21, 2026•1 citation

Vortex motion induced losses in tantalum resonators

Faranak Bahrami, Matthew P. Bland, Nana Shumiya +17 more

Tantalum (Ta) based superconducting circuits have been demonstrated to enable record qubit coherence times and quality factors, motivating a careful study of the microscopic origin of the remaining losses that limit their performance. We have recently shown that the losses in Ta-based resonators are dominated by two-level systems (TLSs) at low microwave powers and millikelvin temperatures. We also observe that some devices exhibit loss that is exponentially activated at a lower temperature inconsistent with the superconducting critical temperature (Tc) of the constituent film. Specifically, dc resistivity measurements show a Tc of over 4 K, while microwave measurements of resonators fabricated from these films show losses that increase exponentially with temperature with an activation energy as low as 0.3 K. Here, we present a comparative study of the structural and thermodynamic properties of Ta-based resonators and identify vortex motion-induced loss as the source of thermally activated microwave loss. Through careful magnetoresistance and x-ray diffraction measurements, we observe that the increased loss occurs for films that are in the clean limit, where the superconducting coherence length is shorter than the mean free path. Vortex motion-induced losses are suppressed for films in the dirty limit, which show evidence of structural defects that can pin vortices. We verify this hypothesis by explicitly pinning vortices via patterning and find that we can suppress the loss by microfabrication.

arXiv:2503.03168•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jan 7, 2026•14 citations

Material Loss Model Calibration for Tantalum Superconducting Resonators

Guy Moshel, Sergei Masis, Moshe Schechter +1 more

Material research is a key frontier in advancing superconducting qubit and circuit performance. In this work, we develop a simple and broadly applicable framework for accurately characterizing two-level system (TLS) loss using internal quality factor measurements of superconducting transmission line resonators over a range of temperatures and readout powers. We applied this method to a series of $α$-Ta resonators that span a wide frequency range, thus providing a methodology for probing the loss mechanisms in the fabrication process of this emerging material for superconducting quantum circuits. We introduce an analytical model that captures the loss behavior without relying on numerical simulations, enabling straightforward interpretation and calibration. Additionally, our measurements reveal empirical frequency-dependent trends in key parameters of the model, suggesting contributions from mechanisms beyond the standard tunneling model of TLSs.

arXiv:2507.12141•Jul 16, 2025•1 citation
Superconducting quantum circuits constitute one of the most advanced and promising platforms for building faulttolerant quantum computers. However, the associated relatively short coherence times remain a major challenge. Therefore quantifying the various responsible loss mechanisms is key, which can be achieved effectively by refined loss modeling. An important source of dissipation is thermal quasi-particles, for which many simulation tools exist. Here we improve on these by integrating two of them in a self-consistent manner into an automated workflow for a circuit composed of two materials. Namely, the workflow consists of a numerical simulation of the Mattis-Bardeen surface impedance and electromagnetic finite element simulation using Ansys HFSS to predict temperature-dependent quasi-particle loss from normal state material properties. As a test, we use it to simulate the quality factors as a function of the temperature of superconducting resonators composed of tantalum. Tantalum resonators are often found to be dominated by quasi-particle loss at a significantly lower temperature (less than 1 K) than what would be expected from the bulk critical temperature (4.4 K) observed to good approximation in DC transport measurements. A likely cause is a defect phase with a low critical temperature, potentially associated with the tantalum beta phase. By fitting the temperature-dependent loss data to the workflow results, we estimate the concentration of the defect phase. This is an important step forward in correlating materials design and microwave loss.
High Resolution Image Download MS PowerPoint Slide The performance and scalability of superconducting quantum circuits are fundamentally constrained by nonequilibrium quasiparticles, which induce microwave losses that limit resonator quality factors and qubit coherence times. Understanding and mitigating these excitations is therefore central to advancing scalable quantum technologies. Here, we demonstrate on-chip microwave sensing of quasiparticles in high- Q α -tantalum coplanar waveguide resonators on silicon, operated in the single-photon regime. Temperature-dependent measurements reveal persistent nonequilibrium quasiparticles at millikelvin temperatures, producing a measurable suppression of the internal quality factor ( Q i ) relative to theoretical expectations. By benchmarking across materials, we find that the quasiparticle density in α-Ta is approximately one-third that of NbN at equivalent normalized temperatures ( T / T c ), directly correlating with reduced microwave loss. Our methodology establishes a scalable platform for probing quasiparticle dynamics and points toward new routes for engineering superconducting circuits with improved coherence, with impact on qubit readout resonators, kinetic-inductance detectors, and emerging quantum processors and sensors.
Superconducting qubits are a leading system for realizing large-scale quantum processors, but overall gate fidelities suffer from coherence times limited by microwave dielectric loss.Recently discovered tantalum-based qubits exhibit record lifetimes exceeding 0.3 ms.Here, we perform systematic, detailed measurements of superconducting tantalum resonators in order to disentangle sources of loss that limit state-of-the-art tantalum devices.By studying the dependence of loss on temperature, microwave photon number, and device geometry, we quantify materials-related losses and observe that the losses are dominated by several types of saturable two-level systems (TLSs), with evidence that both surface and bulk related TLSs contribute to loss.Moreover, we show that surface TLSs can be altered with chemical processing.With four different surface conditions, we quantitatively extract the linear absorption associated with different surface TLS sources.Finally, we quantify the impact of the chemical processing at singlephoton powers, the relevant conditions for qubit device performance.In this regime, we measure resonators with internal quality factors ranging from 5 to 15 × 10 6 , comparable to the best qubits reported.In these devices, the surface and bulk TLS contributions to loss are comparable, showing that systematic improvements in materials on both fronts are necessary to improve qubit coherence further.
For practical superconducting quantum processors, orders of magnitude improvement in coherence is required, motivating efforts to optimize hardware design and explore new materials. Among the latter, the coherence of superconducting transmon qubits has been shown to improve by forming the qubit capacitor pads from α-tantalum, avoiding the metastable β-phase that forms when depositing tantalum at room temperature, and has been previously identified to be a source of microwave losses. In this work, we show lumped element resonators containing β-phase tantalum in the form of inclusions near the metal–substrate interface with internal quality factors (Qi) up to 5.0 ± 2.5×106 in the single photon regime. They perform at least as good as resonators with no sign of the β-phase in x-ray diffraction and thermal quasi-particle loss. Our results indicate that small concentrations of β-phase can be beneficial, enhancing critical magnetic fields and potentially, for improving coherence in tantalum-based superconducting circuits.
Abstract The performance of superconducting resonators underpins a wide range of modern quantum technologies, yet their quality factor often deviates at low temperatures from standard Mattis–Bardeen predictions. This discrepancy is often attributed to nonthermal quasiparticles generated by microwave readout power, which limits the sensitivity of superconducting devices. We present a macroscopic model based on modified Rothwarf–Taylor equations that incorporates a power-dependent phonon generation term, providing an explicit relationship between quality factor, bath temperature and readout power. The model shows excellent agreement with temperature sweep measurements of NbN microstrip resonators with β -Ta terminations over a wide dynamic range of readout power levels, accurately capturing the transition between thermally-dominated and microwave-induced loss regimes. This framework provides a predictive tool for optimising superconducting resonators and advancing the design of high- Q devices for quantum sensing and quantum information processing.
Tantalum (Ta) based superconducting circuits have been demonstrated to enable record qubit coherence times and quality factors, motivating a careful study of the microscopic origin of the remaining losses that limit their performance. We have recently shown that the losses in Ta-based resonators are dominated by two-level systems (TLSs) at low microwave powers and millikelvin temperatures. We also observe that some devices exhibit loss that is exponentially activated at a lower temperature inconsistent with the superconducting critical temperature (Tc) of the constituent film. Specifically, dc resistivity measurements show a Tc of over 4 K, while microwave measurements of resonators fabricated from these films show losses that increase exponentially with temperature with an activation energy as low as 0.3 K. Here, we present a comparative study of the structural and thermodynamic properties of Ta-based resonators and identify vortex motion-induced loss as the source of thermally activated microwave loss. Through careful magnetoresistance and x-ray diffraction measurements, we observe that the increased loss occurs for films that are in the clean limit, where the superconducting coherence length is shorter than the mean free path. Vortex motion-induced losses are suppressed for films in the dirty limit, which show evidence of structural defects that can pin vortices. We verify this hypothesis by explicitly pinning vortices via patterning and find that we can suppress the loss by microfabrication.
Material research is a key frontier in advancing superconducting qubit and circuit performance. In this work, we develop a simple and broadly applicable framework for accurately characterizing two-level system (TLS) loss using internal quality factor measurements of superconducting transmission line resonators over a range of temperatures and readout powers. We applied this method to a series of ααα-Ta resonators that span a wide frequency range, thus providing a methodology for probing the loss mechanisms in the fabrication process of this emerging material for superconducting quantum circuits. We introduce an analytical model that captures the loss behavior without relying on numerical simulations, enabling straightforward interpretation and calibration. Additionally, our measurements reveal empirical frequency-dependent trends in key parameters of the model, suggesting contributions from mechanisms beyond the standard tunneling model of TLSs.