Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The London Edinburgh and Dublin Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science

CX.Consequences of a Matrix Mechanics and a radiating harmonic oscillator without the quantum postulate

A. Press

Published Dec 1, 1927• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Summary In order to avoid postulating quantum conditions from the start, as done in the Heisenberg-Born-Jordan-Dirac Matrix Mechanics, the writer conceived the idea of giving concrete visualization to the elements of the pq-qp matrix by relating them to a classical formula leading to an action (see paper published in the Phil. Mag. for Sept. 1924). This required a slightly modified way of defining the unit matrix.

DOI
10.1080/14786441208564424

Related papers

Consequences of a matrix mechanics and a radiating harmonic oscillator without the quantum postulate.

Abraham. Press

In order to avoid postulating quantum conditions from the start, as done in the Heisenberg-Born-Jordan-Dirac Matrix Mechanics, the writer conceived the idea of giving concrete visualization to the elements of the pq-qp matrix by relating them to a classical formula leading to an action. (See paper published in the Phil. Mag. for Sept., 1924). This required a slightly modified way of defining the unit matrix. If we consider a portion of a radiating gas capable of sending out a series of wave-lengths according to an observed law, then we may attribute to each periodicity a sine element of the p and q matrices. [...]

•Jan 1, 1927•0 citations

Quantum Mechanics in the Heisenberg (Matrix) Picture

Ana María Cetto, Luis de la Peña

Chapter 3 introduces the student to the matrix formulation of quantum mechanics, pioneered by Heisenberg in collaboration with Born and Jordan. It provides the basic formal elements of the Heisenberg description in terms of operators and their matrix representation, derives the Heisenberg inequality, and applies the formalism to the harmonic oscillator as a central and particularly simple quantum problem. It introduces the state vectors and their Hilbert space, and concludes with a brief discussion hinting at the physical significance of the replacement of classical continuous dynamical variables with operators as a manifestation of the coupling of the particle to the radiation field.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Dec 18, 2025•0 citations

The 1925 revolution of matrix mechanics and how to celebrate it in modern quantum mechanics classes

J. Tran, Leanne Doughty, James K. Freericks

In 1925, Heisenberg, Born, and Jordan developed matrix mechanics as a strategy to solve quantum-mechanical problems. While finite-sized matrix formulations are commonly taught in quantum instruction, following the logic and detailed steps of the original matrix mechanics has become a lost art. In preparation for the 100th anniversary of the discovery of quantum mechanics, we present a modernized discussion of how matrix mechanics is formulated, how it is used to solve quantum-mechanical problems, and how it can be employed as the starting point for a postulate-based formulation of quantum-mechanics instruction. We focus on the harmonic oscillator to describe how quantum mechanics advanced from the Bohr–Sommerfeld quantization condition, to matrix mechanics, to the current abstract ladder-operator approach. We also describe a number of different activities that can be included in the quantum mechanics classroom to celebrate this centennial.

American Journal of Physics•Dec 23, 2024•4 citations

A glimpse of matrix mechanics via the harmonic oscillator

Elina Palmgren, Ricardo Karam

In this paper, we provide a glimpse of the original formulation of quantum mechanics (a.k.a. matrix mechanics), as proposed by Heisenberg, Born, and Jordan in 1925, by showing how it solves the quantum harmonic oscillator. This presentation can shed light on the relationship between different formulations and give students a deeper understanding of quantum mechanics.

American Journal of Physics•Dec 23, 2024•1 citation

Matrix Formulation of Quantum Dynamics

Duojie Jia, Latai You

Quantum mechanics can be formulated either in terms of matrix mechanics or in terms of wave mechanics. This chapter centers on a discussion of the historical origins, mathematical structure, and extension to non-Hermitian quantum theory of matrix mechanics. The development of atomic discrete spectra and the old quantum theory showed that classical mechanics could not account for the discreteness of atomic energy levels and spectral lines, which motivated Heisenberg, Born, Jordan, and others to establish matrix mechanics centered on noncommuting physical quantities. Combining the Bohr atomic model, angular momentum quantization, and radiative transitions, one can see how matrix mechanics describes the energy level structure and quantum transitions of atomic systems, and how the Heisenberg equation of motion gives the fundamental form of quantum dynamics. The example of the harmonic oscillator further shows that the discreteness of the energy spectrum can be obtained directly from the matrix method, thereby establishing a clear connection among transition frequencies, matrix elements, and radiation-induced transitions. The matrix representation corresponds to the operator theory in Hilbert space, where state vectors, inner products, complete bases, and spectral decomposition constitute the fundamental mathematical framework of quantum mechanics. For closed quantum systems, physical observables are generally required to be represented by Hermitian or self-adjoint operators, so as to ensure that their eigenvalues possess the physically acceptable property of being real numbers. The Hermiticity of an operator is also closely related to its domain and boundary conditions, which provides a mathematical possibility for the emergence of non-Hermitian Hamiltonians. Based on these discussions, this chapter further explains how non-Hermitian dynamics is connected with open systems, dissipative processes, and special boundary conditions, thereby demonstrating the natural connection between traditional matrix mechanics and modern non-Hermitian quantum theory.

IntechOpen eBooks•Sep 15, 2026•0 citations

Hidden Variables Modelofthe Harmonic Oscillator

Fosco Ruzzene

A hidden variables matrix mechanics model of the harmonic oscillator is presented as a counter-example in examining fundamental assumptions of quantum mechanics. Solutions are obtained which can be interpreted as describing continuous motion of a particle at all times located at points in space. While this is contrary to the basic postulate of Heisenberg, the experimental results of the standard matrix mechanics treatment are nevertheless reproduced. The proposed model is motivated by the foundational issues raised by Bell. Inequalities violation is however, attributed to the mathematical representation of outcome quantities as metric variables rather than the consensus assumption of local causality. Examining the consequence of this alternative conclusion on an actual quantum system creates an overlapping between Bell inspired foundational issues and the original postulates of Heisenberg and Born. Heisenberg’s basic postulates – randomness of transitions and treating the system as an ensemble – are critical. Bohr’s assumption that transitions occur instantaneously, together with Heisenberg’s non-path postulate where the particle can be measured at spatially separated locations without continuous movement between locations, are discarded. The proposed hidden variables are non-contextual. These results question the commonly accepted inequalities violation conclusions that any local and/or non-contextual hidden variables theory cannot reproduce quantum predictions. That the wave function gives a complete description of the quantum state is likewise not supported by the model. Heisenberg’s measurable-only quantities are interpreted as arising from a substructure of periodic endogenous motion of the system.

•Jun 1, 2020•0 citations
Summary In order to avoid postulating quantum conditions from the start, as done in the Heisenberg-Born-Jordan-Dirac Matrix Mechanics, the writer conceived the idea of giving concrete visualization to the elements of the pq-qp matrix by relating them to a classical formula leading to an action (see paper published in the Phil. Mag. for Sept. 1924). This required a slightly modified way of defining the unit matrix.
In order to avoid postulating quantum conditions from the start, as done in the Heisenberg-Born-Jordan-Dirac Matrix Mechanics, the writer conceived the idea of giving concrete visualization to the elements of the pq-qp matrix by relating them to a classical formula leading to an action. (See paper published in the Phil. Mag. for Sept., 1924). This required a slightly modified way of defining the unit matrix. If we consider a portion of a radiating gas capable of sending out a series of wave-lengths according to an observed law, then we may attribute to each periodicity a sine element of the p and q matrices. [...]
Chapter 3 introduces the student to the matrix formulation of quantum mechanics, pioneered by Heisenberg in collaboration with Born and Jordan. It provides the basic formal elements of the Heisenberg description in terms of operators and their matrix representation, derives the Heisenberg inequality, and applies the formalism to the harmonic oscillator as a central and particularly simple quantum problem. It introduces the state vectors and their Hilbert space, and concludes with a brief discussion hinting at the physical significance of the replacement of classical continuous dynamical variables with operators as a manifestation of the coupling of the particle to the radiation field.
In 1925, Heisenberg, Born, and Jordan developed matrix mechanics as a strategy to solve quantum-mechanical problems. While finite-sized matrix formulations are commonly taught in quantum instruction, following the logic and detailed steps of the original matrix mechanics has become a lost art. In preparation for the 100th anniversary of the discovery of quantum mechanics, we present a modernized discussion of how matrix mechanics is formulated, how it is used to solve quantum-mechanical problems, and how it can be employed as the starting point for a postulate-based formulation of quantum-mechanics instruction. We focus on the harmonic oscillator to describe how quantum mechanics advanced from the Bohr–Sommerfeld quantization condition, to matrix mechanics, to the current abstract ladder-operator approach. We also describe a number of different activities that can be included in the quantum mechanics classroom to celebrate this centennial.
Quantum mechanics can be formulated either in terms of matrix mechanics or in terms of wave mechanics. This chapter centers on a discussion of the historical origins, mathematical structure, and extension to non-Hermitian quantum theory of matrix mechanics. The development of atomic discrete spectra and the old quantum theory showed that classical mechanics could not account for the discreteness of atomic energy levels and spectral lines, which motivated Heisenberg, Born, Jordan, and others to establish matrix mechanics centered on noncommuting physical quantities. Combining the Bohr atomic model, angular momentum quantization, and radiative transitions, one can see how matrix mechanics describes the energy level structure and quantum transitions of atomic systems, and how the Heisenberg equation of motion gives the fundamental form of quantum dynamics. The example of the harmonic oscillator further shows that the discreteness of the energy spectrum can be obtained directly from the matrix method, thereby establishing a clear connection among transition frequencies, matrix elements, and radiation-induced transitions. The matrix representation corresponds to the operator theory in Hilbert space, where state vectors, inner products, complete bases, and spectral decomposition constitute the fundamental mathematical framework of quantum mechanics. For closed quantum systems, physical observables are generally required to be represented by Hermitian or self-adjoint operators, so as to ensure that their eigenvalues possess the physically acceptable property of being real numbers. The Hermiticity of an operator is also closely related to its domain and boundary conditions, which provides a mathematical possibility for the emergence of non-Hermitian Hamiltonians. Based on these discussions, this chapter further explains how non-Hermitian dynamics is connected with open systems, dissipative processes, and special boundary conditions, thereby demonstrating the natural connection between traditional matrix mechanics and modern non-Hermitian quantum theory.
A hidden variables matrix mechanics model of the harmonic oscillator is presented as a counter-example in examining fundamental assumptions of quantum mechanics. Solutions are obtained which can be interpreted as describing continuous motion of a particle at all times located at points in space. While this is contrary to the basic postulate of Heisenberg, the experimental results of the standard matrix mechanics treatment are nevertheless reproduced. The proposed model is motivated by the foundational issues raised by Bell. Inequalities violation is however, attributed to the mathematical representation of outcome quantities as metric variables rather than the consensus assumption of local causality. Examining the consequence of this alternative conclusion on an actual quantum system creates an overlapping between Bell inspired foundational issues and the original postulates of Heisenberg and Born. Heisenberg’s basic postulates – randomness of transitions and treating the system as an ensemble – are critical. Bohr’s assumption that transitions occur instantaneously, together with Heisenberg’s non-path postulate where the particle can be measured at spatially separated locations without continuous movement between locations, are discarded. The proposed hidden variables are non-contextual. These results question the commonly accepted inequalities violation conclusions that any local and/or non-contextual hidden variables theory cannot reproduce quantum predictions. That the wave function gives a complete description of the quantum state is likewise not supported by the model. Heisenberg’s measurable-only quantities are interpreted as arising from a substructure of periodic endogenous motion of the system.