Nb and NbN junction development for MM-wave mixers

Z. H. Barber, Mark G. Blamire, Jan E. Evetts

Published Oct 2, 1992• 0 citations

Abstract

Within the past few years all-refractory superconductor-insulator-superconductor (SIS) tunnel junctions based on Nb/Al/AlO/sub x//Nb technology have displaced lead alloy devices as the preferred junctions for SIS mixers. There is growing interest in materials with higher superconducting energy gaps. NbN has a high gap ( approximately 3 meV) and higher critical temperature than Nb. Its main drawback, apart from the greater complexity of the material itself, stems from its short superconducting coherence length which results in a decrease in the measured gap voltage in proximity barrier structures, as generally used for Nb-based junctions. For this reason, most recent work has concentrated on the direct deposition of MgO as a tunnel barrier. The authors summarise work on Nb devices for MM-wave mixers and then report recent work performed at Cambridge on the fabrication of high quality NbN device structures.

Related papers

All refractory NbN/MgO/NbN tunnel junctions

Henry George LeDuc, J. A. Stern, S. Thakoor +1 more

We report the fabrication of all-refractory superconductor-insulator-superconductor tunnel junctions of the form NbN/MgO/NbN. The MgO insulating barrier was deposited by e-beam evaporation. High quality junctions were fabricated with sum gaps of 5.2 meV, and a small subgap leakage parameter (Vm=30 mV, measured at 3mV). These devices are for eventual use as quasiparticle mixer elements in millimeter/submiltimeter wave heterodyne receivers. Fabrication techniques and current-voltage characteristics are discussed. We also propose a new growth mode for MgO films on NbN.

IEEE Transactions on MagneticsMar 1, 198738 citations

Fabrication and testing of NbN/MgO/NbN tunnel junctions for use as high-frequency heterodyne detectors

Jeffrey A. Stern

This thesis describes the development and testing of NbN/MgO/NbN tunnel junctions for use as superconductor-insulator-superconductor (SIS) mixers. SIS mixers are the most sensitive heterodyne detectors in the millimeter wavelength region. Most SIS mixers use Pb alloy tunnel junction. These tunnel junctions have several problems associated with the soft nature of Pb and its low superconducting transition temperature. NbN-based tunnel junctions are being developed to overcome these difficulties. These devices are intended to be used as mixers at millimeter and submillimeter wavelengths. This thesis describes the fabrication process involved in making NbN junctions, and the results of measurements on these devices. The purpose of these measurements is to determine the future possibilities of NbN tunnel junctions as high-frequency mixers. The first chapter is an introduction to SIS mixers and explains how tunnel junction properties affect mixer performance. The basic theory of tunneling and mixing in SIS mixers is first presented. A description of quantum mixer theory is included in this presentation. This theory makes several interesting predictions that cannot be explained using classical theories. This is followed by a description of how real SIS tunnel junctions differ from ideal junctions. The physical origin of these differences is discussed, along with how they affect SIS mixer performance. Finally, the advantages and disadvantages of the various superconducting materials available are discussed. The decision to develop NbN devices is based on these material properties. The second chapter describes the methods used to fabricate small-area NbN/MgO/NbN tunnel junctions. The chapter begins with a description of the various methods that have been used to deposit NbN films. Reactive magnetron sputtering is chosen as the best method for tunnel junction fabrication. Details on the vacuum systems and the methods used for depositing superconducting NbN are discussed. Next, the process used for depositing junction trilayers (NbN/MgO/NbN) is described. The probable growth mode of MgO on NbN is presented. The importance of this growth mode to the junction quality is explained in some detail. Next, standard junction processing steps are reported. The details and limitations of each step are put forth. The standard process allows for the fabrication of 1 [square micron] tunnel junctions. Finally, this chapter discusses several methods of fabaricating submicron junctions that are being pursued. The status of this work is given. The third chapter describes the characterization of NbN films and NbN/Mg0/NbN tunnel junctions. Film properties are described first. The correlation of these properties to deposition conditions is discussed in some detail. Next, values for the various features of the I-V characteristic are given; typical and exceptional values are noted. How these features limit mixer results is described in detail. Several important device attributes were measured using superconducting-quantum-interference-devices (SQUIDs). These attributes are the junction's specific capacitance and the film's magnetic penetration depth. The theory and results of measuring specific capacitance and penetration depth are presented. Following the SQUID results is a large section on RP testing. Mixer tests were made at 205 GHz. The receiver design used, integral inductive tuning circuit used and results are discussed. These results are well understood, with the exception of the temperature dependence of the mixer performance. Finally, measurements of the uniformity of many junctions on a single wafer are presented. The importance of junction uniformity is also described. The final chapter discusses the ultimate limits on NbN mixers, and tells what future work must be done to achieve these limits. The primary high-frequency limit on NbN junctions is the capacitance of NbN/MgO/NbN junctions. The limit imposed by the junction capacitance and circuits used to tune out this capacitance are discussed. Also, the low-frequency limits on NbN junctions are discussed. The status of submicron devices is presented. Junction area is the most immediate limitation on NbN mixer results. The possibility of using other barrier materials to increase the RC speed of NbN junctions is presented. Finally, the possibility of operating NbN junctions at temperatures above 4.2 K is discussed.

Jan 1, 19910 citations

NbN/MgO/NbN SIS tunnel junctions for submm wave mixers

J. A. Stern, B. D. Hunt, Henry George LeDuc +4 more

The authors report on the fabrication and testing of all-refractory NbN/MgO/NbN SIS (superconductor-insulator-superconductor) tunnel junctions for use as high-frequency mixers. Progress in the development of techniques for the fabrication of submicron-area tunnel junctions is described. Junction structures which have been investigated include mesa, crossline, and edge geometries. Using reactive sputtering techniques, NbN tunnel junctions with critical currents in excess of 10/sup 4/ A/cm/sup 2/ have been fabricated with V/sub m/ values as high as 65 mV and areas down to 0.1 mu m/sup 2/. Specific capacitance measurements on NbN/MgO/NbN mesa-type tunnel junctions give values in the range 60-90 fF/ mu m/sup 2/. These SIS tunnel junctions have been integrated with antennas and coupling structures for mixer tests in a waveguide receiver at 207 GHz. Preliminary mixer results are reported.>

IEEE Transactions on MagneticsMar 1, 198917 citations

Fabrication and characterization of high current-density, submicron, NbN/MgO/NbN tunnel junctions

Jeff A. Stern, Henry George LeDuc, A. Judas

At near-millimeter wavelengths, heterodyne receivers based on SIS tunnel junctions are the most sensitive available. However, in order to scale these results to submillimeter wavelengths, certain device properties should be scaled. The tunnel-junction's current density should be increased to reduce the RC product. The device's area should be reduced to efficiently couple power from the antenna to the mixer. Finally, the superconductor used should have a large energy gap to minimize RF losses. Most SIS mixers use Nb or Pb-alloy tunnel junctions; the gap frequency for these materials is approximately 725 GHz. Above the gap frequency, these materials exhibit losses similar to those in a normal metal. The gap frequency in NbN films is as-large-as 1440 GHz. Therefore, we have developed a process to fabricate small area (down to 0.13 sq microns), high current density, NbN/MgO/NbN tunnel junctions.

Jan 1, 199212 citations

0.5-THz waveguide SIS mixers with NbN/AlN/NbN technology

Jing Li, Masanori Takeda, Zhen Wang +1 more

Heterodyne mixers based on superconducting SIS (superconductor-insulator-superconductor) tunnel junctions have been demonstrated to be the most sensitive coherent detectors at millimeter and submillimeter wavelengths. In fact, conventional superconducting SIS mixers with Nb/AlOx/Nb junction and Nb/SiO2/Nb tuning circuit have shown good performances with the noise temperature reaching as low as three times the quantum limit below 0.7THz, which is the gap frequency of Nb-based SIS junctions. However, due to the large loss in Nb thin-film superconducting microstrip lines, the noise performance of Nb SIS mixers deteriorates significantly above 0.7THz. With a gap frequency double that of Nb-based SIS junctions, NbN-based SIS junctions are of particular interest for the development of heterodyne mixers in the terahertz region. Considering the bandwidth and output power of local-oscillator (LO) signal sources are quite limited around 1THz, we firstly develop a waveguide NbN-based SIS mixer at 0.5THz. Three types of SIS junctions, i.e., long junction, parallel-connected tunnel junction (PCTJ) and distributed junction array (DJ) are investigated. They are all comprised of NbN-AlN-NbN tri-layer fabricated on an MgO substrate and have the same current density (Jc) of 10kA/cm2. In this paper, we describe their design, fabrication and preliminary experimental results.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIENov 29, 20073 citations

S-I-S mm-Wave Mixers and Detectors.

D. W. Jillie, Harry Kroger, L. N. Smith +1 more

This program is part of an ongoing effort to fabricate all-refractory S-I-S devices for use as mm-wave detectors and mixers in the quantum regime, and operating in the temperature range of 8-10 K. There are four ongoing approaches to achieve this goal: (1) Development of high-quality NbN-barrier-Nb S-I-S junctions as an intermediate goal towards fabricating all-NbN junctions; (2) Actual development of all-NbN junctions using the results of (1) above as a guide; (3) Development of an in-house NbN deposition capability in order to speed the progress on (2) above; and (4) The use of existing all-NB digital circuit fabrication capability to design and fabricate mm-wave mixers to operate at T less than or approx. 4.2 K, thus gaining valuable experience that can be applied to the eventual design of all-NbN mixers. Sputtered NbN-a:Si-NB Josephson tunnel junctions fabricated using SRC's SNAP process (Selective Niobium Anodization Process) have been developed. All-NbN devices using the plain a:Si barrier have been developed to the point where they exhibit S-I-S tunnelling characteristics. Fourteen types of mm-wave mixer chips have been designed in collaboration with the Goddard Institute for Space Studies using the existing all -NB digital circuit fabrication process. Masks were fabricated, and a trial fabrication proved the integrity of the process. The viability of the proposed mounting scheme has been experimentally ascertained.

Sep 1, 19820 citations