We investigate qubit error bursts in 5- and 7-transmon processors of similar design, fabrication and packaging, but with different types of qubit Josephson junctions. Measurements for each are performed in two refrigerators to discern device-specific from refrigerator-dependent characteristics. The duration and rate of bursts are device specific but within the range of prior experiments and consistent with ionizing radiation. We observe two unforeseen signatures specifically in the processor with Dolan junctions. First, increasing the rate of $π$ pulsing in the detection scheme shortens the recovery time to equilibrium, which is explained by a quasiparticle pumping mechanism. The second signature is an anomalous time dependence in the burst rate: a surge happens days or weeks after cooldown, followed by a strong suppression that persists until thermal cycling.
We investigate qubit error bursts in 5- and 7-transmon processors of similar design, fabrication and packaging, but with different types of qubit Josephson junctions. Measurements for each are performed in two refrigerators to discern device-specific from refrigerator-dependent characteristics. The duration and rate of bursts are device specific but within the range of prior experiments and consistent with ionizing radiation. We observe two unforeseen signatures specifically in the processor with Dolan junctions. First, increasing the rate of π pulsing in the detection scheme shortens the recovery time to equilibrium, which is explained by a quasiparticle pumping mechanism. The second signature is an anomalous time dependence in the burst rate: a surge happens days or weeks after cooldown, followed by a strong suppression that persists until thermal cycling.
One of the roadblocks toward the implementation of a fault-tolerant superconducting quantum processor is impacts of ionizing radiation with the qubit substrate. Such impacts temporarily elevate the density of quasiparticles (QPs) across the device, leading to correlated qubit error bursts. The most damaging errors, T 1 errors, stem from QP tunneling across the qubit Josephson junctions (JJs). Recently, we demonstrated [M. McEwen, K. Miao, , ] that this type of error can be strongly suppressed by engineering the profile of superconducting gap at the JJs in a way that prevents QP tunneling. In this work, we identify a new type of impact-induced correlated error that persists in the presence of gap engineering. We observe that impacts shift the frequencies of the affected qubits, and thus lead to correlated phase errors. The frequency shifts are systematically negative, reach values up to 3 MHz, and last for ∼ 1 ms . We provide evidence that the shifts originate from QP-qubit interactions in the JJ region. Further, we demonstrate that the shift-induced phase errors can be detrimental to the performance of quantum error correction protocols.
Errors in superconducting qubits that are correlated in time and space can pose problems for quantum error correction codes. Radiation from cosmic and terrestrial sources can increase the quasiparticle (QP) density in a superconducting qubit device, resulting in an increased rate of QPs tunneling across proximal Josephson junctions (JJs) and causing correlated errors. Mechanical vibrations, such as those induced by the pulse tube (PT) in a dry dilution refrigerator, are also a known source of correlated errors. We measure two types of errors in the same device, linking the first to ionizing radiation and the second to PT operation. We present a method for distinguishing these two types of errors by their temporal, spatial, and frequency domain features, enabling physically motivated error-mitigation strategies. We also present accelerometer data to study the correlation between PT-induced vibrations and the errors. We measure arrays of transmon qubits where the difference in superconducting gap across the JJ is less than the qubit energy, as well as those where the gap is greater than the qubit energy, which has been shown to mitigate radiation-induced errors. The rate of both types of errors is reduced in these latter devices, suggesting that gap engineering is also protective against PT-induced errors.
Quasiparticle tunneling events are a source of decoherence and correlated errors in superconducting circuits. Understanding and ultimately mitigating these errors calls for real-time detection of quasiparticle tunneling events on individual devices. In this work, we simultaneously detect quasiparticle tunneling events in two co-housed, charge-sensitive transmons coupled to a common waveguide. We measure background quasiparticle tunneling rates at the single-hertz level, with temporal resolution of tens of microseconds. Using time-tagged coincidence analysis, we show that individual events are uncorrelated across devices, whereas burst episodes occur about once per minute and are largely correlated. These bursts have a characteristic lifetime of 7 ms and induce a thousand-fold increase in the quasiparticle tunneling rate across both devices. In addition, we identify a rarer subset of bursts which are accompanied by a shift in the offset charge, at approximately one event per hour. Our results establish a practical and extensible method to identify quasiparticle bursts in superconducting circuits, as well as their correlations and spatial structure, advancing routes to suppress correlated errors in superconducting quantum processors.
Micro-fabricated superconducting circuits have emerged as a leading candidate for quantum computers. However, typical error rates of 10-3 for quantum gates remain a challenge for performing error correction and need to be further decreased for achieving practical quantum computation. Improving qubit coherence times for superconducting qubits is a continuous endeavor in order to decrease error rates. As part of this effort, a topic addressed in this dissertation is the study of the generation mechanism and dynamics of non-equilibrium quasiparticles (QPs), which are electron-like excitations of a superconductor. This source of decoherence was studied by measuring the rate of single-electron changes in the parity state of multiple charge-sensitive transmon qubits under different conditions. The presence of non-equilibrium QPs in superconducting resonators and qubits operating at millikelvin temperature has been known for decades. Understanding the sources and dynamics of these QPs is crucial to evaluate and improve the performance of the devices. Specifically, for superconducting qubits, a single QP tunneling across the Josephson junction changes the total charge parity from even to odd or vice versa, and can induce energy relaxation and dephasing, limiting the coherence of the device. To study the dynamics of non-equilibrium QPs, I utilized a Ramsey-like pulse sequence to measure the rate of single-electron parity changes in transmon qubits, which had a weak charge dispersion, with different shunting capacitor geometries and materials. I started out by measuring a charge parity rate of ~ 33 s-1 for a grounded "x-mon" qubit and ~ 17 s-1 for a galvanically isolated "two-pads" qubit with our standard setup. These rates decreased to ~ 5 s-1 and ~ 2 s-1 for the x-mon and two-pads respectively when IR-filters and extra layers of shielding were installed. From my measurements, I found that the charge parity rates are sensitive to the geometry of the shunting capacitor, weakly depend on the amount of shielding surrounding the device, and independent of using Al or Ta for the superconducting shunting capacitor. To distinguish between two possible mechanisms for the parity switching, I measured the parity rates after cooling one of the qubit devices in an external magnetic field to induce vortices in the superconducting electrodes. After increasing the magnetic field above 23 μT, I measured a faster QP trapping rate and a much smaller T1, suggesting that at least one vortex was added to the superconducting electrode near the Josephson junction. On the other hand, the measured charge parity rates exhibited no clear dependence on the background QP trapping rates. These data suggest that a large portion of parity switching events occurs from QPs being produced at the Josephson junction, where pair-breaking radiation is rectified into QPs by the junction, as opposed to tunneling of QPs residing in the electrodes. To understand the difference in the measured parity rates, I simulated the absorption efficiency of pair-breaking radiation for my two designs and observed a similar difference in absorption rates when a single-mode blackbody radiation with an effective temperature T* ~ 300 mK was assumed to be illuminating the devices. This large T*, which is significantly higher than the device's nominal temperature of 20 mK, is consistent with values reported in the literature. However, its physical origin remains not fully understood. For the other part of my dissertation, I developed a new simplified process for making superconducting air bridges. Air bridges are used to suppress unwanted extraneous high frequency chip modes parasitic to superconducting quantum circuits that can couple to qubits and cause decoherence. Traditional ways of making air bridges utilize thermal reflow to create arched photoresist scaffolds that are limited in heights. This results in insufficient mechanical strength of the bridges which tend to collapse when spanning to larger lengths. My simplified fabrication method that utilizes two-photon lithography, a technique that enables creation of three-dimensional micron-scale structures, relaxes this limitation and is capable of making mechanically stable bridges with lengths up to 100 μm. The resulting Al air bridges, having a superconducting transition temperature of Tc = 1.08 mK and a dc residual resistivity ratio of 3.85, were confirmed to form a good electrical contact with the base metal layers and exhibit a small measurable amount of rf loss when placed over coplanar waveguide resonators, on par with other air bridge fabrication methods.
Ionizing radiation is a known source of correlated errors in superconducting quantum processors, inhibiting the functionality of quantum error correction surface codes. High-energy photons and charged particles deposit pair-breaking energy into these systems leading to excess quasiparticles near Josephson junctions that increase qubit decoherence. Previous investigations of this problem have relied on ambient, stochastic sources of ionizing radiation or alternative methods of quasiparticle generation. Here, we present a facility that couples an electron linear accelerator (linac) to a dilution refrigerator to study ionizing radiation in quantum systems. A single linac electron closely mimics the energy deposition characteristics of a typical cosmic-ray muon, and we demonstrate the facility's usefulness with a multi-qubit superconducting transmon chip. Characteristic radiation-induced relaxation errors are quickly and easily collected with the speed and timing information of the linac. Additionally, we present qubit excitation and detuning errors that can be difficult to detect without the on-demand source of ionizing radiation. These error signatures are shown to be dependent on the junction placement and surrounding superconducting gaps.
Ionizing radiation impacts create bursts of quasiparticle density in superconducting qubits. These bursts temporarily degrade qubit coherence, which can be detrimental for quantum error correction. Here, we experimentally resolve quasiparticle bursts in 3D gap-engineered transmon qubits by continuously monitoring qubit transitions. Gap engineering allows us to reduce the burst detection rate by a factor of 5. This reduction falls 4 orders of magnitude short of that expected if the quasiparticles were to quickly thermalize to the cryostat temperature. We associate the limited effect of gap engineering with the slow thermalization of the phonons in our chips after the burst.