Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2602.11696

Symmetry Spans and Enforced Gaplessness

Takamasa Ando, Kantaro Ohmori

Published Feb 12, 2026• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Anomaly matching for continuous symmetries has been the primary tool for establishing symmetry enforced gaplessness - the phenomenon where global symmetry alone forces a quantum system to be gapless in the infrared. We introduce a new mechanism based on symmetry spans: configurations in which a global symmetry $\mathcal{E}$ is simultaneously embedded into two larger symmetries, as $\mathcal{D}\hookleftarrow\mathcal{E}\hookrightarrow\mathcal{C}$. Any gapped phase with the full symmetry must, upon restriction to $\mathcal{E}$, arise as the restriction of both a gapped $\mathcal{C}$-symmetric phase and a gapped $\mathcal{D}$-symmetric phase. When no such compatible phase exists, gaplessness is enforced. This mechanism can operate with only discrete and non-anomalous continuous symmetries in the UV, both of which admit well-understood lattice realizations. We construct explicit symmetry spans enforcing gaplessness in 1+1 dimensions, exhibit their realization in conformal field theories, and provide lattice Hamiltonians with the relevant symmetry embeddings.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2602.11696

Related papers

Enforced Gaplessness by Combining Non-Anomalous Symmetries

Takamasa Ando, Kantaro Ohmori

Symmetry-enforced gaplessness is a phenomenon in which a quantum system is forced to be gapless due to its global symmetry. Previous works have mainly focused on anomalous symmetries. Another approach, using symmetry spans, which specify two embeddings of a common symmetry into two larger symmetries, was proposed by the authors. In this work, we show that a symmetry span can enforce gaplessness even when both larger symmetries are invertible and non-anomalous: each alone admits a trivially gapped phase, but because the embeddings differ by a twist associated with a symmetry-protected topological phase, the symmetry they generate admits no gapped phase with finitely many ground states. We present such a span of a finite group and $\mathrm{U}(1)^2$ in 1+1 dimensions, with continuum realizations and a lattice Hamiltonian, with a finite-dimensional local Hilbert space and finitely many parameters, that is gapless in any region of its parameter space. We also discuss a 2+1-dimensional example and spans of only finite symmetries.

arXiv:2611.03164•Nov 2, 2026•0 citations

When symmetry does the unexpected

Salvatore D. Pace

Symmetry is foundational in theoretical physics. In this thesis, we show how recent advances in symmetry have reinforced its power to classify, characterize, and constrain quantum systems non-perturbatively. We study symmetries, ranging from spatial symmetries to generalized symmetries, in both quantum field theory and quantum lattice systems. In particular, this thesis develops five sets of results. First, we show that ordinary ordered phases generically host emergent generalized symmetries in the infrared, associated with homotopy defects of the order-parameter space. We use these emergent generalized symmetries to characterize and classify defect-suppressed disorder transitions to phases with topological order and emergent gauge structures. Second, we turn to lattice anomalies and show how the chiral anomaly of a massless Dirac fermion in two spacetime dimensions can be realized on the lattice. In particular, we identify lattice realizations of the vector and axial symmetries and demonstrate how their anomaly is matched by the non-abelian Onsager algebra in the staggered fermion Hamiltonian. Third, we give a microscopic lattice understanding of T-duality in quantum spin chains using non-invertible symmetry. This non-invertible symmetry, together with lattice momentum and winding symmetries, also enforces gaplessness, hence providing a novel way to realize perturbative anomalies in quantum spin-chain models. Fourth, we show that in local lattice models of spinless fermions, fermion-number conservation combined with a non-onsite Majorana translation symmetry enforces a Fermi surface. This symmetry-enforced Fermi surface is a strong form of symmetry-enforced gaplessness. Finally, we introduce a framework of stratified symmetries and stratified anomalies to understand and discover new Lieb–Schultz–Mattis constraints. We apply this framework to modulated symmetries and find an explicit criterion for when local anomaly data imply obstructions to a trivial gapped phase. Together, these results demonstrate the broad applicability and power of symmetry and its generalizations, both for organizing quantum phases and for deriving robust non-perturbative constraints.

•May 1, 2026•0 citations

Non-Invertible Interfaces Between Symmetry-Enriched Critical Phases

Saranesh Prembabu, Shu-Heng Shao, Ruben Verresen

Gapless quantum phases can become distinct when internal symmetries are enforced, in analogy with gapped symmetry-protected topological (SPT) phases. However, this distinction does not always lead to protected edge modes, raising the question of how the bulk-boundary correspondence is generalized to gapless cases. We propose that the spatial interface between gapless phases -- rather than their boundaries -- provides a more robust fingerprint. We show that whenever two 1+1d conformal field theories (CFTs) differ in symmetry charge assignments of local operators or twisted sectors, any symmetry-preserving spatial interface between the theories must flow to a non-invertible defect. We illustrate this general result for different versions of the Ising CFT with $\mathbb{Z}_2 \times \mathbb{Z}_2^T$ symmetry, obtaining a complete classification of allowed conformal interfaces. When the Ising CFTs differ by nonlocal operator charges, the interface hosts 0+1d symmetry-breaking phases with finite-size splittings scaling as $1/L^3$, as well as continuous phase transitions between them. For general gapless phases differing by an SPT entangler, the interfaces between them can be mapped to conformal defects with a certain defect 't Hooft anomaly. This classification also gives implications for higher-dimensional examples, including symmetry-enriched variants of the 2+1d Ising CFT. Our results establish a physical indicator for symmetry-enriched criticality through symmetry-protected interfaces, giving a new handle on the interplay between topology and gapless phases.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2512.23706•Dec 30, 2025•10 citations

Holographic theory for continuous phase transitions: Emergence and symmetry protection of gaplessness

Arkya Chatterjee, Xiao-Gang Wen

Two global symmetries are holoequivalent if their algebras of local symmetric operators are isomorphic. A holoequivalent class of global symmetries is described by a topological order (TO) in one higher dimension (called symmetry TO), which leads to a symmetry/topological-order (Symm/TO) correspondence. We establish that (1) for systems with a symmetry described by symmetry TO $\mathcal{M}$, their gapped and gapless states are classified by condensable algebras $\mathcal{A}$, formed by elementary excitations in $\mathcal{M}$ with trivial self-/mutual statistics. These so-called $\mathcal{A}$ states can describe symmetry breaking orders, symmetry protected topological orders, symmetry enriched topological orders, gapless critical points, etc. in a unified way. (2) The local low-energy properties of an $\mathcal{A}$ state can be calculated from its reduced symmetry TO ${\mathcal{M}}_{/\mathcal{A}}$, using holographic modular bootstrap (holoMB) which takes ${\mathcal{M}}_{/\mathcal{A}}$ as an input. Here ${\mathcal{M}}_{/\mathcal{A}}$ is obtained from $\mathcal{M}$ by condensing excitations in $\mathcal{A}$. Notably, an $\mathcal{A}$ state must be gapless if ${\mathcal{M}}_{/\mathcal{A}}$ is nontrivial. This provides a unified understanding of the emergence and symmetry protection of gaplessness that applies to symmetries that are anomalous, higher-form, and/or noninvertible. (3) The relations between condensable algebras constrain the structure of the global phase diagram. We find that, for $1+1\mathrm{D} {\mathbb{Z}}_{2}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ symmetry with mixed anomaly, there is a stable continuous transition (deconfined quantum critical point) between the ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$-breaking-${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}^{\ensuremath{'}}$-symmetric phase and the ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$-symmetric-${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}^{\ensuremath{'}}$-breaking phase. The critical point is the same as a ${\mathbb{Z}}_{4}$ symmetry breaking critical point. (4) $1+1\mathrm{D}$ bosonic systems with ${S}_{3}$ symmetry have four gapped phases with unbroken symmetries ${S}_{3}, {\mathbb{Z}}_{3}, {\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$, and ${\mathbb{Z}}_{1}$. We find a duality between two transitions ${S}_{3}\ensuremath{\leftrightarrow}{\mathbb{Z}}_{1}$ and ${\mathbb{Z}}_{3}\ensuremath{\leftrightarrow}{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$: they are either both first order or both (stably) continuous, and in the latter case, they are described by the same conformal field theory (CFT). (5) The gapped and gapless states for $1+1\mathrm{D}$ bosonic systems with anomalous ${S}_{3}$ symmetries are obtained as well. For example, anomalous ${S}_{3}^{(1)}$ and ${S}_{3}^{(2)}$ symmetries can have symmetry protected chiral gapless states with only symmetric irrelevant and marginal operators.

arXiv:2205.06244•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Aug 2, 2023•136 citations

Anomalies of coset non-invertible symmetries

Po-Shen Hsin, Ryohei Kobayashi, Carolyn Zhang

Anomalies of global symmetries provide important information on the quantum dynamics. We show the dynamical constraints can be organized into three classes: genuine anomalies, fractional topological responses, and integer responses that can be realized in symmetry-protected topological (SPT) phases. Coset symmetry can be present in many physical systems including quantum spin liquids, and the coset symmetry can be a non-invertible symmetry. We introduce twists in coset symmetries, which modify the fusion rules and the generalized Frobenius-Schur indicators. We call such coset symmetries twisted coset symmetries, and they are labeled by the quadruple (G,K,\omega_{D+1},\alpha_D) ( G , K , ω D + 1 , α D ) in D D spacetime dimensions where G G is a group and K\subset G K ⊂ G is a discrete subgroup, \omega_{D+1} ω D + 1 is a (D+1) ( D + 1 ) -cocycle for group G G , and \alpha_{D} α D is a D D -cochain for group K K . We present several examples with twisted coset symmetries using lattice models and field theory, including both gapped and gapless systems (such as gapless symmetry-protected topological phases). We investigate the anomalies of general twisted coset symmetry, which presents obstructions to realizing the coset symmetry in (gapped) symmetry-protected topological phases. We show that finite coset symmetry G/K G / K becomes anomalous when G G cannot be expressed as the bicrossed product G=H\Join K G = H ⋈ K , and such anomalous coset symmetry leads to symmetry-enforced gaplessness in generic spacetime dimensions. We illustrate examples of anomalous coset symmetries with A_5/\Z_2 symmetry, with realizations in lattice models.

arXiv:2503.00105•SciPost Physics•Jan 13, 2026•25 citations

Symmetry-Enforced Fermi Surfaces

Minho Kim, Salvatore D. Pace, Shu-Heng Shao

We identify a symmetry that enforces every symmetric model to have a Fermi surface. These symmetry-enforced Fermi surfaces are realizations of a powerful form of symmetry-enforced gaplessness. The symmetry we construct exists in quantum lattice fermion models on a d-dimensional Bravais lattice, and is generated by the on-site U(1) fermion number symmetry and non-on-site Majorana translation symmetry. The resulting symmetry group is a noncompact Lie group closely related to the Onsager algebra. For a symmetry-enforced Fermi surface F, we show that this UV symmetry group always includes the subgroup of the ersatz Fermi liquid L_{F}U(1) symmetry group formed by even functions f(k)∈U(1) with k∈F. Furthermore, we comment on the topology of these symmetry-enforced Fermi surfaces, proving they generically exhibit at least two noncontractible components (i.e., open orbits).

arXiv:2512.04150•Physical Review Letters•Mar 25, 2026•10 citations
Anomaly matching for continuous symmetries has been the primary tool for establishing symmetry enforced gaplessness - the phenomenon where global symmetry alone forces a quantum system to be gapless in the infrared. We introduce a new mechanism based on symmetry spans: configurations in which a global symmetry E\mathcal{E}E is simultaneously embedded into two larger symmetries, as D↩E↪C\mathcal{D}\hookleftarrow\mathcal{E}\hookrightarrow\mathcal{C}D↩E↪C. Any gapped phase with the full symmetry must, upon restriction to E\mathcal{E}E, arise as the restriction of both a gapped C\mathcal{C}C-symmetric phase and a gapped D\mathcal{D}D-symmetric phase. When no such compatible phase exists, gaplessness is enforced. This mechanism can operate with only discrete and non-anomalous continuous symmetries in the UV, both of which admit well-understood lattice realizations. We construct explicit symmetry spans enforcing gaplessness in 1+1 dimensions, exhibit their realization in conformal field theories, and provide lattice Hamiltonians with the relevant symmetry embeddings.
Symmetry-enforced gaplessness is a phenomenon in which a quantum system is forced to be gapless due to its global symmetry. Previous works have mainly focused on anomalous symmetries. Another approach, using symmetry spans, which specify two embeddings of a common symmetry into two larger symmetries, was proposed by the authors. In this work, we show that a symmetry span can enforce gaplessness even when both larger symmetries are invertible and non-anomalous: each alone admits a trivially gapped phase, but because the embeddings differ by a twist associated with a symmetry-protected topological phase, the symmetry they generate admits no gapped phase with finitely many ground states. We present such a span of a finite group and U(1)2\mathrm{U}(1)^2U(1)2 in 1+1 dimensions, with continuum realizations and a lattice Hamiltonian, with a finite-dimensional local Hilbert space and finitely many parameters, that is gapless in any region of its parameter space. We also discuss a 2+1-dimensional example and spans of only finite symmetries.
Symmetry is foundational in theoretical physics. In this thesis, we show how recent advances in symmetry have reinforced its power to classify, characterize, and constrain quantum systems non-perturbatively. We study symmetries, ranging from spatial symmetries to generalized symmetries, in both quantum field theory and quantum lattice systems. In particular, this thesis develops five sets of results. First, we show that ordinary ordered phases generically host emergent generalized symmetries in the infrared, associated with homotopy defects of the order-parameter space. We use these emergent generalized symmetries to characterize and classify defect-suppressed disorder transitions to phases with topological order and emergent gauge structures. Second, we turn to lattice anomalies and show how the chiral anomaly of a massless Dirac fermion in two spacetime dimensions can be realized on the lattice. In particular, we identify lattice realizations of the vector and axial symmetries and demonstrate how their anomaly is matched by the non-abelian Onsager algebra in the staggered fermion Hamiltonian. Third, we give a microscopic lattice understanding of T-duality in quantum spin chains using non-invertible symmetry. This non-invertible symmetry, together with lattice momentum and winding symmetries, also enforces gaplessness, hence providing a novel way to realize perturbative anomalies in quantum spin-chain models. Fourth, we show that in local lattice models of spinless fermions, fermion-number conservation combined with a non-onsite Majorana translation symmetry enforces a Fermi surface. This symmetry-enforced Fermi surface is a strong form of symmetry-enforced gaplessness. Finally, we introduce a framework of stratified symmetries and stratified anomalies to understand and discover new Lieb–Schultz–Mattis constraints. We apply this framework to modulated symmetries and find an explicit criterion for when local anomaly data imply obstructions to a trivial gapped phase. Together, these results demonstrate the broad applicability and power of symmetry and its generalizations, both for organizing quantum phases and for deriving robust non-perturbative constraints.
Gapless quantum phases can become distinct when internal symmetries are enforced, in analogy with gapped symmetry-protected topological (SPT) phases. However, this distinction does not always lead to protected edge modes, raising the question of how the bulk-boundary correspondence is generalized to gapless cases. We propose that the spatial interface between gapless phases -- rather than their boundaries -- provides a more robust fingerprint. We show that whenever two 1+1d conformal field theories (CFTs) differ in symmetry charge assignments of local operators or twisted sectors, any symmetry-preserving spatial interface between the theories must flow to a non-invertible defect. We illustrate this general result for different versions of the Ising CFT with Z2×Z2T\mathbb{Z}_2 \times \mathbb{Z}_2^TZ2​×Z2T​ symmetry, obtaining a complete classification of allowed conformal interfaces. When the Ising CFTs differ by nonlocal operator charges, the interface hosts 0+1d symmetry-breaking phases with finite-size splittings scaling as 1/L31/L^31/L3, as well as continuous phase transitions between them. For general gapless phases differing by an SPT entangler, the interfaces between them can be mapped to conformal defects with a certain defect 't Hooft anomaly. This classification also gives implications for higher-dimensional examples, including symmetry-enriched variants of the 2+1d Ising CFT. Our results establish a physical indicator for symmetry-enriched criticality through symmetry-protected interfaces, giving a new handle on the interplay between topology and gapless phases.
Two global symmetries are holoequivalent if their algebras of local symmetric operators are isomorphic. A holoequivalent class of global symmetries is described by a topological order (TO) in one higher dimension (called symmetry TO), which leads to a symmetry/topological-order (Symm/TO) correspondence. We establish that (1) for systems with a symmetry described by symmetry TO M\mathcal{M}M, their gapped and gapless states are classified by condensable algebras A\mathcal{A}A, formed by elementary excitations in M\mathcal{M}M with trivial self-/mutual statistics. These so-called A\mathcal{A}A states can describe symmetry breaking orders, symmetry protected topological orders, symmetry enriched topological orders, gapless critical points, etc. in a unified way. (2) The local low-energy properties of an A\mathcal{A}A state can be calculated from its reduced symmetry TO M/A{\mathcal{M}}_{/\mathcal{A}}M/A​, using holographic modular bootstrap (holoMB) which takes M/A{\mathcal{M}}_{/\mathcal{A}}M/A​ as an input. Here M/A{\mathcal{M}}_{/\mathcal{A}}M/A​ is obtained from M\mathcal{M}M by condensing excitations in A\mathcal{A}A. Notably, an A\mathcal{A}A state must be gapless if M/A{\mathcal{M}}_{/\mathcal{A}}M/A​ is nontrivial. This provides a unified understanding of the emergence and symmetry protection of gaplessness that applies to symmetries that are anomalous, higher-form, and/or noninvertible. (3) The relations between condensable algebras constrain the structure of the global phase diagram. We find that, for $1+1\mathrm{D} {\mathbb{Z}}_{2}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ symmetry with mixed anomaly, there is a stable continuous transition (deconfined quantum critical point) between the Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​-breaking-${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}^{\ensuremath{'}}$-symmetric phase and the Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​-symmetric-${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}^{\ensuremath{'}}$-breaking phase. The critical point is the same as a Z4{\mathbb{Z}}_{4}Z4​ symmetry breaking critical point. (4) 1+1D1+1\mathrm{D}1+1D bosonic systems with S3{S}_{3}S3​ symmetry have four gapped phases with unbroken symmetries S3,Z3,Z2{S}_{3}, {\mathbb{Z}}_{3}, {\mathbb{Z}}_{2}S3​,Z3​,Z2​, and Z1{\mathbb{Z}}_{1}Z1​. We find a duality between two transitions ${S}_{3}\ensuremath{\leftrightarrow}{\mathbb{Z}}_{1}$ and ${\mathbb{Z}}_{3}\ensuremath{\leftrightarrow}{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$: they are either both first order or both (stably) continuous, and in the latter case, they are described by the same conformal field theory (CFT). (5) The gapped and gapless states for 1+1D1+1\mathrm{D}1+1D bosonic systems with anomalous S3{S}_{3}S3​ symmetries are obtained as well. For example, anomalous S3(1){S}_{3}^{(1)}S3(1)​ and S3(2){S}_{3}^{(2)}S3(2)​ symmetries can have symmetry protected chiral gapless states with only symmetric irrelevant and marginal operators.
Anomalies of global symmetries provide important information on the quantum dynamics. We show the dynamical constraints can be organized into three classes: genuine anomalies, fractional topological responses, and integer responses that can be realized in symmetry-protected topological (SPT) phases. Coset symmetry can be present in many physical systems including quantum spin liquids, and the coset symmetry can be a non-invertible symmetry. We introduce twists in coset symmetries, which modify the fusion rules and the generalized Frobenius-Schur indicators. We call such coset symmetries twisted coset symmetries, and they are labeled by the quadruple (G,K,\omega_{D+1},\alpha_D) ( G , K , ω D + 1 , α D ) in D D spacetime dimensions where G G is a group and K\subset G K ⊂ G is a discrete subgroup, \omega_{D+1} ω D + 1 is a (D+1) ( D + 1 ) -cocycle for group G G , and \alpha_{D} α D is a D D -cochain for group K K . We present several examples with twisted coset symmetries using lattice models and field theory, including both gapped and gapless systems (such as gapless symmetry-protected topological phases). We investigate the anomalies of general twisted coset symmetry, which presents obstructions to realizing the coset symmetry in (gapped) symmetry-protected topological phases. We show that finite coset symmetry G/K G / K becomes anomalous when G G cannot be expressed as the bicrossed product G=H\Join K G = H ⋈ K , and such anomalous coset symmetry leads to symmetry-enforced gaplessness in generic spacetime dimensions. We illustrate examples of anomalous coset symmetries with A_5/\Z_2 symmetry, with realizations in lattice models.
We identify a symmetry that enforces every symmetric model to have a Fermi surface. These symmetry-enforced Fermi surfaces are realizations of a powerful form of symmetry-enforced gaplessness. The symmetry we construct exists in quantum lattice fermion models on a d-dimensional Bravais lattice, and is generated by the on-site U(1) fermion number symmetry and non-on-site Majorana translation symmetry. The resulting symmetry group is a noncompact Lie group closely related to the Onsager algebra. For a symmetry-enforced Fermi surface F, we show that this UV symmetry group always includes the subgroup of the ersatz Fermi liquid L_{F}U(1) symmetry group formed by even functions f(k)∈U(1) with k∈F. Furthermore, we comment on the topology of these symmetry-enforced Fermi surfaces, proving they generically exhibit at least two noncontractible components (i.e., open orbits).