Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2503.08238 · Physical Review Research

Single-qubit gates beyond the rotating-wave approximation for strongly anharmonic low-frequency qubits

Martijn F. S. Zwanenburg, Siddharth Singh, Eugene Y. Huang, Figen Yilmaz, Taryn V. Stefanski, Jinlun Hu, Piranavan Kumaravadivel, Christian Kraglund Andersen

Published Nov 17, 2025• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In many quantum platforms, single-qubit gates are applied using a linear drive resonant with the qubit transition frequency, which is often theoretically described within the rotating-wave approximation (RWA). However, for fast gates on low-frequency qubits, the RWA may not hold and we need to consider the contribution from counterrotating terms to the qubit dynamics. The inclusion of counterrotating terms into the theoretical description gives rise to two challenges. First, it becomes challenging to analytically calculate the time evolution as the Hamiltonian is no longer self-commuting. Moreover, the time evolution now depends on the carrier phase such that, in general, every operation in a sequence of gates is different. In this work, we derive and verify a correction to the drive pulses that minimizes the effect of these counterrotating terms in a two-level system. We then derive a second correction term that arises from noncomputational levels for a strongly anharmonic system. We experimentally implement these correction terms on a fluxonium superconducting qubit, which is an example of a strongly anharmonic, low-frequency qubit for which the RWA may not hold, and demonstrate how fast, high-fidelity single-qubit gates can be achieved without the need for additional hardware and calibration complexities.

DOI
10.1103/z62h-kcnh

Related papers

Optimal detuning and gate time for strongly driven single-qubit gates beyond the rotating-wave approximation

Alejandro D. Bendersky, Sergio S. Gomez, Rodolfo H. Romero

Single-qubit quantum gates are implemented as the time-controlled unitary evolution of a two-level system under harmonic driving. The rotating-wave approximation (RWA) provides closed-form gate parameters for weak coupling. Larger amplitudes, desirable to speed up the dynamics, make the RWA-designed gates inaccurate because of the neglected counter-rotating term, which also shifts the resonance (Bloch-Siegert shift). Here we study theoretically the infidelity of gates beyond the RWA, using the effective Magnus-Taylor Hamiltonian through second order in the inverse of the driving frequency. By detuning the driving frequency by an amplitude-dependent shift of Bloch-Siegert type and rescaling the operation time, the RWA gate conditions are recovered with corrected parameters. Numerical solutions of the Schrodinger equation show that these corrections lower the gate infidelity by several orders of magnitude, extending the range of usable amplitudes

quant-pharXiv:2610.40595•Oct 30, 2026•0 citations

Achieving high-fidelity single-qubit gates in a strongly driven silicon-quantum-dot hybrid qubit

Yuan‐Chi Yang, S. N. Coppersmith, Mark G. Friesen

Performing qubit gate operations as quickly as possible can be important to minimize the effects of decoherence. For resonant gates, this requires applying a strong ac drive. However, strong driving can present control challenges by causing leakage to levels that lie outside the qubit subspace. Strong driving can also present theoretical challenges because preferred tools such as the rotating wave approximation can break down, resulting in complex dynamics that are difficult to control. Here we analyze resonant $X$ rotations of a silicon-quantum-double-dot hybrid qubit within a dressed-state formalism, obtaining results beyond the rotating wave approximation. We obtain analytic formulas for the optimum driving frequency and the Rabi frequency, which are both affected by strong driving. While the qubit states exhibit fast oscillations due to counter-rotating terms and leakage, we show that they can be suppressed to the point that gate fidelities above $99.99%$ are possible, in the absence of decoherence. Hence decoherence mechanisms, rather than strong-driving effects, should represent the limiting factor for resonant-gate fidelities in quantum dot hybrid qubits.

arXiv:1705.01468•Physical Review A•Jun 13, 2017•30 citations

Suppressing Counter-Rotating Errors for Fast Single-Qubit Gates with Fluxonium

David A. Rower, Leon Ding, Helin Zhang +12 more

Qubit decoherence unavoidably degrades the fidelity of quantum logic gates. Accordingly, realizing gates that are as fast as possible is a guiding principle for qubit control, necessitating protocols for mitigating error channels that become significant as gate time is decreased. One such error channel arises from the counter-rotating component of strong, linearly polarized drives. This error channel is particularly important when gate times approach the qubit Larmor period and represents the dominant source of infidelity for sufficiently fast single-qubit gates with low-frequency qubits such as fluxonium. In this work, we develop and demonstrate two complementary protocols for mitigating this error channel. The first protocol realizes circularly polarized driving in circuit QED through simultaneous charge and flux control. The second protocol—commensurate pulses—leverages the coherent and periodic nature of counter-rotating fields to regularize their contributions to gates, enabling single-qubit gate fidelities reliably exceeding 99.997%. This protocol is platform independent and requires no additional calibration overhead. This work establishes straightforward strategies for mitigating counter-rotating effects from strong drives in circuit QED and other platforms, which we expect to be helpful in the effort to realize high-fidelity control for fault-tolerant quantum computing. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2406.08295•PRX Quantum•Dec 13, 2024•48 citations

Fast control of semiconductor qubits beyond the rotating-wave approximation

Yang Song, J. P. Kestner, Xin Wang +1 more

We present a theoretical study of single-qubit operations by oscillatory fields on various semiconductor platforms. We explicitly show how to perform faster gate operations by going beyond the universally used rotating-wave approximation (RWA) regime, while using only two sinusoidal pulses. We first show for specific published experiments how much error is currently incurred by implementing pulses designed using standard RWA. We then show that an even modest increase in gate speed would cause problems in using RWA for gate design in the singlet-triplet (ST) and resonant-exchange (RX) qubits. We discuss the extent to which analytically keeping higher orders in the perturbation theory would address the problem. More strikingly, we give a new prescription for gating with strong coupling far beyond the RWA regime. We perform numerical calculations for the phases and the durations of two consecutive pulses to realize the key Hadamard and $\frac{\ensuremath{\pi}}{8}$ gates with coupling strengths up to several times the qubit splitting. Working in this manifestly non-RWA regime, the gate operation speeds up by two to three orders of magnitude and nears the quantum speed limit without requiring complicated pulse shaping or optimal control sequences.

arXiv:1602.05201•Physical Review A•Jul 14, 2016•19 citations

Anharmonicity-limited gate-time boundaries in transmon single-qubit quantum gates

Deniz Türkpençe, Selçuk Çakmak

Logic gates in superconducting quantum processors are implemented through precisely shaped microwave pulses, whose durations are constrained by both device coherence and the multilevel structure of artificial atoms. While single-qubit fidelities above 0.999 are routinely achieved, the physical execution time of these gates remains a major bottleneck for deep quantum circuits. Here we examine single-qubit control across adiabatic [where the rotating-wave approximation (RWA) is valid], intermediate, and diabatic driving regimes using both an ideal two-level model and a realistic weakly anharmonic transmon Hamiltonian. By sweeping pulse durations and drive strengths over experimentally relevant ranges, we compare performance trade-offs and identify the conditions under which ultrashort gates remain viable. Our simulations uncover a quantitative speed-limit mechanism intrinsic to weakly anharmonic superconducting qubits: leakage to higher levels rises sharply once the peak Rabi rate exceeds a fixed fraction of the anharmonicity. Across all pulse shapes and driving regimes studied, we find a consistent numerical threshold at Ω max /|Δ|≈0.15−0.20, where Ω max denotes the peak drive (Rabi) amplitude and Δ is the transmon anharmonicity. Beyond this ratio, gate fidelity deteriorates regardless of waveform engineering. This boundary, obtained from full multilevel time-domain simulations spanning adiabatic, intermediate, and diabatic regimes, constitutes a previously unreported characterization of the fundamental leakage barrier in transmon devices. Our results, therefore, provide the first unified quantitative map linking pulse duration, driving strength, and anharmonicity, establishing why realistic superconducting qubits cannot sustain picosecond-scale gates despite ideal two-level predictions, and offering a practical benchmark for next-generation architectures seeking shorter, high-fidelity control.

Journal of the Optical Society of America B•Dec 19, 2025•0 citations

Analytic Design of Accelerated Adiabatic Gates in Realistic Qubits: General Theory and Applications to Superconducting Circuits

F. Setiawan, Peter Groszkowski, Hugo Ribeiro +1 more

Shortcuts to adiabaticity is a general method for speeding up adiabatic quantum protocols, and has many potential applications in quantum information processing.Unfortunately, analytically constructing shortcuts to adiabaticity for systems having complex interactions and more than a few levels is a challenging task.This is usually overcome by assuming an idealized Hamiltonian [e.g., only a limited subset of energy levels are retained, and the rotating-wave approximation (RWA) is made].Here we develop an analytic approach that allows one to go beyond these limitations.Our method is general and results in analytically derived pulse shapes that correct both nonadiabatic errors and non-RWA errors.We also show that our approach can yield pulses requiring a smaller driving power than conventional nonadiabatic protocols.We show in detail how our ideas can be used to analytically design high-fidelity single-qubit "tripod" gates in a realistic superconducting fluxonium qubit.

arXiv:2102.02370•PRX Quantum•Jul 9, 2021•32 citations
In many quantum platforms, single-qubit gates are applied using a linear drive resonant with the qubit transition frequency, which is often theoretically described within the rotating-wave approximation (RWA). However, for fast gates on low-frequency qubits, the RWA may not hold and we need to consider the contribution from counterrotating terms to the qubit dynamics. The inclusion of counterrotating terms into the theoretical description gives rise to two challenges. First, it becomes challenging to analytically calculate the time evolution as the Hamiltonian is no longer self-commuting. Moreover, the time evolution now depends on the carrier phase such that, in general, every operation in a sequence of gates is different. In this work, we derive and verify a correction to the drive pulses that minimizes the effect of these counterrotating terms in a two-level system. We then derive a second correction term that arises from noncomputational levels for a strongly anharmonic system. We experimentally implement these correction terms on a fluxonium superconducting qubit, which is an example of a strongly anharmonic, low-frequency qubit for which the RWA may not hold, and demonstrate how fast, high-fidelity single-qubit gates can be achieved without the need for additional hardware and calibration complexities.
Single-qubit quantum gates are implemented as the time-controlled unitary evolution of a two-level system under harmonic driving. The rotating-wave approximation (RWA) provides closed-form gate parameters for weak coupling. Larger amplitudes, desirable to speed up the dynamics, make the RWA-designed gates inaccurate because of the neglected counter-rotating term, which also shifts the resonance (Bloch-Siegert shift). Here we study theoretically the infidelity of gates beyond the RWA, using the effective Magnus-Taylor Hamiltonian through second order in the inverse of the driving frequency. By detuning the driving frequency by an amplitude-dependent shift of Bloch-Siegert type and rescaling the operation time, the RWA gate conditions are recovered with corrected parameters. Numerical solutions of the Schrodinger equation show that these corrections lower the gate infidelity by several orders of magnitude, extending the range of usable amplitudes
Performing qubit gate operations as quickly as possible can be important to minimize the effects of decoherence. For resonant gates, this requires applying a strong ac drive. However, strong driving can present control challenges by causing leakage to levels that lie outside the qubit subspace. Strong driving can also present theoretical challenges because preferred tools such as the rotating wave approximation can break down, resulting in complex dynamics that are difficult to control. Here we analyze resonant XXX rotations of a silicon-quantum-double-dot hybrid qubit within a dressed-state formalism, obtaining results beyond the rotating wave approximation. We obtain analytic formulas for the optimum driving frequency and the Rabi frequency, which are both affected by strong driving. While the qubit states exhibit fast oscillations due to counter-rotating terms and leakage, we show that they can be suppressed to the point that gate fidelities above 99.9999.99%99.99 are possible, in the absence of decoherence. Hence decoherence mechanisms, rather than strong-driving effects, should represent the limiting factor for resonant-gate fidelities in quantum dot hybrid qubits.
Qubit decoherence unavoidably degrades the fidelity of quantum logic gates. Accordingly, realizing gates that are as fast as possible is a guiding principle for qubit control, necessitating protocols for mitigating error channels that become significant as gate time is decreased. One such error channel arises from the counter-rotating component of strong, linearly polarized drives. This error channel is particularly important when gate times approach the qubit Larmor period and represents the dominant source of infidelity for sufficiently fast single-qubit gates with low-frequency qubits such as fluxonium. In this work, we develop and demonstrate two complementary protocols for mitigating this error channel. The first protocol realizes circularly polarized driving in circuit QED through simultaneous charge and flux control. The second protocol—commensurate pulses—leverages the coherent and periodic nature of counter-rotating fields to regularize their contributions to gates, enabling single-qubit gate fidelities reliably exceeding 99.997%. This protocol is platform independent and requires no additional calibration overhead. This work establishes straightforward strategies for mitigating counter-rotating effects from strong drives in circuit QED and other platforms, which we expect to be helpful in the effort to realize high-fidelity control for fault-tolerant quantum computing. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
We present a theoretical study of single-qubit operations by oscillatory fields on various semiconductor platforms. We explicitly show how to perform faster gate operations by going beyond the universally used rotating-wave approximation (RWA) regime, while using only two sinusoidal pulses. We first show for specific published experiments how much error is currently incurred by implementing pulses designed using standard RWA. We then show that an even modest increase in gate speed would cause problems in using RWA for gate design in the singlet-triplet (ST) and resonant-exchange (RX) qubits. We discuss the extent to which analytically keeping higher orders in the perturbation theory would address the problem. More strikingly, we give a new prescription for gating with strong coupling far beyond the RWA regime. We perform numerical calculations for the phases and the durations of two consecutive pulses to realize the key Hadamard and $\frac{\ensuremath{\pi}}{8}$ gates with coupling strengths up to several times the qubit splitting. Working in this manifestly non-RWA regime, the gate operation speeds up by two to three orders of magnitude and nears the quantum speed limit without requiring complicated pulse shaping or optimal control sequences.
Logic gates in superconducting quantum processors are implemented through precisely shaped microwave pulses, whose durations are constrained by both device coherence and the multilevel structure of artificial atoms. While single-qubit fidelities above 0.999 are routinely achieved, the physical execution time of these gates remains a major bottleneck for deep quantum circuits. Here we examine single-qubit control across adiabatic [where the rotating-wave approximation (RWA) is valid], intermediate, and diabatic driving regimes using both an ideal two-level model and a realistic weakly anharmonic transmon Hamiltonian. By sweeping pulse durations and drive strengths over experimentally relevant ranges, we compare performance trade-offs and identify the conditions under which ultrashort gates remain viable. Our simulations uncover a quantitative speed-limit mechanism intrinsic to weakly anharmonic superconducting qubits: leakage to higher levels rises sharply once the peak Rabi rate exceeds a fixed fraction of the anharmonicity. Across all pulse shapes and driving regimes studied, we find a consistent numerical threshold at Ω max /|Δ|≈0.15−0.20, where Ω max denotes the peak drive (Rabi) amplitude and Δ is the transmon anharmonicity. Beyond this ratio, gate fidelity deteriorates regardless of waveform engineering. This boundary, obtained from full multilevel time-domain simulations spanning adiabatic, intermediate, and diabatic regimes, constitutes a previously unreported characterization of the fundamental leakage barrier in transmon devices. Our results, therefore, provide the first unified quantitative map linking pulse duration, driving strength, and anharmonicity, establishing why realistic superconducting qubits cannot sustain picosecond-scale gates despite ideal two-level predictions, and offering a practical benchmark for next-generation architectures seeking shorter, high-fidelity control.
Shortcuts to adiabaticity is a general method for speeding up adiabatic quantum protocols, and has many potential applications in quantum information processing.Unfortunately, analytically constructing shortcuts to adiabaticity for systems having complex interactions and more than a few levels is a challenging task.This is usually overcome by assuming an idealized Hamiltonian [e.g., only a limited subset of energy levels are retained, and the rotating-wave approximation (RWA) is made].Here we develop an analytic approach that allows one to go beyond these limitations.Our method is general and results in analytically derived pulse shapes that correct both nonadiabatic errors and non-RWA errors.We also show that our approach can yield pulses requiring a smaller driving power than conventional nonadiabatic protocols.We show in detail how our ideas can be used to analytically design high-fidelity single-qubit "tripod" gates in a realistic superconducting fluxonium qubit.