Low-loss superconducting resonators fabricated from tantalum films grown at room temperature
Guillaume Marcaud, David Perello, Cliff Chen, Esha A. Umbarkar, Conan R. Weiland, Jiansong Gao, Sandra Díez, Victor Ly, Neha Mahuli, Nathan D’Souza, Yuan He, Shahriar Aghaeimeibodi, Rachel Resnick, Cherno Jaye, Abdul K. Rumaiz, Daniel A. Fischer, Matthew Hunt, Oskar J. Painter, Ignace Jarrige
Abstract The use of α -tantalum in superconducting circuits has enabled a considerable improvement in the coherence time of transmon qubits. The standard approach to grow α -tantalum thin films on silicon involves heating the substrate, which takes several hours per deposition and prevents the integration of this material with wafers containing temperature-sensitive components. We report a detailed experimental study of an alternative growth method of α -tantalum on silicon, which is achieved at room temperature through the use of a niobium seed layer. Despite a substantially higher density of oxygen-rich grain boundaries in the films sputtered at room temperature, resonators made from these films are found to have state-of-the-art quality factors, comparable to resonators fabricated from tantalum grown at high temperature. This finding challenges previous assumptions about correlations between material properties and microwave loss of superconducting thin films, and opens a new avenue for the integration of tantalum into fabrication flows with limited thermal budget.
Abstract The use of α -tantalum in superconducting circuits has enabled a considerable improvement in the coherence time of transmon qubits. The standard approach to grow α -tantalum thin films on silicon involves heating the substrate, which takes several hours per deposition and prevents the integration of this material with wafers containing temperature-sensitive components. We report a detailed experimental study of an alternative growth method of α -tantalum on silicon, which is achieved at room temperature through the use of a niobium seed layer. Despite a substantially higher density of oxygen-rich grain boundaries in the films sputtered at room temperature, resonators made from these films are found to have state-of-the-art quality factors, comparable to resonators fabricated from tantalum grown at high temperature. This finding challenges previous assumptions about correlations between material properties and microwave loss of superconducting thin films, and opens a new avenue for the integration of tantalum into fabrication flows with limited thermal budget.
Tantalum thin films sputtered on unheated silicon substrates are characterized with microwaves at around 10 GHz in a 10 mK environment. We show that the phase of tantalum with a body-centered cubic lattice (α-Ta) can be grown selectively by depositing a niobium buffer layer prior to a tantalum film. The physical properties of the films, such as superconducting transition temperature and crystallinity, change markedly with the addition of the buffer layer. Coplanar waveguide resonators based on the composite film exhibit significantly enhanced internal quality factors compared with a film without the buffer layer. The internal quality factor approaches 2 × 107 at a large-photon-number limit. While the quality factor decreases at the single-photon level owing to two-level system (TLS) loss, we have deduced that one of the causes of TLS loss is the amorphous silicon layer at the film–substrate interface, which originates from the substrate cleaning before the film deposition rather than the film itself. The temperature dependence of the internal quality factors shows a marked rise below 200 mK, suggesting the presence of TLS–TLS interactions. The present low-loss tantalum films can be deposited without substrate heating and thus have various potential applications in superconducting quantum electronics.
Abstract Tantalum (Ta) films with a body-centered cubic α-phase play a crucial role in high-performance Ta-based superconducting quantum processors. The growth of pure α-Ta at low temperatures has been a long-term goal. Existing experience with Ta growth on silicon substrates has led to the belief that α-Ta can only be stabilized at high temperatures. In this study, we systematically analyzed the growth mechanism of Ta films on sapphire substrates using first-principles calculations, revealing a narrow growth energy window for pure α-Ta at room temperature (RT). This finding indicates the feasibility of obtaining pure α-Ta at significantly lower temperatures. Experimentally, we successfully achieved pure α-Ta at RT via magnetron sputtering by meticulously adjusting the growth parameters. The resulting superconducting resonators based on the developed RT α-Ta exhibit an internal quality factor ( Q i ) of approximately 2.1 × 10 6 at single-photon levels, comparable to those fabricated at high temperatures. Additionally, fixed-frequency transmon qubits fabricated using the RT α-Ta film demonstrate a coherence time exceeding 280 µs, underscoring the film’s high quality. The RT α-Ta without a seed layer simplifies the fabrication process, offering a more efficient and flexible approach for producing Ta-based superconducting quantum processors.
Superconducting qubits and microwave resonators based on tantalum thin films have recently demonstrated large increases in performance. This makes Ta an at- tractive material for superconducting quantum computing applications, but, so far, direct deposition has largely relied on high substrate temperatures exceeding 400 ◦C to achieve the cubic (BCC) phase of tantalum. Here, we show that changing the sputter gas from argon to krypton promotes synthesis of very high crystallinity BCC tantalum films on silicon at temperatures as low as 200 ◦C. This provides a wide process window compatible with back-end-of-the-line fabrication standards. The microwave performance of coplanar waveguide resonators fabricated from krypton-sputtered films shows a tight performance distribution at the state of the art. Higher temperature-grown films exhibit higher losses, in correlation with the degree of tantalum/silicon intermixing. Finally, with these films, we demonstrate transmon qubits with a relatively compact, 20 μm capacitor gap, achieving a time-averaged quality factor up to 16.9 million.
Superconducting qubits are a promising platform for large-scale quantum computing. Besides the Josephson junction, most parts of a superconducting qubit are made of a planar, patterned superconducting thin films. In the past, most qubit architectures have relied on niobium (Nb) as the material of choice for the superconducting layer. However, there is also a variety of alternative materials with potentially less losses, which may thereby result in increased qubit performance. One such material is tantalum (Ta), for which high-performance qubit components have already been demonstrated. In this study, we report the sputter-deposition of Ta thin films directly on heated and unheated silicon (Si) substrates as well as onto different, nanometer-thin seed layers from tantalum nitride (TaN), titanium nitride (TiN) or aluminum nitride (AIN) that were deposited first. The thin films are characterized in terms of surface morphology, crystal structure, phase composition, critical temperature, residual resistance ratio (RRR) and RF-performance. We obtain thin films indicative of pure alpha-Ta for high temperature (600°C) sputtering directly on silicon and for Ta deposited on TaN or TiN seed layers. Coplanar waveguide (CPW) resonator measurements show that the Ta deposited directly on the heated silicon substrate performs best with internal quality factors Qi reaching 1xl06in the single-photon regime, measured at T=100 mK.
Superconducting qubits based on tantalum (Ta) thin films have demonstrated the highest-performing microwave resonators and qubits. This makes Ta an attractive material for superconducting quantum computing applications, but, so far, direct deposition has largely relied on high substrate temperatures exceeding \SI{400}{\celsius} to achieve the body-centered cubic phase, BCC (\textalpha-Ta). This leads to compatibility issues for scalable fabrication leveraging standard semiconductor fabrication lines. Here, we show that changing the sputter gas from argon (Ar) to krypton (Kr) promotes BCC Ta synthesis on silicon (Si) at temperatures as low as \SI{200}{\celsius}, providing a wide process window compatible with back-end-of-the-line fabrication standards. Furthermore, we find these films to have substantially higher electronic conductivity, consistent with clean-limit superconductivity. We validated the microwave performance through coplanar waveguide resonator measurements, finding that films deposited at \SI{250}{\celsius} and \SI{350}{\celsius} exhibit a tight performance distribution at the state of the art. Higher temperature-grown films exhibit higher losses, in correlation with the degree of Ta/Si intermixing revealed by cross-sectional transmission electron microscopy. Finally, with these films, we demonstrate transmon qubits with a relatively compact, \SI{20}{\micro\meter} capacitor gap, achieving a median quality factor up to 14 million.
Abstract Tantalum (Ta) is a promising material for superconducting qubits due to its stable chemical properties, formation of a single oxide, and resistance to reaction with other substances. However, achieving the desired α -Ta typically requires high-temperature substrate heating, leading to a time-consuming process and stringent requirements for the film deposition system. Here we demonstrate the deposition of high-quality α -Ta at room temperature using a niobium (Nb) film as a buffer layer. The buffered films are characterized using x-ray diffraction, transmission electron microscopy, and scanning electron microscopy. Transmons with capacitors, transmission lines, and readout resonators fabricated with such Nb-buffered Ta exhibit excellent performance. We observed an “inflection point” in the dependence of the Q i of the resonators on the input microwave photons, which can be fitted well with an expression for the superposition of the buffered resonators. These experimental results show that the buffered films deposited at room temperature have promising applications in superconducting devices.