Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2406.09341

Investigate the Performance of Distribution Loading with Conditional Quantum Generative Adversarial Network Algorithm on Quantum Hardware with Error Suppression

Anh T. Pham, Andrew Vlasic

Published Jun 13, 2024• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The study examines the efficacy of the Fire Opal error suppression and AI circuit optimization system integrated with IBM's quantum computing platform for a multi-modal distribution loading algorithm. Using Kullback-Leibler (KL) divergence as a quantitative error analysis, the results indicate that Fire Opal can improve on the time-dependent distributions generated by our Conditional Quantum Generative Adversarial algorithm by 30-40\% in comparison with the results on the simulator. In addition, Fire Opal's performance remains consistent for complex circuits despite the needs to run more trials. The research concludes that Fire Opal's error suppression and circuit optimization significantly enhanced quantum computing processes, highlighting its potential for practical applications. In addition, the study also reviews leading error mitigation strategies, including zero noise extrapolation (ZNE), probabilistic error cancellation (PEC), Pauli twirling, measurement error mitigation, and machine learning methods, assessing their advantages and disadvantages in terms of technical implementation, quantum resources, and scalability.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2406.09341

Related papers

Error mitigation strategies in quantum neural networks and their impact on gradient descent convergence

Alexander Zarichkovyi, Eduard Zharikov, Kateryna Igoryvna Lishchuk +1 more

The paper presents a comprehensive review of current error mitigation strategies within quantum neural networks operating in the NISQ era. The research models complex hardware noise environments using Qiskit Aer simulators to evaluate various error compensation algorithms. Specifically, the study investigates how global depolarizing channels fundamentally flatten the optimization landscape and artificially exacerbate the barren plateaus phenomenon, effectively preventing the convergence of gradient-based optimizers. To address these hardware limitations, the study tests the efficiency of Zero-Noise Extrapolation (ZNE), Probabilistic Error Cancellation (PEC), Readout Error Mitigation (REM), and Clifford Data Regression (CDR). The empirical analysis demonstrates that quantum error mitigation techniques successfully restore the true direction of the gradient vector by compensating for the amplitude attenuation caused by decoherence. Consequently, the optimization process strictly requires an exponential or linear increase in the number of measurement shots to compensate for the heavily inflated statistical variance introduced by the mitigation models. The investigation identifies REM as a mandatory baseline classical processing step that corrects asymmetric measurement biases without incurring additional quantum sampling costs. Simultaneously, the study restricts the practical utility of ZNE to shallow quantum circuits to prevent the accumulation of severe extrapolation inaccuracies, which otherwise cause destabilizing oscillations during the late epochs of gradient descent. Furthermore, the analysis proves that while PEC supplies mathematically unbiased gradient estimators, its exponential sampling overhead renders it intractable for deep parameterized architectures. Moreover, the experiments reveal a complex trade-off between optimization accuracy and computational overhead on the quantum coprocessor, highlighting CDR as a highly scalable alternative that shifts the mitigation burden to classical pre-processing. As a result, the authors propose a dynamic orchestration methodology that strategically combines ZNE, CDR and PEC mitigation strategies throughout the training cycle to ensure stable gradient descent convergence while minimizing resource consumption. The findings provide a robust theoretical foundation for designing resilient hybrid quantum-classical machine learning architectures and integrating them into modern MLOps pipelines.

Науковий вісник НЛТУ України•Sep 24, 2026•0 citations

Machine Learning-based Quantum Error Mitigation for Variational Algorithms

Nikita Korolev, Kirill Lakhmanskiy, Daniil Rabinovich

Machine Learning-based quantum error mitigation (ML-QEM) has emerged as a promising approach for improving the performance of noisy quantum algorithms. However, existing ML-QEM methods often have restricted applicability to variational circuits and rely on inaccessible noiseless training data. In this work, we propose a practical ML-QEM protocol tailored to variational quantum algorithms, which generates training data by simulating (near-)Clifford circuits. This data is used for model selection and training, producing a mitigation model that can correct variational circuits with arbitrary parameters and transfer across different target Hamiltonians of similar structure. We benchmark the proposed method on the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) task for the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick Hamiltonian of up to $n=12$ qubits under various noise models, analyzing its effect on trainability and comparing its performance against standard Zero-Noise Extrapolation (ZNE). The results demonstrate consistent several-fold error suppression across all tested settings and superior performance over ZNE in the high-noise regime, providing evidence for the applicability of the proposed protocol to present-day NISQ processors.

quant-pharXiv:2606.02697•Jun 3, 2026•2 citations

Experimental Benchmarking of an Automated Deterministic Error-Suppression Workflow for Quantum Algorithms

Pranav Mundada, Aaron Barbosa, Smarak Maity +8 more

Excitement about the promise of quantum computers is tempered by the reality that the hardware remains exceptionally fragile and error prone, forming a bottleneck in the development of alternative applications. In this paper, we describe and experimentally test a fully autonomous workflow designed to deterministically suppress errors in quantum algorithms from the gate level through to circuit execution and measurement. We introduce the key elements of this workflow, delivered as a software package called Fire Opal, and survey the underlying physical concepts: error-aware compilation, automated system-wide gate optimization, automated dynamical decoupling embedding for circuit-level error cancellation, and calibration-efficient measurement-error mitigation. We then present a comprehensive suite of performance benchmarks executed on IBM hardware, demonstrating up to $>1000\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}$ improvement over the best alternative expert-configured techniques available in the open literature. Benchmarking includes experiments using up to 16 qubit systems executing the following: Bernstein Vazirani, quantum Fourier transform, Grover's search, quantum approximate optimization algorithm, variational quantum eigensolver, syndrome extraction on a five-qubit quantum error-correction code, and quantum volume. Experiments reveal a strong contribution of Non-Markovian errors to baseline algorithmic performance; in all cases the deterministic error-suppression workflow delivers the highest performance and approaches incoherent error bounds without the need for any additional sampling or randomization overhead, while maintaining compatibility with all additional probabilistic error suppression techniques.

arXiv:2209.06864•Physical Review Applied•Aug 14, 2023•55 citations

Reliable high-accuracy error mitigation for utility-scale quantum circuits

Dorit Aharonov, Ori Alberton, Itai Arad +36 more

Error mitigation is essential for unlocking the full potential of quantum algorithms and accelerating the timeline toward quantum advantage. As quantum hardware progresses to push the boundaries of classical simulation, efficient and robust error mitigation methods are becoming increasingly important for producing accurate and reliable outputs. However, existing error-mitigation approaches face a fundamental tradeoff between practical performance and reliability: heuristic methods such as zero-noise extrapolation (ZNE) enjoy faster runtime but lack accuracy guarantees, while rigorous techniques such as probabilistic error cancellation (PEC) provide unbiased estimates at prohibitive computational cost. We introduce a characterization-based, rigorously-grounded quantum error mitigation and error suppression framework (QESEM) that resolves this tradeoff by leveraging the accuracy guarantees of quasi-probabilistic mitigation with dramatically reduced overhead. We explain the innovative methods underlying QESEM and demonstrate its capabilities in the largest utility-scale error mitigation experiment based on an unbiased method. This experiment simulates the kicked transverse field Ising model with far-from-Clifford parameters on an IBM Heron device. We further validate QESEM's versatility across arbitrary quantum circuits and devices through high-accuracy error-mitigated molecular VQE circuits executed on IBM Heron and IonQ trapped-ion devices. Compared with multiple variants of the widely used zero-noise extrapolation method, QESEM consistently achieves higher accuracy while avoiding the prohibitive runtime overhead associated with PEC. These results mark a significant step forward in accuracy and reliability for running quantum circuits on current devices across diverse applications. Finally, we provide projections of QESEM's performance on near-term devices toward quantum advantage.

arXiv:2508.10997•Aug 14, 2025•24 citations

Error Mitigation in Dynamic Circuits for Hamiltonian Simulation

Sumeet Shirgure, Siyuan Niu

Dynamic quantum circuits integrate mid-circuit measurements and feed-forward operations to enable real-time classical processing and conditional quantum logic. These capabilities are central to key quantum protocols such as quantum error correction, and have recently demonstrated significant potential for reducing quantum resources, including circuit depth and gate count, across a range of applications. However, executing dynamic circuits on real quantum hardware introduces a critical trade-off: while resource requirements decrease, circuit fidelity degrades due to high error rates of mid-circuit measurements, as well as the decoherence errors accumulated during the extended idle periods introduced by both mid-circuit measurements and feed-forward operations. In this paper, we systematically investigate the impact of standard error mitigation techniques on dynamic circuit applications pertaining to Hamiltonian simulation and ground state estimation of physically relevant systems like the Heisenberg model. We explore dynamical decoupling (DD) as a strategy to suppress decoherence and crosstalk errors during idle windows introduced by mid-circuit measurements and feed-forward delays, and also examine error mitigation via zero-noise extrapolation (ZNE). Through experiments conducted on IBM quantum hardware, we benchmark effective combinations of these strategies that maximize the practical benefits of dynamic quantum circuits in these applications. We demonstrate that a combination of DD and ZNE is effective in mitigating the errors introduced during mid-circuit measurements and feed-forward operations, as well as the errors arising from faulty measurements. This approach yields a energy gap improvement of at least 60% in ground state estimation and reduces observed error of time-evolved states by up to 99% for the Ising model and up to 20% for the Heisenberg model.

quant-pharXiv:2605.05256•ACM Great Lakes Symposium on VLSI (GLSVLSI)•May 7, 2026•3 citations

Error Mitigation in the NISQ Era: Applying Measurement Error Mitigation Techniques to Enhance Quantum Circuit Performance

Misha Urooj Khan, Muhammad Ahmad Kamran, Wajiha Rahim Khan +3 more

In quantum computing, noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices offer unprecedented computational capabilities but are vulnerable to errors, notably measurement inaccuracies that impact computation accuracy. This study explores the efficacy of error mitigation techniques in improving quantum circuit performance on NISQ devices. Techniques such as dynamic decoupling (DD), twirled readout error extraction (T-REx) and zero-noise extrapolation (ZNE) are examined through extensive experimentation on an ideal simulator, IBM Kyoto, and IBM Osaka quantum computers. Results reveal significant performance discrepancies across scenarios, with error mitigation techniques notably enhancing both estimator result and variance values, aligning more closely with ideal simulator outcomes. The comparison results with ideal simulator (having expected result value 0.8284) shows that T-Rex has improved results on IBM Kyoto and enhanced average expected result value from 0.09 to 0.35. Similarly, DD has improved average expected result values from 0.2492 to 0.3788 on IBM Osaka. These findings underscore the critical role of error mitigation in bolstering quantum computation reliability. The results suggest that selection of mitigation technique depends upon quantum circuit and its depth, type of hardware and operations to be performed.

Mathematics•Jul 17, 2024•22 citations
The study examines the efficacy of the Fire Opal error suppression and AI circuit optimization system integrated with IBM's quantum computing platform for a multi-modal distribution loading algorithm. Using Kullback-Leibler (KL) divergence as a quantitative error analysis, the results indicate that Fire Opal can improve on the time-dependent distributions generated by our Conditional Quantum Generative Adversarial algorithm by 30-40% in comparison with the results on the simulator. In addition, Fire Opal's performance remains consistent for complex circuits despite the needs to run more trials. The research concludes that Fire Opal's error suppression and circuit optimization significantly enhanced quantum computing processes, highlighting its potential for practical applications. In addition, the study also reviews leading error mitigation strategies, including zero noise extrapolation (ZNE), probabilistic error cancellation (PEC), Pauli twirling, measurement error mitigation, and machine learning methods, assessing their advantages and disadvantages in terms of technical implementation, quantum resources, and scalability.
The paper presents a comprehensive review of current error mitigation strategies within quantum neural networks operating in the NISQ era. The research models complex hardware noise environments using Qiskit Aer simulators to evaluate various error compensation algorithms. Specifically, the study investigates how global depolarizing channels fundamentally flatten the optimization landscape and artificially exacerbate the barren plateaus phenomenon, effectively preventing the convergence of gradient-based optimizers. To address these hardware limitations, the study tests the efficiency of Zero-Noise Extrapolation (ZNE), Probabilistic Error Cancellation (PEC), Readout Error Mitigation (REM), and Clifford Data Regression (CDR). The empirical analysis demonstrates that quantum error mitigation techniques successfully restore the true direction of the gradient vector by compensating for the amplitude attenuation caused by decoherence. Consequently, the optimization process strictly requires an exponential or linear increase in the number of measurement shots to compensate for the heavily inflated statistical variance introduced by the mitigation models. The investigation identifies REM as a mandatory baseline classical processing step that corrects asymmetric measurement biases without incurring additional quantum sampling costs. Simultaneously, the study restricts the practical utility of ZNE to shallow quantum circuits to prevent the accumulation of severe extrapolation inaccuracies, which otherwise cause destabilizing oscillations during the late epochs of gradient descent. Furthermore, the analysis proves that while PEC supplies mathematically unbiased gradient estimators, its exponential sampling overhead renders it intractable for deep parameterized architectures. Moreover, the experiments reveal a complex trade-off between optimization accuracy and computational overhead on the quantum coprocessor, highlighting CDR as a highly scalable alternative that shifts the mitigation burden to classical pre-processing. As a result, the authors propose a dynamic orchestration methodology that strategically combines ZNE, CDR and PEC mitigation strategies throughout the training cycle to ensure stable gradient descent convergence while minimizing resource consumption. The findings provide a robust theoretical foundation for designing resilient hybrid quantum-classical machine learning architectures and integrating them into modern MLOps pipelines.
Machine Learning-based quantum error mitigation (ML-QEM) has emerged as a promising approach for improving the performance of noisy quantum algorithms. However, existing ML-QEM methods often have restricted applicability to variational circuits and rely on inaccessible noiseless training data. In this work, we propose a practical ML-QEM protocol tailored to variational quantum algorithms, which generates training data by simulating (near-)Clifford circuits. This data is used for model selection and training, producing a mitigation model that can correct variational circuits with arbitrary parameters and transfer across different target Hamiltonians of similar structure. We benchmark the proposed method on the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) task for the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick Hamiltonian of up to n=12n=12n=12 qubits under various noise models, analyzing its effect on trainability and comparing its performance against standard Zero-Noise Extrapolation (ZNE). The results demonstrate consistent several-fold error suppression across all tested settings and superior performance over ZNE in the high-noise regime, providing evidence for the applicability of the proposed protocol to present-day NISQ processors.
Excitement about the promise of quantum computers is tempered by the reality that the hardware remains exceptionally fragile and error prone, forming a bottleneck in the development of alternative applications. In this paper, we describe and experimentally test a fully autonomous workflow designed to deterministically suppress errors in quantum algorithms from the gate level through to circuit execution and measurement. We introduce the key elements of this workflow, delivered as a software package called Fire Opal, and survey the underlying physical concepts: error-aware compilation, automated system-wide gate optimization, automated dynamical decoupling embedding for circuit-level error cancellation, and calibration-efficient measurement-error mitigation. We then present a comprehensive suite of performance benchmarks executed on IBM hardware, demonstrating up to $>1000\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}$ improvement over the best alternative expert-configured techniques available in the open literature. Benchmarking includes experiments using up to 16 qubit systems executing the following: Bernstein Vazirani, quantum Fourier transform, Grover's search, quantum approximate optimization algorithm, variational quantum eigensolver, syndrome extraction on a five-qubit quantum error-correction code, and quantum volume. Experiments reveal a strong contribution of Non-Markovian errors to baseline algorithmic performance; in all cases the deterministic error-suppression workflow delivers the highest performance and approaches incoherent error bounds without the need for any additional sampling or randomization overhead, while maintaining compatibility with all additional probabilistic error suppression techniques.
Error mitigation is essential for unlocking the full potential of quantum algorithms and accelerating the timeline toward quantum advantage. As quantum hardware progresses to push the boundaries of classical simulation, efficient and robust error mitigation methods are becoming increasingly important for producing accurate and reliable outputs. However, existing error-mitigation approaches face a fundamental tradeoff between practical performance and reliability: heuristic methods such as zero-noise extrapolation (ZNE) enjoy faster runtime but lack accuracy guarantees, while rigorous techniques such as probabilistic error cancellation (PEC) provide unbiased estimates at prohibitive computational cost. We introduce a characterization-based, rigorously-grounded quantum error mitigation and error suppression framework (QESEM) that resolves this tradeoff by leveraging the accuracy guarantees of quasi-probabilistic mitigation with dramatically reduced overhead. We explain the innovative methods underlying QESEM and demonstrate its capabilities in the largest utility-scale error mitigation experiment based on an unbiased method. This experiment simulates the kicked transverse field Ising model with far-from-Clifford parameters on an IBM Heron device. We further validate QESEM's versatility across arbitrary quantum circuits and devices through high-accuracy error-mitigated molecular VQE circuits executed on IBM Heron and IonQ trapped-ion devices. Compared with multiple variants of the widely used zero-noise extrapolation method, QESEM consistently achieves higher accuracy while avoiding the prohibitive runtime overhead associated with PEC. These results mark a significant step forward in accuracy and reliability for running quantum circuits on current devices across diverse applications. Finally, we provide projections of QESEM's performance on near-term devices toward quantum advantage.
Dynamic quantum circuits integrate mid-circuit measurements and feed-forward operations to enable real-time classical processing and conditional quantum logic. These capabilities are central to key quantum protocols such as quantum error correction, and have recently demonstrated significant potential for reducing quantum resources, including circuit depth and gate count, across a range of applications. However, executing dynamic circuits on real quantum hardware introduces a critical trade-off: while resource requirements decrease, circuit fidelity degrades due to high error rates of mid-circuit measurements, as well as the decoherence errors accumulated during the extended idle periods introduced by both mid-circuit measurements and feed-forward operations. In this paper, we systematically investigate the impact of standard error mitigation techniques on dynamic circuit applications pertaining to Hamiltonian simulation and ground state estimation of physically relevant systems like the Heisenberg model. We explore dynamical decoupling (DD) as a strategy to suppress decoherence and crosstalk errors during idle windows introduced by mid-circuit measurements and feed-forward delays, and also examine error mitigation via zero-noise extrapolation (ZNE). Through experiments conducted on IBM quantum hardware, we benchmark effective combinations of these strategies that maximize the practical benefits of dynamic quantum circuits in these applications. We demonstrate that a combination of DD and ZNE is effective in mitigating the errors introduced during mid-circuit measurements and feed-forward operations, as well as the errors arising from faulty measurements. This approach yields a energy gap improvement of at least 60% in ground state estimation and reduces observed error of time-evolved states by up to 99% for the Ising model and up to 20% for the Heisenberg model.
In quantum computing, noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices offer unprecedented computational capabilities but are vulnerable to errors, notably measurement inaccuracies that impact computation accuracy. This study explores the efficacy of error mitigation techniques in improving quantum circuit performance on NISQ devices. Techniques such as dynamic decoupling (DD), twirled readout error extraction (T-REx) and zero-noise extrapolation (ZNE) are examined through extensive experimentation on an ideal simulator, IBM Kyoto, and IBM Osaka quantum computers. Results reveal significant performance discrepancies across scenarios, with error mitigation techniques notably enhancing both estimator result and variance values, aligning more closely with ideal simulator outcomes. The comparison results with ideal simulator (having expected result value 0.8284) shows that T-Rex has improved results on IBM Kyoto and enhanced average expected result value from 0.09 to 0.35. Similarly, DD has improved average expected result values from 0.2492 to 0.3788 on IBM Osaka. These findings underscore the critical role of error mitigation in bolstering quantum computation reliability. The results suggest that selection of mitigation technique depends upon quantum circuit and its depth, type of hardware and operations to be performed.