Simplified Josephson-junction fabrication process for reproducibly high-performance superconducting qubits
Amr Osman, J. Simon, Andreas Bengtsson, Sandoko Kosen, Philip Krantz, Daniel Pérez Lozano, Marco Scigliuzzo, Per Delsing, Jonas Bylander, Anita Fadavi Roudsari
We introduce a simplified fabrication technique for Josephson junctions and demonstrate superconducting Xmon qubits with T1 relaxation times averaging above 50 μs (Q>1.5×106). Current shadow-evaporation techniques for aluminum-based Josephson junctions require a separate lithography step to deposit a patch that makes a galvanic, superconducting connection between the junction electrodes and the circuit wiring layer. The patch connection eliminates parasitic junctions, which otherwise contribute significantly to dielectric loss. In our patch-integrated cross-type junction technique, we use one lithography step and one vacuum cycle to evaporate both the junction electrodes and the patch. This eliminates a key bottleneck in manufacturing superconducting qubits by reducing the fabrication time and cost. In a study of more than 3600 junctions, we show an average resistance variation of 3.7% on a wafer that contains forty 0.5×0.5-cm2 chips, with junction areas ranging between 0.01 and 0.16 μm2. The average on-chip spread in resistance is 2.7%, with 20 chips varying between 1.4% and 2%. For the junction sizes used for transmon qubits, we deduce a wafer-level transition-frequency variation of 1.7%–2.5%. We show that 60%–70% of this variation is attributed to junction-area fluctuations, while the rest is caused by tunnel-junction inhomogeneity. Such high frequency predictability is a requirement for scaling-up the number of qubits in a quantum computer.
We introduce a simplified fabrication technique for Josephson junctions and demonstrate superconducting Xmon qubits with T1 relaxation times averaging above 50 μs (Q>1.5×106). Current shadow-evaporation techniques for aluminum-based Josephson junctions require a separate lithography step to deposit a patch that makes a galvanic, superconducting connection between the junction electrodes and the circuit wiring layer. The patch connection eliminates parasitic junctions, which otherwise contribute significantly to dielectric loss. In our patch-integrated cross-type junction technique, we use one lithography step and one vacuum cycle to evaporate both the junction electrodes and the patch. This eliminates a key bottleneck in manufacturing superconducting qubits by reducing the fabrication time and cost. In a study of more than 3600 junctions, we show an average resistance variation of 3.7% on a wafer that contains forty 0.5×0.5-cm2 chips, with junction areas ranging between 0.01 and 0.16 μm2. The average on-chip spread in resistance is 2.7%, with 20 chips varying between 1.4% and 2%. For the junction sizes used for transmon qubits, we deduce a wafer-level transition-frequency variation of 1.7%–2.5%. We show that 60%–70% of this variation is attributed to junction-area fluctuations, while the rest is caused by tunnel-junction inhomogeneity. Such high frequency predictability is a requirement for scaling-up the number of qubits in a quantum computer.
The most commonly used physical realization of superconducting qubits for quantum circuits is a transmon. There are a number of superconducting quantum circuits applications, where Josephson junction critical current reproducibility over a chip is crucial. Here, we report on a robust chip scale Al/AlOx/Al junctions fabrication method due to comprehensive study of shadow evaporation and oxidation steps. We experimentally demonstrate the evidence of optimal Josephson junction electrodes thickness, deposition rate and deposition angle, which ensure minimal electrode surface and line edge roughness. The influence of oxidation method, pressure and time on critical current reproducibility is determined. With the proposed method we demonstrate Al/AlOx/Al junction fabrication with the critical current variation (σ/Ic) less than 3.9% (from 150×200 to 150×600nm2 area) and 7.7% (for 100×100nm2 area) over 20×20mm2 chip. Finally, we fabricate separately three 5×10mm2 chips with 18 transmon qubits (near 4.3 GHz frequency) showing less than 1.9% frequency variation between qubit on different chips. The proposed approach and optimization criteria can be utilized for a robust wafer-scale superconducting qubit circuits fabrication.
Josephson tunnel junctions are the centerpiece of almost any superconducting electronic circuit, including qubits. Typically, the junctions for qubits are fabricated using shadow evaporation techniques to reduce dielectric loss contributions from the superconducting film interfaces. In recent years, however, sub-micrometer scale overlap junctions have started to attract attention. Compared to shadow mask techniques, neither an angle dependent deposition nor free-standing bridges or overlaps are needed, which are significant limitations for wafer-scale processing. This comes at the cost of breaking the vacuum during fabrication, but simplifies integration in multi-layered circuits and implementation of vastly different junction sizes and enables fabrication on a larger scale in an industrially standardized process. In this work, we demonstrate the feasibility of a subtractive process for the fabrication of overlap junctions. In an array of test contacts, we find low aging of the average normal state resistance of only 1.6% over 6 months. We evaluate the coherence properties of the junctions by employing them in superconducting transmon qubits. In time domain experiments, we find that both, the qubit life- and coherence time of our best device, are, on average, greater than 20 μs. Finally, we discuss potential improvements to our technique. This work paves the way toward a more standardized process flow with advanced materials and growth processes, and constitutes an important step for the large scale fabrication of superconducting quantum circuits.
Abstract The most commonly used physical realization of superconducting qubits for quantum circuits is a transmon. There are a number of superconducting quantum circuits applications, where Josephson junction critical current reproducibility over a chip is crucial. Here, we report on a robust chip scale Al/AlO x /Al junctions fabrication method due to comprehensive study of shadow evaporation and oxidation steps. We experimentally demonstrate the evidence of optimal Josephson junction electrodes thickness, deposition rate and deposition angle, which ensure minimal electrode surface and line edge roughness. The influence of oxidation method, pressure and time on critical current reproducibility is determined. With the proposed method we demonstrate Al/AlO x /Al junction fabrication with the critical current variation (σ/⟨Ic⟩) ( σ / ⟨ I c ⟩ ) less than 3.9% (from 150 × 200 to 150 × 600 nm 2 area) and 7.7% (for 100 × 100 nm 2 area) over 20 × 20 mm 2 chip. Finally, we fabricate separately three 5 × 10 mm 2 chips with 18 transmon qubits (near 4.3 GHz frequency) showing less than 1.9% frequency variation between qubits on different chips. The proposed approach and optimization criteria can be utilized for a robust wafer-scale superconducting qubit circuits fabrication.
The performance of superconducting electronic devices such as superconducting quantum bits (qubits) and superconducting quantum interference devices (SQUIDs) strongly relies on high-quality Josephson junctions (JJ) and their integration into surrounding circuit elements. Therefore, a corresponding fabrication technology should allow for the fabrication of all required elements including the JJs, inductances, capacitances and waveguides. For a long time, shadow evaporation technique was the state of the art for the implementation of sub-μ m sized JJs based on aluminum for qubits of high coherence times. Although, the use of a single lithographic step represents a major advantage of this technique. However, shadowing effects limit sample size, device complexity, and thus scalability of the circuitry. To overcome these limitations and to meet the demands of next generation scalable quantum circuits, in this work we introduce our cross -type JJ aluminum technology, where JJs are defined by the overlap of two narrow perpendicular stripes. We discuss the technological challenges, with a focus on our newly developed dry etching process for patterning of the aluminum thin film. Compared to a lift-off based process, this advanced wafer-scale fabrication technology offers a high integration density and the required design flexibility. We will present first results on cross -type aluminum JJs.
Abstract Quantum bits, or qubits, are an example of coherent circuits envisioned for next-generation computers and detectors. A robust superconducting qubit with a coherent lifetime of O(100 µs) is the transmon: a Josephson junction functioning as a non-linear inductor shunted with a capacitor to form an anharmonic oscillator. In a complex device with many such transmons, precise control over each qubit frequency is often required, and thus variations of the junction area and tunnel barrier thickness must be sufficiently minimized to achieve optimal performance while avoiding spectral overlap between neighboring circuits. Simply transplanting our recipe optimized for single, stand-alone devices to wafer-scale (producing 64, 1x1 cm dies from a 150 mm wafer) initially resulted in global drifts in room-temperature tunneling resistance of ± 30%. Inferring a critical current I c variation from this resistance distribution, we present an optimized process developed from a systematic 38 wafer study that results in < 3.5% relative standard deviation (RSD) in critical current ( ≡ σ I c / I c ) for 3000 Josephson junctions (both single-junctions and asymmetric SQUIDs) across an area of 49 cm2. Looking within a 1x1 cm moving window across the substrate gives an estimate of the variation characteristic of a given qubit chip. Our best process, utilizing ultrasonically assisted development, uniform ashing, and dynamic oxidation has shown σ I c / I c = 1.8% within 1x1 cm, on average, with a few 1x1 cm areas having σ I c / I c < 1.0% (equivalent to σ f / f < 0.5%). Such stability would drastically improve the yield of multi-junction chips with strict critical current requirements.
Abstract Josephson superconducting qubits and parametric amplifiers are prominent examples of superconducting quantum circuits that have shown rapid progress in recent years. As such devices become more complex, the requirements for reproducibility of their electrical properties across a chip are being tightened. Critical current of the Josephson junction Ic is the essential electrical parameter in a chip. So, its variation is to be minimized. According to the Ambegaokar–Baratoff formula, critical current is related to normal-state resistance, which can be measured at room temperature. In this study, we focused on the dominant source of non-uniformity for the Josephson junction critical current–junction area variation. We optimized Josephson junction fabrication process and demonstrated resistance variation of 9.8–4.4% and 4.8–2.3% across 22 × 22 mm2 and 5 × 10 mm2 chip areas, respectively. For a wide range of junction areas from 0.008 to 0.12 μm2, we ensure a small linewidth standard deviation of 4 nm measured over 4500 junctions with linear dimensions from 80 to 680 nm. We found that the dominate source of junction area variation limiting Ic I c reproducibility is the imperfection of the evaporation system. The developed fabrication process was tested on superconducting highly coherent transmon qubits (T1 > 100 μs) and a nonlinear asymmetric inductive element parametric amplifier.