Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2004.14576 · CRC Press eBooks

Superconducting Materials for Microwave Kinetic Inductance Detectors

Benjamin A. Mazin

Published May 17, 2022• 25 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The superconducting materials that make up an MKID have a significant effect on its performance. The $T_\textrm{c}$ and normal state resistivity $ρ_\textrm{N}$ of the film determine the penetration depth $λ$ and therefore how much kinetic inductance it has. The ratio of kinetic inductance to total inductance ($α$), the volume of the inductor, and $Q_\textrm{m}$ determines the magnitude of the response to incoming energy. The quasiparticle lifetime $τ_\textrm{qp}$ is the characteristic time during which the MKID's surface impedance is modified by the incoming energy. Many materials have been explored for use in superconducting resonators and MKIDs, but that information is often not published or scattered around the literature. This chapter contains information and references on the work that has been done with thin film lithographed circuits for MKIDs over the last two decades. Note that measured material properties such as the internal loss quality factor $Q_\textrm{i}$ and quasiparticle lifetime $τ_\textrm{qp}$ vary significantly depending on how the MKID superconducting thin film is made and the system they are measured in, so it is best to interpret all stated values as typical but not definitive. Values are omitted in cases when there aren't enough measurements or there is too much disagreement in the literature to estimate a typical value. In order to be as complete as possible some unpublished results from the author's lab are included and can be identified by the lack of a reference. Unless noted all films are polycrystalline or amorphous.

DOI
10.1201/9781003139638-58

Related papers

Validity of analytical Microwave Kinetic Inductance Detector responsivity expressions

Elmore Vaal

Astrophysical photons with a sub-millimetre wavelength are of great value to research star and galaxy formation. Superconductors have a small energy gap with which these sub-millimetre photons can be measured. Superconductors can absorb photons so that quasiparticles are created, which will in turn change the complex conductivity: incoming photons change the electrical response of the superconductor. This principle can be used to realise a detector. This is done with the Microwave Kinetic Inductance Detectors (MKIDs) that consist of a superconducting film embedded in a resonant circuit, so that photons falling in will change the resonant frequency. This can be measured with a readout signal. To enhance the sensitivity of the MKID, we want to increase the responsivity of an MKID as much as possible.A previous study has proposed a figure of merit regarding the material properties of a superconductor to achieve a high responsivity. However, the readout frequency used is not included in this figure. The goal of this work is to extend the figure of merit so that the readout frequency of the MKID can be optimised for a higher responsivity.

•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations

Design and measurement of superconducting microwave kinetic inductance detectors

Florian Blauth

Microwave kinetic inductance detectors (MKID) are superconducting broadband direct detectors. If a superconducting thin film patterned into a resonator is illuminated with photons, Cooper pairs break up and the kinetic inductance of the film changes. This shifts the resonance frequency downwards and the dissipation of the resonator increases, which can be detected in the phase and amplitude of a transmitted signal. \n \nIn this thesis, a waveguide coupled MKID is designed and simulated. 350 GHz radiation is coupled into a copper waveguide via a horn antenna. A waveguide probe leads the signal onto a 9 µm silicon membrane where it is absorbed in a 40 nm superconducting aluminum film which is the inductive part of a superconducting resonator. The capacitor of the resonator is made of niobium. Two versions of the device are developed, a transmission line resonator and a lumped element resonator design. The new design will enable an accurate understanding of the optical sensitivity of MKIDs and allow comparison of different resonator materials. Since two different resonator types are used, the direct comparison of transmission line and lumped resonators will also be possible. \n \nA measurement setup is developed including an ADR cryostat to cool MKID devices down to below 40 mK. An analog readout system using either a vector network analyzer or an IQ mixer is designed and built. The necessary software to control the ADR, the temperature monitoring, the readout signal generation and detection and the signal acquisition of the setup is also developed. \n \nThe waveguide coupled MKID design is fabricated in our in-house microfabrication laboratory and measured in the new setup. In my measurements, the devices do not show a resonance feature. The VNA and DC measurements are analyzed to determine a plausible hypothesis of the failure. The devices are diagnosed for critical issues during fabrication which will be addressed in a future iteration. \n \nTo verify the measurement setup, a test device of the IRAM NIKA 2 MKID camera is measured and the complete analysis pipeline is exercised. The quasi-particle lifetime in the aluminum thin films is measured and a dark and optical noise equivalent power are determined. The results are within the uncertainty comparable to measurements of IRAM themselves. \n \nA test chip designed in my master thesis that contains eight NbTiN resonators is measured in the new setup and non-linear effects under strong readout power are studied. Parametric amplification and oscillation of a resonator are shown qualitatively.

•Oct 1, 2019•0 citations

High quality factor platinum silicide microwave kinetic inductance detectors

Paul Szypryt, B. A. Mazin, G. Ulbricht +4 more

We report on the development of microwave kinetic inductance detectors (MKIDs) using platinum silicide as the sensor material. MKIDs are an emerging superconducting detector technology, capable of measuring the arrival times of single photons to better than two microseconds and their energies to around ten percent. Previously, MKIDs have been fabricated using either sub-stoichiometric titanium nitride or aluminum, but TiN suffers from the spatial inhomogeneities in the superconducting critical temperature and Al has a low kinetic inductance fraction, causing low detector sensitivity. To address these issues, we have instead fabricated the PtSi microresonators with the superconducting critical temperatures of 944 ± 12 mK and high internal quality factors (Qi≳106). These devices show typical quasiparticle lifetimes of τqp≈30–40 μs and spectral resolution, R=λ/Δλ, of 8 at 406.6 nm. We compare PtSi MKIDs to those fabricated with TiN and detail the substantial advantages that PtSi MKIDs have to offer.

arXiv:1610.00725•Applied Physics Letters•Oct 10, 2016•37 citations

Superconducting Films for Absorber-Coupled MKID Detectors for Sub-Millimeter and Far-Infrared Astronomy

Thomas R. Stevenson, J. S. Adams, Wen-Ting Hsieh +5 more

We describe measurements of the properties, at dc, gigahertz, and terahertz frequencies, of thin (10 nm) aluminum films with 10 Omega/square normal state sheet resistance. Such films can be applied to construct microwave kinetic inductance detector arrays for submillimeter and far-infrared astronomical applications in which incident power excites quasiparticles directly in a superconducting resonator that is configured to present a matched-impedance to the high frequency radiation being detected. For films 10 nm thick, we report normal state sheet resistance, resistance-temperature curves for the superconducting transition, quality factor and kinetic inductance fraction for microwave resonators made from patterned films, and terahertz measurements of sheet impedance measured with a Fourier Transform Spectrometer. We compare properties with similar resonators made from niobium 600 nm thick.

IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity•Jun 1, 2009•7 citations

Far-infrared kinetic-inductance detectors

Erich N. Grossman, Donald G. McDonald, Joseph E. Sauvageau

Extremely sensitive far-infrared detectors suitable for both direct detection and heterodyne applications, based on mu m-sized thin films with thickness less than a superconducting penetration depth are possible. The penetration depth of such a film, and therefore its inductance, varies with temperature and with quasiparticle population (described by an effective temperature T*), resulting in both bolometric and nonequilibrium photoinductive responses. Incident radiation is coupled into the small-area kinetic inductor by a lithographic antenna, and the resulting inductance changes are amplified and converted to a voltage signal by an integrated microstrip DC SQUID. The device is sensitive because, unlike junction-based devices with large capacitive reactances, the kinetic inductor is naturally well matched to the antenna impedance at the far-IR frequency ( nu >2 Delta /h) and to the preamplifier (SQUID) impedance at microwave or video frequencies ( nu <<2 Delta /h). The best kinetic inductor materials are those with low electronic mean free path, large penetration depth, and high critical current density. Thus, common magnet alloys such as NbTi are the natural choice for liquid-He temperature operation. A detailed analysis predicts a (phonon-limited) NEP of 4*10/sup -17/ W/ square root Hz for a bolometer with an iridium kinetic inductor operated at 0.1 K. A heterodyne noise temperature of 2250 K (single-sideband) at 3 THz, with a 200-MHz bandwidth, is predicted for a Nb-Ti mixer operated at 4 K.

IEEE Transactions on Magnetics•Mar 1, 1991•39 citations

Characterization of the kinetic inductance fraction of NbTiN MKIDs

Wei-Tao Lv, Qing Shi, Jing Li +2 more

Microwave Kinetic Inductance Detectors (MKIDs), with high sensitivity and relatively simple frequency multiplexing, are emerging as a kind of large-array detectors in the terahertz (THz) band. An MKID, like a superconducting resonator, is composed of a planar capacitor and inductor that are made from superconducting films. The energy gap of the superconducting film for the planar inductor (at least part of it) is lower than the energy of photons to be detected. The kinetic inductance of the superconducting film irradiated by the photons is increased, shifting the resonance frequency toward a lower frequency. The frequency shift is proportional to the kinetic inductance fraction, i.e., the ratio of the kinetic inductance to the total inductance of the planar superconducting inductor. In this paper, we thoroughly investigate the kinetic inductance fraction for lumped-element and antenna-coupled MKIDs, which are both made from NbTiN. The detailed simulation, calculation, and measurement results will be presented.

Infrared, Millimeter-Wave, and Terahertz Technologies•Oct 8, 2021•0 citations
The superconducting materials that make up an MKID have a significant effect on its performance. The TcT_\textrm{c}Tc​ and normal state resistivity ρNρ_\textrm{N}ρN​ of the film determine the penetration depth λλλ and therefore how much kinetic inductance it has. The ratio of kinetic inductance to total inductance (ααα), the volume of the inductor, and QmQ_\textrm{m}Qm​ determines the magnitude of the response to incoming energy. The quasiparticle lifetime τqpτ_\textrm{qp}τqp​ is the characteristic time during which the MKID's surface impedance is modified by the incoming energy. Many materials have been explored for use in superconducting resonators and MKIDs, but that information is often not published or scattered around the literature. This chapter contains information and references on the work that has been done with thin film lithographed circuits for MKIDs over the last two decades. Note that measured material properties such as the internal loss quality factor QiQ_\textrm{i}Qi​ and quasiparticle lifetime τqpτ_\textrm{qp}τqp​ vary significantly depending on how the MKID superconducting thin film is made and the system they are measured in, so it is best to interpret all stated values as typical but not definitive. Values are omitted in cases when there aren't enough measurements or there is too much disagreement in the literature to estimate a typical value. In order to be as complete as possible some unpublished results from the author's lab are included and can be identified by the lack of a reference. Unless noted all films are polycrystalline or amorphous.
Astrophysical photons with a sub-millimetre wavelength are of great value to research star and galaxy formation. Superconductors have a small energy gap with which these sub-millimetre photons can be measured. Superconductors can absorb photons so that quasiparticles are created, which will in turn change the complex conductivity: incoming photons change the electrical response of the superconductor. This principle can be used to realise a detector. This is done with the Microwave Kinetic Inductance Detectors (MKIDs) that consist of a superconducting film embedded in a resonant circuit, so that photons falling in will change the resonant frequency. This can be measured with a readout signal. To enhance the sensitivity of the MKID, we want to increase the responsivity of an MKID as much as possible.A previous study has proposed a figure of merit regarding the material properties of a superconductor to achieve a high responsivity. However, the readout frequency used is not included in this figure. The goal of this work is to extend the figure of merit so that the readout frequency of the MKID can be optimised for a higher responsivity.
Microwave kinetic inductance detectors (MKID) are superconducting broadband direct detectors. If a superconducting thin film patterned into a resonator is illuminated with photons, Cooper pairs break up and the kinetic inductance of the film changes. This shifts the resonance frequency downwards and the dissipation of the resonator increases, which can be detected in the phase and amplitude of a transmitted signal. \n \nIn this thesis, a waveguide coupled MKID is designed and simulated. 350 GHz radiation is coupled into a copper waveguide via a horn antenna. A waveguide probe leads the signal onto a 9 µm silicon membrane where it is absorbed in a 40 nm superconducting aluminum film which is the inductive part of a superconducting resonator. The capacitor of the resonator is made of niobium. Two versions of the device are developed, a transmission line resonator and a lumped element resonator design. The new design will enable an accurate understanding of the optical sensitivity of MKIDs and allow comparison of different resonator materials. Since two different resonator types are used, the direct comparison of transmission line and lumped resonators will also be possible. \n \nA measurement setup is developed including an ADR cryostat to cool MKID devices down to below 40 mK. An analog readout system using either a vector network analyzer or an IQ mixer is designed and built. The necessary software to control the ADR, the temperature monitoring, the readout signal generation and detection and the signal acquisition of the setup is also developed. \n \nThe waveguide coupled MKID design is fabricated in our in-house microfabrication laboratory and measured in the new setup. In my measurements, the devices do not show a resonance feature. The VNA and DC measurements are analyzed to determine a plausible hypothesis of the failure. The devices are diagnosed for critical issues during fabrication which will be addressed in a future iteration. \n \nTo verify the measurement setup, a test device of the IRAM NIKA 2 MKID camera is measured and the complete analysis pipeline is exercised. The quasi-particle lifetime in the aluminum thin films is measured and a dark and optical noise equivalent power are determined. The results are within the uncertainty comparable to measurements of IRAM themselves. \n \nA test chip designed in my master thesis that contains eight NbTiN resonators is measured in the new setup and non-linear effects under strong readout power are studied. Parametric amplification and oscillation of a resonator are shown qualitatively.
We report on the development of microwave kinetic inductance detectors (MKIDs) using platinum silicide as the sensor material. MKIDs are an emerging superconducting detector technology, capable of measuring the arrival times of single photons to better than two microseconds and their energies to around ten percent. Previously, MKIDs have been fabricated using either sub-stoichiometric titanium nitride or aluminum, but TiN suffers from the spatial inhomogeneities in the superconducting critical temperature and Al has a low kinetic inductance fraction, causing low detector sensitivity. To address these issues, we have instead fabricated the PtSi microresonators with the superconducting critical temperatures of 944 ± 12 mK and high internal quality factors (Qi≳106). These devices show typical quasiparticle lifetimes of τqp≈30–40 μs and spectral resolution, R=λ/Δλ, of 8 at 406.6 nm. We compare PtSi MKIDs to those fabricated with TiN and detail the substantial advantages that PtSi MKIDs have to offer.
We describe measurements of the properties, at dc, gigahertz, and terahertz frequencies, of thin (10 nm) aluminum films with 10 Omega/square normal state sheet resistance. Such films can be applied to construct microwave kinetic inductance detector arrays for submillimeter and far-infrared astronomical applications in which incident power excites quasiparticles directly in a superconducting resonator that is configured to present a matched-impedance to the high frequency radiation being detected. For films 10 nm thick, we report normal state sheet resistance, resistance-temperature curves for the superconducting transition, quality factor and kinetic inductance fraction for microwave resonators made from patterned films, and terahertz measurements of sheet impedance measured with a Fourier Transform Spectrometer. We compare properties with similar resonators made from niobium 600 nm thick.
Extremely sensitive far-infrared detectors suitable for both direct detection and heterodyne applications, based on mu m-sized thin films with thickness less than a superconducting penetration depth are possible. The penetration depth of such a film, and therefore its inductance, varies with temperature and with quasiparticle population (described by an effective temperature T*), resulting in both bolometric and nonequilibrium photoinductive responses. Incident radiation is coupled into the small-area kinetic inductor by a lithographic antenna, and the resulting inductance changes are amplified and converted to a voltage signal by an integrated microstrip DC SQUID. The device is sensitive because, unlike junction-based devices with large capacitive reactances, the kinetic inductor is naturally well matched to the antenna impedance at the far-IR frequency ( nu >2 Delta /h) and to the preamplifier (SQUID) impedance at microwave or video frequencies ( nu <<2 Delta /h). The best kinetic inductor materials are those with low electronic mean free path, large penetration depth, and high critical current density. Thus, common magnet alloys such as NbTi are the natural choice for liquid-He temperature operation. A detailed analysis predicts a (phonon-limited) NEP of 4*10/sup -17/ W/ square root Hz for a bolometer with an iridium kinetic inductor operated at 0.1 K. A heterodyne noise temperature of 2250 K (single-sideband) at 3 THz, with a 200-MHz bandwidth, is predicted for a Nb-Ti mixer operated at 4 K.
Microwave Kinetic Inductance Detectors (MKIDs), with high sensitivity and relatively simple frequency multiplexing, are emerging as a kind of large-array detectors in the terahertz (THz) band. An MKID, like a superconducting resonator, is composed of a planar capacitor and inductor that are made from superconducting films. The energy gap of the superconducting film for the planar inductor (at least part of it) is lower than the energy of photons to be detected. The kinetic inductance of the superconducting film irradiated by the photons is increased, shifting the resonance frequency toward a lower frequency. The frequency shift is proportional to the kinetic inductance fraction, i.e., the ratio of the kinetic inductance to the total inductance of the planar superconducting inductor. In this paper, we thoroughly investigate the kinetic inductance fraction for lumped-element and antenna-coupled MKIDs, which are both made from NbTiN. The detailed simulation, calculation, and measurement results will be presented.