arXiv:2002.06272 · Physical Review A

Range of applicability of the Hu-Paz-Zhang master equation

Gábor Homa, András Csordás, Mihály A. Csirik, József Zsolt Bernád

Published Aug 10, 2020• 10 citations

Abstract

We investigate a case of the Hu-Paz-Zhang master equation of the Caldeira-Leggett model without Lindblad form obtained in the weak-coupling limit up to the second-order perturbation. In our study, we use Gaussian initial states to be able to employ a sufficient and necessary condition, which can expose positivity violations of the density operator during the time evolution. We demonstrate that the evolution of the non-Markovian master equation has problems when the stationary solution is not a positive operator, i.e., does not have physical interpretation. We also show that solutions always remain physical for small times of evolution. Moreover, we identify a strong anomalous behavior, when the trace of the solution is diverging. We also provide results for the corresponding Markovian master equation and show that positivity violations occur for various types of initial conditions even when the stationary solution is a positive operator. Based on our numerical results, we conclude that this non-Markovian master equation is superior to the corresponding Markovian one.

DOI: 10.1103/physreva.102.022206

Related papers

Analytical evaluation of the coefficients of the Hu-Paz-Zhang master equation: Ohmic spectral density, zero temperature, and consistency check

Gábor Homa, József Zsolt Bernád, András Csordás

We investigate the exact master equation of Hu, Paz, and Zhang for a quantum harmonic oscillator at zero temperature with a Lorentz-Drude type Ohmic spectral density. This master equation plays an important role in the study of quantum Brownian motion and in various applications. In this paper, we give an analytical evaluation of the coefficients of this non-Markovian master equation without Lindblad form, which allows us to investigate consistencies of the solutions, the positivity of the stationary density operator, and the boundaries of the model's parameters.

arXiv:2211.15722Physical Review AJul 20, 20239 citations

Master equation for non-Markovian quantum Brownian motion: The emergence of lateral coherences

Sapphire Lally, Nicholas Werren, Jim Al-Khalili +1 more

Understanding the behavior of a quantum system coupled to its environment is of fundamental interest in the general field of quantum technologies. It also has important repercussions on foundational problems in physics, such as the process of decoherence and the so-called quantum measurement problem. There have been many approaches to explore Markovian and non-Markovian dynamics within the framework of open quantum systems, but the richness of the ensuing dynamics is still not fully understood. In this paper we develop a non-Markovian extension of the standard Caldeira-Leggett model, based on expanding the dynamics of the reduced system at high temperature in inverse powers of the high-frequency cutoff of the Ohmic spectral density of the environment and derive a non-Markovian master equation for the reduced density matrix for the case of a general potential. We also obtain a fully analytical solution in the free particle case. While the short-time behavior of this solution does not diverge substantially from the Markovian behavior, at intermediate times we find a resurgence of coherence, which we name lateral coherence. We identify this with a corresponding transient negative entropy production rate, which is understood to be characteristic of non-Markovian dynamics. We also analyze the positivity of the reduced density matrix and derive the corresponding Fokker-Planck equation in the classical limit.

arXiv:1907.05874Physical Review AJan 18, 20226 citations

Equilibration and asymptotic stationarity for non-Markovian master equations

Joshua Wilkie, Yin Mei Wong

We show that certain positivity-preserving non-Markovian generalizations of the Kossakowski–Lindblad master equation can exhibit equilibration to an asymptotic state which is stationary with respect to the shifted system Hamiltonian for general system–bath coupling. This is in sharp contrast to results for Markovian forms which require strong relations between these operators (e.g. commutation of isolated system Hamiltonian and coupling operator). We also expand the list of sufficient conditions for positivity of non-Markovian master equations.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and TheoreticalJun 7, 20112 citations

Steady states of quantum Brownian motion and decomposition of quantum states into ensembles of Gaussian packets having a uniform position variance

Yan Gu

Abstract After replacing the reduced density matrix of a quantum harmonic oscillator linearly coupled to a thermal bath by its ‘characteristic function’ (a non-negative definite function defined on the Heisenberg-Weyl group), the master equation of the reduced density matrix can be transformed into a first-order linear partial differential equation of the characteristic function. We derive stationary solutions for the Caldeira–Leggett (CL) master equation as well as for the late-time Hu–Paz–Zhang master equation, and examine the positivity problem for these solutions. In order to illustrate to what extent classical properties of quantum states of the damping oscillator emerge dynamically due to coupling to the environment, we discuss the problem of how and under what conditions a steady state predicted by the CL master equation could be expressed as a statistical mixture of Gaussian packets having a uniform position variance. Similar studies are carried out for the solutions of a Lindblad-form generalization of the CL master equation, where the positivity problem is certainly absent. Our results show that in the low-temperature regime the steady states predicted by the Lindblad-type master equation may depend on the damping strength of the bath and there are cases which may not show Gaussian-packet decomposition.

Physica ScriptaJun 26, 20193 citations

Dissipation in the Caldeira-Leggett model

Luca Ferialdi

Caldeira and Leggett (CL), in a seminal paper, derived a master equation describing Markovian quantum Brownian motion. Such an equation suffered from not being completely positive, and many efforts have been made to solve this issue. We show that when a careful mathematical analysis is performed, the model considered by CL leads to a nondissipative master equation. We argue that the correct way to understand the master equation derived in the CL regime is to consider it non-Markovian. Moreover, we show that if one wants to provide a microscopic description of quantum Brownian motion with the CL model, one always needs to consider a non-Markovian dynamics. We conclude that dissipation is a genuinely non-Markovian feature.

arXiv:1701.05024Physical Review AMay 11, 201736 citations

Dissipation in open quantum systems

Luca Ferialdi

Caldeira and Leggett (CL) in a seminal paper derived a master equation describing Markovian Quantum Brownian motion. Such an equation suffered of not being completely positive, and many efforts have been made to solve this issue. We show that, when a careful mathematical analysis is performed, the model considered by CL leads to a non dissipative master equation. We argue that the correct way to understand the master equation derived in the CL regime is to consider it non-Markovian. Moreover, we show that if one wants to provide a microscopic description of Quantum Brownian motion one always needs to consider a non-Markovian dynamics. We conclude that dissipation is a genuinely non-Markovian feature.

Jan 18, 20170 citations