In this note we consider lattice fermions on Z2 with a locally unique gapped ground state and show how to apply the non-equilibrium almost stationary state (NEASS) approach to linear response to derive a formula for the Hall conductance in terms of the ground state expectation of a commutator of modified step functions. This formula is usually derived by a charge pumping argument going back to Laughlin. Here we show that it can also be obtained as the linear response coefficient of the microscopic current response to an adiabatic increase of the chemical potential on a half plane (or more generally on any cone-like region). Indeed, in a manner reminiscent of the bulk-boundary correspondence, we show that raising the chemical potential in any cone-like region gives rise to a current that flows along its boundary and is nearly linear in the increase in chemical potential. We also discuss the connection with the double commutator formula with modified position operators for the Hall conductivity derived in [Wesle et al., Commun. Math. Phys. 406, 199 (2025)] as the linear response coefficient of the macroscopic current response to the adiabatic application of a constant electric field.
We first review the problem of a rigorous justification of Kubo’s formula for transport coefficients in gapped extended Hamiltonian quantum systems at zero temperature. In particular, the theoretical understanding of the quantum Hall effect rests on the validity of Kubo’s formula for such systems, a connection that we review briefly as well. We then highlight an approach to linear response theory based on non-equilibrium almost-stationary states (NEASS) and on a corresponding adiabatic theorem for such systems that was recently proposed and worked out by one of us in [51] for interacting fermionic systems on finite lattices. In the second part of our paper, we show how to lift the results of [51] to infinite systems by taking a thermodynamic limit.
Abstract We consider an infinitely extended system of fermions on a d-dimensional lattice with (magnetic) translation-invariant short-range interactions. We further assume that the system has a gapped ground state. Physically, this is a model for the bulk of a generic topological insulator at zero temperature, and we are interested in the current response of such a system to a constant external electric field. Using the non-equilibrium almost-stationary states approach, we prove that the longitudinal current density induced by a constant electric field of strength
ε ε is of order
O(ε∞) O ( ε ∞ ) , i.e. the system is an insulator in the usual sense. For the Hall current density we show instead that it is linear in
ε ε up to terms of order
O(ε∞) O ( ε ∞ ) . The proportionality factor
σH σ H is by definition the Hall conductivity, and we show that it is given by a generalization of the well known double commutator formula to interacting systems. As a by-product of our results, we find that the Hall conductivity is constant within gapped phases, and that for
d=2 d = 2 the relevant observable that “measures” the Hall conductivity in experiments, the Hall conductance, not only agrees with
σH σ H in expectation up to
O(ε∞) O ( ε ∞ ) , but also has vanishing variance. A notable difference to several existing results on the current response in interacting fermion systems is that we consider a macroscopic system exposed to a small constant electric field, rather than to a small voltage drop.
Motivated by recent work on Hall viscosity, we derive from first principles the Kubo formulas for the stress-stress response function at zero wave vector that can be used to define the full complex frequency-dependent viscosity tensor, both with and without a uniform magnetic field. The formulas in the existing literature are frequently incomplete, incorrect, or lack a derivation; in particular, Hall viscosity is overlooked. Our approach begins from the response to a uniform external strain field, which is an active time-dependent coordinate transformation in
d space dimensions. These transformations form the group GL
(d,R) of invertible matrices, and the infinitesimal generators are called strain generators. These enable us to express the Kubo formula in different ways, related by Ward identities; some of these make contact with the adiabatic transport approach. The importance of retaining contact terms, analogous to the diamagnetic term in the familiar Kubo formula for conductivity, is emphasized. For Galilean-invariant systems, we derive a relation between the stress response tensor and the conductivity tensor that is valid at all frequencies and in both the presence and absence of a magnetic field. In the presence of a magnetic field and at low frequency, this yields a relation between the Hall viscosity, the
q2 part of the Hall conductivity, the inverse compressibility (suitably defined), and the diverging part of the shear viscosity (if any); this relation generalizes a result found recently by others. We show that the correct value of the Hall viscosity at zero frequency can be obtained (at least in the absence of low-frequency bulk and shear viscosity) by assuming that there is an orbital spin per particle that couples to a perturbing electromagnetic field as a magnetization per particle. We study several examples as checks on our formulation. We also present formulas for the stress response that directly generalize the Berry (adiabatic) curvature expressions for zero-frequency Hall conductivity or viscosity to the full tensors at all frequencies.
We study the topological band theory of quantum Hall systems in which the adiabatic flux parameters of an external gauge potential form a high-dimensional manifold. This situation arises both for strongly correlated matter on spatial Riemann surfaces of genus
g>1, as well as in the formal study of matter on compact oriented manifolds of dimension
4ℓ+2=2p coupled to
p-form gauge potentials. In these cases, the underlying topological invariants defined over the parameter space are significantly richer than the low-dimensional (i.e., two-dimensional) case and involve both the curvature (i.e., first Chern class) as well as higher order curvature invariants. These higher curvature invariants correspond to topologically protected contributions to Kubo-like formulae, constructed from correlation functions of the physical current operators. We illustrate these general considerations with an explicit example from hyperbolic band theory based on the genus-two Bolza Riemann surface, a case which has recently been simulated on a synthetic-dimension platform.
An extension of the Hellmann-Feynman theorem to one employing dynamical parameters that vary with time according to quantum dynamics is rigorously derived, avoiding any linear response or other approximations. The resulting theorem for the dynamics of observables, valid to all orders in external fields, is found to contain generalized Berry curvature type of quantities that incorporate the dynamics through explicit and nontrivial time-dependence; these Berry quantities resemble the so called anomalous terms (in semiclassical equations of motion in solids) but are both of magnetic and electric type, the former being associated with Quantum Hall Effect type of behaviors and the latter with Polarization type of behaviors. By way of application of the new theorem, the quantum equations of motion of a spinless and a spinfull electron in a solid are derived without any adiabatic or semiclassical approximation. The charge current formula for a many-body and interacting spinfull system is also derived and is found to consist of a longitudinal and a transverse part; phenomenological interpretations with respect to polarization and magnetization currents respectively then emerge in a natural way. In addition, a formula for the topological magnetoelectric effect for an interacting spinfull electron system is also provided. By carefully defining singlevaluedness in parameter space, in a nonstandard fashion and in higher rigor than usual, we are able to discuss in clarity the issue of possible obstruction of this singlevaluedness, the associated creation of Berry monopoles in parameter space and the quantization of the flux of Berry curvature (but with nontrivial dynamics included in its definition).