Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/9701021

Correlation between Quantum Mechanics and Classical Theory of Rotating Electron Models and Possible Experiment

V.N. Melekhin

Published Jan 17, 1997• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

It is shown that the point charge and magnetic moment of electron produce together such a field that total electromagnetic momentum has a component perpendicular to electron velocity. As a result classical electron models, having magnetic moment, move not along a straight line, if there is no external force, but along a spiral, the space period and radius of which are comparable with de-Broglie wave length. Some other surprising coincidences with quantum theory arise as a result of calculation. An experiment is proposed for direct observation of quantum or of new type electron delocalization.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/9701021

Related papers

The quantum theory of the electron

P. A. M. Dirac

Abstract The new quantum mechanics, when applied to the problem of the structure of the atom with point-charge electrons, does not give results in agreement with experiment. The discrepancies consist of “duplexity ” phenomena, the observed number of stationary states for an electron in an atom being twice the number given by the theory. To meet the difficulty, Goudsmit and Uhlenbeck have introduced the idea of an electron with a spin angular momentum of half a quantum and a magnetic moment of one Bohr magneton. This model for the electron has been fitted into the new mechanics by Pauli,* and Darwin,† working with an equivalent theory, has shown that it gives results in agreement with experiment for hydrogen-like spectra to the first order of accuracy. The question remains as to why Nature should have chosen this particular model for the electron instead of being satisfied with the point-charge. One would like to find some incompleteness in the previous methods of applying quantum mechanics to the point-charge electron such that, when removed, the whole of the duplexity phenomena follow without arbitrary assumptions. In the present paper it is shown that this is the case, the incompleteness of the previous theories lying in their disagreement with relativity, or, alternatetively, with the general transformation theory of quantum mechanics. It appears that the simplest Hamiltonian for a point-charge electron satisfying the requirements of both relativity and the general transformation theory leads to an explanation of all duplexity phenomena without further assumption. All the same there is a great deal of truth in the spinning electron model, at least as a first approximation. The most important failure of the model seems to be that the magnitude of the resultant orbital angular momentum of an electron moving in an orbit in a central field of force is not a constant, as the model leads one to expect.

Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series A Containing Papers of a Mathematical and Physical Character•Feb 1, 1928•3,847 citations

Helical Model of the Electron

Oliver Consa

A semiclassical model of the electron is presented based on the Principle of Helical Motion (“A free electron always moves at the speed of light following a helical motion, with a constant radius, and with the direction of movement perpendicular to the rotation plane”). This model interprets the Zitterbewegung as a real motion that causes rotation of the electron spin and its magnetic moment. Based on this model, the quantum magnetic flux and quantum Hall resistance are obtained as parameters of the electron and special relativity theory is derived from the helical motion of the electron. Finally, a fix is proposed for the De Broglie’s wavelength that questions the very validity of the Dirac equation.

•Aug 1, 2014•2 citations

The Value of em by Deflection Experiments

G. E. Uhlenbeck, Lloyd A. Young

To clarify the discussion as to whether or not a quantum mechanical treatment of the motion of electrons in magnetic fields will lead to a formula for $\frac{e}{m}$, differing from that obtained by classical electro-dynamics the following problem was solved. A uniform magnetic field in the $z$-direction exists in the half-space $x>0$. A plane monochromatic de Broglie wave, travelling in the positive $x$-direction representing electrons of arbitrary energy, impinges normally on the plane $x=0$. Solutions of the wave equation were found fulfilling appropriate boundary conditions at the plane $x=0$. Currents are calculated quantum mechanically and compared with the corresponding classical expressions. It was found that for electrons possessing energies of the order of magnitude used in deflection experiments, no observable deviations from classical results are predicted. Another quantum mechanical effect is diffraction at slits. Simple approximate calculations show that this effect can produce a fractional error in $\frac{e}{m}$ of the order of the de Broglie wave-length divided by the slit width. These results are opposite to the conclusions reached by Page. We may remark that he solved a problem of "stationary states" which does not represent the actual experiments.

Physical Review•Dec 15, 1930•9 citations

Spin in Classical and Quantum Theory

Herbert C. Corben

The classical equations of motion of a charged point-particle with intrinsic spin under the influence of an external electromagnetic field are restated and compared with the Heisenberg equations of motion derived from the Dirac theory. The partition of angular momentum between particle and field in the classical theory is contrasted to the Dirac theory of electron spin. The analogy between the Dirac equation and the theory of parametric amplification is pointed out.A free spinning point particle moving according to the laws of classical relativistic point-particle mechanics may move along a helix. The sum of the intrinsic spin $\ensuremath{\sigma}$ and the angular momentum of the helical motion in this classical analog of zitterbewegung is an effective spin vector S which is a constant of the motion. Because of this internal motion, the effective mass $M$ of the particle differs from the mass $m$ which is ascribed to it in the equations of motion. Solutions are found in which S is parallel or antiparallel to the momentum, and the sign of $M$ is determined by the helicity. When placed in a uniform electromagnetic field, the particle behaves as if it had a rest mass $M$ and a magnetic moment $\frac{e\ensuremath{\sigma}}{\mathrm{Mc}}$, in addition to any explicit magnetic moment that may be ascribed to it.

Physical Review•Mar 15, 1961•81 citations

Time-Crystal Model of the Electron Spin

Mário G. Silveirinha

The wave-particle duality is one of the most intriguing properties of quantum objects. The duality is rather pervasive in the quantum world in the sense that not only classical particles sometimes behave like waves, but also classical waves, e.g., light, may behave as point particles. In this article, motivated by the wave-particle duality, I develop a deterministic time-crystal Lorentz-covariant mechanical model for an electron with spin. In the proposed time-crystal model an electron is formed by two components: a particle-type component that transports the electric charge, and a wave component that moves at the speed of light and whirls around the massive component. Interestingly, the motion of the particle-component is completely ruled by the trajectory of the wave-component, somewhat analogous to the pilot-wave theory of de Broglie-Bohm. The dynamics of the time-crystal electron is controlled by a generalized least action principle. The model predicts that the electron stationary states have a constant spin angular momentum, predicts the spin vector precession in a magnetic field and gives a possible explanation for the physical origin of the anomalous magnetic moment. Remarkably, the developed model has nonlocal features that prevent the divergence of the self-field interactions. The classical theory of the electron is recovered as an effective theory valid on a coarse time scale. The reported results suggest that time-crystal models may be used to describe some features of the quantum world that are inaccessible to the standard classical theory.

•Jul 22, 2021•0 citations

A Planck-Einstein-Dirac Wave Model of Electron

Zhaoxin Wang

The spherical model of electron cannot explain Bohr magneton, de Broglie wave, etc. To explain these properties physically, we propose that spin, one core concept of quantum theory, is a reality, and introduce this alternative solely based on experimental findings, Planck’s, Einstein’s, and Dirac’s insights, and follows classical laws, that an electron is an electrical wave with a literal $\frac{1}{2}$ spin (Dirac), i.e., spins two circles in one cycle, both angular momentum are ℏ. Its wavelength is determined by $E=h\nu_{m_0}=\frac{hc}{\lambda_{m_0}}=m_0c^2$ (Plank and Einstein), λ m 0 is the Compton wavelength. As E⃗ ⊥ c⃗ for a transverse wave, it has a net electricity due to the first spin, $f(E_q)=\frac{1}{2}E_0\left(1-\cos(2\omega_0t)\right)$, half of its cycle, i.e., the minimal meaningful unit as F = E q , is related with its charge, q = E q ϵ 0 . Moreover, an electron has a ring shape due to the second spin, 2 π R 0 = λ m 0 , λ m 0 is the electron-impact cross section. As $\hbar=\frac{h}{\lambda_{m_0}}\frac{\lambda_{m_0}}{2\pi}=m_0cR_0$, it has a quantized classical angular momentum, with a speed of c . The Bohr magneton, $\vec{\mu_B}=\vec{\frac{q}{2m_0}\hbar}$, g -factor is 2. Critically, the full Dirac’s equation of an electron with a constant velocity is $\vec{mc} = \vec{\hbar_\perp}+\vec{p_\perp } +\vec{\hbar_{//}} +\vec{p_{//}}$, and its electromagnetic properties due to charge are $\vec{f(E_q)} = \vec{f(E_q)\frac{\sqrt{c^2-v^{'2}}}{c}} + \vec{f(E_q) \frac{v\rq}{c}} = \vec{E_{net}^{//}} + \vec{E_q^\perp}$, $\vec{v\rq} // \vec{\hbar_\perp}$ or $\vec{v\rq} // \vec{\hbar_{//}}$, and $\vec{v\rq} // \vec{E_{net}}$. Assuming heavy charged particles have equivalent though shall not identical mechanisms, mathematically this model is equivalent to Special Relativity, and supports ALL its formulas, i.e., v < c , E = m c 2 , direction-insensitive m = γ m 0 and $t=\frac{t_0}{\gamma}$; Moreover, the net electricity $\vec{E_{net}^{//}}$ and Bohr magneton is orientation-quantized, direction-sensitive and follows Lorentz transformation, leading to Lorentz transformation of length contraction; while following Relativity, magnetism can be defined by $\vec{f(B)} =\vec{f(E_q)\frac{v\rq}{c^2}}$, which is not circularly symmetric and self-evidently does not follow Lorentz transformation. The temporospatial averaged magnetic intensity of a current is relativistic, $\bar{\vec{B}} =\sum\vec{{f(E_q)}\frac{\Delta v}{c^2 }}=\frac{\vec{I}}{2 \pi \epsilon_0 c^2}=\frac{\mu_0\vec{I}}{2\pi}$, and μ 0 ϵ 0 c 2 = 1, supporting Maxwell’s equations. Further implications include chirality therefore magnetic spatial quantization, de Broglie wave, etc. The spherical model should be just an observation due to orientation quantization of $\vec{E_{net}}$. We conclude this model of electron may provide one step further to the ultimate Quantum Theory in a nonrelativistic spacetime.

•Nov 14, 2025•0 citations
It is shown that the point charge and magnetic moment of electron produce together such a field that total electromagnetic momentum has a component perpendicular to electron velocity. As a result classical electron models, having magnetic moment, move not along a straight line, if there is no external force, but along a spiral, the space period and radius of which are comparable with de-Broglie wave length. Some other surprising coincidences with quantum theory arise as a result of calculation. An experiment is proposed for direct observation of quantum or of new type electron delocalization.
Abstract The new quantum mechanics, when applied to the problem of the structure of the atom with point-charge electrons, does not give results in agreement with experiment. The discrepancies consist of “duplexity ” phenomena, the observed number of stationary states for an electron in an atom being twice the number given by the theory. To meet the difficulty, Goudsmit and Uhlenbeck have introduced the idea of an electron with a spin angular momentum of half a quantum and a magnetic moment of one Bohr magneton. This model for the electron has been fitted into the new mechanics by Pauli,* and Darwin,† working with an equivalent theory, has shown that it gives results in agreement with experiment for hydrogen-like spectra to the first order of accuracy. The question remains as to why Nature should have chosen this particular model for the electron instead of being satisfied with the point-charge. One would like to find some incompleteness in the previous methods of applying quantum mechanics to the point-charge electron such that, when removed, the whole of the duplexity phenomena follow without arbitrary assumptions. In the present paper it is shown that this is the case, the incompleteness of the previous theories lying in their disagreement with relativity, or, alternatetively, with the general transformation theory of quantum mechanics. It appears that the simplest Hamiltonian for a point-charge electron satisfying the requirements of both relativity and the general transformation theory leads to an explanation of all duplexity phenomena without further assumption. All the same there is a great deal of truth in the spinning electron model, at least as a first approximation. The most important failure of the model seems to be that the magnitude of the resultant orbital angular momentum of an electron moving in an orbit in a central field of force is not a constant, as the model leads one to expect.
A semiclassical model of the electron is presented based on the Principle of Helical Motion (“A free electron always moves at the speed of light following a helical motion, with a constant radius, and with the direction of movement perpendicular to the rotation plane”). This model interprets the Zitterbewegung as a real motion that causes rotation of the electron spin and its magnetic moment. Based on this model, the quantum magnetic flux and quantum Hall resistance are obtained as parameters of the electron and special relativity theory is derived from the helical motion of the electron. Finally, a fix is proposed for the De Broglie’s wavelength that questions the very validity of the Dirac equation.
To clarify the discussion as to whether or not a quantum mechanical treatment of the motion of electrons in magnetic fields will lead to a formula for em\frac{e}{m}me​, differing from that obtained by classical electro-dynamics the following problem was solved. A uniform magnetic field in the zzz-direction exists in the half-space x>0x>0x>0. A plane monochromatic de Broglie wave, travelling in the positive xxx-direction representing electrons of arbitrary energy, impinges normally on the plane x=0x=0x=0. Solutions of the wave equation were found fulfilling appropriate boundary conditions at the plane x=0x=0x=0. Currents are calculated quantum mechanically and compared with the corresponding classical expressions. It was found that for electrons possessing energies of the order of magnitude used in deflection experiments, no observable deviations from classical results are predicted. Another quantum mechanical effect is diffraction at slits. Simple approximate calculations show that this effect can produce a fractional error in em\frac{e}{m}me​ of the order of the de Broglie wave-length divided by the slit width. These results are opposite to the conclusions reached by Page. We may remark that he solved a problem of "stationary states" which does not represent the actual experiments.
The classical equations of motion of a charged point-particle with intrinsic spin under the influence of an external electromagnetic field are restated and compared with the Heisenberg equations of motion derived from the Dirac theory. The partition of angular momentum between particle and field in the classical theory is contrasted to the Dirac theory of electron spin. The analogy between the Dirac equation and the theory of parametric amplification is pointed out.A free spinning point particle moving according to the laws of classical relativistic point-particle mechanics may move along a helix. The sum of the intrinsic spin $\ensuremath{\sigma}$ and the angular momentum of the helical motion in this classical analog of zitterbewegung is an effective spin vector S which is a constant of the motion. Because of this internal motion, the effective mass MMM of the particle differs from the mass mmm which is ascribed to it in the equations of motion. Solutions are found in which S is parallel or antiparallel to the momentum, and the sign of MMM is determined by the helicity. When placed in a uniform electromagnetic field, the particle behaves as if it had a rest mass MMM and a magnetic moment $\frac{e\ensuremath{\sigma}}{\mathrm{Mc}}$, in addition to any explicit magnetic moment that may be ascribed to it.
The wave-particle duality is one of the most intriguing properties of quantum objects. The duality is rather pervasive in the quantum world in the sense that not only classical particles sometimes behave like waves, but also classical waves, e.g., light, may behave as point particles. In this article, motivated by the wave-particle duality, I develop a deterministic time-crystal Lorentz-covariant mechanical model for an electron with spin. In the proposed time-crystal model an electron is formed by two components: a particle-type component that transports the electric charge, and a wave component that moves at the speed of light and whirls around the massive component. Interestingly, the motion of the particle-component is completely ruled by the trajectory of the wave-component, somewhat analogous to the pilot-wave theory of de Broglie-Bohm. The dynamics of the time-crystal electron is controlled by a generalized least action principle. The model predicts that the electron stationary states have a constant spin angular momentum, predicts the spin vector precession in a magnetic field and gives a possible explanation for the physical origin of the anomalous magnetic moment. Remarkably, the developed model has nonlocal features that prevent the divergence of the self-field interactions. The classical theory of the electron is recovered as an effective theory valid on a coarse time scale. The reported results suggest that time-crystal models may be used to describe some features of the quantum world that are inaccessible to the standard classical theory.
The spherical model of electron cannot explain Bohr magneton, de Broglie wave, etc. To explain these properties physically, we propose that spin, one core concept of quantum theory, is a reality, and introduce this alternative solely based on experimental findings, Planck’s, Einstein’s, and Dirac’s insights, and follows classical laws, that an electron is an electrical wave with a literal 12\frac{1}{2}21​ spin (Dirac), i.e., spins two circles in one cycle, both angular momentum are ℏ. Its wavelength is determined by E=hνm0=hcλm0=m0c2E=h\nu_{m_0}=\frac{hc}{\lambda_{m_0}}=m_0c^2E=hνm0​​=λm0​​hc​=m0​c2 (Plank and Einstein), λ m 0 is the Compton wavelength. As E⃗ ⊥ c⃗ for a transverse wave, it has a net electricity due to the first spin, f(Eq)=12E0(1−cos⁡(2ω0t))f(E_q)=\frac{1}{2}E_0\left(1-\cos(2\omega_0t)\right)f(Eq​)=21​E0​(1−cos(2ω0​t)), half of its cycle, i.e., the minimal meaningful unit as F = E q , is related with its charge, q = E q ϵ 0 . Moreover, an electron has a ring shape due to the second spin, 2 π R 0 = λ m 0 , λ m 0 is the electron-impact cross section. As ℏ=hλm0λm02π=m0cR0\hbar=\frac{h}{\lambda_{m_0}}\frac{\lambda_{m_0}}{2\pi}=m_0cR_0ℏ=λm0​​h​2πλm0​​​=m0​cR0​, it has a quantized classical angular momentum, with a speed of c . The Bohr magneton, μB⃗=q2m0ℏ⃗\vec{\mu_B}=\vec{\frac{q}{2m_0}\hbar}μB​​=2m0​q​ℏ​, g -factor is 2. Critically, the full Dirac’s equation of an electron with a constant velocity is mc⃗=ℏ⊥⃗+p⊥⃗+ℏ//⃗+p//⃗\vec{mc} = \vec{\hbar_\perp}+\vec{p_\perp } +\vec{\hbar_{//}} +\vec{p_{//}}mc=ℏ⊥​​+p⊥​​+ℏ//​​+p//​​, and its electromagnetic properties due to charge are f(Eq)⃗=f(Eq)c2−v′2c⃗+f(Eq)v′c⃗=Enet//⃗+Eq⊥⃗\vec{f(E_q)} = \vec{f(E_q)\frac{\sqrt{c^2-v^{'2}}}{c}} + \vec{f(E_q) \frac{v\rq}{c}} = \vec{E_{net}^{//}} + \vec{E_q^\perp}f(Eq​)​=f(Eq​)cc2−v′2​​​+f(Eq​)cv′​​=Enet//​​+Eq⊥​​, v′⃗//ℏ⊥⃗\vec{v\rq} // \vec{\hbar_\perp}v′//ℏ⊥​​ or v′⃗//ℏ//⃗\vec{v\rq} // \vec{\hbar_{//}}v′//ℏ//​​, and v′⃗//Enet⃗\vec{v\rq} // \vec{E_{net}}v′//Enet​​. Assuming heavy charged particles have equivalent though shall not identical mechanisms, mathematically this model is equivalent to Special Relativity, and supports ALL its formulas, i.e., v < c , E = m c 2 , direction-insensitive m = γ m 0 and t=t0γt=\frac{t_0}{\gamma}t=γt0​​; Moreover, the net electricity Enet//⃗\vec{E_{net}^{//}}Enet//​​ and Bohr magneton is orientation-quantized, direction-sensitive and follows Lorentz transformation, leading to Lorentz transformation of length contraction; while following Relativity, magnetism can be defined by f(B)⃗=f(Eq)v′c2⃗\vec{f(B)} =\vec{f(E_q)\frac{v\rq}{c^2}}f(B)​=f(Eq​)c2v′​​, which is not circularly symmetric and self-evidently does not follow Lorentz transformation. The temporospatial averaged magnetic intensity of a current is relativistic, B⃗ˉ=∑f(Eq)Δvc2⃗=I⃗2πϵ0c2=μ0I⃗2π\bar{\vec{B}} =\sum\vec{{f(E_q)}\frac{\Delta v}{c^2 }}=\frac{\vec{I}}{2 \pi \epsilon_0 c^2}=\frac{\mu_0\vec{I}}{2\pi}Bˉ=∑f(Eq​)c2Δv​​=2πϵ0​c2I​=2πμ0​I​, and μ 0 ϵ 0 c 2 = 1, supporting Maxwell’s equations. Further implications include chirality therefore magnetic spatial quantization, de Broglie wave, etc. The spherical model should be just an observation due to orientation quantization of Enet⃗\vec{E_{net}}Enet​​. We conclude this model of electron may provide one step further to the ultimate Quantum Theory in a nonrelativistic spacetime.