Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0509045

Heisenberg's wave packet reconsidered

J. Orlin Grabbe

Published Sep 7, 2005• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

This note shows that Heisenberg's choice for a wave function in his original paper on the uncertainty principle is simply a renormalized characteristic function of a stable distribution with certain restrictions on the parameters. Relaxing Heisenberg's restrictions leads to a more general formulation of the uncertainty principle. This reformulation shows quantum uncertainty can exist at a macroscopic level. These modifications also give rise to a new form of Schrodinger's wave equation as the equation of a vibrating string. Although a heat equation version can also be given, the latter shows the traditional formulation of Schrodinger's equation involves a hidden Cauchy amplitude assumption.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/0509045

Related papers

Bouncing Wave Packets, Ehrenfest Theorem, and Uncertainty Relation based upon a new Concept for the Momentum of a Particle in a Box

I. Albrecht, J. Herrmann, A. Mariani +2 more

For a particle in a box, the operator $-i\partial_x$ is not self-adjoint and thus does not qualify as the physical momentum. As a result, in general the Ehrenfest theorem is violated. Based upon a recently developed new concept for a self-adjoint momentum operator, we reconsider the theorem and find that it is now indeed satisfied for all physically admissible boundary conditions. We illustrate these results for bouncing wave packets which first spread, then shrink, and return to their original form after a certain revival time. We derive a very simple form of the general Heisenberg-Robertson-Schrödinger uncertainty relation and show that our construction also provides a physical interpretation for it.

arXiv:2206.07531•Jun 15, 2022•1 citation

Bouncing wave packets, Ehrenfest theorem, and uncertainty relation based upon a new concept for the momentum of a particle in a box

I. Albrecht, Joachım Herrmann, A. Mariani +2 more

For a particle in a box, the operator −i∂x is not self-adjoint and thus does not qualify as the physical momentum. As a result, in general the Ehrenfest theorem is violated. Based upon a recently developed new concept for a self-adjoint momentum operator, we reconsider the theorem and find that it is now indeed satisfied for all physically admissible boundary conditions. We illustrate these results for bouncing wave packets which first spread, then shrink, and return to their original form after a certain revival time. We derive a very simple form of the general Heisenberg–Robertson–Schrödinger uncertainty relation and show that our construction also provides a physical interpretation for it.

Annals of Physics•Mar 22, 2023•7 citations

The Time-Dependent Schrödinger Equation

Reinhold A. Bertlmann, Nicolai Friis

Abstract The second chapter introduces the notion of wave functions and their equation of motion proposed by Erwin Schrödinger. The interpretation and normalization of the wave function are discussed, leading to the continuity equation. The chapter also introduces basic mathematical operations that can be carried out for wave functions and operators, describing e.g., how to calculate scalar products and commutators, as well as expectation values and variances of observables. With these tools at hand, Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle is re-examined, focusing on the example of a Gaussian wave packet, which is studied both in position space and momentum space. We also discuss the time evolution of general states and of the exemplary wave packet. Finally, we will see how classical physics is recovered as a limiting case of the quantum-mechanical description

•Sep 7, 2023•0 citations

An Alternative Formulation of Quantum Dynamics Based on a Displacement Interpretation of the Schrödinger Equation

Gong Song, Guan Long Song

In this work, we propose an alternative formulation for the description of quantum dynamics based on a displacement interpretation of the Schrödinger equation. Startingfrom a generalized wave propagation framework, we show that the Schrödinger equation can be recovered in a form that admits a displacement-type interpretation ofthe wave function. Within this formulation, we derive a momentum-related relation, referred to as the Schrödinger momentum equation, which provides an effective description of quantumpropagation. This relation allows for a unified discussion of several foundational aspects of quantum mechanics, including interference phenomena, coherence anddecoherence, and quantum correlations. The proposed framework is deterministic and explicitly nonlocal, and remains consistent with established experimental observations. In addition, we examine theimplications of this formulation for the interpretation of the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle, showing that uncertainty-type relations can be naturally obtained within thisapproach while preserving measurement-dependent limitations. Overall, the present work offers a complementary perspective on quantum mechanics that may contribute to ongoing discussions on its conceptual foundations.

•May 8, 2026•0 citations

A Light-based Interpretation of Schrodinger's Wave Equation and Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle with Implications on Quantum Computation

Pravir Malik

Quantum computation as currently conceived is based on the largely unproven Copenhagen Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics. By viewing light as a multi-layered, symmetrical construct though, it is possible to interpret quantum-level dynamics assumed as fundamental, differently. Hence, looking at Schrodinger's Wave Equation and Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle from the point of view of light, it becomes possible to understand quantum-level dynamics as an outcome of a multi-layered, symmetry-based model of light. Such a different view of quantum-level dynamics suggests a different way to conceive of quantum computation. As such, Schrodinger's Wave Equation can be viewed as an arbitration to take information from behind the quantum-veil that may exist in antecedent layers of light, and through such arbitration or rate of change of the wave-function, compute it into material existence. Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle suggests that meta-level function seeking to precipitate or to be arbitrated into material existence may take different form while still fulfilling the intent of the meta-level function. Quantum computation, therefore, can be conceived as a creative as opposed to a solely constructive process. The object of quantum computation in such an interpretation of quantum phenomena is nothing other than to continue to create something new, or to continue to enhance materialization of meta-level function, rather than to simply construct based on regurgitating programming-based instruction.

IEEE International IOT, Electronics and Mechatronics Conference (IEMTRONICS)•Apr 21, 2021•6 citations

The Wave Equation

M. Srirama Rao

The uncertainty principle comes into force because of the wave like properties of “particles” like electrons and protons. The waves tell the dynamics of the particle – its momentum, its energy and even its angular momentum. Wave packets are made by adding together many simple waves that run forever. If electrons have the wave properties then there must be a wave equation and a wave function to describe the electron waves just as the waves of light, sound and strings are described. The success of wave mechanics was well demonstrated by Erwin Schrödinger before an acceptable interpretation of the wave function was known. Max Born utilized the probability concepts of the uncertainty principle to give us the presently accepted ideas of the wave function.

CRC Press eBooks•Oct 13, 2022•0 citations
This note shows that Heisenberg's choice for a wave function in his original paper on the uncertainty principle is simply a renormalized characteristic function of a stable distribution with certain restrictions on the parameters. Relaxing Heisenberg's restrictions leads to a more general formulation of the uncertainty principle. This reformulation shows quantum uncertainty can exist at a macroscopic level. These modifications also give rise to a new form of Schrodinger's wave equation as the equation of a vibrating string. Although a heat equation version can also be given, the latter shows the traditional formulation of Schrodinger's equation involves a hidden Cauchy amplitude assumption.
For a particle in a box, the operator −i∂x-i\partial_x−i∂x​ is not self-adjoint and thus does not qualify as the physical momentum. As a result, in general the Ehrenfest theorem is violated. Based upon a recently developed new concept for a self-adjoint momentum operator, we reconsider the theorem and find that it is now indeed satisfied for all physically admissible boundary conditions. We illustrate these results for bouncing wave packets which first spread, then shrink, and return to their original form after a certain revival time. We derive a very simple form of the general Heisenberg-Robertson-Schrödinger uncertainty relation and show that our construction also provides a physical interpretation for it.
For a particle in a box, the operator −i∂x is not self-adjoint and thus does not qualify as the physical momentum. As a result, in general the Ehrenfest theorem is violated. Based upon a recently developed new concept for a self-adjoint momentum operator, we reconsider the theorem and find that it is now indeed satisfied for all physically admissible boundary conditions. We illustrate these results for bouncing wave packets which first spread, then shrink, and return to their original form after a certain revival time. We derive a very simple form of the general Heisenberg–Robertson–Schrödinger uncertainty relation and show that our construction also provides a physical interpretation for it.
Abstract The second chapter introduces the notion of wave functions and their equation of motion proposed by Erwin Schrödinger. The interpretation and normalization of the wave function are discussed, leading to the continuity equation. The chapter also introduces basic mathematical operations that can be carried out for wave functions and operators, describing e.g., how to calculate scalar products and commutators, as well as expectation values and variances of observables. With these tools at hand, Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle is re-examined, focusing on the example of a Gaussian wave packet, which is studied both in position space and momentum space. We also discuss the time evolution of general states and of the exemplary wave packet. Finally, we will see how classical physics is recovered as a limiting case of the quantum-mechanical description
In this work, we propose an alternative formulation for the description of quantum dynamics based on a displacement interpretation of the Schrödinger equation. Startingfrom a generalized wave propagation framework, we show that the Schrödinger equation can be recovered in a form that admits a displacement-type interpretation ofthe wave function. Within this formulation, we derive a momentum-related relation, referred to as the Schrödinger momentum equation, which provides an effective description of quantumpropagation. This relation allows for a unified discussion of several foundational aspects of quantum mechanics, including interference phenomena, coherence anddecoherence, and quantum correlations. The proposed framework is deterministic and explicitly nonlocal, and remains consistent with established experimental observations. In addition, we examine theimplications of this formulation for the interpretation of the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle, showing that uncertainty-type relations can be naturally obtained within thisapproach while preserving measurement-dependent limitations. Overall, the present work offers a complementary perspective on quantum mechanics that may contribute to ongoing discussions on its conceptual foundations.
Quantum computation as currently conceived is based on the largely unproven Copenhagen Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics. By viewing light as a multi-layered, symmetrical construct though, it is possible to interpret quantum-level dynamics assumed as fundamental, differently. Hence, looking at Schrodinger's Wave Equation and Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle from the point of view of light, it becomes possible to understand quantum-level dynamics as an outcome of a multi-layered, symmetry-based model of light. Such a different view of quantum-level dynamics suggests a different way to conceive of quantum computation. As such, Schrodinger's Wave Equation can be viewed as an arbitration to take information from behind the quantum-veil that may exist in antecedent layers of light, and through such arbitration or rate of change of the wave-function, compute it into material existence. Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle suggests that meta-level function seeking to precipitate or to be arbitrated into material existence may take different form while still fulfilling the intent of the meta-level function. Quantum computation, therefore, can be conceived as a creative as opposed to a solely constructive process. The object of quantum computation in such an interpretation of quantum phenomena is nothing other than to continue to create something new, or to continue to enhance materialization of meta-level function, rather than to simply construct based on regurgitating programming-based instruction.
The uncertainty principle comes into force because of the wave like properties of “particles” like electrons and protons. The waves tell the dynamics of the particle – its momentum, its energy and even its angular momentum. Wave packets are made by adding together many simple waves that run forever. If electrons have the wave properties then there must be a wave equation and a wave function to describe the electron waves just as the waves of light, sound and strings are described. The success of wave mechanics was well demonstrated by Erwin Schrödinger before an acceptable interpretation of the wave function was known. Max Born utilized the probability concepts of the uncertainty principle to give us the presently accepted ideas of the wave function.