arXiv:quant-ph/0503162

Transition From Quantum To Classical Mechanics As Information Localization

Alex Granik

Published Mar 18, 2005• 1 citation

Abstract

Quantum parallelism implies a spread of information over the space in contradistinction to the classical mechanical situation where the information is "centered" on a fixed trajectory of a classical particle. This means that a quantum state becomes specified by more indefinite data. The above spread resembles, without being an exact analogy, a transfer of energy to smaller and smaller scales observed in the hydrodynamical turbulence. There, in spite of the presence of dissipation (in a form of kinematic viscosity), energy is still conserved. The analogy with the information spread in classical to quantum transition means that in this process the information is also conserved. To illustrate that, we show (using as an example a specific case of a coherent quantum oscillator) how the Shannon information density continuously changes in the above transition . In a more general scheme of things, such an analogy allows us to introduce a "dissipative" term (connected with the information spread) in the Hamilton-Jacobi equation and arrive in an elementary fashion at the equations of classical quantum mechanics (ranging from the Schrödinger to Klein-Gordon equations). We also show that the principle of least action in quantum mechanics is actually the requirement for the energy to be bounded from below.

DOI: 10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/0503162

Related papers

The Statistical-Mechanical Meaning of the Wave Function of Quantum Mechanics

A. Robledo

We address the paradoxical transformation of a classical-mechanical particle motion when the space and time scales of observation pass below the uncertainty principle threshold. This is analyzed in the language of classical statistical mechanics, considering specifically many-particle systems inhomogeneous along one spatial direction. We employ the density functional formalism in its square-gradient form and find: (i) The macroscopic solution is analogous to the classical trajectory of a particle under a potential of force given by (minus) the free energy density. Whereas, (ii) fluctuations around the solution in (i) are equal to the quantum-mechanical wave functions of a particle under a potential given by the curvature of the free energy density. We illustrate this situation with three textbook examples: A particle in a box, the harmonic oscillator, and the hydrogen atom. We show that their time-independent Schrödinger equation wave functions describe, respectively, the fluctuations of a fluid interface, of critical point fluctuations, and of a confined ideal gas. At large scales, sharp probability distributions make fluctuations irrelevant; the vanishing of the first variation yields the macroscopically observable statistical-mechanical non-uniformity, equivalent to the classical particle trajectory. But at sufficiently small scales, with necessarily very few particles, distributions appear much wider, fluctuations dominate, and one obtains the Schrödinger equation (for the microscopic potential).

EntropyJun 20, 20260 citations

Uncertainty and information in classical mechanics formulation. Common ground for thermodynamics and quantum mechanics

Adrian Faigon

Mechanics can be founded on a principle relating the uncertainty delta-q in the trajectory of an observable particle to its motion relative to the observer. From this principle, p.delta-q=const., p being the q-conjugated momentum, mechanical laws are derived and the meaning of the Lagrangian and Hamiltonian functions are discussed. The connection between the presented principle and Hamilton's Least Action Principle is examined. Wave mechanics and Schrodinger equation appear without additional assumptions by choosing the representation for delta-q in the case the motion is not trajectory describable. The Cramer-Rao inequality serves that purpose. For a particle hidden from direct observation, the position uncertainty determined by the enclosing boundaries leads to thermodynamics in a straightforward extension of the presented formalism. The introduction of uncertainty in classical mechanics formulation enables the translation of mechanical laws into the wide ranging conceptual framework of information theory. The boundaries between classical mechanics, thermodynamics and quantum mechanics are defined in terms of informational changes associated with the system evolution. As a direct application of the proposed formulation upper bounds for the rate of information transfer are derived.

arXiv:quant-ph/0311153Nov 22, 20032 citations

Hamilton-Jacobi as model reduction, extension to Newtonian particle mechanics, and a wave mechanical curiosity

Amit Acharya

The Hamilton-Jacobi equation of classical mechanics is approached as a model reduction of conservative particle mechanics where the velocity degrees-of-freedom are eliminated. This viewpoint allows an extension of the association of the Hamilton-Jacobi equation from conservative systems to general Newtonian particle systems involving non-conservative forces, including dissipative ones. A geometric optics approximation leads to a dissipative Schrödinger equation, with the expected limiting form when the associated classical force system involves conservative forces.

math-phCross-listedarXiv:2512.21281Dec 25, 20250 citations

Dissipative Hamilton Jacobi Dynamics and the Emergence of Quantum Wave Mechanics

Naleli Jubert Matjelo

We develop a dissipative extension of classical mechanics based on a complex, and more generally quaternionic, action principle that endows every classical system with an intrinsic environment. Decomposing the action into conservative and divergence-induced components yields two coupled Hamilton Jacobi equations describing a dynamically intertwined system environment pair. This motivates a Dual Sector or Dual Environmental Interpretation (DSI/DEI), in which the additional degrees of freedom behave as an image sector exchanging energy, information, and phase with the system. Applying a generalized Madelung transform produces a nonlinear dissipative wave equation whose symmetric equilibrium limit reduces to the Schroedinger equation, with the quantum potential and linearity emerging from balanced intersector coupling. In this framework, the wavefunction is not fundamental but encodes the interaction geometry between system and environment, providing a classical origin for interference, amplitude phase coupling, and probabilistic structure. Extending the imaginary structure to multiple independent directions yields a multienvironment generalization capable of representing measurement-like processes, nonMarkovian memory, and entanglement type correlations. The formulation unifies aspects of dual-system models, hydrodynamic approaches, and non-Hermitian dynamics within a single action-based framework, and suggests that quantum mechanics corresponds to a stable symmetric phase of a broader dissipative classical theory.

quant-pharXiv:2604.06455Apr 9, 20260 citations

Quantum-classical transition in dissipative systems through scaled trajectories

S V Mousavi, Salvador Miret-Artés

A nonlinear quantum–classical transition wave equation is proposed for dissipative systems within the Caldirola-Kanai model. Equivalence of this transition equation to a scaled Schrödinger equation is proved. The dissipative dynamics is then studied in terms of what we call scaled trajectories following the standard procedure used in Bohmian mechanics. These trajectories depend on a continuous parameter allowing us a smooth transition from Bohmian to classical trajectories. Arrival times and actual momentum distribution functions are also analyzed. The propagation of a Gaussian wave packet in a viscid medium under the presence of constant, linear and harmonic potentials is studied. The gradual decoherence process and localization are easily visualized and understood within this theoretical framework.

arXiv:1711.07207Journal of Physics CommunicationsMar 8, 201817 citations

Schroedinger revisited:How the time-dependent wave equation follows from the Hamilton-Jacobi equation

Alex Granik

It is shown how using the classical Hamilton-Jacobi equation one can arrive at the time-dependent wave equation. Although the former equation was originally used by E.Schroedinger to get the wave equation, we propose a different approach. In the first place, we do not use the principle of least action and, in addition, we arrive at the time-dependent equation, while Schroedinger (in his first seminal paper) used the least action principle and obtained the stationary wave equation. The proposed approach works for any classical Hamilton-Jacobi equation. In addition, by introducing information loss into the Hamilton-Jacobi equation we derive in an elementary fashion the wave equations (ranging from the Shroedinger to Klein-Gordon, to Dirac equations). We also apply this technique to a relativistic particle in the gravitational field and obtain the respective wave equation. All this supports 't Hooft's proposal about a possibility of arriving at quantum description from a classical continuum in the presence of information loss.

arXiv:quant-ph/0409018Sep 3, 20041 citation