Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0103153 · American Journal of Physics

Self-adjoint extensions of operators and the teaching of quantum mechanics

Guy Bonneau, Jacques Faraut, Galliano Valent A

Published Mar 1, 2001• 313 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

For the example of the infinite well potential, we point out some paradoxes which are solved by a careful analysis of what is a truly self-adjoint operator. We then describe the self-adjoint extensions and their spectra for the momentum and the Hamiltonian operators in different settings. Additional physical requirements such as parity, time reversal, and positivity are used to restrict the large class of self-adjoint extensions of the Hamiltonian.

DOI
10.1119/1.1328351

Related papers

Self-adjoint Extensions in Quantum Mechanics

Dmitri M Gitman, Igor Viktorovich Tyutin, Boris Leonidovich Voronov

Quantization of physical systems requires a correct definition of quantum-mechanical observables, such as the Hamiltonian, momentum, etc., as self-adjoint operators in appropriate Hilbert spaces and t

Birkhäuser Boston eBooks•Jan 1, 2012•158 citations

Observables in Quantum Mechanics and the Importance of Self-Adjointness

Tajron Jurić

We are focused on the idea that observables in quantum physics are a bit more then just hermitian operators and that this is, in general, a “tricky business”. The origin of this idea comes from the fact that there is a subtle difference between symmetric, hermitian, and self-adjoint operators which are of immense importance in formulating Quantum Mechanics. The theory of self-adjoint extensions is presented through several physical examples and some emphasis is given on the physical implications and applications.

arXiv:2103.01080•Universe•Feb 17, 2022•15 citations

Self-adjointness and spontaneously broken symmetry

ANTON Z. CAPRI

The notion of self-adjointness as distinct from Hermiticity is usually avoided in elementary quantum mechanics courses due to a feeling that it has nothing to do with physics or else is too mathematical. This is definitely not the case, and we use the model of a free particle restricted to motion on a line over a finite interval, to demonstrate this. For such a particle, there is one-parameter infinity of self-adjoint extensions of the momentum operator. We use one of these, corresponding to ’’antiperiodic’’ boundary conditions, to show that physical phenomena different from the usual case (periodic boundary conditions) occur. In fact, in this case, we have a model displaying many of the properties of spontaneously broken symmetry.

American Journal of Physics•Sep 1, 1977•28 citations

Self-Adjointness and the Renormalization of Singular Potentials

Sarang Gopalakrishnan, William Loinaz

Schrodinger operators with very singular potentials fail to produce reasonable spectra, because the usual boundary conditions are insufficient to make them self-adjoint. If one regularizes a singular potential at a length , the bound state energies diverge as → 0. A meaningful spectrum can be restored by picking a self-adjoint extension of the operator, by renormalizing the theory, or by allowing nonunitary time evolution. We show that renormalizations of the 1/r potential fall into two classes: those that are asymptotically equivalent to self-adjoint extensions, and those that reduce to treatments of delta functions. We also apply the apparatus of self-adjoint extensions and renormalization to clarify aspects of anomalous symmetry breaking, supersymmetric quantum mechanics, and one-dimensional quantum mechanics. Lines composed upon reading a thesis abstract by S. Gopalakrishnan Think a moment, dear reader, of that long-legged fly, The sprung meniscus underfoot, And what asymptotes invisible to well-trained eyes Still break the surface at its root. How a singular potential picks tight-bounded energy Apart till it no longer recognizes Its own mirrored face, its extensions, or symmetry; Unless one cautiously renormalizes. You have tried in these pensive pages to show the stuff Such theory’s made of, its quiddity When logic is applied to the diamond rough, And quantum notes ring purely. May Apollo’s clarity pierce through your reasoning And self-adjointed truth and fact Elevate your thought to that sense so pleasing When truth recovers nature’s pact.

•Jan 1, 2006•12 citations

Non-self-adjoint operators with real spectra and extensions of quantum mechanics

Natália Bebiano, João da Providência

In this article, we review the quantum mechanical setting associated with a non-self-adjoint Hamiltonian with a real spectrum. The spectral properties of the Hamiltonian of a Swanson-like model are investigated. The eigenfunctions associated with the real simple eigenvalues are shown to form complete systems but not a (Riesz) basis, which gives rise to difficulties in the rigorous mathematical formulation of quantum mechanics. A new inner product, appropriate for the physical interpretation of the model, has been consistently introduced. The dynamics of the system is described. Some specificities of the theory of non-self-adjoint operators with implications in quantum mechanics are discussed.

arXiv:1808.08863•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Jan 1, 2019•5 citations

ON NON-SELF-ADJOINT OPERATORS FOR OBSERVABLES IN QUANTUM MECHANICS AND QUANTUM FIELD THEORY

Erasmo Recami, V. S. Olkhovsky, Sergei P. Maydanyuk

The aim of this paper is to show the possible significance, and usefulness, of various non-self-adjoint operators for suitable Observables in nonrelativistic and relativistic quantum mechanics, and in quantum electrodynamics. More specifically, this work deals with: (i) the maximal Hermitian (but not self-adjoint) time operator in nonrelativistic quantum mechanics and in quantum electrodynamics; (ii) the problem of the four-position and four-momentum operators, each one with its Hermitian and anti-Hermitian parts, for relativistic spin-zero particles. Afterwards, other physically important applications of non-self-adjoint (and even non-Hermitian) operators are discussed: in particular, (iii) we reanalyze in detail the interesting possibility of associating quasi-Hermitian Hamiltonians with (decaying) unstable states in nuclear physics. Finally, we briefly mention the cases of quantum dissipation, as well as of the nuclear optical potential.

arXiv:0903.3187•International Journal of Modern Physics A•Apr 10, 2010•14 citations
For the example of the infinite well potential, we point out some paradoxes which are solved by a careful analysis of what is a truly self-adjoint operator. We then describe the self-adjoint extensions and their spectra for the momentum and the Hamiltonian operators in different settings. Additional physical requirements such as parity, time reversal, and positivity are used to restrict the large class of self-adjoint extensions of the Hamiltonian.
We are focused on the idea that observables in quantum physics are a bit more then just hermitian operators and that this is, in general, a “tricky business”. The origin of this idea comes from the fact that there is a subtle difference between symmetric, hermitian, and self-adjoint operators which are of immense importance in formulating Quantum Mechanics. The theory of self-adjoint extensions is presented through several physical examples and some emphasis is given on the physical implications and applications.
The notion of self-adjointness as distinct from Hermiticity is usually avoided in elementary quantum mechanics courses due to a feeling that it has nothing to do with physics or else is too mathematical. This is definitely not the case, and we use the model of a free particle restricted to motion on a line over a finite interval, to demonstrate this. For such a particle, there is one-parameter infinity of self-adjoint extensions of the momentum operator. We use one of these, corresponding to ’’antiperiodic’’ boundary conditions, to show that physical phenomena different from the usual case (periodic boundary conditions) occur. In fact, in this case, we have a model displaying many of the properties of spontaneously broken symmetry.
Schrodinger operators with very singular potentials fail to produce reasonable spectra, because the usual boundary conditions are insufficient to make them self-adjoint. If one regularizes a singular potential at a length , the bound state energies diverge as → 0. A meaningful spectrum can be restored by picking a self-adjoint extension of the operator, by renormalizing the theory, or by allowing nonunitary time evolution. We show that renormalizations of the 1/r potential fall into two classes: those that are asymptotically equivalent to self-adjoint extensions, and those that reduce to treatments of delta functions. We also apply the apparatus of self-adjoint extensions and renormalization to clarify aspects of anomalous symmetry breaking, supersymmetric quantum mechanics, and one-dimensional quantum mechanics. Lines composed upon reading a thesis abstract by S. Gopalakrishnan Think a moment, dear reader, of that long-legged fly, The sprung meniscus underfoot, And what asymptotes invisible to well-trained eyes Still break the surface at its root. How a singular potential picks tight-bounded energy Apart till it no longer recognizes Its own mirrored face, its extensions, or symmetry; Unless one cautiously renormalizes. You have tried in these pensive pages to show the stuff Such theory’s made of, its quiddity When logic is applied to the diamond rough, And quantum notes ring purely. May Apollo’s clarity pierce through your reasoning And self-adjointed truth and fact Elevate your thought to that sense so pleasing When truth recovers nature’s pact.
In this article, we review the quantum mechanical setting associated with a non-self-adjoint Hamiltonian with a real spectrum. The spectral properties of the Hamiltonian of a Swanson-like model are investigated. The eigenfunctions associated with the real simple eigenvalues are shown to form complete systems but not a (Riesz) basis, which gives rise to difficulties in the rigorous mathematical formulation of quantum mechanics. A new inner product, appropriate for the physical interpretation of the model, has been consistently introduced. The dynamics of the system is described. Some specificities of the theory of non-self-adjoint operators with implications in quantum mechanics are discussed.
The aim of this paper is to show the possible significance, and usefulness, of various non-self-adjoint operators for suitable Observables in nonrelativistic and relativistic quantum mechanics, and in quantum electrodynamics. More specifically, this work deals with: (i) the maximal Hermitian (but not self-adjoint) time operator in nonrelativistic quantum mechanics and in quantum electrodynamics; (ii) the problem of the four-position and four-momentum operators, each one with its Hermitian and anti-Hermitian parts, for relativistic spin-zero particles. Afterwards, other physically important applications of non-self-adjoint (and even non-Hermitian) operators are discussed: in particular, (iii) we reanalyze in detail the interesting possibility of associating quasi-Hermitian Hamiltonians with (decaying) unstable states in nuclear physics. Finally, we briefly mention the cases of quantum dissipation, as well as of the nuclear optical potential.