Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0008096

Quantum Optical Discussion of Uncertainty and Complementarity in a Mach-Zehnder Interferometer

Doron ludwin, Y. Ben-Aryeh, A. Mann

Published Aug 23, 2000• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We discuss complementarity and uncertainty in a gedanken Which-Way (Welcher-Weg) experiment in a Mach-Zehnder interferometer. Although a Welcher-Weg measurement can be performed with only a negligible amount of momentum change in the detector itself, the change in the interference pattern must correspond to a change in the momentum distribution of the particle. Entanglement between the Mach-Zehnder interferometer and the Welcher-Weg measurement introduces orthogonality that disables the interference of the particle, but simultaneously, it also generates a momentum transfer between the particle and other parts of the whole entangled system (including macroscopic parts). This analysis can be related to the Delayed Choice interpretation. We show where the momentum change takes place and we conclude that entanglement is the key to understand how complementarity (i.e. Which Way versus interference) and the position-momentum uncertainty relation are interwoven.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/0008096

Related papers

Collapse of the quantum wavefunction and Welcher-Weg (WW) experiments

Y. Ben-Aryeh

The 'collapse' of the wave function in a general measuring process is analyzed by a pure quantum mechanical (QM) approach. The problem of the delayed choice and Welcher-Weg (WW) experiments is analyzed for Mach-Zehnder (MZ) interferometer. The WW effect is related to complementarity principle and orthogonality of wavefunctions although it produces small momentum changes between the electromagnetic (EM) field and the beam-splitters (BS's). For QM states for which we have a superposition of states and interference effects there is no reality before measurement, but by excluding such effects the system gets a real meaning already before measurement.

arXiv:1201.5461•Jan 26, 2012•0 citations

Complementarity and Uncertainty in Mach-Zehnder Interferometry and beyond

Paul Busch, C. R. Shilladay

A coherent account of the connections and contrasts between the principles of com-plementarity and uncertainty is developed starting from a survey of the various formalizations of these principles. The conceptual analysis is illustrated by means of a set of experimental schemes based on Mach-Zehnder interferometry. In particu-lar, path detection via entanglement with a probe system and (quantitative) quan-tum erasure are exhibited to constitute instances of joint unsharp measurements of complementary pairs of physical quantities, path and interference observables. The analysis uses the representation of observables as positive-operator-valued measures (POVMs). The reconciliation of complementary experimental options in the sense of simultaneous unsharp preparations and measurements is expressed in terms of uncertainty relations of different kinds. The feature of complementarity, manifest in the present examples in the mutual exclusivity of path detection and interference observation, is recovered as a limit case from the appropriate uncertainty relation. It is noted that the complementarity and uncertainty principles are neither completely logically independent nor logical consequences of one another. Since entanglement is an instance of the uncertainty of quantum properties (of compound systems), it is moot to play out uncertainty and entanglement against each other as possible mechanisms enforcing complementarity.

•Jan 1, 2006•58 citations

Complementarity and uncertainty in quantum interference

C. R. Shilladay

This thesis is concerned with the notions of complementarity and uncertainty encountered in quantum mechanics. Its starting point is an assessment of how these concepts have been represented and illustrated by various writers dating back to their inception. Following the survey a coherent account of the connections and contrasts between complementarity and uncertainty is developed in the context of Mach-Zehnder interferometry. The effect on the interference pattern contrast of path detection via entanglement with a probe system, is explored and a joint unsharp measurement scheme of the complementary pairs, path and interference, described. The Mach-Zehnder set-up proves sufficiently versatile to show that quantum erasure and quantitative quantum erasure constitute instances of joint unsharp measurement of complementary observables. The analysis uses the representation of observables as positive operator valued measures.Path detection and interference observation require different experimental set-ups but can be reconciled in the simultaneous unsharp measurement and preparation. This reconciliation is expressed as an uncertainty relation however the mutually exclusive feature of complementarity is not discarded. It is possible to recover strict complementarity as a limit case of the appropriate uncertainty relation.One motivation for this study is the effort some authors have made in trying to express the founding features of quantum mechanics in the form of a hierarchy of significance. Here it is shown that complementarity and uncertainty have separate identities but are not completely independent of each other. Consequently, establishing a hierarchy of these features within the present formalism of quantum mechanics is not possible.

•Jan 1, 2007•0 citations

Entangled Non-Local Quantum Interferometry

Giovanni Di Giuseppe, F. De Martini, D. Boschi +1 more

A novel quantum optical interference experiment based on a delayed correlation technique and involving photons prepared in a polarization-entangled state is presented. The resulting phenomenology is found to be determined by the simultaneous realization of several non-classical interference processes of distinct nature albeit strictly interrelated. A formal interpretation of the results is attempted by a standard quantum analysis and by the adoption of a set of interfering Feynman diagrams. In addition, a physical interpre-tation at a deeper level is undertaken by introducing for the system the basic theoretical background of a new concept in quantum optics: entangled interferometry. As a relevant application of this new paradigm, a novel two-photon welcher-weg argument within a delayed-choice experiment is presented. It leads to an unexpected complementarity puzzle which expresses the manifestation of the EPR non-locality within the general context of interferometry. PACS numbers: 03.65.Bz, 42.50.-p, 42.50.Wm.

Fortschritte der Physik•Nov 1, 1998•3 citations

Randomization of quantum relative phase in welcher Weg measurements

Alfredo Luis, Luis Lorenzo Sánchez-Soto

Welcher Weg (which-path) detectors where complementarity is enforced without altering the interfering beams are analysed in terms of the quantum relative phase. In such a case, the measurement disturbs the interference via random classical phase shifts. This applies when the interfering particles are atoms or photons. In the case of photons, the quantum relative phase coincides with the field phase difference.

Journal of Optics B Quantum and Semiclassical Optics•Nov 16, 1999•9 citations

Two-photon interferometry, the quantum measurement problem, and more

Marlan O. Scully, Muhammad Suhail Zubairy

As was demonstrated in the previous chapter, the process of observation and acquisition of information or at least the possibility of ‘knowing’ (whether or not we bother to ‘look’) can profoundly change the outcome of an experiment. For example, in the case of the micromaser which-path detector, we do not need to ‘look at’ or ‘interrogate’ the masers in order to lose the interference cross term; it is enough that we could have known. Experiments along these lines provide a dramatic example of the importance of which-path, or ‘Welcher-Weg’, information. The present chapter treats the Welcher-Weg quantum eraser problem from a different vantage. We first consider the interference of light as it is scattered from simple atomic systems consisting of single atoms located at two neighboring sites. From this simple model, we can gain a wealth of insight into such problems as complementarity, delayed choice, and the quantum eraser via field–field and photon–photon correlation functions, i.e., via G (1) ( r , t ) and G (2) ( r , r ′ t , t ′). The chapter concludes with a demonstration that such considerations can, in principle, even lead to new kinds of high-resolution spectroscopy.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Sep 4, 1997•0 citations
We discuss complementarity and uncertainty in a gedanken Which-Way (Welcher-Weg) experiment in a Mach-Zehnder interferometer. Although a Welcher-Weg measurement can be performed with only a negligible amount of momentum change in the detector itself, the change in the interference pattern must correspond to a change in the momentum distribution of the particle. Entanglement between the Mach-Zehnder interferometer and the Welcher-Weg measurement introduces orthogonality that disables the interference of the particle, but simultaneously, it also generates a momentum transfer between the particle and other parts of the whole entangled system (including macroscopic parts). This analysis can be related to the Delayed Choice interpretation. We show where the momentum change takes place and we conclude that entanglement is the key to understand how complementarity (i.e. Which Way versus interference) and the position-momentum uncertainty relation are interwoven.
The 'collapse' of the wave function in a general measuring process is analyzed by a pure quantum mechanical (QM) approach. The problem of the delayed choice and Welcher-Weg (WW) experiments is analyzed for Mach-Zehnder (MZ) interferometer. The WW effect is related to complementarity principle and orthogonality of wavefunctions although it produces small momentum changes between the electromagnetic (EM) field and the beam-splitters (BS's). For QM states for which we have a superposition of states and interference effects there is no reality before measurement, but by excluding such effects the system gets a real meaning already before measurement.
A coherent account of the connections and contrasts between the principles of com-plementarity and uncertainty is developed starting from a survey of the various formalizations of these principles. The conceptual analysis is illustrated by means of a set of experimental schemes based on Mach-Zehnder interferometry. In particu-lar, path detection via entanglement with a probe system and (quantitative) quan-tum erasure are exhibited to constitute instances of joint unsharp measurements of complementary pairs of physical quantities, path and interference observables. The analysis uses the representation of observables as positive-operator-valued measures (POVMs). The reconciliation of complementary experimental options in the sense of simultaneous unsharp preparations and measurements is expressed in terms of uncertainty relations of different kinds. The feature of complementarity, manifest in the present examples in the mutual exclusivity of path detection and interference observation, is recovered as a limit case from the appropriate uncertainty relation. It is noted that the complementarity and uncertainty principles are neither completely logically independent nor logical consequences of one another. Since entanglement is an instance of the uncertainty of quantum properties (of compound systems), it is moot to play out uncertainty and entanglement against each other as possible mechanisms enforcing complementarity.
This thesis is concerned with the notions of complementarity and uncertainty encountered in quantum mechanics. Its starting point is an assessment of how these concepts have been represented and illustrated by various writers dating back to their inception. Following the survey a coherent account of the connections and contrasts between complementarity and uncertainty is developed in the context of Mach-Zehnder interferometry. The effect on the interference pattern contrast of path detection via entanglement with a probe system, is explored and a joint unsharp measurement scheme of the complementary pairs, path and interference, described. The Mach-Zehnder set-up proves sufficiently versatile to show that quantum erasure and quantitative quantum erasure constitute instances of joint unsharp measurement of complementary observables. The analysis uses the representation of observables as positive operator valued measures.Path detection and interference observation require different experimental set-ups but can be reconciled in the simultaneous unsharp measurement and preparation. This reconciliation is expressed as an uncertainty relation however the mutually exclusive feature of complementarity is not discarded. It is possible to recover strict complementarity as a limit case of the appropriate uncertainty relation.One motivation for this study is the effort some authors have made in trying to express the founding features of quantum mechanics in the form of a hierarchy of significance. Here it is shown that complementarity and uncertainty have separate identities but are not completely independent of each other. Consequently, establishing a hierarchy of these features within the present formalism of quantum mechanics is not possible.
A novel quantum optical interference experiment based on a delayed correlation technique and involving photons prepared in a polarization-entangled state is presented. The resulting phenomenology is found to be determined by the simultaneous realization of several non-classical interference processes of distinct nature albeit strictly interrelated. A formal interpretation of the results is attempted by a standard quantum analysis and by the adoption of a set of interfering Feynman diagrams. In addition, a physical interpre-tation at a deeper level is undertaken by introducing for the system the basic theoretical background of a new concept in quantum optics: entangled interferometry. As a relevant application of this new paradigm, a novel two-photon welcher-weg argument within a delayed-choice experiment is presented. It leads to an unexpected complementarity puzzle which expresses the manifestation of the EPR non-locality within the general context of interferometry. PACS numbers: 03.65.Bz, 42.50.-p, 42.50.Wm.
As was demonstrated in the previous chapter, the process of observation and acquisition of information or at least the possibility of ‘knowing’ (whether or not we bother to ‘look’) can profoundly change the outcome of an experiment. For example, in the case of the micromaser which-path detector, we do not need to ‘look at’ or ‘interrogate’ the masers in order to lose the interference cross term; it is enough that we could have known. Experiments along these lines provide a dramatic example of the importance of which-path, or ‘Welcher-Weg’, information. The present chapter treats the Welcher-Weg quantum eraser problem from a different vantage. We first consider the interference of light as it is scattered from simple atomic systems consisting of single atoms located at two neighboring sites. From this simple model, we can gain a wealth of insight into such problems as complementarity, delayed choice, and the quantum eraser via field–field and photon–photon correlation functions, i.e., via G (1) ( r , t ) and G (2) ( r , r ′ t , t ′). The chapter concludes with a demonstration that such considerations can, in principle, even lead to new kinds of high-resolution spectroscopy.