Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:hep-ph/9705354 · Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields

Order 1/N corrections to the time-dependent Hartree approximation for a system of N+1 oscillators

Bogdan Mihaila, John F. Dawson, Fred Cooper

Published Nov 1, 1997• 20 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We solve numerically to order $1/N$ the time evolution of a quantum dynamical system of $N$ oscillators of mass $m$ coupled quadratically to a massless dynamic variable. We use Schwinger's closed time path formalism to derive the equations. We compare two methods which differ by terms of order ${1/N}^{2}.$ The first method is a direct perturbation theory in $1/N$ using the path integral. The second solves exactly the theory defined by the effective action to order $1/N.$ We compare the results of both methods as a function of $N.$ At $N=1,$ where we expect the expansion to be quite innacurate, we compare our results to an exact numerical solution of the Schr\"odinger equation. In this case we find that when the two methods disagree they also diverge from the exact answer. We also find at $N=1$ that the $1/N$ corrected evolutions track the exact answer for the expectation values much longer than the mean field $(N=\ensuremath{\infty})$ result.

DOI
10.1103/physrevd.56.5400

Related papers

Exact and approximate dynamics of the quantum mechanical O(N) model

Bogdan Mihaila, Tara Athan, Fred Cooper +2 more

We study the dynamics of the quantum mechanical $O(N)$ model as a specific example to investigate the systematics of a $1/N$ expansion. The closed time path formalism melded with an expansion in $1/N$ is used to derive time evolution equations valid to order $1/N$ (next-to-leading order). The effective potential is also obtained to this order and its properties are elucidated. In order to compare theoretical predictions against numerical solutions of the time-dependent Schr\"odinger equation, we consider two initial conditions consistent with $O(N)$ symmetry, one of them a quantum roll, the other a wave packet initially to one side of the potential minimum, whose center has all coordinates equal. For the case of the quantum roll we map out the domain of validity of the large-N expansion. We also discuss the existence of unitarity violation in this expansion, a well-known problem faced by moment truncation techniques. The $1/N$ results, both static and dynamic, are contrasted with those given by a Hartree variational ansatz at given values of N. A comparison against numerical results leads us to conclude that late-time dynamical behavior, where nonlinear effects are significant, is not well described by either approximation.

arXiv:hep-ph/0003105•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Nov 27, 2000•36 citations

Nonequilibrium dynamics in the O(N) model to next-to-next-to-leading order in the 1/N expansion

Gert Aarts A, Anders Tranberg B

Nonequilibrium dynamics in quantum field theory has been studied extensively using truncations of the 2PI effective action. Both $1/N$ and loop expansions beyond leading order show remarkable improvement when compared to mean-field approximations. However, in truncations used so far, only the leading-order parts of the self-energy responsible for memory loss, damping and equilibration are included, which makes it difficult to discuss convergence systematically. For that reason we derive the real and causal evolution equations for an $O(N)$ model to next-to-next-to-leading order in the 2PI-$1/N$ expansion. Because of the appearance of internal vertices the resulting equations appear intractable for a full-fledged $3+1$ dimensional field theory. Instead, we solve the closely related three-loop approximation in the auxiliary-field formalism numerically in $0+1$ dimensions (quantum mechanics) and compare to previous approximations and the exact numerical solution of the Schr\"odinger equation.

arXiv:hep-th/0604156•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Jul 6, 2006•30 citations

Chaos in time-dependent variational approximations to quantum dynamics

Fred Cooper, John F. Dawson, Salman Habib +1 more

Dynamical chaos has recently been shown to exist in the Gaussian approximation in quantum mechanics and in the self-consistent mean field approach to studying the dynamics of quantum fields. In this study, we first note that any variational approximation to the dynamics of a quantum system based on the Dirac action principle leads to a classical Hamiltonian dynamics for the variational parameters. Since this Hamiltonian is generically nonlinear and nonintegrable, the dynamics thus generated can be chaotic, in distinction to the exact quantum evolution. We then restrict our attention to a system of two biquadratically coupled quantum oscillators and study two variational schemes, the leading order large-$N$ (four canonical variables) and Hartree (six canonical variables) approximations. The chaos seen in the approximate dynamics is an artifact of the approximations: this is demonstrated by the fact that its onset occurs on the same characteristic time scale as the breakdown of the approximations when compared to numerical solutions of the time-dependent Schr\"odinger equation.

arXiv:quant-ph/9610013•Physical review. E, Statistical physics, plasmas, fluids, and related interdisciplinary topics•Feb 1, 1998•50 citations

Comparison between quantum and classical dynamics in the effective action formalism

Fabrizio Cametti, Giovanni Jona-Lasinio, Carlo Presilla A +1 more

A major difficulty in comparing quantum and classical behavior resides in the struc- tural differences between the corresponding mathematical languages. The Heisenberg equations of motion are operator equations only formally identical to the classical equations of motion. By taking the expectation of these equations, the well-known Ehrenfest theorem provides identities which, however, are not a closed system of equations which allows to evaluate the time evolution of the system. The formalism of the effective action seems to offer a possibility of comparing quantum and classical evolutions in a system- atic and logically consistent way by naturally providing approximation schemes for the expectations of the coordinates which at the zeroth order coincide with the classical evolution [1]. The effective action formalism leads to equations of motion which differ from the classical equations by the addition of terms nonlocal in the time variable. This means that for these equations an initial value problem is not meaningful and they have to be interpreted in an appropriate way. Here we analyze situations in which the nonlocal terms can be reasonably approximated by local ones, so that the quantum corrections do not modify the locality of classical equations. In the simplest approximation, the effective Lagrangian differs from the corresponding classical one by a renormalization of both the potential- and the kinetic-energy terms. We shall not discuss the causal formalism used, for example, in refs. [2-4], as in the approximation considered this would lead to the same local equations. The present contribution describes the beginning of a systematic study of semiclassical evolutions using the effective action formalism. In the first part, after introducing the formalism of the effective action and its expansion in powers of hbar (loop expansion) in the context of quantum mechanics, we concentrate on the structure of the first-order corrections in li. These corrections are evaluated to the second order in the derivative expansion [5], by two different methods. The first is based on a Euclidean approach [6], the second one on an adiabatic approximation in evaluating functional determinants. In the second part of the article we put the formalism at work, choosing as our case study a two-dimensional (2D) anharmonic oscillator of the kind considered in molecular physics. The results of the simulations show that by increasing lithe effective dynamics tends to regularize the classical motion and becomes qualitatively very similar to the quantum evolution provided the energy is sufficiently small. The evaluation of the effective dynamics in more general cases will be presented in a forthcoming paper.

arXiv:quant-ph/9910065•Oct 14, 1999•41 citations

Quantum mechanics in general quantum systems (I): Exact solution

An Min Wang

Starting from our idea of combining the Feynman path integral spirit and the Dyson series kernel, we find an explicit and general form of time evolution operator that is a $c$-number function and a power series of perturbation including all order approximations in the unperturbed Hamiltonian representation. Based on it, we obtain an exact solution of the Schrödinger equation in general quantum systems independent of time. Comparison of our exact solution with the existed perturbation theory makes some features and significance of our exact solution clear. The conclusions expressly indicate that our exact solution is obviously consistent with the usual time-independent perturbation theory at any order approximation, it explicitly calculates out the expanding coefficients of the unperturbed state in the non-perturbation method, and it fully solves the recurrence equation of the expansion coefficients of final state in the unperturbed Hamiltonian representation from a view of time-dependent perturbation theory. At the same time, the exact solution of the von Neumann equation is also given. Our results can be thought of as theoretical developments of quantum dynamics, and are helpful for understanding the dynamical behavior and related subjects of general quantum systems in both theory and application. Our exact solution, together with its sequence studies on perturbation theory [An Min Wang, quant-ph/0611217] and open system dynamics [An Min Wang, quant-ph/0601051] can be used to establish the foundation of theoretical formulism of quantum mechanics in general quantum systems. Further applications of our exact solution to quantum theory can be expected.

arXiv:quant-ph/0611216•Nov 21, 2006•4 citations

Time-Dependent Logarithmic Perturbation Theory for Quantum Dynamics: Formulation and Applications

Juan Carlos del Valle, Paul Bergold, Karolina Kropielnicka

We present a time-dependent extension of logarithmic perturbation theory for nonrelativistic quantum dynamics governed by the Schrödinger equation, in which the logarithm of the wave function is expanded in powers of a coupling constant. The resulting hierarchy of equations defining the perturbative corrections is governed by a gauge-rotated Hamiltonian of the unperturbed system and leads to closed-integral expressions for the time-dependent corrections based on Duhamel's formula. This closed-integral structure of corrections is a hallmark of time-independent logarithmic perturbation theory and is preserved in the present extension. This structure, in particular, provides a computable expression for the instantaneous energy shift. Furthermore, dynamic energy shifts arise naturally within this framework in the form of time-averaged expectation values of pseudopotentials and can be related, for example, to AC Stark shifts and electric polarizabilities. As an illustration, we apply the method to the harmonic oscillator and the hydrogen atom, both driven by a time-dependent laser field. The harmonic oscillator provides a proof of principle for which the exact solution is recovered, while the hydrogen atom illustrates the method applied to atomic systems. Supported by numerical simulations, we demonstrate the applicability to obtain relevant physical observables with high accuracy. The present approach offers a promising alternative for analytical studies of time-dependent multi-photon processes in the perturbative regime.

quant-pharXiv:2604.14812•Apr 17, 2026
We solve numerically to order 1/N1/N1/N the time evolution of a quantum dynamical system of NNN oscillators of mass mmm coupled quadratically to a massless dynamic variable. We use Schwinger's closed time path formalism to derive the equations. We compare two methods which differ by terms of order 1/N2.{1/N}^{2}.1/N2. The first method is a direct perturbation theory in 1/N1/N1/N using the path integral. The second solves exactly the theory defined by the effective action to order 1/N.1/N.1/N. We compare the results of both methods as a function of N.N.N. At N=1,N=1,N=1, where we expect the expansion to be quite innacurate, we compare our results to an exact numerical solution of the Schr"odinger equation. In this case we find that when the two methods disagree they also diverge from the exact answer. We also find at N=1N=1N=1 that the 1/N1/N1/N corrected evolutions track the exact answer for the expectation values much longer than the mean field (N=\ensuremath∞)(N=\ensuremath{\infty})(N=\ensuremath∞) result.
We study the dynamics of the quantum mechanical O(N)O(N)O(N) model as a specific example to investigate the systematics of a 1/N1/N1/N expansion. The closed time path formalism melded with an expansion in 1/N1/N1/N is used to derive time evolution equations valid to order 1/N1/N1/N (next-to-leading order). The effective potential is also obtained to this order and its properties are elucidated. In order to compare theoretical predictions against numerical solutions of the time-dependent Schr\"odinger equation, we consider two initial conditions consistent with O(N)O(N)O(N) symmetry, one of them a quantum roll, the other a wave packet initially to one side of the potential minimum, whose center has all coordinates equal. For the case of the quantum roll we map out the domain of validity of the large-N expansion. We also discuss the existence of unitarity violation in this expansion, a well-known problem faced by moment truncation techniques. The 1/N1/N1/N results, both static and dynamic, are contrasted with those given by a Hartree variational ansatz at given values of N. A comparison against numerical results leads us to conclude that late-time dynamical behavior, where nonlinear effects are significant, is not well described by either approximation.
Nonequilibrium dynamics in quantum field theory has been studied extensively using truncations of the 2PI effective action. Both 1/N1/N1/N and loop expansions beyond leading order show remarkable improvement when compared to mean-field approximations. However, in truncations used so far, only the leading-order parts of the self-energy responsible for memory loss, damping and equilibration are included, which makes it difficult to discuss convergence systematically. For that reason we derive the real and causal evolution equations for an O(N)O(N)O(N) model to next-to-next-to-leading order in the 2PI-1/N1/N1/N expansion. Because of the appearance of internal vertices the resulting equations appear intractable for a full-fledged 3+13+13+1 dimensional field theory. Instead, we solve the closely related three-loop approximation in the auxiliary-field formalism numerically in 0+10+10+1 dimensions (quantum mechanics) and compare to previous approximations and the exact numerical solution of the Schr\"odinger equation.
Dynamical chaos has recently been shown to exist in the Gaussian approximation in quantum mechanics and in the self-consistent mean field approach to studying the dynamics of quantum fields. In this study, we first note that any variational approximation to the dynamics of a quantum system based on the Dirac action principle leads to a classical Hamiltonian dynamics for the variational parameters. Since this Hamiltonian is generically nonlinear and nonintegrable, the dynamics thus generated can be chaotic, in distinction to the exact quantum evolution. We then restrict our attention to a system of two biquadratically coupled quantum oscillators and study two variational schemes, the leading order large-NNN (four canonical variables) and Hartree (six canonical variables) approximations. The chaos seen in the approximate dynamics is an artifact of the approximations: this is demonstrated by the fact that its onset occurs on the same characteristic time scale as the breakdown of the approximations when compared to numerical solutions of the time-dependent Schr\"odinger equation.
A major difficulty in comparing quantum and classical behavior resides in the struc- tural differences between the corresponding mathematical languages. The Heisenberg equations of motion are operator equations only formally identical to the classical equations of motion. By taking the expectation of these equations, the well-known Ehrenfest theorem provides identities which, however, are not a closed system of equations which allows to evaluate the time evolution of the system. The formalism of the effective action seems to offer a possibility of comparing quantum and classical evolutions in a system- atic and logically consistent way by naturally providing approximation schemes for the expectations of the coordinates which at the zeroth order coincide with the classical evolution [1]. The effective action formalism leads to equations of motion which differ from the classical equations by the addition of terms nonlocal in the time variable. This means that for these equations an initial value problem is not meaningful and they have to be interpreted in an appropriate way. Here we analyze situations in which the nonlocal terms can be reasonably approximated by local ones, so that the quantum corrections do not modify the locality of classical equations. In the simplest approximation, the effective Lagrangian differs from the corresponding classical one by a renormalization of both the potential- and the kinetic-energy terms. We shall not discuss the causal formalism used, for example, in refs. [2-4], as in the approximation considered this would lead to the same local equations. The present contribution describes the beginning of a systematic study of semiclassical evolutions using the effective action formalism. In the first part, after introducing the formalism of the effective action and its expansion in powers of hbar (loop expansion) in the context of quantum mechanics, we concentrate on the structure of the first-order corrections in li. These corrections are evaluated to the second order in the derivative expansion [5], by two different methods. The first is based on a Euclidean approach [6], the second one on an adiabatic approximation in evaluating functional determinants. In the second part of the article we put the formalism at work, choosing as our case study a two-dimensional (2D) anharmonic oscillator of the kind considered in molecular physics. The results of the simulations show that by increasing lithe effective dynamics tends to regularize the classical motion and becomes qualitatively very similar to the quantum evolution provided the energy is sufficiently small. The evaluation of the effective dynamics in more general cases will be presented in a forthcoming paper.
Starting from our idea of combining the Feynman path integral spirit and the Dyson series kernel, we find an explicit and general form of time evolution operator that is a ccc-number function and a power series of perturbation including all order approximations in the unperturbed Hamiltonian representation. Based on it, we obtain an exact solution of the Schrödinger equation in general quantum systems independent of time. Comparison of our exact solution with the existed perturbation theory makes some features and significance of our exact solution clear. The conclusions expressly indicate that our exact solution is obviously consistent with the usual time-independent perturbation theory at any order approximation, it explicitly calculates out the expanding coefficients of the unperturbed state in the non-perturbation method, and it fully solves the recurrence equation of the expansion coefficients of final state in the unperturbed Hamiltonian representation from a view of time-dependent perturbation theory. At the same time, the exact solution of the von Neumann equation is also given. Our results can be thought of as theoretical developments of quantum dynamics, and are helpful for understanding the dynamical behavior and related subjects of general quantum systems in both theory and application. Our exact solution, together with its sequence studies on perturbation theory [An Min Wang, quant-ph/0611217] and open system dynamics [An Min Wang, quant-ph/0601051] can be used to establish the foundation of theoretical formulism of quantum mechanics in general quantum systems. Further applications of our exact solution to quantum theory can be expected.
We present a time-dependent extension of logarithmic perturbation theory for nonrelativistic quantum dynamics governed by the Schrödinger equation, in which the logarithm of the wave function is expanded in powers of a coupling constant. The resulting hierarchy of equations defining the perturbative corrections is governed by a gauge-rotated Hamiltonian of the unperturbed system and leads to closed-integral expressions for the time-dependent corrections based on Duhamel's formula. This closed-integral structure of corrections is a hallmark of time-independent logarithmic perturbation theory and is preserved in the present extension. This structure, in particular, provides a computable expression for the instantaneous energy shift. Furthermore, dynamic energy shifts arise naturally within this framework in the form of time-averaged expectation values of pseudopotentials and can be related, for example, to AC Stark shifts and electric polarizabilities. As an illustration, we apply the method to the harmonic oscillator and the hydrogen atom, both driven by a time-dependent laser field. The harmonic oscillator provides a proof of principle for which the exact solution is recovered, while the hydrogen atom illustrates the method applied to atomic systems. Supported by numerical simulations, we demonstrate the applicability to obtain relevant physical observables with high accuracy. The present approach offers a promising alternative for analytical studies of time-dependent multi-photon processes in the perturbative regime.