Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:cond-mat/0107458 · Physical review. B, Condensed matter

Nonexistence of a strong coupling two-channel Kondo fixed point for microscopic models of tunneling centers

I. L. Aleǐner, Davide Controzzi

Published Jul 19, 2002• 18 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We consider the problem of a heavy particle in a double well potential (DWP) interacting with an electron bath. Under general assumptions, we map the problem to a three-color logarithmic gas model, where the size of the core of the charged particles is proportional to the tunneling time, ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{tun}},$ of the heavy particle between the two wells. For times larger than ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{tun}}$ this model is equivalent to the anisotropic two-channel Kondo (2CK) model in a transverse field. This allows us to establish a relationship between the microscopic parameters of DWP and the 2CK problem. We show that the strong coupling fixed point of the 2CK model can never be reached for the DWP problem, in agreement with the results of Kagan and Prokof'ev [Sov. Phys. JETP 69, 836 (1989)] and Aleiner et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 86, 2629 (2001)].

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.66.045107

Related papers

Two-channel Kondo physics in tunnel-coupled double quantum dots

Frederic W. Jayatilaka, Martin R. Galpin, David E. Logan

We investigate theoretically the possibility of observing two-channel Kondo (2CK) physics in tunnel-coupled double quantum dots (TCDQDs), at both zero and finite magnetic fields; taking the two-impurity Anderson model as the basic TCDQD model, together with effective low-energy models arising from it by Schrieffer-Wolff transformations to second and third order in the tunnel couplings. The models are studied primarily using Wilson's numerical renormalization group. At zero field our basic conclusion is that while 2CK physics arises in principle provided the system is sufficiently strongly correlated, the temperature window over which it could be observed is much lower than is experimentally feasible. This finding disagrees with recent work on the problem, and we explain why. At finite field, we show that the quantum phase transition known to arise at zero field in the two-impurity Kondo model, with an essentially 2CK quantum critical point, persists at finite fields. This raises the prospect of access to 2CK physics by tuning a magnetic field, although preliminary investigation suggests this to be even less feasible than at zero field.

arXiv:1106.5450•Physical Review B•Sep 14, 2011•22 citations

Low-temperature properties of a two-level system interacting with conduction electrons: An application of the overcompensated multichannel Kondo model

Pedro D Sacramento, P. Schlottmann

We consider an atom in a double-well potential [parametrized by a two-level system (TLS)] interacting with screened conduction electrons. The tunneling of the TLS is assisted by the Fermi gas. Close to the strong-coupling fixed point the renormalization-group equations for the noncommutative model in the case of spinless fermions, but an arbitrary number of relevant orbital channels, lead to the n-channel Kondo problem with S=1/2. By solving the thermodynamic Bethe-ansatz equations for the n-channel Kondo problem numerically in the presence of a magnetic field, we discuss the low-temperature properties of the TLS close to the fixed point. The Zeeman splitting corresponds to the energy difference between the two positions of the tunneling atom. The atom is not localized at one of the potential minima. The susceptibility diverges as H\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0 and T\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0, indicating that the symmetric TLS is unstable against a local lattice deformation via coupling to phonons. The lattice distortion disappears above a critical temperature ${\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}$. The ground-state equilibrium situation of the TLS corresponds to H\ensuremath{\ne}0 and a Fermi-liquid picture applies. The values for the specific heat become very large as H\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0. For small fields the specific heat shows a double-peak structure, which is particularly pronounced for n=2.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Jun 1, 1991•116 citations

Numerical Renormalization Group Studies of the Partially Broken SU(3) Kondo Model

Evaristus Fuh Chuo

The two-channel Kondo (2CK) effect with its exotic ground state properties has remained difficult to realize in physical systems. At low energies, a quantum impurity with orbital degree of freedom, like a proton bound in an interstitial lattice space, comprises a 3-level system with a unique ground state and (at least) doubly degenerate rotational excitations with excitation energy $Delta_0$. When immersed in a metal, electronic angular momentum scattering induces transitions between any two of these levels (couplings $J$), while the electron spin is conserved. We show by extensive numerical renormalization group (NRG) calculations that without fine-tuning of parameters this system exhibits a 2CK fixed point, due to Kondo correlations in the excited-state doublet whose degeneracy is stabilized by the host lattice parity, while the channel symmetry (electron spin) is guaranteed by time reversal symmetry. We find a pronounced plateau in the entropy at $S(T_K < T < Delta_0) = k_B ln 2$ between the high-$T$ value, $S(T gg Delta_0) = k_B ln 3$, and the 2CK ground state value, $S(0) = k_B lnsqrt{2}$. This indicates a downward renormalization of the doublet below the non-interacting ground state, thus realizing the 2CK fixed point, in agreement with earlier conjectures. We mapped out the phase diagram of the model in the $J-Delta_0$ plane. The Kondo temperature $T_K$ shows non-monotonic $J$-dependence, characteristic for 2CK systems.newline indent Beside the two-channel Kondo effect of the model, we also study the single-channel version, which is realized by applying a strong magnetic field to the conduction band electrons so that their degeneracy is lifted and consequently having only one kind of electrons scattering off the impurity. This single-channel case is easier to analyze since the Hilbert space is not as large as that of the 2CK. We equally find a downward renormalization of the excited state energy by the Kondo correlations in the SU(2) doublet. In a wide range of parameter values this stabilizes the single-channel Kondo fixed point and a phase diagram is also mapped out for the model. In the single-channel version a plateau is found in the entropy at $S(T_K < T < Delta_0) = k_B ln 2$ between high-$T$ value, $S(T gg Delta_0) = k_B ln 3$, and the single-channel Kondo ground state value, $S(0) = k_B ln 1$.

•May 29, 2013•0 citations

Strong versus weak coupling duality and coupling dependence of the Kondo temperature in the two-channel Kondo model

Christian Kolf, Johann Kroha

We perform numerical renormalization group (NRG) as well as analytical calculations for the two-channel Kondo (2CK) model to obtain the dependence of the Kondo temperature ${T}_{K}$ on the dimensionless (bare) spin exchange coupling $g$ over the complete parameter range from $g⪡1$ to $g⪢1$. We show that there exists a duality between the regimes of small and large coupling. It is unique for the two-channel model and enables a mapping between the strong and the weak coupling cases via the identification $g\ensuremath{\leftrightarrow}3∕(2g)$, implying an exponential dependence of ${T}_{K}$ on $1∕g$ and $g$, respectively, in the two regimes. This agrees quantitatively with our NRG calculations where we extract ${T}_{K}(g)$ over the complete parameter range and obtain a nonmonotonic ${T}_{K}(g)$ dependence, strongly peaked at the 2CK fixed point coupling ${g}^{*}$. These results may be relevant for resolving the long-standing puzzle within the 2CK interpretation of certain random defect systems as to why no broad distribution of ${T}_{K}$ is observed in those systems.

arXiv:cond-mat/0610631•Physical Review B•Jan 26, 2007•16 citations

Theory of tunneling centers in metallic systems: Role of excited states and orbital Kondo effect

Gergely Zaránd, A. Zawadowski

The interaction between a tunneling atom in a double potential well and the conduction electrons of different angular momenta results in an anisotropic two-channel orbital Kondo problem, but the Kondo temperature ${\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{K}}$ found earlier has always been somewhat small. That difficulty can be resolved by including some of the excited states of the atom in the well. The ${\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{K}}$ calculated is around 1--10 K in agreement with experiments. The same result can be obtained even if the direct electron assisted tunneling is ignored.

Physical Review Letters•Jan 24, 1994•51 citations

Overscreened single-channel Kondo problem

Anirvan M. Sengupta, Yong Baek Kim

We consider the single-channel Kondo problem with the Kondo coupling between a spin $S$ impurity and conduction electrons with spin $j$. These problems arise as multicritical points in the parameter spaces of two-and higher-level tunneling systems and some impurity models of heavy fermion compounds. In contrast to the previous Bethe-ansatz conjectures, it turns out that the dynamics of the spin sector is the same as that of a spin-$S$ impurity coupled to $k(j)$ channels of spin-\textonehalf{} electrons with $k(j)=2\frac{j(j+1)(2j+1)}{3}$. As a result, for $2S<k(j)$, the system shows non-Fermi-liquid behavior with the same exponents for the thermodynamic quantities as those of the $k(j)$-channel Kondo problem. However, both the finite-size spectrum and the operator content are different due to the presence of the other sectors and can be obtained by conformal field theory techniques.

arXiv:cond-mat/9602100•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Dec 1, 1996•22 citations
We consider the problem of a heavy particle in a double well potential (DWP) interacting with an electron bath. Under general assumptions, we map the problem to a three-color logarithmic gas model, where the size of the core of the charged particles is proportional to the tunneling time, \ensuremathτtun,{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{tun}},\ensuremathτtun​, of the heavy particle between the two wells. For times larger than \ensuremathτtun{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{tun}}\ensuremathτtun​ this model is equivalent to the anisotropic two-channel Kondo (2CK) model in a transverse field. This allows us to establish a relationship between the microscopic parameters of DWP and the 2CK problem. We show that the strong coupling fixed point of the 2CK model can never be reached for the DWP problem, in agreement with the results of Kagan and Prokof'ev [Sov. Phys. JETP 69, 836 (1989)] and Aleiner et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 86, 2629 (2001)].
We investigate theoretically the possibility of observing two-channel Kondo (2CK) physics in tunnel-coupled double quantum dots (TCDQDs), at both zero and finite magnetic fields; taking the two-impurity Anderson model as the basic TCDQD model, together with effective low-energy models arising from it by Schrieffer-Wolff transformations to second and third order in the tunnel couplings. The models are studied primarily using Wilson's numerical renormalization group. At zero field our basic conclusion is that while 2CK physics arises in principle provided the system is sufficiently strongly correlated, the temperature window over which it could be observed is much lower than is experimentally feasible. This finding disagrees with recent work on the problem, and we explain why. At finite field, we show that the quantum phase transition known to arise at zero field in the two-impurity Kondo model, with an essentially 2CK quantum critical point, persists at finite fields. This raises the prospect of access to 2CK physics by tuning a magnetic field, although preliminary investigation suggests this to be even less feasible than at zero field.
We consider an atom in a double-well potential [parametrized by a two-level system (TLS)] interacting with screened conduction electrons. The tunneling of the TLS is assisted by the Fermi gas. Close to the strong-coupling fixed point the renormalization-group equations for the noncommutative model in the case of spinless fermions, but an arbitrary number of relevant orbital channels, lead to the n-channel Kondo problem with S=1/2. By solving the thermodynamic Bethe-ansatz equations for the n-channel Kondo problem numerically in the presence of a magnetic field, we discuss the low-temperature properties of the TLS close to the fixed point. The Zeeman splitting corresponds to the energy difference between the two positions of the tunneling atom. The atom is not localized at one of the potential minima. The susceptibility diverges as H\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0 and T\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0, indicating that the symmetric TLS is unstable against a local lattice deformation via coupling to phonons. The lattice distortion disappears above a critical temperature Tc{\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}Tc​. The ground-state equilibrium situation of the TLS corresponds to H\ensuremath{\ne}0 and a Fermi-liquid picture applies. The values for the specific heat become very large as H\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0. For small fields the specific heat shows a double-peak structure, which is particularly pronounced for n=2.
The two-channel Kondo (2CK) effect with its exotic ground state properties has remained difficult to realize in physical systems. At low energies, a quantum impurity with orbital degree of freedom, like a proton bound in an interstitial lattice space, comprises a 3-level system with a unique ground state and (at least) doubly degenerate rotational excitations with excitation energy Delta0Delta_0Delta0​. When immersed in a metal, electronic angular momentum scattering induces transitions between any two of these levels (couplings JJJ), while the electron spin is conserved. We show by extensive numerical renormalization group (NRG) calculations that without fine-tuning of parameters this system exhibits a 2CK fixed point, due to Kondo correlations in the excited-state doublet whose degeneracy is stabilized by the host lattice parity, while the channel symmetry (electron spin) is guaranteed by time reversal symmetry. We find a pronounced plateau in the entropy at S(TK<T<Delta0)=kBln2S(T_K < T < Delta_0) = k_B ln 2S(TK​<T<Delta0​)=kB​ln2 between the high-TTT value, S(TggDelta0)=kBln3S(T gg Delta_0) = k_B ln 3S(TggDelta0​)=kB​ln3, and the 2CK ground state value, S(0)=kBlnsqrt2S(0) = k_B lnsqrt{2}S(0)=kB​lnsqrt2. This indicates a downward renormalization of the doublet below the non-interacting ground state, thus realizing the 2CK fixed point, in agreement with earlier conjectures. We mapped out the phase diagram of the model in the J−Delta0J-Delta_0J−Delta0​ plane. The Kondo temperature TKT_KTK​ shows non-monotonic JJJ-dependence, characteristic for 2CK systems.newline indent Beside the two-channel Kondo effect of the model, we also study the single-channel version, which is realized by applying a strong magnetic field to the conduction band electrons so that their degeneracy is lifted and consequently having only one kind of electrons scattering off the impurity. This single-channel case is easier to analyze since the Hilbert space is not as large as that of the 2CK. We equally find a downward renormalization of the excited state energy by the Kondo correlations in the SU(2) doublet. In a wide range of parameter values this stabilizes the single-channel Kondo fixed point and a phase diagram is also mapped out for the model. In the single-channel version a plateau is found in the entropy at S(TK<T<Delta0)=kBln2S(T_K < T < Delta_0) = k_B ln 2S(TK​<T<Delta0​)=kB​ln2 between high-TTT value, S(TggDelta0)=kBln3S(T gg Delta_0) = k_B ln 3S(TggDelta0​)=kB​ln3, and the single-channel Kondo ground state value, S(0)=kBln1S(0) = k_B ln 1S(0)=kB​ln1.
We perform numerical renormalization group (NRG) as well as analytical calculations for the two-channel Kondo (2CK) model to obtain the dependence of the Kondo temperature TK{T}_{K}TK​ on the dimensionless (bare) spin exchange coupling ggg over the complete parameter range from g⪡1g⪡1g⪡1 to g⪢1g⪢1g⪢1. We show that there exists a duality between the regimes of small and large coupling. It is unique for the two-channel model and enables a mapping between the strong and the weak coupling cases via the identification $g\ensuremath{\leftrightarrow}3∕(2g)$, implying an exponential dependence of TK{T}_{K}TK​ on 1∕g1∕g1∕g and ggg, respectively, in the two regimes. This agrees quantitatively with our NRG calculations where we extract TK(g){T}_{K}(g)TK​(g) over the complete parameter range and obtain a nonmonotonic TK(g){T}_{K}(g)TK​(g) dependence, strongly peaked at the 2CK fixed point coupling g∗{g}^{*}g∗. These results may be relevant for resolving the long-standing puzzle within the 2CK interpretation of certain random defect systems as to why no broad distribution of TK{T}_{K}TK​ is observed in those systems.
The interaction between a tunneling atom in a double potential well and the conduction electrons of different angular momenta results in an anisotropic two-channel orbital Kondo problem, but the Kondo temperature TK{\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{K}}TK​ found earlier has always been somewhat small. That difficulty can be resolved by including some of the excited states of the atom in the well. The TK{\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{K}}TK​ calculated is around 1--10 K in agreement with experiments. The same result can be obtained even if the direct electron assisted tunneling is ignored.
We consider the single-channel Kondo problem with the Kondo coupling between a spin SSS impurity and conduction electrons with spin jjj. These problems arise as multicritical points in the parameter spaces of two-and higher-level tunneling systems and some impurity models of heavy fermion compounds. In contrast to the previous Bethe-ansatz conjectures, it turns out that the dynamics of the spin sector is the same as that of a spin-SSS impurity coupled to k(j)k(j)k(j) channels of spin-\textonehalf{} electrons with k(j)=2j(j+1)(2j+1)3k(j)=2\frac{j(j+1)(2j+1)}{3}k(j)=23j(j+1)(2j+1)​. As a result, for 2S<k(j)2S<k(j)2S<k(j), the system shows non-Fermi-liquid behavior with the same exponents for the thermodynamic quantities as those of the k(j)k(j)k(j)-channel Kondo problem. However, both the finite-size spectrum and the operator content are different due to the presence of the other sectors and can be obtained by conformal field theory techniques.