Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Dipolar Condensates: Collapse Thresholds and Droplet Densities Under the Bounds

William Alexander Aldred

Published Nov 12, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Magnetic dipolar condensates add a long-range anisotropic interaction that can destabilise the mean-field gas, producing collapse, droplets stabilised by quantum fluctuations, and supersolid phases. This paper computes the dipolar length for dysprosium-164 and erbium-168 from their magnetic moments, states the mean-field collapse criterion in terms of the ratio of dipolar to contact interaction strengths, and compares droplet densities with the density bound. The dipolar lengths are 133 Bohr radii for dysprosium and 67 for erbium, matching published values, and a representative droplet density of 1.0e+21 per cubic metre stands at a ratio of 2.80e-62 to the bound. Collapse and droplet formation are therefore interaction-geometry phenomena of the dilute gas, occurring at densities far below the fundamental ceiling and stabilised by fluctuation physics rather than by any bound. The work is computed from published atomic properties, not measured.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.24155395

Related papers

Binary quantum droplets and dipolar supersolids

 Joseph Smith

We consider a binary magnetic gas and develop an extended Gross-Pitaevskii theory to study the system. We apply this theory to the regime where the two- body interactions are attractive for some arrangements of the atoms, and mean- field theory predicts mechanical collapse. In this regime quantum droplets of the binary magnetic gas can emerge, stabilised by quantum fluctuations. These quantum droplets can exist in miscible and immiscible regimes, and we characterise their properties over a broad parameter space. Simplified theories are developed to describe the droplets, and benchmarked against the full numerical calculations. The system dynamics are simulated for scenarios involving droplet formation and crossing the miscible-immiscible transition. Three-body loss is modelled in the dynamical simulations to account for the dominant loss process expected in experiments. We also study the supersolidity of a single-component dipolar gas in an infinite tube potential. An accurate computational algorithm is developed to calculate the ground state of the system in a unit cell. This algorithm is used to determine the phase diagram by characterising the crystalline order and superfluid fraction. Our results reveal that a system confined in a radially harmonic trap has a continuous transition for a range of density values, but is discontinuous for densities above and below this range. The theory is used to calculate the crystalline and supersolid states of a binary magnetic gas in a tube potential.

•Jan 1, 2023•0 citations

Dipolar physics: a review of experiments with magnetic quantum gases

Lauriane Chomaz, Igor Ferrier-Barbut, Francesca Ferlaino +3 more

Since the achievement of quantum degeneracy in gases of chromium atoms in 2004, the experimental investigation of ultracold gases made of highly magnetic atoms has blossomed. The field has yielded the observation of many unprecedented phenomena, in particular those in which long-range and anisotropic dipole-dipole interactions (DDIs) play a crucial role. In this review, we aim to present the aspects of the magnetic quantum-gas platform that make it unique for exploring ultracold and quantum physics as well as to give a thorough overview of experimental achievements. Highly magnetic atoms distinguish themselves by the fact that their electronic ground-state configuration possesses a large electronic total angular momentum. This results in a large magnetic moment and a rich electronic transition spectrum. Such transitions are useful for cooling, trapping, and manipulating these atoms. The complex atomic structure and large dipolar moments of these atoms also lead to a dense spectrum of resonances in their two-body scattering behaviour. These resonances can be used to control the interatomic interactions and, in particular, the relative importance of contact over dipolar interactions. These features provide exquisite control knobs for exploring the few- and many-body physics of dipolar quantum gases. The study of dipolar effects in magnetic quantum gases has covered various few-body phenomena that are based on elastic and inelastic anisotropic scattering. Various many-body effects have also been demonstrated. These affect both the shape, stability, dynamics, and excitations of fully polarised repulsive Bose or Fermi gases. Beyond the mean-field instability, strong dipolar interactions competing with slightly weaker contact interactions between magnetic bosons yield new quantum-stabilised states, among which are self-bound droplets, droplet assemblies, and supersolids. Dipolar interactions also deeply affect the physics of atomic gases with an internal degree of freedom as these interactions intrinsically couple spin and atomic motion. Finally, long-range dipolar interactions can stabilise strongly correlated excited states of 1D gases and also impact the physics of lattice-confined systems, both at the spin-polarised level (Hubbard models with off-site interactions) and at the spinful level (XYZ models). In the present manuscript, we aim to provide an extensive overview of the various related experimental achievements up to the present.

arXiv:2201.02672•Reports on Progress in Physics•Dec 2, 2022•463 citations

Dipolar gases in two dimensions: From dipolar BKT superfluid to self-organized supersolid

Yifei He

This thesis discusses the experiments on 2D dipolar Bose gas of ultracold erbium atoms. Long-range and anisotropic dipole-dipole interaction induces complex orders in quantum many-body systems. Highly magnetic lanthanide atoms such as dysprosium and erbium have the largest magnetic moment in the periodic table, which has attracted significant attention in the past decades. Starting from quantum degenerate dysprosium and erbium atoms, exotic phases like quantum droplets, supersolid, dipolar quantum solid in the Hubbard regime have been studied. However, the 2D dipolar superfluid still remains understudied, despite being theoretically discussed for over two decades. Although tremendous theoretical proposals predict different phenomena in 2D dipolar superfluids, our first interest is to know how the superfluidity emerges in the 2D dipolar gases at finite temperatures. Our observations suggest that the superfluid transition can be well described by the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless transition with an effective contact interaction as a function of dipolar orientation. With the 2D dipolar superfluid with strong DDI, we characterized the elementary excitation of the matter: the collective breathing mode. Our measurements establish how the competition between local and nonlocal interaction in strongly dipolar 2D superfluid retains quasi-scale invariance or strongly breaks scale invariance. By further searching the interaction parameters, we created stripes with global coherence, which are the first supersolid stripes in 2D. Experiments including measuring density fluctuation, coherence, and collective mode have been performed to understand the 2D supersolid. At last, we also observe unconventional light scattering from round-disk dipolar BECs, which provides new possibilities for atom optics.

•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

Induced supersolidity in a Dy-Er mixture

Soumyadeep Halder, Subrata Das, Sonjoy Majumder

The recent experimental realization of the heteronuclear dipolar mixture of Dy and Er atoms opens fascinating prospects for creating intriguing novel phases in dipolar quantum gases. The experimentally measured value of intraspecies $s$-wave scattering length of $^{166}\mathrm{Er}$ condensate in a $^{164}\mathrm{Dy}\text{\ensuremath{-}}^{166}\mathrm{Er}$ mixture is larger than its intraspecies dipolar length implies that the $^{166}\mathrm{Er}$ condensate itself will not be in a regime of dominated dipole-dipole interaction (DDI). However, we find that the presence of $^{164}\mathrm{Dy}$ atoms with high magnetic moment induces droplet nucleation and supersolidity in the $^{166}\mathrm{Er}$ condensate via the long-range and anisotropic interspecies DDI. Remarkably, we find that the imbalance in the magnetic dipole moment combined with its strong anisotropic coupling leads to the emergence of unique ground-state phases. The emerging phases include doubly superfluid states, a mixture of insulating droplets and supersolid states, binary supersolids with uniform and alternating domains and a combination of supersolid-superfluid mixed states. We delineate the properties of all these ground-state phases and construct a phase diagram. We also explore the dynamical evolution across these phase boundaries via a linear quench of interspecies scattering length. Although we demonstrate the result for the $^{164}\mathrm{Dy}\text{\ensuremath{-}}^{166}\mathrm{Er}$ mixture, our results are generally valid for other dipolar bosonic mixtures of different Dy-Er isotope combinations and may become an important benchmark for future experimental scenarios.

arXiv:2309.16799•Physical Review A•Jun 17, 2024•8 citations

Control of Dy 164 Bose-Einstein condensate phases and dynamics with dipolar anisotropy

Soumyadeep Halder, K. Mukherjee, S. I. Mistakidis +5 more

We investigate the quench dynamics of quasi-one- and two-dimensional dipolar Bose-Einstein condensates of $^{164}\mathrm{Dy}$ atoms under the influence of a fast rotating magnetic field. The magnetic field thus controls both the magnitude and sign of the dipolar potential. We account for quantum fluctuations, critical to formation of exotic quantum droplet and supersolid phases in the extended Gross-Pitaevskii formalism, which includes the so-called Lee-Huang-Yang correction. An analytical variational ansatz allows us to obtain the phase diagrams of the superfluid and droplet phases. The crossover from the superfluid to the supersolid phase and to single and droplet arrays is probed with particle number and dipolar interaction. The dipolar strength is tuned by rotating the magnetic field with subsequent effects on phase boundaries. Following interaction quenches across the aforementioned phases, we monitor the dynamical formation of supersolid clusters or droplet lattices. We include losses due to three-body recombination over the crossover regime, where the three-body recombination rate coefficient scales with the fourth power of the scattering length $({a}_{s})$ or the dipole length $({a}_{dd})$. For fixed values of the dimensionless parameter, ${\ensuremath{\epsilon}}_{dd}={a}_{dd}/{a}_{s}$, tuning the dipolar anisotropy leads to an enhancement of the droplet lifetimes.

arXiv:2205.05193•Physical Review Research•Nov 21, 2022•26 citations

Liquid quantum droplets of ultracold magnetic atoms

Igor Ferrier-Barbut, Matthias Schmitt, Matthias Wenzel +2 more

Abstract The simultaneous presence of two competing inter-particle interactions can lead to the emergence of new phenomena in a many-body system. Among others, such effects are expected in dipolar Bose–Einstein condensates, subject to dipole–dipole interaction and short-range repulsion. Magnetic quantum gases and in particular Dysprosium gases, offering a comparable short-range contact and a long-range dipolar interaction energy, remarkably exhibit such emergent phenomena. In addition an effective cancellation of mean-field effects of the two interactions results in a pronounced importance of quantum-mechanical beyond mean-field effects. For a weakly dominant dipolar interaction the striking consequence is the existence of a new state of matter equilibrated by the balance between weak mean-field attraction and beyond mean-field repulsion. Though exemplified here in the case of dipolar Bose gases, this state of matter should appear also with other microscopic interactions types, provided a competition results in an effective cancellation of the total mean-field. The macroscopic state takes the form of so-called quantum droplets. We present the effects of a long-range dipolar interaction between these droplets.

arXiv:1609.03937•Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Oct 18, 2016•98 citations
Magnetic dipolar condensates add a long-range anisotropic interaction that can destabilise the mean-field gas, producing collapse, droplets stabilised by quantum fluctuations, and supersolid phases. This paper computes the dipolar length for dysprosium-164 and erbium-168 from their magnetic moments, states the mean-field collapse criterion in terms of the ratio of dipolar to contact interaction strengths, and compares droplet densities with the density bound. The dipolar lengths are 133 Bohr radii for dysprosium and 67 for erbium, matching published values, and a representative droplet density of 1.0e+21 per cubic metre stands at a ratio of 2.80e-62 to the bound. Collapse and droplet formation are therefore interaction-geometry phenomena of the dilute gas, occurring at densities far below the fundamental ceiling and stabilised by fluctuation physics rather than by any bound. The work is computed from published atomic properties, not measured.
We consider a binary magnetic gas and develop an extended Gross-Pitaevskii theory to study the system. We apply this theory to the regime where the two- body interactions are attractive for some arrangements of the atoms, and mean- field theory predicts mechanical collapse. In this regime quantum droplets of the binary magnetic gas can emerge, stabilised by quantum fluctuations. These quantum droplets can exist in miscible and immiscible regimes, and we characterise their properties over a broad parameter space. Simplified theories are developed to describe the droplets, and benchmarked against the full numerical calculations. The system dynamics are simulated for scenarios involving droplet formation and crossing the miscible-immiscible transition. Three-body loss is modelled in the dynamical simulations to account for the dominant loss process expected in experiments. We also study the supersolidity of a single-component dipolar gas in an infinite tube potential. An accurate computational algorithm is developed to calculate the ground state of the system in a unit cell. This algorithm is used to determine the phase diagram by characterising the crystalline order and superfluid fraction. Our results reveal that a system confined in a radially harmonic trap has a continuous transition for a range of density values, but is discontinuous for densities above and below this range. The theory is used to calculate the crystalline and supersolid states of a binary magnetic gas in a tube potential.
Since the achievement of quantum degeneracy in gases of chromium atoms in 2004, the experimental investigation of ultracold gases made of highly magnetic atoms has blossomed. The field has yielded the observation of many unprecedented phenomena, in particular those in which long-range and anisotropic dipole-dipole interactions (DDIs) play a crucial role. In this review, we aim to present the aspects of the magnetic quantum-gas platform that make it unique for exploring ultracold and quantum physics as well as to give a thorough overview of experimental achievements. Highly magnetic atoms distinguish themselves by the fact that their electronic ground-state configuration possesses a large electronic total angular momentum. This results in a large magnetic moment and a rich electronic transition spectrum. Such transitions are useful for cooling, trapping, and manipulating these atoms. The complex atomic structure and large dipolar moments of these atoms also lead to a dense spectrum of resonances in their two-body scattering behaviour. These resonances can be used to control the interatomic interactions and, in particular, the relative importance of contact over dipolar interactions. These features provide exquisite control knobs for exploring the few- and many-body physics of dipolar quantum gases. The study of dipolar effects in magnetic quantum gases has covered various few-body phenomena that are based on elastic and inelastic anisotropic scattering. Various many-body effects have also been demonstrated. These affect both the shape, stability, dynamics, and excitations of fully polarised repulsive Bose or Fermi gases. Beyond the mean-field instability, strong dipolar interactions competing with slightly weaker contact interactions between magnetic bosons yield new quantum-stabilised states, among which are self-bound droplets, droplet assemblies, and supersolids. Dipolar interactions also deeply affect the physics of atomic gases with an internal degree of freedom as these interactions intrinsically couple spin and atomic motion. Finally, long-range dipolar interactions can stabilise strongly correlated excited states of 1D gases and also impact the physics of lattice-confined systems, both at the spin-polarised level (Hubbard models with off-site interactions) and at the spinful level (XYZ models). In the present manuscript, we aim to provide an extensive overview of the various related experimental achievements up to the present.
This thesis discusses the experiments on 2D dipolar Bose gas of ultracold erbium atoms. Long-range and anisotropic dipole-dipole interaction induces complex orders in quantum many-body systems. Highly magnetic lanthanide atoms such as dysprosium and erbium have the largest magnetic moment in the periodic table, which has attracted significant attention in the past decades. Starting from quantum degenerate dysprosium and erbium atoms, exotic phases like quantum droplets, supersolid, dipolar quantum solid in the Hubbard regime have been studied. However, the 2D dipolar superfluid still remains understudied, despite being theoretically discussed for over two decades. Although tremendous theoretical proposals predict different phenomena in 2D dipolar superfluids, our first interest is to know how the superfluidity emerges in the 2D dipolar gases at finite temperatures. Our observations suggest that the superfluid transition can be well described by the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless transition with an effective contact interaction as a function of dipolar orientation. With the 2D dipolar superfluid with strong DDI, we characterized the elementary excitation of the matter: the collective breathing mode. Our measurements establish how the competition between local and nonlocal interaction in strongly dipolar 2D superfluid retains quasi-scale invariance or strongly breaks scale invariance. By further searching the interaction parameters, we created stripes with global coherence, which are the first supersolid stripes in 2D. Experiments including measuring density fluctuation, coherence, and collective mode have been performed to understand the 2D supersolid. At last, we also observe unconventional light scattering from round-disk dipolar BECs, which provides new possibilities for atom optics.
The recent experimental realization of the heteronuclear dipolar mixture of Dy and Er atoms opens fascinating prospects for creating intriguing novel phases in dipolar quantum gases. The experimentally measured value of intraspecies sss-wave scattering length of 166Er^{166}\mathrm{Er}166Er condensate in a $^{164}\mathrm{Dy}\text{\ensuremath{-}}^{166}\mathrm{Er}$ mixture is larger than its intraspecies dipolar length implies that the 166Er^{166}\mathrm{Er}166Er condensate itself will not be in a regime of dominated dipole-dipole interaction (DDI). However, we find that the presence of 164Dy^{164}\mathrm{Dy}164Dy atoms with high magnetic moment induces droplet nucleation and supersolidity in the 166Er^{166}\mathrm{Er}166Er condensate via the long-range and anisotropic interspecies DDI. Remarkably, we find that the imbalance in the magnetic dipole moment combined with its strong anisotropic coupling leads to the emergence of unique ground-state phases. The emerging phases include doubly superfluid states, a mixture of insulating droplets and supersolid states, binary supersolids with uniform and alternating domains and a combination of supersolid-superfluid mixed states. We delineate the properties of all these ground-state phases and construct a phase diagram. We also explore the dynamical evolution across these phase boundaries via a linear quench of interspecies scattering length. Although we demonstrate the result for the $^{164}\mathrm{Dy}\text{\ensuremath{-}}^{166}\mathrm{Er}$ mixture, our results are generally valid for other dipolar bosonic mixtures of different Dy-Er isotope combinations and may become an important benchmark for future experimental scenarios.
We investigate the quench dynamics of quasi-one- and two-dimensional dipolar Bose-Einstein condensates of 164Dy^{164}\mathrm{Dy}164Dy atoms under the influence of a fast rotating magnetic field. The magnetic field thus controls both the magnitude and sign of the dipolar potential. We account for quantum fluctuations, critical to formation of exotic quantum droplet and supersolid phases in the extended Gross-Pitaevskii formalism, which includes the so-called Lee-Huang-Yang correction. An analytical variational ansatz allows us to obtain the phase diagrams of the superfluid and droplet phases. The crossover from the superfluid to the supersolid phase and to single and droplet arrays is probed with particle number and dipolar interaction. The dipolar strength is tuned by rotating the magnetic field with subsequent effects on phase boundaries. Following interaction quenches across the aforementioned phases, we monitor the dynamical formation of supersolid clusters or droplet lattices. We include losses due to three-body recombination over the crossover regime, where the three-body recombination rate coefficient scales with the fourth power of the scattering length (as)({a}_{s})(as​) or the dipole length (add)({a}_{dd})(add​). For fixed values of the dimensionless parameter, ${\ensuremath{\epsilon}}_{dd}={a}_{dd}/{a}_{s}$, tuning the dipolar anisotropy leads to an enhancement of the droplet lifetimes.
Abstract The simultaneous presence of two competing inter-particle interactions can lead to the emergence of new phenomena in a many-body system. Among others, such effects are expected in dipolar Bose–Einstein condensates, subject to dipole–dipole interaction and short-range repulsion. Magnetic quantum gases and in particular Dysprosium gases, offering a comparable short-range contact and a long-range dipolar interaction energy, remarkably exhibit such emergent phenomena. In addition an effective cancellation of mean-field effects of the two interactions results in a pronounced importance of quantum-mechanical beyond mean-field effects. For a weakly dominant dipolar interaction the striking consequence is the existence of a new state of matter equilibrated by the balance between weak mean-field attraction and beyond mean-field repulsion. Though exemplified here in the case of dipolar Bose gases, this state of matter should appear also with other microscopic interactions types, provided a competition results in an effective cancellation of the total mean-field. The macroscopic state takes the form of so-called quantum droplets. We present the effects of a long-range dipolar interaction between these droplets.