Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Ontology-Information Dichotomy Framework: The Truth Identity Axiom and Empirical Evidence for Macroscopic Apparent Randomness

Jiale Wu

Published Nov 3, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

If all hidden variables behind so‑called intrinsic randomness were known to me, would it still be intrinsic randomness? This question exposes a fatal logical impasse within traditional physics: the moment complete information () is achieved, random phenomena vanish. Therefore, all observable randomness in reality is structurally tied to an information gap. This paper proposes the "Ontology‑Information Dichotomy Framework" and the "Theorem of Information Gap‑Randomness Necessity". Through time‑sequence‑separated macroscopic dice‑cup experiments (decoupling physical perturbation from information occlusion) and control tests with AI vision algorithms, we empirically demonstrate that apparent randomness is an inevitable product of finite physical information systems under , independent of biological consciousness. We further prove that unobservable hidden variables and pure observational information deficiency are observationally equivalent. Any claim of "intrinsic randomness" lacking decisive evidence under complete‑input conditions () is either a self‑contradictory notion or a metaphysical presupposition. Ranging from engineering encapsulation (e.g., lotteries, PRNGs) to microscopic quantum scenarios, apparent randomness strictly derived from the information gap constitutes the only empirically supported and logically self‑consistent mechanism.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23926754

Related papers

The Principle of Ontological Statistical Convergence: Physical Statistical Convergence Laws in Deterministic Causal Systems

Jiale Wu

Traditional physics often directly attributes the phenomenon of frequency convergence in large samples to the existence of intrinsic randomness at the fundamental physical level. However, the mathematical Law of Large Numbers (LLN) is merely a theorem within a formal axiomatic system and makes no ontological assertions regarding its physical origin. Equating frequency convergence with intrinsic randomness is an unverified logical extrapolation. Building upon the "Ontology-Information Dichotomy Framework," this paper proposes the Principle of Ontological Statistical Convergence: In a physical system with an underlying fully deterministic causal structure, the frequency of sample occurrences will progressively converge to the objective frequency ratio inherent in the ontological statistical truth set after numerous independent repeated physical samplings. This convergence behavior does not depend on object intrinsic randomness, information gap , or the existence of an observer. This paper designs a transparent visualized shaking experiment, a foreign object perturbation experiment, and a sample size-relative fluctuation experiment. Under the conditions of (complete information) and completely determined single-run physical results, the large-sample frequency convergence phenomenon is reproduced, and it is empirically demonstrated that the convergence target is entirely determined by the physical interaction structure. This paper strictly distinguishes the mathematical LLN from physical statistical convergence, corrects the traditional logical leap of attributing convergence to intrinsic randomness, and lays a solid foundation for a unified physical statistical theory across macro and micro scales.

•Nov 4, 2026•0 citations

The Principle of Information Set Superposition: An Empirical Study on the Nature of Superposition States and Observational Collapse

Jiale Wu

In traditional quantum mechanical interpretations, "superposition states" are often understood as physical objects simultaneously existing in multiple mutually exclusive states, and "observational collapse" is understood as an abrupt change of the physical ontology during observation. This paper points out that this understanding confuses the physical ontological layer with the information derivative layer, incorrectly projecting the coexistence of multiple candidates at the information level as an objective superposition of the physical ontology. Building upon the "Ontology-Information Dichotomy Framework" and the "Principle of Ontological Statistical Convergence," this paper proposes the Principle of Information Set Superposition: The physical ontology always maintains a unique truth value, and there is no state branching at the ontological level. The so-called superposition of multiple possibilities is the coexistence of multiple candidate results within the observer's information set under the condition of an information gap ; as effective information is input ( decreases), eliminates contradictory candidates and continuously contracts; when information is complete , collapses to a single truth value. This paper designs four groups of lottery jar controlled experiments (different prior information groups, zero-information blind state group, incremental information group, false information group). Keeping the physical ontology constant, only the information input to the observer is altered to empirically demonstrate that the possibility set is constructed by information pruning. This paper reinterprets the information essence of Schrödinger's cat as a typical case, and strictly states: if one assumes ontological superposition in microscopic quantum systems, independent experimental evidence is required; however, regarding phenomena alone, the information set mechanism can perfectly reproduce all observations. The main text strictly strips away subjective consciousness and free will, relegating them only as an independent philosophical extension in the Appendix.

•Nov 4, 2026•0 citations

Truth Is Nothing: Conditional Universality and the Ontology of Belief-Structures

Jihoon Yang

This paper argues that truth has no ontological substance — no metaphysical core, no intrinsic property, no transcendent ground. What exists instead are belief-structures that stabilize under specific boundary conditions. Truth is a survival-effect of such structures. The paper develops this thesis across two interlocking registers: a philosophical argument and a formal mathematical grounding. Philosophically, the paper introduces the concept of conditional universality: universality is not rule-invariance across all contexts but structural recurrence under contextual transformation. A belief-structure is conditionally universal when it maintains a strictly positive viability distance from collapse across a family of variable contexts. This dissolves the classical dichotomy between absolutism (which requires rule-invariance) and relativism (which denies any universal condition). Under this framework, transparency is not a moral preference but an ontological necessity — opacity eliminates the self-correction required for sustained viability. Formally, the paper establishes two theorems. The Born-Consistency Theorem proves that any probability measure on the projectors of a Hilbert space satisfying Non-Contextuality (NC), Countable Additivity, and Tensor-Product Multiplicativity uniquely takes the form μ(P) = Tr(ρP) for a density operator ρ. This covers all dimensions including the qubit case (dim = 2) left open by Gleason's theorem, resolved here via composite embedding and partial trace. The Capture Theorem establishes the converse: NC violation entails the impossibility of a global density operator, forcing fragmentation into a family of frame-local measures disintegrated over a disjoint union of non-commutative contexts. These two results provide the formal foundation for the paper's central claim: global state representability is equivalent to measure invariance across contexts. Truth, formally construed, is this invariance condition — not a relation to an external world, not coherence within a framework, but measure-theoretic consistency across the full event algebra. The paper absorbs Foucauldian genealogy into this structural framework while specifying the conditions genealogy leaves implicit: the ontological difference between genuine structural viability and domination through suppressed differentiation. Keywords truth ontology · belief-structures · conditional universality · viability dynamics · Born rule · Gleason's theorem · non-contextuality · quantum logic · Foucault · measure theory · density operators · Yang Jihoon Dynamics Series Context This paper is the first in the Yang Jihoon Dynamics series, which develops a unified formal framework across philosophy, mathematics, and AI ethics through the concept of boundary-survival dynamics. Paper 1 (this paper): Static foundations — truth as measure-theoretic consistency Paper 2: Collapse taxonomy — fixation collapse, dissolution collapse, and capture as formal endpoints Paper 3: Yang Jihoon Dynamics as viability dynamics — the core mathematical paper Paper 4: Asymmetric correction as structural error correction Paper 5: Algorithmic capture as environment-induced decoherence of meaning License Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)

•Mar 2, 2026•0 citations

La objetividad del azar en un mundo determinista

Sergio F. Martínez

This paper deals with the notion of objective randomness in classical deterministic theories. After the introduction, section 2 establishes an important distinction between a strictly metaphysical thesis of determinism (as characterized in the Montague-Earman definition, for example), and the doctrine of determinism, which can be roughly characterized as a methodological set of principles. The doctrine of determinism is associated with the idea that probability assignments can only reflect our ignorance of facts, and it also grounds the (ontological) thesis of separability: A system or process can be characterized completely in terms of the properties that a system has when in a given state, independently of the properties of other systems, The key notions of "completeness" and "independence" are only briefly discussed, as they are examined more in depth elsewhere. Section three examines attempts to characterize a notion of objective randomness in ergodic theory. The characterization can be seen to be equivalent to the formulation of a notion of a "physically impossible process". One way of expressing this idea is grounded on the thesis of the "coarse graining" of our measuring instruments. This leads to the problem of distinguishing "objective" from "apparent" randomness. The problem seems to be intrinsic to any attempt of characterizing the required notion of physical impossibility (and thus of objective randomness) in terms of an ideal observer. The alternative of trying to characterize physical impossibility in terms of a theory of algorithms suffers from the difficulty that it is not clear what would be the required notion of (non-epistemic) computability. The "coarse graining" approach, as well as the alternative in terms of a theory of algorithms seem to share the usual confusion between a strictly metaphysical thesis of determinism and the (methodological) doctrine of determinism. In section four an alternative approach is suggested. It is noticed that a denial of the thesis of separability is compatible with a strict deterministic theory, and thus that at least some classical systems (the "statistical" ones) can be described in terms of non-separable states. We do not have to think that the impossibility of preparing a classical state is too only possible explanation for physical (objective) randomness in deterministic theories. This proposal is an elaboration of an idea of Blatt (1959), although Blatt was still trying to understand objective randomness within an ideal-observer framework.[S.M.]

Crítica (México D F En línea)•Dec 13, 1990•3 citations

The Methodological Defect of Subjective Appearance Precedence: Universal Problems in Mainstream Quantum, Logical and Cognitive Theories and the Revised Scheme of Ontology-Cognitive Entropy Paradigm

Xiangsheng Yu

Mainstream quantum mechanical interpretations, classical logical paradox resolution frameworks, cognitive theories of human deceptive behavior, and probabilistic artificial intelligence models universally exhibit a fundamental methodological flaw. These conventional approaches prioritize subjective observational phenomena and cognitively constructed appearances as theoretical presuppositions, thereby conflating the intrinsic determinacy of objective ontology with illusory uncertainty arising from incomplete information and limited cognitive capacity. This study systematically examines such paradigm-level biases by conducting a cross-disciplinary methodological comparison between prevalent theoretical frameworks and the dual paradigm integrating the binary excluded middle law and ontology–cognitive entropy. The proposed paradigm establishes the binary determinacy of objective ontology—independent of observation, reasoning, and subjective perception—as the foundational axiom. All apparent uncertainties, including quantum superposition, instantaneous quantum transitions, formal logical contradictions, cognitive ambiguity, and probabilistic model outputs, are attributed to transient cognitive entropy states induced by insufficient information convergence. The dynamic cognitive entropy metric complements the missing continuous evolutionary mechanism in traditional quantum theories and fundamentally resolves the inherent defects of appearance-oriented methodological frameworks. Cross-domain comparisons demonstrate that the ontology–cognitive entropy dual paradigm features ontology–cognition dichotomy, dynamic entropy quantification, and full logical self-consistency without subjective presuppositions. This framework provides a rigorous, unified, and objective theoretical foundation for addressing pervasive uncertainty problems in fundamental physics, formal logic, cognitive science, and artificial intelligence, supporting both basic theoretical innovation and engineering risk-control applications.

•Jul 19, 2026•0 citations

The Power of Observation: Anomalies in Macroscopic Randomness and the Simulation Hypothesis

YALÇIN ATABEY

This study presents a multi-layered research framework that integrates experimental analyses of macroscopic randomness with cognitive, philosophical, and interdisciplinary theoretical perspectives. The core of the research is based on controlled experiments designed to examine the effect of observation and participation on statistical outcomes in classical random systems. Within this framework, coin tosses, dice rolls, roulette scenarios, and card-based experiments were tested under observed and unobserved conditions. Up to 10,000 trials per experiment were conducted, and the resulting datasets were analyzed using various statistical methods. The findings indicate that: Statistically significant deviations emerge under observed conditions (p < 0.001), Results under unobserved conditions remain closer to theoretical distributions, Active participation tends to amplify the observed deviation effect. The study is structured in a systematic academic format, including introduction, literature review, methodology, findings, statistical analyses, methodological limitations, reliability assessment, and raw data appendices. Beyond the experimental framework, the study also addresses broader theoretical domains: Simulation Hypothesis and observation-dependent models of reality, Interpretation of dreams as cognitive “internal simulations”, Temporal recall and decision threshold models, Interaction between consciousness and system-level processes, Concepts of death, continuity of perception, and memory reconstruction, Philosophical and theological approaches to system boundaries and exit concepts, A conceptual model referred to as the “Invisible Connection Theory,” aiming to explain patterns between events, decisions, and past interactions. The primary objective is to establish an interdisciplinary connection between experimentally observed statistical deviations and frameworks from cognitive science, neuroscience, philosophy, and information-based models of reality. The results should be interpreted with caution. Alternative explanations such as experimental bias, environmental factors, and statistical fluctuations must also be considered. While not claiming to provide definitive proof, the study aims to serve as a strong foundation for future interdisciplinary research.

•Mar 23, 2026•0 citations
If all hidden variables behind so‑called intrinsic randomness were known to me, would it still be intrinsic randomness? This question exposes a fatal logical impasse within traditional physics: the moment complete information () is achieved, random phenomena vanish. Therefore, all observable randomness in reality is structurally tied to an information gap. This paper proposes the "Ontology‑Information Dichotomy Framework" and the "Theorem of Information Gap‑Randomness Necessity". Through time‑sequence‑separated macroscopic dice‑cup experiments (decoupling physical perturbation from information occlusion) and control tests with AI vision algorithms, we empirically demonstrate that apparent randomness is an inevitable product of finite physical information systems under , independent of biological consciousness. We further prove that unobservable hidden variables and pure observational information deficiency are observationally equivalent. Any claim of "intrinsic randomness" lacking decisive evidence under complete‑input conditions () is either a self‑contradictory notion or a metaphysical presupposition. Ranging from engineering encapsulation (e.g., lotteries, PRNGs) to microscopic quantum scenarios, apparent randomness strictly derived from the information gap constitutes the only empirically supported and logically self‑consistent mechanism.
Traditional physics often directly attributes the phenomenon of frequency convergence in large samples to the existence of intrinsic randomness at the fundamental physical level. However, the mathematical Law of Large Numbers (LLN) is merely a theorem within a formal axiomatic system and makes no ontological assertions regarding its physical origin. Equating frequency convergence with intrinsic randomness is an unverified logical extrapolation. Building upon the "Ontology-Information Dichotomy Framework," this paper proposes the Principle of Ontological Statistical Convergence: In a physical system with an underlying fully deterministic causal structure, the frequency of sample occurrences will progressively converge to the objective frequency ratio inherent in the ontological statistical truth set after numerous independent repeated physical samplings. This convergence behavior does not depend on object intrinsic randomness, information gap , or the existence of an observer. This paper designs a transparent visualized shaking experiment, a foreign object perturbation experiment, and a sample size-relative fluctuation experiment. Under the conditions of (complete information) and completely determined single-run physical results, the large-sample frequency convergence phenomenon is reproduced, and it is empirically demonstrated that the convergence target is entirely determined by the physical interaction structure. This paper strictly distinguishes the mathematical LLN from physical statistical convergence, corrects the traditional logical leap of attributing convergence to intrinsic randomness, and lays a solid foundation for a unified physical statistical theory across macro and micro scales.
In traditional quantum mechanical interpretations, "superposition states" are often understood as physical objects simultaneously existing in multiple mutually exclusive states, and "observational collapse" is understood as an abrupt change of the physical ontology during observation. This paper points out that this understanding confuses the physical ontological layer with the information derivative layer, incorrectly projecting the coexistence of multiple candidates at the information level as an objective superposition of the physical ontology. Building upon the "Ontology-Information Dichotomy Framework" and the "Principle of Ontological Statistical Convergence," this paper proposes the Principle of Information Set Superposition: The physical ontology always maintains a unique truth value, and there is no state branching at the ontological level. The so-called superposition of multiple possibilities is the coexistence of multiple candidate results within the observer's information set under the condition of an information gap ; as effective information is input ( decreases), eliminates contradictory candidates and continuously contracts; when information is complete , collapses to a single truth value. This paper designs four groups of lottery jar controlled experiments (different prior information groups, zero-information blind state group, incremental information group, false information group). Keeping the physical ontology constant, only the information input to the observer is altered to empirically demonstrate that the possibility set is constructed by information pruning. This paper reinterprets the information essence of Schrödinger's cat as a typical case, and strictly states: if one assumes ontological superposition in microscopic quantum systems, independent experimental evidence is required; however, regarding phenomena alone, the information set mechanism can perfectly reproduce all observations. The main text strictly strips away subjective consciousness and free will, relegating them only as an independent philosophical extension in the Appendix.
This paper argues that truth has no ontological substance — no metaphysical core, no intrinsic property, no transcendent ground. What exists instead are belief-structures that stabilize under specific boundary conditions. Truth is a survival-effect of such structures. The paper develops this thesis across two interlocking registers: a philosophical argument and a formal mathematical grounding. Philosophically, the paper introduces the concept of conditional universality: universality is not rule-invariance across all contexts but structural recurrence under contextual transformation. A belief-structure is conditionally universal when it maintains a strictly positive viability distance from collapse across a family of variable contexts. This dissolves the classical dichotomy between absolutism (which requires rule-invariance) and relativism (which denies any universal condition). Under this framework, transparency is not a moral preference but an ontological necessity — opacity eliminates the self-correction required for sustained viability. Formally, the paper establishes two theorems. The Born-Consistency Theorem proves that any probability measure on the projectors of a Hilbert space satisfying Non-Contextuality (NC), Countable Additivity, and Tensor-Product Multiplicativity uniquely takes the form μ(P) = Tr(ρP) for a density operator ρ. This covers all dimensions including the qubit case (dim = 2) left open by Gleason's theorem, resolved here via composite embedding and partial trace. The Capture Theorem establishes the converse: NC violation entails the impossibility of a global density operator, forcing fragmentation into a family of frame-local measures disintegrated over a disjoint union of non-commutative contexts. These two results provide the formal foundation for the paper's central claim: global state representability is equivalent to measure invariance across contexts. Truth, formally construed, is this invariance condition — not a relation to an external world, not coherence within a framework, but measure-theoretic consistency across the full event algebra. The paper absorbs Foucauldian genealogy into this structural framework while specifying the conditions genealogy leaves implicit: the ontological difference between genuine structural viability and domination through suppressed differentiation. Keywords truth ontology · belief-structures · conditional universality · viability dynamics · Born rule · Gleason's theorem · non-contextuality · quantum logic · Foucault · measure theory · density operators · Yang Jihoon Dynamics Series Context This paper is the first in the Yang Jihoon Dynamics series, which develops a unified formal framework across philosophy, mathematics, and AI ethics through the concept of boundary-survival dynamics. Paper 1 (this paper): Static foundations — truth as measure-theoretic consistency Paper 2: Collapse taxonomy — fixation collapse, dissolution collapse, and capture as formal endpoints Paper 3: Yang Jihoon Dynamics as viability dynamics — the core mathematical paper Paper 4: Asymmetric correction as structural error correction Paper 5: Algorithmic capture as environment-induced decoherence of meaning License Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
This paper deals with the notion of objective randomness in classical deterministic theories. After the introduction, section 2 establishes an important distinction between a strictly metaphysical thesis of determinism (as characterized in the Montague-Earman definition, for example), and the doctrine of determinism, which can be roughly characterized as a methodological set of principles. The doctrine of determinism is associated with the idea that probability assignments can only reflect our ignorance of facts, and it also grounds the (ontological) thesis of separability: A system or process can be characterized completely in terms of the properties that a system has when in a given state, independently of the properties of other systems, The key notions of "completeness" and "independence" are only briefly discussed, as they are examined more in depth elsewhere. Section three examines attempts to characterize a notion of objective randomness in ergodic theory. The characterization can be seen to be equivalent to the formulation of a notion of a "physically impossible process". One way of expressing this idea is grounded on the thesis of the "coarse graining" of our measuring instruments. This leads to the problem of distinguishing "objective" from "apparent" randomness. The problem seems to be intrinsic to any attempt of characterizing the required notion of physical impossibility (and thus of objective randomness) in terms of an ideal observer. The alternative of trying to characterize physical impossibility in terms of a theory of algorithms suffers from the difficulty that it is not clear what would be the required notion of (non-epistemic) computability. The "coarse graining" approach, as well as the alternative in terms of a theory of algorithms seem to share the usual confusion between a strictly metaphysical thesis of determinism and the (methodological) doctrine of determinism. In section four an alternative approach is suggested. It is noticed that a denial of the thesis of separability is compatible with a strict deterministic theory, and thus that at least some classical systems (the "statistical" ones) can be described in terms of non-separable states. We do not have to think that the impossibility of preparing a classical state is too only possible explanation for physical (objective) randomness in deterministic theories. This proposal is an elaboration of an idea of Blatt (1959), although Blatt was still trying to understand objective randomness within an ideal-observer framework.[S.M.]
Mainstream quantum mechanical interpretations, classical logical paradox resolution frameworks, cognitive theories of human deceptive behavior, and probabilistic artificial intelligence models universally exhibit a fundamental methodological flaw. These conventional approaches prioritize subjective observational phenomena and cognitively constructed appearances as theoretical presuppositions, thereby conflating the intrinsic determinacy of objective ontology with illusory uncertainty arising from incomplete information and limited cognitive capacity. This study systematically examines such paradigm-level biases by conducting a cross-disciplinary methodological comparison between prevalent theoretical frameworks and the dual paradigm integrating the binary excluded middle law and ontology–cognitive entropy. The proposed paradigm establishes the binary determinacy of objective ontology—independent of observation, reasoning, and subjective perception—as the foundational axiom. All apparent uncertainties, including quantum superposition, instantaneous quantum transitions, formal logical contradictions, cognitive ambiguity, and probabilistic model outputs, are attributed to transient cognitive entropy states induced by insufficient information convergence. The dynamic cognitive entropy metric complements the missing continuous evolutionary mechanism in traditional quantum theories and fundamentally resolves the inherent defects of appearance-oriented methodological frameworks. Cross-domain comparisons demonstrate that the ontology–cognitive entropy dual paradigm features ontology–cognition dichotomy, dynamic entropy quantification, and full logical self-consistency without subjective presuppositions. This framework provides a rigorous, unified, and objective theoretical foundation for addressing pervasive uncertainty problems in fundamental physics, formal logic, cognitive science, and artificial intelligence, supporting both basic theoretical innovation and engineering risk-control applications.
This study presents a multi-layered research framework that integrates experimental analyses of macroscopic randomness with cognitive, philosophical, and interdisciplinary theoretical perspectives. The core of the research is based on controlled experiments designed to examine the effect of observation and participation on statistical outcomes in classical random systems. Within this framework, coin tosses, dice rolls, roulette scenarios, and card-based experiments were tested under observed and unobserved conditions. Up to 10,000 trials per experiment were conducted, and the resulting datasets were analyzed using various statistical methods. The findings indicate that: Statistically significant deviations emerge under observed conditions (p < 0.001), Results under unobserved conditions remain closer to theoretical distributions, Active participation tends to amplify the observed deviation effect. The study is structured in a systematic academic format, including introduction, literature review, methodology, findings, statistical analyses, methodological limitations, reliability assessment, and raw data appendices. Beyond the experimental framework, the study also addresses broader theoretical domains: Simulation Hypothesis and observation-dependent models of reality, Interpretation of dreams as cognitive “internal simulations”, Temporal recall and decision threshold models, Interaction between consciousness and system-level processes, Concepts of death, continuity of perception, and memory reconstruction, Philosophical and theological approaches to system boundaries and exit concepts, A conceptual model referred to as the “Invisible Connection Theory,” aiming to explain patterns between events, decisions, and past interactions. The primary objective is to establish an interdisciplinary connection between experimentally observed statistical deviations and frameworks from cognitive science, neuroscience, philosophy, and information-based models of reality. The results should be interpreted with caution. Alternative explanations such as experimental bias, environmental factors, and statistical fluctuations must also be considered. While not claiming to provide definitive proof, the study aims to serve as a strong foundation for future interdisciplinary research.