Universality and weak-ergodicity breaking in quantum quenches

Understanding equilibration and universality after sudden quantum quenches remains a central challenge in isolated many-body systems. Persistent oscillations and anomalous scaling reported in lattice models appear to challenge the standard picture based on integrability and quantum-to-classical correspondence. Focusing on the quantum $O(n)$ model in the large- $n$ limit, we show that these apparent anomalies originate from lattice effects and an underlying integrable structure. In particular, we map the post-quench dynamics onto an integrable Neumann system and we derive a new action-angle description valid in the thermodynamic limit. This framework explains both the convergence of long-time averages to the generalized Gibbs ensemble and the emergence of persistent oscillations associated with an isolated mode at the upper edge of the phonon spectrum. We further show that the expected thermal universality class is recovered in the appropriate scaling regime, while the oscillations disappear in the quantum field theory limit.Understanding equilibration and universality after sudden quantum quenches remains a central challenge in isolated many-body systems. Persistent oscillations and anomalous scaling reported in lattice models appear to challenge the standard picture based on integrability and quantum-to-classical correspondence. Focusing on the quantum $O(n)$ model in the large-$n$ limit, we show that these apparent anomalies originate from lattice effects and an underlying integrable structure. In particular, we map the post-quench dynamics onto an integrable Neumann system and we derive a new action-angle description valid in the thermodynamic limit. This framework explains both the convergence of long-time averages to the generalized Gibbs ensemble and the emergence of persistent oscillations associated with an isolated mode at the upper edge of the phonon spectrum. We further show that the expected thermal universality class is recovered in the appropriate scaling regime, while the oscillations disappear in the quantum field theory limit.

cond-mat.stat-mechCross-listedarXiv:2511.08687Physical Review ResearchNov 13, 20251 citation

Quantum quenches across continuous and first-order quantum transitions in one-dimensional quantum Ising models

Andrea Pelissetto, Davide Rossini, Ettore Vicari

We investigate the quantum dynamics generated by quantum quenches (QQs) of the Hamiltonian parameters in many-body systems, focusing on protocols that cross first-order and continuous quantum transitions, both in finite-size systems and in the thermodynamic limit. As a paradigmatic example, we consider the quantum Ising chain in the presence of homogeneous transverse ( $g$ ) and longitudinal ( $h$ ) magnetic fields. This model exhibits a continuous quantum transition (CQT) at $g=g_c$ and $h=0$ , and first-order quantum transitions (FOQTs) driven by $h$ along the line $h=0$ ( $g<g_c$ ). In the integrable limit $h=0$ , the system can be mapped onto a quadratic fermionic theory; however, any nonvanishing longitudinal field breaks integrability and the spectrum of the resulting Hamiltonian is generally expected to enter a chaotic regime. We analyze QQs in which the longitudinal field is suddenly changed from a negative value $h_i < 0$ to a positive value $h_f>0$ . We focus on values of $h_f$ such that the spectrum of the post-QQ Hamiltonian $H(g,h_f)$ lies in the chaotic regime, where thermalization may emerge at asymptotically long times. We study the out-of-equilibrium dynamics for different values of $g$ , finding qualitatively distinct behaviors for $g > g_c$ (where the chain is in the disordered phase), for $g = g_c$ (QQ across the CQT), and for $g<g_c$ (QQ across the FOQT line).We investigate the quantum dynamics generated by quantum quenches (QQs) of the Hamiltonian parameters in many-body systems, focusing on protocols that cross first-order and continuous quantum transitions, both in finite-size systems and in the thermodynamic limit. As a paradigmatic example, we consider the quantum Ising chain in the presence of homogeneous transverse ($g$) and longitudinal ($h$) magnetic fields. This model exhibits a continuous quantum transition (CQT) at $g=g_c$ and $h=0$, and first-order quantum transitions (FOQTs) driven by $h$ along the line $h=0$ ($g<g_c$). In the integrable limit $h=0$, the system can be mapped onto a quadratic fermionic theory; however, any nonvanishing longitudinal field breaks integrability and the spectrum of the resulting Hamiltonian is generally expected to enter a chaotic regime. We analyze QQs in which the longitudinal field is suddenly changed from a negative value $h_i < 0$ to a positive value $h_f>0$. We focus on values of $h_f$ such that the spectrum of the post-QQ Hamiltonian $H(g,h_f)$ lies in the chaotic regime, where thermalization may emerge at asymptotically long times. We study the out-of-equilibrium dynamics for different values of $g$, finding qualitatively distinct behaviors for $g > g_c$ (where the chain is in the disordered phase), for $g = g_c$ (QQ across the CQT), and for $g<g_c$ (QQ across the FOQT line).

cond-mat.stat-mechCross-listedarXiv:2512.17333Physical review. B./Physical review. BDec 22, 20251 citation

Dynamical critical scaling and effective thermalization in quantum quenches: Role of the initial state

Shusa Deng, Gerardo Ortíz, Lorenza Viola

We explore the robustness of universal dynamical scaling behavior in a quantum system near criticality with respect to initialization in a large class of states with finite energy. By focusing on a homogeneous $\mathit{XY}$ quantum spin chain in a transverse field, we characterize the nonequilibrium response under adiabatic and sudden quench processes originating from a pure as well as a mixed excited initial state, and involving either a regular quantum critical or a multicritical point. We find that the critical exponents of the ground-state quantum phase transition can be encoded in the dynamical scaling exponents despite the finite energy of the initial state. In particular, we identify conditions on the initial distribution of quasiparticle excitation that ensure that Kibble-Zurek scaling persists. The emergence of effective thermal equilibrium behavior following a sudden quench toward criticality is also investigated, with focus on the long-time expectation value of the quasiparticle number operator. Despite the integrability of the $\mathit{XY}$ model, this observable is found to behave thermally in quenches to a regular quantum critical point, provided that the system is initially prepared at sufficiently high temperature. However, a similar thermalization behavior fails to occur in quenches toward a multicritical point. We argue that the observed lack of thermalization originates in this case in the asymmetry of the impulse region that is also responsible for anomalous multicritical dynamical scaling.We explore the robustness of universal dynamical scaling behavior in a quantum system near criticality with respect to initialization in a large class of states with finite energy. By focusing on a homogeneous $\mathit{XY}$ quantum spin chain in a transverse field, we characterize the nonequilibrium response under adiabatic and sudden quench processes originating from a pure as well as a mixed excited initial state, and involving either a regular quantum critical or a multicritical point. We find that the critical exponents of the ground-state quantum phase transition can be encoded in the dynamical scaling exponents despite the finite energy of the initial state. In particular, we identify conditions on the initial distribution of quasiparticle excitation that ensure that Kibble-Zurek scaling persists. The emergence of effective thermal equilibrium behavior following a sudden quench toward criticality is also investigated, with focus on the long-time expectation value of the quasiparticle number operator. Despite the integrability of the $\mathit{XY}$ model, this observable is found to behave thermally in quenches to a regular quantum critical point, provided that the system is initially prepared at sufficiently high temperature. However, a similar thermalization behavior fails to occur in quenches toward a multicritical point. We argue that the observed lack of thermalization originates in this case in the asymmetry of the impulse region that is also responsible for anomalous multicritical dynamical scaling.

arXiv:1011.0781Physical Review BMar 25, 201138 citations

Prethermalization and universal dynamics in near-integrable quantum systems

Tim Langen, Thomas Gasenzer, Jörg Schmiedmayer

Abstract We review the recent progress in the understanding of the relaxation of isolated near-integrable quantum many-body systems. Focusing on prethermalization and universal dynamics following a quench, we describe the experiments with ultracold atomic gases that illustrate these phenomena and summarize the essential theoretical concepts employed to interpret them. Our discussion highlights the key topics that link the different approaches to this interdisciplinary field, including the generalized Gibbs ensemble, non-thermal fixed points, critical slowing and universal scaling. Finally, we point to new experimental challenges demonstrating these fundamental features of many-body quantum systems out of equilibrium.Abstract We review the recent progress in the understanding of the relaxation of isolated near-integrable quantum many-body systems. Focusing on prethermalization and universal dynamics following a quench, we describe the experiments with ultracold atomic gases that illustrate these phenomena and summarize the essential theoretical concepts employed to interpret them. Our discussion highlights the key topics that link the different approaches to this interdisciplinary field, including the generalized Gibbs ensemble, non-thermal fixed points, critical slowing and universal scaling. Finally, we point to new experimental challenges demonstrating these fundamental features of many-body quantum systems out of equilibrium.

arXiv:1603.09385Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and ExperimentJun 1, 2016254 citations

Initial-state dependence of the quench dynamics in integrable quantum systems. II. Thermal states

Kai He, Marcos Rigol

We study properties of isolated integrable quantum systems after a sudden quench starting from thermal states. We show that, even if the system is initially in thermal equilibrium at finite temperature, the diagonal entropy after a quench remains a fraction of the entropy in the generalized ensembles introduced to describe integrable systems after relaxation. The latter is also, in general, different from the entropy in thermal equilibrium. Furthermore, we examine the difference in the distributions of conserved quantities in the thermal versus the generalized ensembles after a quench and show that they are also, in general, different from each other. This explains why these systems fail to thermalize. A finite-size scaling analysis is presented for each quantity, which allows us to make predictions for thermodynamically large lattice sizes.We study properties of isolated integrable quantum systems after a sudden quench starting from thermal states. We show that, even if the system is initially in thermal equilibrium at finite temperature, the diagonal entropy after a quench remains a fraction of the entropy in the generalized ensembles introduced to describe integrable systems after relaxation. The latter is also, in general, different from the entropy in thermal equilibrium. Furthermore, we examine the difference in the distributions of conserved quantities in the thermal versus the generalized ensembles after a quench and show that they are also, in general, different from each other. This explains why these systems fail to thermalize. A finite-size scaling analysis is presented for each quantity, which allows us to make predictions for thermodynamically large lattice sizes.

arXiv:1204.4739Physical Review AJun 11, 201253 citations

Quantum quench in long-range field theories

M. A. Rajabpour, Spyros Sotiriadis

We study the equilibration properties of observables in long-range field theories after the mass quench in $d=1$ , 2, and 3 dimensions. We classify the regimes where we expect equilibration or its absence in different dimensions. In addition, we study the effect of the initial state in the equilibration properties of our system. In the case of free field theories, we show that whenever we have equilibration, the long-time limit of correlations can be described by the generalized Gibbs ensemble. We prove that all integrals of motion in our system are nonlocal.We study the equilibration properties of observables in long-range field theories after the mass quench in $d=1$, 2, and 3 dimensions. We classify the regimes where we expect equilibration or its absence in different dimensions. In addition, we study the effect of the initial state in the equilibration properties of our system. In the case of free field theories, we show that whenever we have equilibration, the long-time limit of correlations can be described by the generalized Gibbs ensemble. We prove that all integrals of motion in our system are nonlocal.

arXiv:1409.6558Physical Review BJan 21, 201544 citations

O(n)

model in the large-

n

limit, we show that these apparent anomalies originate from lattice effects and an underlying integrable structure. In particular, we map the post-quench dynamics onto an integrable Neumann system and we derive a new action-angle description valid in the thermodynamic limit. This framework explains both the convergence of long-time averages to the generalized Gibbs ensemble and the emergence of persistent oscillations associated with an isolated mode at the upper edge of the phonon spectrum. We further show that the expected thermal universality class is recovered in the appropriate scaling regime, while the oscillations disappear in the quantum field theory limit.

g

) and longitudinal (

h

) magnetic fields. This model exhibits a continuous quantum transition (CQT) at

g=g_c

and

h=0

, and first-order quantum transitions (FOQTs) driven by

h

along the line

h=0

(

g<g_c

). In the integrable limit

h=0

, the system can be mapped onto a quadratic fermionic theory; however, any nonvanishing longitudinal field breaks integrability and the spectrum of the resulting Hamiltonian is generally expected to enter a chaotic regime. We analyze QQs in which the longitudinal field is suddenly changed from a negative value

h_i < 0

to a positive value

h_f>0

. We focus on values of

h_f

such that the spectrum of the post-QQ Hamiltonian

H(g,h_f)

lies in the chaotic regime, where thermalization may emerge at asymptotically long times. We study the out-of-equilibrium dynamics for different values of

g

, finding qualitatively distinct behaviors for

g > g_c

(where the chain is in the disordered phase), for

g = g_c

(QQ across the CQT), and for

g<g_c

(QQ across the FOQT line).

\mathit{XY}

quantum spin chain in a transverse field, we characterize the nonequilibrium response under adiabatic and sudden quench processes originating from a pure as well as a mixed excited initial state, and involving either a regular quantum critical or a multicritical point. We find that the critical exponents of the ground-state quantum phase transition can be encoded in the dynamical scaling exponents despite the finite energy of the initial state. In particular, we identify conditions on the initial distribution of quasiparticle excitation that ensure that Kibble-Zurek scaling persists. The emergence of effective thermal equilibrium behavior following a sudden quench toward criticality is also investigated, with focus on the long-time expectation value of the quasiparticle number operator. Despite the integrability of the

\mathit{XY}

model, this observable is found to behave thermally in quenches to a regular quantum critical point, provided that the system is initially prepared at sufficiently high temperature. However, a similar thermalization behavior fails to occur in quenches toward a multicritical point. We argue that the observed lack of thermalization originates in this case in the asymmetry of the impulse region that is also responsible for anomalous multicritical dynamical scaling.

We study the equilibration properties of observables in long-range field theories after the mass quench in

d=1

, 2, and 3 dimensions. We classify the regimes where we expect equilibration or its absence in different dimensions. In addition, we study the effect of the initial state in the equilibration properties of our system. In the case of free field theories, we show that whenever we have equilibration, the long-time limit of correlations can be described by the generalized Gibbs ensemble. We prove that all integrals of motion in our system are nonlocal.