Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

From Pilot Waves to Topological Sampling Reconstructing de Broglie's Double Solution as a Two-Layer Ontology

GenMin Li

Published Oct 12, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

De Broglie's late Double Solution Theory is the most profound — and most marginalized — ontological program in the realist tradition of quantum mechanics. Its central claim is that beneath the standard wave function Ψ there exists a real, nonlinear continuous wave field (*u*-wave), of which the particle is a localized singularity; Ψ is merely a statistical description of the singularity's position. De Broglie, however, never answered three fundamental questions: What is the physical nature of the *u*-wave? Where does the nonlinearity come from? Why is probability given by the squared modulus? We argue that this failure has been fundamentally misread. The Double Solution Theory is not a hidden-variable theory; it is a two-layer ontology — an ontological layer (*u*-wave) and an observational layer (Ψ-wave). What is misread as "hidden variables" is in fact a missing mathematical bridge between two layers. This is the ontological gap of quantum mechanics: every mainstream interpretation — Copenhagen, hidden variables, many-worlds, relational, decoherence-based, stochastic — works within a single-layer ontology, and none of them explicitly constructs the layered structure de Broglie anticipated. This paper reconstructs the Double Solution within Discrete Frame Ontology (DFO), with the homotopy-theoretic machinery of Brokenness Homotopy Theory (BHT) as its mathematical foundation. We give precise counterparts for the four elements of de Broglie's theory: *u*-wave → the sampling projection (continuous approximation); singularity → the homotopy kernel (topological residue); pilot wave → the cross-level transfer (boundary coupling); Ψ-wave → the sampled statistics on the -page. The two-layer structure corresponds to the three-layer functor of the configuration library. We argue that the ontological gap of quantum mechanics is precisely this two-layer structure and its mathematical bridge, and that DFO—on the BHT foundation—supplies the missing bridge.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23313189

Related papers

De Broglie-Bohmova interpretacija kvantne mehanike

Doris Todorović

The de Broglie–Bohm interpretation (Bohmian mechanics, hidden-variables theory, causal interpretation or pilot-wave theory) is one of the interpretations of quantum mechanics which opposes to the claim of standard interpretation on the completeness of description of the state of quantummechanical system, that description in Bohmian mechanics is completed by defining positions of the particles of the system i.e. hidden variables and their dynamics. These facts are the basis of motivation for the introduction of a new theory that can describe dubious axiomatic requirements of standard interpretation. The presented theory is deterministic and explicitly nonlocal. Originators of Bohmian mechanics were L. de Broglie (1927.) and D. Bohm (1952.) who presented mathematically more general and conceptual elaborate formulation. Along with the historical overview, a note is given about the main properties of the theory, such as the issue of nonlocality and hidden variables. The aim of this paper is to present and explain the main ideas and properties of the theory as well as to give a systematic overview of present and historical mathematical construction of the theory and most of all to discuss implications of de Broglie–Bohm theory on the ontology of quantum-mechanical picture, showcasing examples of the equivalency of the description of a free particle as a propagation of the plane wave in space or as the ensemble of the trajectories and of the spreading of the Gaussian wave packet. The main example of the obvious conceptual clashing of the interpretations is presented: the double-slit experiment, with a detailed examination of the Bohmian mechanics’ predictions using presented formalism on the two double-slit experiment. The graphs of trajectories for given examples are obtained.

•Sep 11, 2019•0 citations

De Broglie's Double Solution Realized: The Self-Consistent Soliton as Physical uuu-Wave

Fabien Dechery

In 1927, Louis de Broglie presented his Double Solution program at the Solvay Conference: a physical theory wherein every quantum corpuscle consists of a localized, non-linear singular wave ($u$) locked in phase with an extended, linear wave ($\psi$) that guides its motion. Lacking a concrete non-linear equation, stable localized solutions, and a framework for multi-particle states in physical space, de Broglie retreated to the simplified pilot-wave kinematics, later revived by Bohm (1952) at the cost of an ontological dualism (point particle plus configuration-space field) and an ad hoc quantum potential. Here, we demonstrate that de Broglie's original vision is realized within the Foundation Programme. The physical $u$-wave is identified with the structurally stable, self-consistent soliton of the non-linear generative substrate $\mathcal{G}$ satisfying the Structural Stability Requirement (SSR). The guiding $\psi$-wave is not an independent physical field in configuration space, but the screened descriptive projection $\psi = \Pi(\phi)$ in $\mathcal{D}$ under probe constraints. We derive de Broglie's Theorem of Phase Harmony directly from the Lorentz covariance of the stationary solitonic internal clock (Zitterbewegung), corroborate this derivation with experimental channeling data (Catillon et al., 2008), and construct a rigorous four-level hierarchy of approximations connecting the non-linear substrate field to standard quantum mechanics. We compute the non-linear correction to Bohm's quantum potential, proving it scales as $(\lambda_C/L)^2$ and vanishes asymptotically at laboratory scales. Finally, measurement is shown to be a deterministic attractor bifurcation in $\mathcal{G}$, resolving the measurement problem without collapse postulates. The Born probability rule is derived — not postulated — through a four-step chain: Gleason's theorem, Koopman-equivariant measures, DGZ typicality, and Valentini relaxation, with quantitative support from the positive Lyapunov exponent of the Soler model. We evaluate de Broglie's programme against eleven explicit criteria and show that all are either formally established or structurally argued with clear mathematical pathways. In this architecture, de Broglie-Bohm pilot-wave theory is eliminated as a fundamental ontology and re-established as a controlled intermediate approximation.

•Nov 9, 2026•0 citations

Pilot Wave

It is easy to pass from the double solution exposed in the previous chapter to the pilot wave to be discussed in the present one. Essentially, what we have to do is to forget anything concerning the second solution, that is to say concerning the u -waves and their singularities, and to preserve the first solution Ψ and the guidance formula driving the underlying hidden objective particles. Then, these particles are piloted by the wave Ψ, hence the name of the theory. We are still left with two versions, the pilot wave theory of Louis de Broglie, and the pilot wave theory of Bohm. They essentially differ by the epistemological status of Ψ, subjective for Louis de Broglie and objective for Bohm, and by the fact that Bohm developed the theory much further, up to its logical conclusion, as he wrote. In particular, objections which have been addressed to the version by Louis de Broglie have been successfully enough answered by Bohm. Therefore, to avoid any inconvenient redundancy on this matter, we shall now on discuss Bohm’s version, and the terminology “pilot wave”, excepted possibly when specified otherwise, will refer to this version.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Mar 1, 2025•0 citations

Pilot-Wave Theories as Hidden Markov Models

Jacob A. Barandes

The original version of the de Broglie-Bohm pilot-wave theory, also called Bohmian mechanics, attempted to treat the wave function or pilot wave as a part of the physical ontology of nature. More recent versions of the de Broglie-Bohm theory appearing in the last few decades have tried to regard the pilot wave instead as an aspect of the theory's nomology, or dynamical laws. This paper argues that neither of these views is correct, and that the de Broglie-Bohm pilot wave is best understood as a collection of latent variables in the sense of a hidden Markov model, a construct that was not available when de Broglie and Bohm originally formulated what became their pilot-wave theory. This paper also discusses several other challenges for the ontological view of the pilot wave. One such challenge is due to Foldy-Wouthuysen gauge transformations, which connect up with the Deotto-Ghirardi ambiguity in the de Broglie-Bohm theory. Another challenge arises from the freedom to carry out canonical transformations in the wave function's own notion of phase space, as defined by Strocchi and Heslot.

quant-pharXiv:2602.10569•Feb 12, 2026•1 citation

The Closed Loop of Precision and Its Blind Spots: Geometric Measures and Topological Residues in Quantum Mechanics

GenMin Li

Quantum mechanics has achieved a prediction precision of one part in a trillion in local experiments (e.g., the electron anomalous magnetic moment ), but this extremely brilliant precision does not point to ontological transparency; instead, it is accompanied by long-standing measurement difficulties and a deadlock at the interface with quantum gravity. This paper points out that the precision of quantum mechanics originates from the fact that the "observation instrument" and the "theoretical model" share the same geometric slice, thereby forming a geometric closed loop. Within the local validity domain inside this closed loop, the sheaf property ("sheafiness") holds to a high degree; and its difficulties correspond precisely to the necessary failure of the sheaf property at the boundary of the closed loop (). This paper argues that the measurement problem and the conflict with quantum gravity are not "the theory has not yet been calculated correctly," but topological manifestations of the inability of the geometric slice to be glued at the boundary. By introducing the perspectives of sheaf theory and homotopy theory, we characterize this failure as topological aliasing caused by projection, and point out that the erased high-dimensional information is locked in the projection as homotopy kernel () residues. In order to completely avoid the historical predicament of "hidden variables" in single-layer ontology, this paper proposes a two-layer ontology, reconstructing the high-dimensional information as "topological residue." The path to breaking this predicament is not to patch the local geometry, but to establish a topological diagnostic framework targeting the boundary blind spots—DHT (Defect–Homotopy–Topos).

•Oct 27, 2026•0 citations

De Broglie–Bohm Pilot‐Wave Theory: Many Worlds in Denial?

Antony Valentini

Abstract This chapter replies to claims that the pilot-wave theory of de Broglie and Bohm is really a many-worlds theory with a superfluous configuration appended to one of the worlds. Assuming that pilot-wave theory does contain an ontological pilot wave (a complex-valued field in configuration space), the chapter shows that such claims arise from not interpreting pilot-wave theory on its own terms. Specifically, the theory has its own (‘subquantum’) theory of measurement, and in general describes a ‘non-equilibrium’ state that violates the Born rule. Furthermore, in realistic models of the classical limit, one does not obtain localised pieces of an ontological pilot wave following alternative macroscopic trajectories: from a de Broglie–Bohm viewpoint, alternative trajectories are merely mathematical and not ontological. Thus, from the perspective of pilot-wave theory itself, many worlds is an illusion. It is further argued that, even leaving pilot-wave theory aside, the theory of many worlds is rooted in the intrinsically unlikely assumption that quantum measurements should be modelled on classical measurements, and is therefore unlikely to be true.

arXiv:0811.0810•Oxford University Press eBooks•Jun 24, 2010•67 citations
De Broglie's late Double Solution Theory is the most profound — and most marginalized — ontological program in the realist tradition of quantum mechanics. Its central claim is that beneath the standard wave function Ψ there exists a real, nonlinear continuous wave field (u-wave), of which the particle is a localized singularity; Ψ is merely a statistical description of the singularity's position. De Broglie, however, never answered three fundamental questions: What is the physical nature of the u-wave? Where does the nonlinearity come from? Why is probability given by the squared modulus? We argue that this failure has been fundamentally misread. The Double Solution Theory is not a hidden-variable theory; it is a two-layer ontology — an ontological layer (u-wave) and an observational layer (Ψ-wave). What is misread as "hidden variables" is in fact a missing mathematical bridge between two layers. This is the ontological gap of quantum mechanics: every mainstream interpretation — Copenhagen, hidden variables, many-worlds, relational, decoherence-based, stochastic — works within a single-layer ontology, and none of them explicitly constructs the layered structure de Broglie anticipated. This paper reconstructs the Double Solution within Discrete Frame Ontology (DFO), with the homotopy-theoretic machinery of Brokenness Homotopy Theory (BHT) as its mathematical foundation. We give precise counterparts for the four elements of de Broglie's theory: u-wave → the sampling projection (continuous approximation); singularity → the homotopy kernel (topological residue); pilot wave → the cross-level transfer (boundary coupling); Ψ-wave → the sampled statistics on the -page. The two-layer structure corresponds to the three-layer functor of the configuration library. We argue that the ontological gap of quantum mechanics is precisely this two-layer structure and its mathematical bridge, and that DFO—on the BHT foundation—supplies the missing bridge.
The de Broglie–Bohm interpretation (Bohmian mechanics, hidden-variables theory, causal interpretation or pilot-wave theory) is one of the interpretations of quantum mechanics which opposes to the claim of standard interpretation on the completeness of description of the state of quantummechanical system, that description in Bohmian mechanics is completed by defining positions of the particles of the system i.e. hidden variables and their dynamics. These facts are the basis of motivation for the introduction of a new theory that can describe dubious axiomatic requirements of standard interpretation. The presented theory is deterministic and explicitly nonlocal. Originators of Bohmian mechanics were L. de Broglie (1927.) and D. Bohm (1952.) who presented mathematically more general and conceptual elaborate formulation. Along with the historical overview, a note is given about the main properties of the theory, such as the issue of nonlocality and hidden variables. The aim of this paper is to present and explain the main ideas and properties of the theory as well as to give a systematic overview of present and historical mathematical construction of the theory and most of all to discuss implications of de Broglie–Bohm theory on the ontology of quantum-mechanical picture, showcasing examples of the equivalency of the description of a free particle as a propagation of the plane wave in space or as the ensemble of the trajectories and of the spreading of the Gaussian wave packet. The main example of the obvious conceptual clashing of the interpretations is presented: the double-slit experiment, with a detailed examination of the Bohmian mechanics’ predictions using presented formalism on the two double-slit experiment. The graphs of trajectories for given examples are obtained.
In 1927, Louis de Broglie presented his Double Solution program at the Solvay Conference: a physical theory wherein every quantum corpuscle consists of a localized, non-linear singular wave (uuu) locked in phase with an extended, linear wave (ψ\psiψ) that guides its motion. Lacking a concrete non-linear equation, stable localized solutions, and a framework for multi-particle states in physical space, de Broglie retreated to the simplified pilot-wave kinematics, later revived by Bohm (1952) at the cost of an ontological dualism (point particle plus configuration-space field) and an ad hoc quantum potential. Here, we demonstrate that de Broglie's original vision is realized within the Foundation Programme. The physical uuu-wave is identified with the structurally stable, self-consistent soliton of the non-linear generative substrate G\mathcal{G}G satisfying the Structural Stability Requirement (SSR). The guiding ψ\psiψ-wave is not an independent physical field in configuration space, but the screened descriptive projection ψ=Π(ϕ)\psi = \Pi(\phi)ψ=Π(ϕ) in D\mathcal{D}D under probe constraints. We derive de Broglie's Theorem of Phase Harmony directly from the Lorentz covariance of the stationary solitonic internal clock (Zitterbewegung), corroborate this derivation with experimental channeling data (Catillon et al., 2008), and construct a rigorous four-level hierarchy of approximations connecting the non-linear substrate field to standard quantum mechanics. We compute the non-linear correction to Bohm's quantum potential, proving it scales as (λC/L)2(\lambda_C/L)^2(λC​/L)2 and vanishes asymptotically at laboratory scales. Finally, measurement is shown to be a deterministic attractor bifurcation in G\mathcal{G}G, resolving the measurement problem without collapse postulates. The Born probability rule is derived — not postulated — through a four-step chain: Gleason's theorem, Koopman-equivariant measures, DGZ typicality, and Valentini relaxation, with quantitative support from the positive Lyapunov exponent of the Soler model. We evaluate de Broglie's programme against eleven explicit criteria and show that all are either formally established or structurally argued with clear mathematical pathways. In this architecture, de Broglie-Bohm pilot-wave theory is eliminated as a fundamental ontology and re-established as a controlled intermediate approximation.
It is easy to pass from the double solution exposed in the previous chapter to the pilot wave to be discussed in the present one. Essentially, what we have to do is to forget anything concerning the second solution, that is to say concerning the u -waves and their singularities, and to preserve the first solution Ψ and the guidance formula driving the underlying hidden objective particles. Then, these particles are piloted by the wave Ψ, hence the name of the theory. We are still left with two versions, the pilot wave theory of Louis de Broglie, and the pilot wave theory of Bohm. They essentially differ by the epistemological status of Ψ, subjective for Louis de Broglie and objective for Bohm, and by the fact that Bohm developed the theory much further, up to its logical conclusion, as he wrote. In particular, objections which have been addressed to the version by Louis de Broglie have been successfully enough answered by Bohm. Therefore, to avoid any inconvenient redundancy on this matter, we shall now on discuss Bohm’s version, and the terminology “pilot wave”, excepted possibly when specified otherwise, will refer to this version.
The original version of the de Broglie-Bohm pilot-wave theory, also called Bohmian mechanics, attempted to treat the wave function or pilot wave as a part of the physical ontology of nature. More recent versions of the de Broglie-Bohm theory appearing in the last few decades have tried to regard the pilot wave instead as an aspect of the theory's nomology, or dynamical laws. This paper argues that neither of these views is correct, and that the de Broglie-Bohm pilot wave is best understood as a collection of latent variables in the sense of a hidden Markov model, a construct that was not available when de Broglie and Bohm originally formulated what became their pilot-wave theory. This paper also discusses several other challenges for the ontological view of the pilot wave. One such challenge is due to Foldy-Wouthuysen gauge transformations, which connect up with the Deotto-Ghirardi ambiguity in the de Broglie-Bohm theory. Another challenge arises from the freedom to carry out canonical transformations in the wave function's own notion of phase space, as defined by Strocchi and Heslot.
Quantum mechanics has achieved a prediction precision of one part in a trillion in local experiments (e.g., the electron anomalous magnetic moment ), but this extremely brilliant precision does not point to ontological transparency; instead, it is accompanied by long-standing measurement difficulties and a deadlock at the interface with quantum gravity. This paper points out that the precision of quantum mechanics originates from the fact that the "observation instrument" and the "theoretical model" share the same geometric slice, thereby forming a geometric closed loop. Within the local validity domain inside this closed loop, the sheaf property ("sheafiness") holds to a high degree; and its difficulties correspond precisely to the necessary failure of the sheaf property at the boundary of the closed loop (). This paper argues that the measurement problem and the conflict with quantum gravity are not "the theory has not yet been calculated correctly," but topological manifestations of the inability of the geometric slice to be glued at the boundary. By introducing the perspectives of sheaf theory and homotopy theory, we characterize this failure as topological aliasing caused by projection, and point out that the erased high-dimensional information is locked in the projection as homotopy kernel () residues. In order to completely avoid the historical predicament of "hidden variables" in single-layer ontology, this paper proposes a two-layer ontology, reconstructing the high-dimensional information as "topological residue." The path to breaking this predicament is not to patch the local geometry, but to establish a topological diagnostic framework targeting the boundary blind spots—DHT (Defect–Homotopy–Topos).
Abstract This chapter replies to claims that the pilot-wave theory of de Broglie and Bohm is really a many-worlds theory with a superfluous configuration appended to one of the worlds. Assuming that pilot-wave theory does contain an ontological pilot wave (a complex-valued field in configuration space), the chapter shows that such claims arise from not interpreting pilot-wave theory on its own terms. Specifically, the theory has its own (‘subquantum’) theory of measurement, and in general describes a ‘non-equilibrium’ state that violates the Born rule. Furthermore, in realistic models of the classical limit, one does not obtain localised pieces of an ontological pilot wave following alternative macroscopic trajectories: from a de Broglie–Bohm viewpoint, alternative trajectories are merely mathematical and not ontological. Thus, from the perspective of pilot-wave theory itself, many worlds is an illusion. It is further argued that, even leaving pilot-wave theory aside, the theory of many worlds is rooted in the intrinsically unlikely assumption that quantum measurements should be modelled on classical measurements, and is therefore unlikely to be true.