Origin of Complex and Spinor Structures in Quantum Mechanics from Real Second-Order Dynamics

Nicos Makris

vol. 81, 1926 paper, Schrödinger has developed a clear understanding about the wave equation that produces the correct quadratic dispersion relation for matter-waves and he first presents a real-valued wave equation that is fourth-order in space and second-order in time. In the view of the mathematical difficulties associated with the eigenvalue analysis of a fourth-order, differential equation in association with the structure of the Hamilton-Jacobi equation, Schrödinger splits the fourth-order real operator into the product of two, second-order, conjugate complex operators and retains only one of the two complex operators to construct his iconic second-order, complex-valued wave equation. In this paper, we show that Schrödinger's original fourth-order, real-valued wave equation is a stiffer equation that produces higher energy levels than his second-order, complex-valued wave equation that predicts with remarkable accuracy the energy levels observed in the atomic line spectra of the chemical elements. Accordingly, the fourth-order, real-valued wave equation is too stiff to predict the emitted energy levels from the electrons of the chemical elements; therefore, the paper concludes that quantum mechanics can only be described with the less stiff, second-order, complex-valued wave equation.

Tosch Ono

Chen Ning Yang

Helmut Rauch, Samuel A. Werner

Abstract The spinor calculus can be regarded as applying a deeper level of structure of space-time than that described by the standard quantum mechanics. It makes transparent some of the subtler properties of space-time phenomena. The essential reason is that the basic spin space is two-dimensional (but complex) rather than the four-dimensional (real) space-time structure. Spinor properties have profound links with the complex numbers that appear in quantum mechanics (Penrose and Rindler 1984).

Srinivasa Mugeraya

Spinors are used for the computation of probability in quantum mechanics. They are treated as elements of a complex vector space in contrast to a real vector space. Spinor theory is abstract mathematics with an ambiguous interpretation. The overall phase of spinors does not affect the computation of probability in quantum mechanics. If two spinors have an overall phase of imaginary number , then they can be treated like vectors in a real vector space. The square of the magnitude of the number, which is the sum of dot product and the term having basis vector of cross product of two such vectors, is equal to the probability computed using the corresponding spinors. Therefore, the geometry of such spinors can be easily depicted in a three-dimensional space like vectors in a real vector space. Spinors are not isotropic vectors in Hilbert space. The sum of dot product and cross product of two complex numbers is equivalent to the quotient of the division of one complex number by another. Similarly, the sum of dot product and cross product of two vectors is the quotient of the division of one vector by another. Using the rules of division of vectors, we can find the rules of multiplication of vectors. The rules of multiplication and division of basis vector match the rules of multiplication and division of imaginary number . Therefore, basis vector is nothing but imaginary number . Multiplication of dot and cross product of two vectors to the second vector will give us the components of the first vector that are parallel and orthogonal to the second vector. Vectors are also made up of complex numbers like spinors. The reason for finding dot product of complex numbers in the process of computing the probability is to ignore the overall phase in contrast to the phase difference. This is misconstrued as complex vector space in quantum mechanics. 3-D number which is nothing but a spinor with new notation is an extension of vector algebra. It can have a real number as a term in addition to the terms , and . In all other respects, it is a vector. 3-D numbers are part of the number system like real numbers and complex numbers. The real numbers are one dimensional numbers, the complex numbers are two-dimensional numbers and the 3-D numbers as well as vectors and spinors are three-dimensional numbers. As polarisation and spin are one and the same, we can straight away apply 3-D numbers to polarisation of light. 3-D numbers will greatly simplify the study of areas of science where three-dimensional space is involved.

Holger Friedrich Hofmann