Output Side Information Changes the Entanglement-Breaking Threshold
Oliver Tuma
Discarding an output subsystem is a local post-processing operation, so an entanglement-breaking channel remains entanglement breaking after output reduction. The converse need not hold: a reduced channel can be entanglement breaking even when a richer output still carries reference entanglement. This preprint gives an exactly solvable two-parameter benchmark that quantifies this asymmetry. On two qubits, let (\Pi_\pm=(I\pm Z\otimes I)/2), let (\mathcal L(X)=\sum_s\Pi_sX\Pi_s) be sector dephasing, let (\mathcal M(X)=\sum_s\operatorname{Tr}(\Pi_sX)\Pi_s/2) be measure-and-prepare within the two sectors, and let (\mathcal D_4(X)=\operatorname{Tr}(X)I_4/4). The channel family is [\Phi_{t,\eta}=(1-\eta)\big[(1-t)\mathcal L+t\mathcal M\big]+\eta\mathcal D_4,\qquad 0\le t,\eta\le1.] For the reduced task, a variable second-qubit input is embedded with an arbitrary fixed first-qubit state and the first output qubit is discarded. The induced qubit channel is depolarizing with parameter (q=(1-\eta)(1-t)), and is entanglement breaking exactly when (q\le1/3). For the full four-dimensional output, the partially transposed normalized Choi state has one potentially negative eigenvalue, [\lambda_- = \frac{-4(1-\eta)+6(1-\eta)t+\eta}{16},] with multiplicity two. The block structure makes PPT sufficient for separability in this family. Hence, for (\eta<1), [t_{\rm red}(\eta)=\max!\left{0,1-\frac{1}{3(1-\eta)}\right},\qquadt_{\rm full}(\eta)=\max!\left{0,\frac{4-5\eta}{6(1-\eta)}\right}.] The exact region in which the reduced channel is already entanglement breaking while the full channel is not is (t_{\rm red}(\eta)\le t<t_{\rm full}(\eta)). Its width is [w(\eta)=\begin{cases}\eta/[6(1-\eta)],&0\le\eta\le2/3,\(4-5\eta)/[6(1-\eta)],&2/3\le\eta<4/5,\0,&4/5\le\eta\le1,\end{cases}] and reaches the exact maximum (w_{\max}=1/3) at (\eta=2/3). The Choi negativities are [\mathcal N_{\rm red}=\frac{[3(1-\eta)(1-t)-1]+}{4},\qquad\mathcal N{\rm full}=\frac{[4-5\eta-6(1-\eta)t]_+}{8}.] Therefore the maximal full-output Choi negativity compatible with an already entanglement-breaking reduced output is (1/12), attained at ((\eta,t)=(2/3,0)). The result is a controlled benchmark for output-access dependence: the same physical channel family can cross the entanglement-breaking boundary at different noise values solely because an output subsystem is retained or discarded.
•Sep 29, 2026•0 citations