Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Preparation of Strongly Correlated Superconducting States on a Quantum Computer with Hints of Quantum Advantage

LeeAnn M. Sager-Smith, David A. Mazziotti

Published Feb 17, 2021• 1 citation
OpenAlex

Abstract

One of the most correlated quantum phenomena achievable is superconductivity. In superconductivity pairs of electrons condense, in a manner analogous to Bose-Einstein condensation, into the same quantum state with their subsequent entanglement permitting frictionless conductivity. Quantum computers have the potential to predict complex, entangled quantum states at non-exponential cost, unlike their classical counterparts, with possible applications to hard problems from physics to economics. Here, using pairs of qubits to represent the electron pairs, we create superconductivity on a transmon-qubit quantum computer. A series of maximally entangled superconducting states with different numbers of electron pairs is prepared, and then the occupation of the superconducting state is measured by tomography. Each occupation on the order of the number of electrons $O(N)$ confirms the formation of a maximally entangled superconducting state. Moreover, the large eigenvalue provides experimental validation of C. N. Yang's derivation of large occupation being associated with off-diagonal long-range order. The work provides a critically important step in predicting strongly entangled quantum physics as well as mathematically related non-local phenomena in the pure and social sciences on quantum computers.

Related papers

Superconductivity and Non-Classical Long-Range Order on a Quantum Computer

LeeAnn M. Sager-Smith, David A. Mazziotti

An important problem in quantum information is the practical demonstration of non-classical long-range order on quantum computers. One of the best known examples of a quantum system with non-classical long-range order is a superconductor. Here we achieve Cooper pairing of qubits on a quantum computer to represent superconducting or superfluid states. We rigorously confirm the quantum long-range order by measuring the large $O(N)$ eigenvalue of the two-electron reduced density matrix. The demonstration of maximal quantum long-range order is an important step towards more complex modeling of superconductivity and superfluidity as well as other phenomena with significant quantum long-range order on quantum computers.

•Feb 17, 2021•0 citations

Cooper-pair condensates with nonclassical long-range order on quantum devices

LeeAnn M. Sager-Smith, David A. Mazziotti

An important problem in quantum information is the practical demonstration of nonclassical long-range order on quantum computers. One of the best known examples of a quantum system with nonclassical long-range order is a superconductor. Here we achieve Cooper-like pairing of qubits on a quantum computer, which can be interpreted as superconducting or superfluid states via a Jordan-Wigner mapping. We rigorously confirm the quantum long-range order by measuring the large $O(N)$ eigenvalue of the two-electron reduced density matrix. The demonstration of maximal quantum long-range order is an important step toward more complex modeling of phenomena with significant quantum long-range order on quantum computers such as superconductivity and superfluidity.

arXiv:2102.08960•Physical Review Research•Jan 3, 2022•17 citations

Topological and non-equilibrium superconductivity in low-dimensional strongly correlated quantum systems

Sebastian Paeckel

Superconductivity in its various manifestations has been stimulating both experimental and theoretical progress in condensed-matter physics for more than a hundred years. The remarkable property of electrons to pair up and form quasi-particles gives rise to a plethora of phenomena featuring important practical applications not only in science, but, for instance, also in medicine and metrology. Recently, new directions in investigating this fascinating subject emerged, such as superconductivity out-of equilibrium and topological superconductors. Providing experimental evidence for enhanced superconducting correlations in optically pumped copper oxides at temperatures far above the equilibrium transition temperature, the first issue caused considerable excitement. On the other hand, topological superconductors are believed to provide realizations of highly fault-tolerant qubits by means of hosting non-Abelian quasi-particles, which can be the building blocks of scalable quantum computers. Experimentally verifying the emergence of these Majorana edge modes, exotic quasi-particles in heterostructures consisting of a conventional superconductor and semiconductors or topological insulators, is one of the most urgent questions to be answered right now. Both subjects cannot be accounted for with analytically solvable approximations only, and also provide very challenging numerical problems. We implemented a matrix-product state (MPS) based toolkit exploiting $U(1)$ symmetries, providing a flexible and efficient platform to study these complex systems. In order to efficiently simulate out-of equilibrium setups we studied, compared, and developed time-evolution algorithms for MPS enabling us to choose the most suitable method for a given task. We also developed a new framework to represent operators in an enlarged Hilbert space so that benefits from conserving $U(1)$ symmetries can also be exploited in systems that originally break such symmetries (projected purification). Using this method we could efficiently model mesoscopic phenomena such as a charging energy controlled by a gate electrode without further approximations. Equipped with this techniques we studied out-of equilibrium spectral functions to explore how to identify superconducting correlations more reliably on ultra-short timescales. We found conclusive evidence that in particular two-particle spectral functions yield excellent probes for the formation of a (quasi-)condensate out-of equilibrium. Furthermore, we also investigated the question whether in a particular model system there is the possibility of true long-range order out-of equilibrium by studying correlation matrices and the scaling of their eigenvalues. Here, we observe a change in the algebraic decay of the correlations, even though the extrapolated order parameter is still zero within the error bounds. Furthermore, we also investigated the effects of coupling a superconductor-semiconductor heterostructure, which is subject to an in-plane magnetic field and a charging energy controlled by a gate voltage, to normal leads. In the context of experimentally verifying the existence of Majorana edge modes, such systems are believed to be the most promising and recent studies seem to underline this expectation. However, in order to consistently analyze the experimental data, the effects of quantum fluctuations caused by hybridization of the heterostructure with the leads have to be understood. Here, only perturbative limits are available so far, i.e., the weak and strong tunneling limit, while the experimentally relevant regime is expected to be somewhere inbetween. We aimed to fill this gap using the projected purification method to calculate the ground state phase diagram over a wide parameter regime. Our results indicate that the experimental situation is much more involved than what is predicted from perturbative analysis.

•Jan 1, 2020•4 citations

High-temperature macroscopic entanglement

Vlatko Vedral

In this paper, we intend to show that macroscopic entanglement is possible at high temperatures. We have analysed multipartite entanglement produced by the η-pairing mechanism, which features strongly in the fermionic lattice models of high T c superconductivity. This problem is shown to be equivalent to calculating multipartite entanglement in totally symmetric states of qubits. It is demonstrated that we can conclusively calculate the relative entropy of entanglement within any subset of qubits in the overall symmetric state. Three main results are then presented. First, the condition for superconductivity, namely existence of the off-diagonal long-range order (ODLRO), is dependent not on two-site entanglement but just classical correlations as the sites become more and more distant. Secondly, the entanglement that does survive in the thermodynamical limit is the entanglement of the total lattice and, at half-filling, it scales with the log of the number of sites. It is this entanglement that will exist at temperatures below the superconducting critical temperature, which can currently be as high as 160 K. Finally, it is proved that a complete mixture of symmetric states does not contain any entanglement in the macroscopic limit. On the other hand, a mixture of symmetric states possesses the same two qubit entanglement features as the pure states involved, in the sense that the mixing does not destroy entanglement for a finite number of qubits, albeit it does decrease it. Furthermore, maximal mixing of symmetric states does not destroy ODLRO and classical correlations. We discuss generalizations to the subsystems of any dimensionality (i.e. higher than spin-half).

arXiv:quant-ph/0405102•New Journal of Physics•Aug 9, 2004•133 citations

Strongly correlated quantum walks with a 12-qubit superconducting processor

Zhiguang Yan, Yu-Ran Zhang, Ming Gong +18 more

Quantum walks are the quantum analogs of classical random walks, which allow for the simulation of large-scale quantum many-body systems and the realization of universal quantum computation without time-dependent control. We experimentally demonstrate quantum walks of one and two strongly correlated microwave photons in a one-dimensional array of 12 superconducting qubits with short-range interactions. First, in one-photon quantum walks, we observed the propagation of the density and correlation of the quasiparticle excitation of the superconducting qubit and quantum entanglement between qubit pairs. Second, when implementing two-photon quantum walks by exciting two superconducting qubits, we observed the fermionization of strongly interacting photons from the measured time-dependent long-range anticorrelations, representing the antibunching of photons with attractive interactions. The demonstration of quantum walks on a quantum processor, using superconducting qubits as artificial atoms and tomographic readout, paves the way to quantum simulation of many-body phenomena and universal quantum computation.

Science•May 2, 2019•262 citations

Entanglement in a 20-Qubit Superconducting Quantum Computer

Gary J. Mooney, Charles D. Hill, Lloyd C. L. Hollenberg

The ability to prepare sizeable multi-qubit entangled states with full qubit control is a critical milestone for physical platforms upon which quantum computers are built. We investigate the extent to which entanglement is found within a prepared graph state on the 20-qubit superconducting quantum computer IBM Q Poughkeepsie. We prepared a graph state along a path consisting of all twenty qubits within the device and performed full quantum state tomography on all groups of four connected qubits along this path. We determined that each pair of connected qubits was inseparable and hence the prepared state was entangled. Additionally, a genuine multipartite entanglement witness was measured on all qubit subpaths of the graph state and we found genuine multipartite entanglement on chains of up to three qubits. These results represent a demonstration of entanglement in one of the largest solid-state qubit arrays to date and indicate the positive direction of progress towards the goal of implementing complex quantum algorithms relying on such effects.

arXiv:1903.11747•Scientific Reports•Sep 17, 2019•115 citations
One of the most correlated quantum phenomena achievable is superconductivity. In superconductivity pairs of electrons condense, in a manner analogous to Bose-Einstein condensation, into the same quantum state with their subsequent entanglement permitting frictionless conductivity. Quantum computers have the potential to predict complex, entangled quantum states at non-exponential cost, unlike their classical counterparts, with possible applications to hard problems from physics to economics. Here, using pairs of qubits to represent the electron pairs, we create superconductivity on a transmon-qubit quantum computer. A series of maximally entangled superconducting states with different numbers of electron pairs is prepared, and then the occupation of the superconducting state is measured by tomography. Each occupation on the order of the number of electrons O(N)O(N)O(N) confirms the formation of a maximally entangled superconducting state. Moreover, the large eigenvalue provides experimental validation of C. N. Yang's derivation of large occupation being associated with off-diagonal long-range order. The work provides a critically important step in predicting strongly entangled quantum physics as well as mathematically related non-local phenomena in the pure and social sciences on quantum computers.
An important problem in quantum information is the practical demonstration of non-classical long-range order on quantum computers. One of the best known examples of a quantum system with non-classical long-range order is a superconductor. Here we achieve Cooper pairing of qubits on a quantum computer to represent superconducting or superfluid states. We rigorously confirm the quantum long-range order by measuring the large O(N)O(N)O(N) eigenvalue of the two-electron reduced density matrix. The demonstration of maximal quantum long-range order is an important step towards more complex modeling of superconductivity and superfluidity as well as other phenomena with significant quantum long-range order on quantum computers.
An important problem in quantum information is the practical demonstration of nonclassical long-range order on quantum computers. One of the best known examples of a quantum system with nonclassical long-range order is a superconductor. Here we achieve Cooper-like pairing of qubits on a quantum computer, which can be interpreted as superconducting or superfluid states via a Jordan-Wigner mapping. We rigorously confirm the quantum long-range order by measuring the large O(N)O(N)O(N) eigenvalue of the two-electron reduced density matrix. The demonstration of maximal quantum long-range order is an important step toward more complex modeling of phenomena with significant quantum long-range order on quantum computers such as superconductivity and superfluidity.
Superconductivity in its various manifestations has been stimulating both experimental and theoretical progress in condensed-matter physics for more than a hundred years. The remarkable property of electrons to pair up and form quasi-particles gives rise to a plethora of phenomena featuring important practical applications not only in science, but, for instance, also in medicine and metrology. Recently, new directions in investigating this fascinating subject emerged, such as superconductivity out-of equilibrium and topological superconductors. Providing experimental evidence for enhanced superconducting correlations in optically pumped copper oxides at temperatures far above the equilibrium transition temperature, the first issue caused considerable excitement. On the other hand, topological superconductors are believed to provide realizations of highly fault-tolerant qubits by means of hosting non-Abelian quasi-particles, which can be the building blocks of scalable quantum computers. Experimentally verifying the emergence of these Majorana edge modes, exotic quasi-particles in heterostructures consisting of a conventional superconductor and semiconductors or topological insulators, is one of the most urgent questions to be answered right now. Both subjects cannot be accounted for with analytically solvable approximations only, and also provide very challenging numerical problems. We implemented a matrix-product state (MPS) based toolkit exploiting U(1)U(1)U(1) symmetries, providing a flexible and efficient platform to study these complex systems. In order to efficiently simulate out-of equilibrium setups we studied, compared, and developed time-evolution algorithms for MPS enabling us to choose the most suitable method for a given task. We also developed a new framework to represent operators in an enlarged Hilbert space so that benefits from conserving U(1)U(1)U(1) symmetries can also be exploited in systems that originally break such symmetries (projected purification). Using this method we could efficiently model mesoscopic phenomena such as a charging energy controlled by a gate electrode without further approximations. Equipped with this techniques we studied out-of equilibrium spectral functions to explore how to identify superconducting correlations more reliably on ultra-short timescales. We found conclusive evidence that in particular two-particle spectral functions yield excellent probes for the formation of a (quasi-)condensate out-of equilibrium. Furthermore, we also investigated the question whether in a particular model system there is the possibility of true long-range order out-of equilibrium by studying correlation matrices and the scaling of their eigenvalues. Here, we observe a change in the algebraic decay of the correlations, even though the extrapolated order parameter is still zero within the error bounds. Furthermore, we also investigated the effects of coupling a superconductor-semiconductor heterostructure, which is subject to an in-plane magnetic field and a charging energy controlled by a gate voltage, to normal leads. In the context of experimentally verifying the existence of Majorana edge modes, such systems are believed to be the most promising and recent studies seem to underline this expectation. However, in order to consistently analyze the experimental data, the effects of quantum fluctuations caused by hybridization of the heterostructure with the leads have to be understood. Here, only perturbative limits are available so far, i.e., the weak and strong tunneling limit, while the experimentally relevant regime is expected to be somewhere inbetween. We aimed to fill this gap using the projected purification method to calculate the ground state phase diagram over a wide parameter regime. Our results indicate that the experimental situation is much more involved than what is predicted from perturbative analysis.
In this paper, we intend to show that macroscopic entanglement is possible at high temperatures. We have analysed multipartite entanglement produced by the η-pairing mechanism, which features strongly in the fermionic lattice models of high T c superconductivity. This problem is shown to be equivalent to calculating multipartite entanglement in totally symmetric states of qubits. It is demonstrated that we can conclusively calculate the relative entropy of entanglement within any subset of qubits in the overall symmetric state. Three main results are then presented. First, the condition for superconductivity, namely existence of the off-diagonal long-range order (ODLRO), is dependent not on two-site entanglement but just classical correlations as the sites become more and more distant. Secondly, the entanglement that does survive in the thermodynamical limit is the entanglement of the total lattice and, at half-filling, it scales with the log of the number of sites. It is this entanglement that will exist at temperatures below the superconducting critical temperature, which can currently be as high as 160 K. Finally, it is proved that a complete mixture of symmetric states does not contain any entanglement in the macroscopic limit. On the other hand, a mixture of symmetric states possesses the same two qubit entanglement features as the pure states involved, in the sense that the mixing does not destroy entanglement for a finite number of qubits, albeit it does decrease it. Furthermore, maximal mixing of symmetric states does not destroy ODLRO and classical correlations. We discuss generalizations to the subsystems of any dimensionality (i.e. higher than spin-half).
Quantum walks are the quantum analogs of classical random walks, which allow for the simulation of large-scale quantum many-body systems and the realization of universal quantum computation without time-dependent control. We experimentally demonstrate quantum walks of one and two strongly correlated microwave photons in a one-dimensional array of 12 superconducting qubits with short-range interactions. First, in one-photon quantum walks, we observed the propagation of the density and correlation of the quasiparticle excitation of the superconducting qubit and quantum entanglement between qubit pairs. Second, when implementing two-photon quantum walks by exciting two superconducting qubits, we observed the fermionization of strongly interacting photons from the measured time-dependent long-range anticorrelations, representing the antibunching of photons with attractive interactions. The demonstration of quantum walks on a quantum processor, using superconducting qubits as artificial atoms and tomographic readout, paves the way to quantum simulation of many-body phenomena and universal quantum computation.
The ability to prepare sizeable multi-qubit entangled states with full qubit control is a critical milestone for physical platforms upon which quantum computers are built. We investigate the extent to which entanglement is found within a prepared graph state on the 20-qubit superconducting quantum computer IBM Q Poughkeepsie. We prepared a graph state along a path consisting of all twenty qubits within the device and performed full quantum state tomography on all groups of four connected qubits along this path. We determined that each pair of connected qubits was inseparable and hence the prepared state was entangled. Additionally, a genuine multipartite entanglement witness was measured on all qubit subpaths of the graph state and we found genuine multipartite entanglement on chains of up to three qubits. These results represent a demonstration of entanglement in one of the largest solid-state qubit arrays to date and indicate the positive direction of progress towards the goal of implementing complex quantum algorithms relying on such effects.