Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1903.11747 · Scientific Reports

Entanglement in a 20-Qubit Superconducting Quantum Computer

Gary J. Mooney, Charles D. Hill, Lloyd C. L. Hollenberg

Published Sep 17, 2019• 115 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The ability to prepare sizeable multi-qubit entangled states with full qubit control is a critical milestone for physical platforms upon which quantum computers are built. We investigate the extent to which entanglement is found within a prepared graph state on the 20-qubit superconducting quantum computer IBM Q Poughkeepsie. We prepared a graph state along a path consisting of all twenty qubits within the device and performed full quantum state tomography on all groups of four connected qubits along this path. We determined that each pair of connected qubits was inseparable and hence the prepared state was entangled. Additionally, a genuine multipartite entanglement witness was measured on all qubit subpaths of the graph state and we found genuine multipartite entanglement on chains of up to three qubits. These results represent a demonstration of entanglement in one of the largest solid-state qubit arrays to date and indicate the positive direction of progress towards the goal of implementing complex quantum algorithms relying on such effects.

DOI
10.1038/s41598-019-49805-7

Related papers

Whole‐Device Entanglement in a 65‐Qubit Superconducting Quantum Computer

Gary J. Mooney, Gregory A. L. White, Charles D. Hill +1 more

Abstract The ability to generate large‐scale entanglement is an important progenitor of quantum information processing capability in noisy intermediate‐scale quantum (NISQ) devices. In this paper, the extent to which entangled quantum states over large numbers of qubits can be prepared on current superconducting quantum devices is investigated. Native‐graph states on the IBM Quantum 65‐qubit ibmq_manhattan device and the 53‐qubit ibmq_rochester device are prepared and quantum readout‐error mitigation (QREM) is applied. Connected entanglement graphs spanning each of the full devices are detected, indicating bipartite entanglement over the whole of each device. The application of QREM is shown to increase the observed entanglement within all measurements, in particular, the detected number of entangled pairs of qubits found within ibmq_rochester increases from 31 to 56 of the total 58 connected pairs. The results of this work indicate full bipartite entanglement in two of the largest superconducting devices to date.

arXiv:2102.11521•Advanced Quantum Technologies•Sep 5, 2021•86 citations

Benchmarking Multipartite Entanglement Generation with Graph States

René Zander, Colin Kai‐Uwe Becker

Abstract As quantum computing technology slowly matures and the number of available qubits on a QPU gradually increases, interest in assessing the capabilities of quantum computing hardware in a scalable manner is growing. One of the key properties for quantum computing is the ability to generate multipartite entangled states. In this study, aspects of benchmarking entanglement generation capabilities of noisy intermediate‐scale quantum (NISQ) devices are discussed based on the preparation of graph states and the verification of entanglement in the prepared states. Thereby, entanglement witnesses that are specifically suited for a scalable experiment design are used. This choice of entanglement witnesses can detect A) bipartite entanglement and B) genuine multipartite entanglement for graph states with constant two measurement settings if the prepared graph state is based on a two‐colorable graph, e.g., a square grid graph or one of its subgraphs. With this, it is experimentally verified that a bipartite entangled state comprising all qubits can be prepared on a 127‐qubit IBM Quantum superconducting QPU, and genuine multipartite entanglement can be detected for states of up to 23 qubits with quantum readout error mitigation.

arXiv:2402.00766•Advanced Quantum Technologies•Oct 9, 2024•4 citations

Characterization of entanglement on superconducting quantum computers of up to 414 qubits

John F. Kam, Haiyue Kang, Charles D. Hill +2 more

As quantum technology advances and the size of quantum computers grow, it becomes increasingly important to understand the extent of quality in the devices. As large-scale entanglement is a quantum resource crucial for achieving quantum advantage, the challenge in its generation makes it a valuable benchmark for measuring the performance of universal quantum devices. In this paper, we study entanglement in Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) and graph states prepared on the range of IBM Quantum devices. We generate GHZ states and investigate their coherence times with respect to state size and dynamical decoupling techniques. A GHZ fidelity of 0.519 ± 0.014 is measured on a 32-qubit GHZ state, certifying its genuine multipartite entanglement (GME). We show a substantial improvement in GHZ decoherence rates for a seven-qubit GHZ state after implementing dynamical decoupling, and observe a linear trend in the decoherence rate of α = ( 7.13 N + 5.54 ) × 10 − 3 µ s − 1 for up to N = 15 qubits, confirming the absence of superdecoherence. Additionally, we prepare and characterize fully bipartite entangled native-graph states on 22 superconducting quantum devices with qubit counts as high as 414 qubits, all active qubits of the 433-qubit IBM Osprey device. Analysis of the decay of two-qubit entanglement within the prepared states shows suppression of coherent noise signals with the implementation of dynamical decoupling techniques. Additionally, we observe that the entanglement in some qubit pairs oscillates over time, which is likely caused by residual ZZ-interactions. Characterizing entanglement in native-graph states, along with detecting entanglement oscillations, can be an effective approach to low-level device benchmarking that encapsulates two-qubit error rates along with additional sources of noise, with possible applications to quantum circuit compilation. We develop several tools to automate the preparation and entanglement characterization of GHZ and graph states. In particular, a method to characterize graph state bipartite entanglement using just 36 circuits, constant with respect to the number of qubits. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2312.15170•Physical Review Research•Aug 12, 2024•25 citations

16-qubit IBM universal quantum computer can be fully entangled

Yuanhao Wang, Ying Li, Zhang-qi Yin +1 more

Abstract Entanglement is an important evidence that a quantum device can potentially solve problems intractable for classical computers. In this paper, we prepare connected graph states involving 8 to 16 qubits onibmqx5, a 16-qubit superconducting quantum processor accessible via IBM cloud, using low-depth circuits. We demonstrate that the prepared state is fully entangled, i.e., the state is inseparable with respect to any fixed partition.

arXiv:1801.03782•npj Quantum Information•Sep 21, 2018•148 citations

10-Qubit Entanglement and Parallel Logic Operations with a Superconducting Circuit

Chao Song, Kai Xu, Wuxin Liu +16 more

Here we report on the production and tomography of genuinely entangled Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger states with up to ten qubits connecting to a bus resonator in a superconducting circuit, where the resonator-mediated qubit-qubit interactions are used to controllably entangle multiple qubits and to operate on different pairs of qubits in parallel. The resulting 10-qubit density matrix is probed by quantum state tomography, with a fidelity of 0.668±0.025. Our results demonstrate the largest entanglement created so far in solid-state architectures and pave the way to large-scale quantum computation.

arXiv:1703.10302•Physical Review Letters•Nov 3, 2017•449 citations

Quantifying Geometric Measure of Entanglement of Multi-qubit Graph States on the IBM’s Quantum Computer

N. A. Susulovska, Kh. P. Gnatenko

Quantum entanglement gives rise to a range of non-classical effects, which are extensively exploited in quantum computing and quantum communication. Therefore, detection and quantification of entanglement as well as preparation of highly entangled quantum states remain the fundamental objectives in these fields. Much attention has been devoted to the studies of graph states, which play a role of a central resource in quantum error correction, quantum cryptography and practical quantum metrology in the presence of noise.We examine multi-qubit graph states generated by the action of controlled phase shift operators on a separable quantum state of a system, in which all the qubits are in arbitrary identical states. Analytical expression is obtained for the geometric measure of entanglement of a qubit with other qubits in graph states represented by arbitrary graphs. We conclude that this quantity depends on the degree of the vertex corresponding to the qubit, the absolute values of the parameter of the phase shift gate and the parameter of the initial state the gate is acting on. Moreover, the geometric measure of entanglement of certain types of graph states is quantified on the IBM’s quantum computer ibmq_athens based on the measurements of the mean spin. Namely, we consider states associated with the native connectivity of ibmq_athens, the claw and the complete graphs. Appropriate protocols are proposed to prepare these states on the quantum computer. The results of quantum computations verify our theoretical findings [1].

IEEE International Conference on Quantum Computing and Engineering (QCE)•Oct 1, 2021•3 citations
The ability to prepare sizeable multi-qubit entangled states with full qubit control is a critical milestone for physical platforms upon which quantum computers are built. We investigate the extent to which entanglement is found within a prepared graph state on the 20-qubit superconducting quantum computer IBM Q Poughkeepsie. We prepared a graph state along a path consisting of all twenty qubits within the device and performed full quantum state tomography on all groups of four connected qubits along this path. We determined that each pair of connected qubits was inseparable and hence the prepared state was entangled. Additionally, a genuine multipartite entanglement witness was measured on all qubit subpaths of the graph state and we found genuine multipartite entanglement on chains of up to three qubits. These results represent a demonstration of entanglement in one of the largest solid-state qubit arrays to date and indicate the positive direction of progress towards the goal of implementing complex quantum algorithms relying on such effects.
Abstract The ability to generate large‐scale entanglement is an important progenitor of quantum information processing capability in noisy intermediate‐scale quantum (NISQ) devices. In this paper, the extent to which entangled quantum states over large numbers of qubits can be prepared on current superconducting quantum devices is investigated. Native‐graph states on the IBM Quantum 65‐qubit ibmq_manhattan device and the 53‐qubit ibmq_rochester device are prepared and quantum readout‐error mitigation (QREM) is applied. Connected entanglement graphs spanning each of the full devices are detected, indicating bipartite entanglement over the whole of each device. The application of QREM is shown to increase the observed entanglement within all measurements, in particular, the detected number of entangled pairs of qubits found within ibmq_rochester increases from 31 to 56 of the total 58 connected pairs. The results of this work indicate full bipartite entanglement in two of the largest superconducting devices to date.
Abstract As quantum computing technology slowly matures and the number of available qubits on a QPU gradually increases, interest in assessing the capabilities of quantum computing hardware in a scalable manner is growing. One of the key properties for quantum computing is the ability to generate multipartite entangled states. In this study, aspects of benchmarking entanglement generation capabilities of noisy intermediate‐scale quantum (NISQ) devices are discussed based on the preparation of graph states and the verification of entanglement in the prepared states. Thereby, entanglement witnesses that are specifically suited for a scalable experiment design are used. This choice of entanglement witnesses can detect A) bipartite entanglement and B) genuine multipartite entanglement for graph states with constant two measurement settings if the prepared graph state is based on a two‐colorable graph, e.g., a square grid graph or one of its subgraphs. With this, it is experimentally verified that a bipartite entangled state comprising all qubits can be prepared on a 127‐qubit IBM Quantum superconducting QPU, and genuine multipartite entanglement can be detected for states of up to 23 qubits with quantum readout error mitigation.
As quantum technology advances and the size of quantum computers grow, it becomes increasingly important to understand the extent of quality in the devices. As large-scale entanglement is a quantum resource crucial for achieving quantum advantage, the challenge in its generation makes it a valuable benchmark for measuring the performance of universal quantum devices. In this paper, we study entanglement in Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) and graph states prepared on the range of IBM Quantum devices. We generate GHZ states and investigate their coherence times with respect to state size and dynamical decoupling techniques. A GHZ fidelity of 0.519 ± 0.014 is measured on a 32-qubit GHZ state, certifying its genuine multipartite entanglement (GME). We show a substantial improvement in GHZ decoherence rates for a seven-qubit GHZ state after implementing dynamical decoupling, and observe a linear trend in the decoherence rate of α = ( 7.13 N + 5.54 ) × 10 − 3 µ s − 1 for up to N = 15 qubits, confirming the absence of superdecoherence. Additionally, we prepare and characterize fully bipartite entangled native-graph states on 22 superconducting quantum devices with qubit counts as high as 414 qubits, all active qubits of the 433-qubit IBM Osprey device. Analysis of the decay of two-qubit entanglement within the prepared states shows suppression of coherent noise signals with the implementation of dynamical decoupling techniques. Additionally, we observe that the entanglement in some qubit pairs oscillates over time, which is likely caused by residual ZZ-interactions. Characterizing entanglement in native-graph states, along with detecting entanglement oscillations, can be an effective approach to low-level device benchmarking that encapsulates two-qubit error rates along with additional sources of noise, with possible applications to quantum circuit compilation. We develop several tools to automate the preparation and entanglement characterization of GHZ and graph states. In particular, a method to characterize graph state bipartite entanglement using just 36 circuits, constant with respect to the number of qubits. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
Here we report on the production and tomography of genuinely entangled Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger states with up to ten qubits connecting to a bus resonator in a superconducting circuit, where the resonator-mediated qubit-qubit interactions are used to controllably entangle multiple qubits and to operate on different pairs of qubits in parallel. The resulting 10-qubit density matrix is probed by quantum state tomography, with a fidelity of 0.668±0.025. Our results demonstrate the largest entanglement created so far in solid-state architectures and pave the way to large-scale quantum computation.
Quantum entanglement gives rise to a range of non-classical effects, which are extensively exploited in quantum computing and quantum communication. Therefore, detection and quantification of entanglement as well as preparation of highly entangled quantum states remain the fundamental objectives in these fields. Much attention has been devoted to the studies of graph states, which play a role of a central resource in quantum error correction, quantum cryptography and practical quantum metrology in the presence of noise.We examine multi-qubit graph states generated by the action of controlled phase shift operators on a separable quantum state of a system, in which all the qubits are in arbitrary identical states. Analytical expression is obtained for the geometric measure of entanglement of a qubit with other qubits in graph states represented by arbitrary graphs. We conclude that this quantity depends on the degree of the vertex corresponding to the qubit, the absolute values of the parameter of the phase shift gate and the parameter of the initial state the gate is acting on. Moreover, the geometric measure of entanglement of certain types of graph states is quantified on the IBM’s quantum computer ibmq_athens based on the measurements of the mean spin. Namely, we consider states associated with the native connectivity of ibmq_athens, the claw and the complete graphs. Appropriate protocols are proposed to prepare these states on the quantum computer. The results of quantum computations verify our theoretical findings [1].