© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

Terms Privacy Legal Notice

Asymmetric Bethe-Salpeter Equation for Pairing and Condensation

Klaus Morawetz

Published May 1, 2011• 5 citations

Abstract

The Martin-Schwinger hierarchy of correlations are reexamined and the three-particle correlations are investigated under various partial summations. Besides the known approximations of screened, ladder and maximally crossed diagrams the pair-pair correlations are considered. It is shown that the recently proposed asymmetric Bethe-Salpeter equation to avoid unphysical repeated collisions is derived as a result of the hierarchical dependencies of correlations. Exceeding the parquet approximation we show that an asymmetry appears in the selfconsistent propagators. This form is superior over the symmetric selfconsistent one since it provides the Nambu-Gorkov equations and gap equation for fermions and the Beliaev equations for bosons while from the symmetric form no gap equation results. The selfenergy diagrams which account for the subtraction of unphysical repeated collisions are derived from the pair-pair correlation in the three-particle Green's function. It is suggested to distinguish between two types of selfconsistency, the channel-dressed propagators and the completely dressed propagators, with the help of which the asymmetric expansion completes the Ward identity and is I broken vertical bar-derivable.

Related papers

Systems with Condensates and Pairing

Klaus Morawetz

Abstract The Bose–Einstein condensation and appearance of superfluidity and superconductivity are introduced from basic phenomena. A systematic theory based on the asymmetric expansion of chapter 11 is shown to correct the T-matrix from unphysical multiple-scattering events. The resulting generalised Soven scheme provides the Beliaev equations for Boson’s and the Nambu–Gorkov equations for fermions without the usage of anomalous and non-conserving propagators. This systematic theory allows calculating the fluctuations above and below the critical parameters. Gap equations and Bogoliubov–DeGennes equations are derived from this theory. Interacting Bose systems with finite temperatures are discussed with successively better approximations ranging from Bogoliubov and Popov up to corrected T-matrices. For superconductivity, the asymmetric theory leading to the corrected T-matrix allows for establishing the stability of the condensate and decides correctly about the pair-breaking mechanisms in contrast to conventional approaches. The relation between the correlated density from nonlocal kinetic theory and the density of Cooper pairs is shown.

•Dec 21, 2017•0 citations

Strongly correlated electrons: Analytic mean-field theories with two-particle self-consistency

V. Janiš, Peter Zalom, Vladislav Pokorný +1 more

A two-particle self-consistency is rarely part of mean-field theories. It is, however, essential for avoiding spurious critical transitions and unphysical behavior. We present a general scheme for constructing analytically controllable approximations with self-consistent equations for the two-particle vertices based on the parquet equations. We explain in detail how to reduce the full set of parquet equations so as not to miss quantum criticality in strong coupling. We further introduce a decoupling of convolutions of the dynamical variables in the Bethe-Salpeter equations to make them analytically solvable. We connect the self-energy with the two-particle vertices to satisfy the Ward identity and the Schwinger-Dyson equation and discuss the role of the one-particle self-consistency in making the approximations reliable in the whole spectrum of the input parameters. Finally, we demonstrate the general construction on the simplest static approximation that we apply to the Kondo behavior of the single-impurity Anderson model.

arXiv:1906.04081•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Nov 11, 2019•13 citations

1 Parquet theory for correlated thermodynamic Greens functions

Peter Kleinert

We address the problem of finding self-consistent parquet equations for two-body correlated Greens functions that arise out of a cumulant expansion. The general theory as developed for non-relativistic electron systems reproduces the conventional two-body parquet diagrammatic technique for the vertex functions. As an application, the crossing-invariant linearized basic parquet equations are treated for the correlated two-particle Greens function. It is pointed out that besides the Cooperon there are two additional prominent crossing-symmetric two-particle channels in many-particle systems with pair interaction.

•Aug 15, 2016•1 citation

Ladder equation for the three-particle vertex and its approximate solution

Patrick Kappl, T. Ribic, Anna Kauch +1 more

We generalize the three two-particle Bethe-Salpeter equations to ten three-particle ladders. These equations are exact and yield the exact three-particle vertex, if we knew the three-particle vertex irreducible in one of the ten channels. However, as we do not have this three-particle irreducible vertex at hand, we approximate this building block for the ladder by the sum of two-particle irreducible vertices, each connecting two fermionic lines. The comparison to the exact solution shows that this approximation is only good for rather weak interactions and even then only qualitatively—at least for the nonlinear response function analyzed.

arXiv:2412.01848•Physical Review Research•Sep 10, 2025•0 citations

Parquet Theory for Correlated Thermodynamic Greens Functions

P. Kleinert

We address the problem of finding self-consistent parquet equations for two-body correlated Greens functions that arise out of a cumulant expansion. The general theory as developed for non-relativistic electron systems reproduces the conventional two-body parquet diagrammatic technique for the vertex functions. As an application, the crossing-invariant linearized basic parquet equations are treated for the correlated two-particle Greens function. It is pointed out that besides the Cooperon there are two additional prominent crossing-symmetric two-particle channels in many-particle systems with pair interaction.

arXiv:0911.1668•Progress of Theoretical Physics•Feb 1, 2010•1 citation

Approximations for the Selfenergy

Klaus Morawetz

Abstract The systematic expansion of the selfenergy is presented with the help of the closure relation of chapter 7. Besides Hartree–Fock leading to meanfield kinetic equations, the random phase approximation (RPA) is shown to result into the Lennard–Balescu kinetic equation, and the ladder approximation into the Beth–Uehling–Uhlenbeck kinetic equation. The deficiencies of the ladder approximation are explored compared to the exact T-matrix by missing maximally crossed diagrams. The T-matrix provides the Bethe–Salpeter equation for the two-particle correlation functions. Vertex corrections to the RPA are presented. For a two-dimensional example, the selfenergy and effective mass are calculated. The structure factor and the pair-correlation function are introduced and calculated for various approximations.

•Dec 21, 2017•0 citations

The Martin-Schwinger hierarchy of correlations are reexamined and the three-particle correlations are investigated under various partial summations. Besides the known approximations of screened, ladder and maximally crossed diagrams the pair-pair correlations are considered. It is shown that the recently proposed asymmetric Bethe-Salpeter equation to avoid unphysical repeated collisions is derived as a result of the hierarchical dependencies of correlations. Exceeding the parquet approximation we show that an asymmetry appears in the selfconsistent propagators. This form is superior over the symmetric selfconsistent one since it provides the Nambu-Gorkov equations and gap equation for fermions and the Beliaev equations for bosons while from the symmetric form no gap equation results. The selfenergy diagrams which account for the subtraction of unphysical repeated collisions are derived from the pair-pair correlation in the three-particle Green's function. It is suggested to distinguish between two types of selfconsistency, the channel-dressed propagators and the completely dressed propagators, with the help of which the asymmetric expansion completes the Ward identity and is I broken vertical bar-derivable.

Abstract The Bose–Einstein condensation and appearance of superfluidity and superconductivity are introduced from basic phenomena. A systematic theory based on the asymmetric expansion of chapter 11 is shown to correct the T-matrix from unphysical multiple-scattering events. The resulting generalised Soven scheme provides the Beliaev equations for Boson’s and the Nambu–Gorkov equations for fermions without the usage of anomalous and non-conserving propagators. This systematic theory allows calculating the fluctuations above and below the critical parameters. Gap equations and Bogoliubov–DeGennes equations are derived from this theory. Interacting Bose systems with finite temperatures are discussed with successively better approximations ranging from Bogoliubov and Popov up to corrected T-matrices. For superconductivity, the asymmetric theory leading to the corrected T-matrix allows for establishing the stability of the condensate and decides correctly about the pair-breaking mechanisms in contrast to conventional approaches. The relation between the correlated density from nonlocal kinetic theory and the density of Cooper pairs is shown.

A two-particle self-consistency is rarely part of mean-field theories. It is, however, essential for avoiding spurious critical transitions and unphysical behavior. We present a general scheme for constructing analytically controllable approximations with self-consistent equations for the two-particle vertices based on the parquet equations. We explain in detail how to reduce the full set of parquet equations so as not to miss quantum criticality in strong coupling. We further introduce a decoupling of convolutions of the dynamical variables in the Bethe-Salpeter equations to make them analytically solvable. We connect the self-energy with the two-particle vertices to satisfy the Ward identity and the Schwinger-Dyson equation and discuss the role of the one-particle self-consistency in making the approximations reliable in the whole spectrum of the input parameters. Finally, we demonstrate the general construction on the simplest static approximation that we apply to the Kondo behavior of the single-impurity Anderson model.

We address the problem of finding self-consistent parquet equations for two-body correlated Greens functions that arise out of a cumulant expansion. The general theory as developed for non-relativistic electron systems reproduces the conventional two-body parquet diagrammatic technique for the vertex functions. As an application, the crossing-invariant linearized basic parquet equations are treated for the correlated two-particle Greens function. It is pointed out that besides the Cooperon there are two additional prominent crossing-symmetric two-particle channels in many-particle systems with pair interaction.

We generalize the three two-particle Bethe-Salpeter equations to ten three-particle ladders. These equations are exact and yield the exact three-particle vertex, if we knew the three-particle vertex irreducible in one of the ten channels. However, as we do not have this three-particle irreducible vertex at hand, we approximate this building block for the ladder by the sum of two-particle irreducible vertices, each connecting two fermionic lines. The comparison to the exact solution shows that this approximation is only good for rather weak interactions and even then only qualitatively—at least for the nonlinear response function analyzed.

We address the problem of finding self-consistent parquet equations for two-body correlated Greens functions that arise out of a cumulant expansion. The general theory as developed for non-relativistic electron systems reproduces the conventional two-body parquet diagrammatic technique for the vertex functions. As an application, the crossing-invariant linearized basic parquet equations are treated for the correlated two-particle Greens function. It is pointed out that besides the Cooperon there are two additional prominent crossing-symmetric two-particle channels in many-particle systems with pair interaction.

Abstract The systematic expansion of the selfenergy is presented with the help of the closure relation of chapter 7. Besides Hartree–Fock leading to meanfield kinetic equations, the random phase approximation (RPA) is shown to result into the Lennard–Balescu kinetic equation, and the ladder approximation into the Beth–Uehling–Uhlenbeck kinetic equation. The deficiencies of the ladder approximation are explored compared to the exact T-matrix by missing maximally crossed diagrams. The T-matrix provides the Bethe–Salpeter equation for the two-particle correlation functions. Vertex corrections to the RPA are presented. For a two-dimensional example, the selfenergy and effective mass are calculated. The structure factor and the pair-correlation function are introduced and calculated for various approximations.