Balanced Homodyne Detection of Optical Quantum States at Audio-Band Frequencies and Below
Michael Stefszky, Conor M Mow-Lowry, S. Chua, D. A. Shaddock, B. C. Buchler, H. Vahlbruch, A. Khalaidovski, Roman Schnabel, Ping Koy Lam, David E. McClelland
The advent of stable, highly squeezed states of light has generated great interest in the gravitational wave community as a means for improving the quantumnoise- limited performance of advanced interferometric detectors. To confidently measure these squeezed states, it is first necessary to measure the shot-noise across the frequency band of interest. Technical noise, such as non-stationary events, beam pointing, and parasitic interference, can corrupt shot-noise measurements at low Fourier frequencies, below tens of kilo-Hertz. In this paper we present a qualitative investigation into all of the relevant noise sources and the methods by which they can be identified and mitigated in order to achieve quantum noise limited balanced homodyne detection. Using these techniques, flat shot-noise down to Fourier frequencies below 0.5 Hz is produced. This enables the direct observation of large magnitudes of squeezing across the entire audio-band, of particular interest for ground-based interferometric gravitational wave detectors. 11.6 dB of shot-noise suppression is directly observed, with more than 10 dB down to 10 Hz.
The advent of stable, highly squeezed states of light has generated great interest in the gravitational wave community as a means for improving the quantumnoise- limited performance of advanced interferometric detectors. To confidently measure these squeezed states, it is first necessary to measure the shot-noise across the frequency band of interest. Technical noise, such as non-stationary events, beam pointing, and parasitic interference, can corrupt shot-noise measurements at low Fourier frequencies, below tens of kilo-Hertz. In this paper we present a qualitative investigation into all of the relevant noise sources and the methods by which they can be identified and mitigated in order to achieve quantum noise limited balanced homodyne detection. Using these techniques, flat shot-noise down to Fourier frequencies below 0.5 Hz is produced. This enables the direct observation of large magnitudes of squeezing across the entire audio-band, of particular interest for ground-based interferometric gravitational wave detectors. 11.6 dB of shot-noise suppression is directly observed, with more than 10 dB down to 10 Hz.
The advent of stable, highly squeezed states of light has generated great interest in the gravitational wave community as a means for improving the quantumnoise- limited performance of advanced interferometric detectors. To confidently measure these squeezed states, it is first necessary to measure the shot-noise across the frequency band of interest. Technical noise, such as non-stationary events, beam pointing, and parasitic interference, can corrupt shot-noise measurements at low Fourier frequencies, below tens of kilo-Hertz. In this paper we present a qualitative investigation into all of the relevant noise sources and the methods by which they can be identified and mitigated in order to achieve quantum noise limited balanced homodyne detection. Using these techniques, flat shot-noise down to Fourier frequencies below 0.5 Hz is produced. This enables the direct observation of large magnitudes of squeezing across the entire audio-band, of particular interest for ground-based interferometric gravitational wave detectors. 11.6 dB of shot-noise suppression is directly observed, with more than 10 dB down to 10 Hz.
Stable squeezed noise sources of large magnitude across the audio frequency band has generated great interest in the gravitational wave community as a means for improving the quantum-noise-limited performance of advanced interferometric detectors. We present our most recent results showing 8.5dB of squeezing over most of the frequency band of interest for ground based detectors. We discuss many of the issues that were overcome in order to reach this level of squeezing at these frequencies such as scattered light, beam jitter and electronics.
Gravitational-wave astronomy promises a radically new method of investigating the universe, one that does not detect elementary particles, but rather ripples in space-time itself. One might expect that with this radically new method, our understanding of the universe will make an equally giant leap. One of the most promising methods for the eventual detection of gravitational-waves is that of interferometric gravitational-wave detection. The sensitivity of these devices is nothing short of amazing, and their sensitivity continues to improve. The next generation of detectors are expected reach a point where increasing the laser power, previously used to increase the sensitivity, is no longer expected to provide any benefit. One of the most promising options for further increasing the sensitivity, through reduction of the quantum noise, is via the application of "squeezed states of light". Squeezed states of light are light fields for which the noise of some observable has been reduced below the quantum noise limit. These states have been shown for many years to offer increased sensitivity in interferometers and recently in interferometric gravitational-wave detectors. One of the most challenging tasks to make suitable squeezed light sources for these detectors is to produce low-frequency squeezing, corresponding to the detection band of these interferometers. This thesis details the doubly resonant travelling wave bow-tie squeezer as a source of squeezing for interferometric gravitational-wave detection. This squeezer achieves record results of squeezing in the gravitational-wave detection band. For the first time, 10 dB of shot noise suppression at 10Hz is directly observed and above 200Hz, 11.6 dB is observed. The work presented in this thesis provides evidence that further substantiates previous progress indicating that squeezed states of light are now ready for full-time integration into interferometric gravitational-wave detectors. The new cavity design, described in detail throughout this thesis, is shown to outperform previous designs and provide benefits when integrating squeezing into these detectors, in particular, isolation to backscattered light from the interferometer. The noise sources that typically lead to degradation in squeezing measurements are investigated and discussed. Additionally, a modification to the standard locking technique used to control these vacuum squeezed states, coherent locking, is presented and discussed. The modified technique reduces the required number of locking loops and provides a larger beat note from which to derive an error signal for one of the remaining loops. A squeezer using these design philosophies is then constructed and used to inject squeezing into the LIGO gravitational-wave detector. Injection of the squeezed state provides enhancement of the sensitivity of the detector at frequencies around 200Hz and above. The sensitivity seen was equivalent to approximately 2 dB of shot noise reduction. The enhancement is limited by the loss within the interferometer. Injection of the squeezed state did not show any degradation in the sensitivity of the device below 200Hz, indicating for the first time that noise couplings between the interferometer and the squeezer could be sufficiently suppressed at these frequencies even for the most sensitive detectors.
Vacuum fluctuation at audio frequencies is very important and interesting in many research fields, such as the gravitational wave detection, ultra-weak magnetic field measurement, and the research of quantum metrology, etc. Since the generation of squeezed light in 1985, most of the squeezed light have been generated and measured at radio frequencies (～MHz) as there has not been much technical noise at higher frequencies. In the Michelson-interferometer-based gravitational wave detection, the detection band has frequencies from a few to tens of thousands Hz. Measuring vacuum noise at such low frequencies is a challenge since we have to stabilize and control all the audio noises and the interferences from a variety of mechanical and electronic noises, therefore a very high classical noise suppression is needed when the measurement time increases. In order to measure the squeezed light of low frequencies, the standard vacuum noise at audio frequencies must be measured. In this paper, a balanced homodyne detection system for measuring the low-frequency quantum vacuum noises is reported. It is not trivial to extend the detected frequency to very low analysis frequencies. Through a self-made self-subtraction balanced homodyne configuration, which can eliminate the DC component of each photocurrent from the photodiode and the classical common-mode technical noise, the standard vacuum noise has been detected. The linearity of the vacuum noise power has been validated by varying the local oscillator power, showing that the saturation power of light incidence is about 3.2 mW. When the incident-light power is 400 W, the standard vacuum noise is 11 dB higher than the electronic noise at 80 Hz. In the regime of about 80 Hz to 400 kHz, the linearity of the standard noise power as a function of incident laser power is verified. However, when the measurement is carried out at even lower frequencies, for example, 50 Hz, we may encounter some excess and non-stationary noises and find that the measured noise power is not proportional to the incident light power any more. These non-stationary noises are the main technical obstacle at low frequencies. The average common mode rejection ratio in the test frequency range from 10 Hz to 400 kHz is 55 dB and its maximum 63 dB at 100 Hz is obtained, implying a high suppression of the technical noise. This self-made homodyne vacuum noise detector can be widely used for precision measurement in quantum metrology and quantum optics.
The ability to directly detect gravitational waves will open a completely new branch of astronomy to view the Universe, one that is inaccessible to electromagnetic-based astronomy. First generation ground-based interferometric gravitational-wave detectors have achieved strain sensitivities of order one part in ten to the twenty-one, at 100 Hz detection frequency. A new generation of detectors are under construction, designed to improve on the sensitivity of the first-generation detectors by a factor of 10. The quantum nature of light will broadly limit the sensitivity of these new instruments. This quantum noise will originate from the quantum vacuum fluctuations that enter the unused port of the interferometer. One of the most promising options for reducing the quantum noise impact and further increasing the sensitivity is applying quantum squeezed vacuum states. These squeezed states have lower noise in one quadrature than the vacuum state. By replacing the quantum vacuum fluctuations entering the interferometer with squeezed vacuum states, the quantum noise impact is reduced. This thesis firstly details the development of a squeezed light source that produces squeezed states applicable for enhancing interferometric gravitational-wave detectors. A doubly-resonant, travelling-wave bow-tie cavity squeezed light source is presented. For the first time, greater than 10 dB of quantum noise suppression across the gravitational-wave detection band is directly observed, and 11.6 dB of quantum noise suppression is observed above 200 Hz. This squeezing cavity design also has benefits with intrinsic isolation to backscattered light. Experiments that quantify this isolation are reported. The properties affecting squeezing magnitude and low-frequency squeezing measurement are discussed. In addition, a modified squeezing-ellipse-phase control technique for squeezed vacuum states is presented. This thesis secondly presents results from the LIGO Squeezed Light Injection Experiment, undertaken to test squeezed light injection into a 4 km interferometric gravitational-wave detector. The results of the experiment show the first measurement of squeezing-enhancement in a 4 km gravitational-wave detector, with 2.15 dB measured above 250 Hz. This represents the best sensitivity to gravitational waves yet achieved at these frequencies by any single gravitational-wave detector to date. An unknown area was whether the addition of a squeezer would introduce noise couplings that degrade the crucial low frequency sensitivity. The results demonstrate that injected squeezed states are compatible with low frequency gravitational-wave measurement. The characterisation of squeezing-injection optical losses and fluctuations of the squeezing angle are also reported. The knowledge and processes gained, from both the squeezed light source development work and the LIGO Squeezed Light Injection Experiment, will inform the design, planning and implementation of squeezed states in future gravitational-wave detectors.
Future generations of gravitational-wave detectors (GWD) are targeting an effective quantum noise reduction of 10 dB via the application of squeezed states of light. In the last joint observation run O3, the advanced large-scale GWDs LIGO and Virgo already used the squeezing technology, albeit with a moderate efficiency. Here, we report on the first successful 10 dB sensitivity enhancement of a shot-noise limited tabletop Michelson interferometer via squeezed light in the fundamental Gaussian laser mode, where we also implement the balanced homodyne detection scheme that is planned for the third GWD generation. In addition, we achieved a similarly strong quantum noise reduction when the interferometer was operated in higher-order Hermite-Gaussian modes, which are discussed for the GWD thermal noise mitigation. Our results are an important step toward the targeted quantum noise level in future GWDs and, moreover, represent significant progress in the application of nonclassical states in higher-order modes for interferometry, increased spatial resolution, and multichannel sensing.