Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Determinate Values for Quantum Observables

Roderich Tumulka

Published Apr 1, 2006• 3 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

This is a comment on J. A. Barrett's article ``The Preferred-Basis Problem and the Quantum Mechanics of Everything'' in Brit. J. Phil. Sci. 56 (2005), which concerns theories postulating that certain quantum observables have determinate values, corresponding to additional (often called ``hidden'') variables. I point out that it is far from clear, for most observables, what such a postulate is supposed to mean, unless the postulated additional variable is related to a clear ontology in space-time, such as particle world lines, string world sheets, or fields.

Related papers

Determinate Values for Quantum Observables

Roderich Tumulka

This is a comment on J. A. Barrett's article ‘The Preferred-Basis Problem and the Quantum Mechanics of Everything’ ([2005]), which concerns theories postulating that certain quantum observables have determinate values, corresponding to additional (often called ‘hidden’) variables. I point out that it is far from clear, for most observables, what such a postulate is supposed to mean, unless the postulated additional variable is related to a clear ontology in space-time, such as particle world lines, string world sheets, or fields.

arXiv:quant-ph/0605130•The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science•May 4, 2007•3 citations

BOHM AND BOHMIAN MECHANICS

G. Introzzi, Marco Rossetti

The standard, or Copenhagen, formulation of quantum mechanics postulates that the complete specification of a quantum state is given by the corresponding state vector (completeness). A different approach is possible, assuming instead the incompleteness of the theory. Additional parameters, called “hidden variables” since they are not empirically known, would be needed to completely characterize the quantum state. The knowledge of these hidden variables would allow the precise determination of the values for the observables of the quantum system. In 1952 David Bohm, starting from such an assumption, has proposed a hidden variables formulation of quantum mechanics that is empirically equivalent to standard quantum mechanics, but offers a more rational and coherent picture of reality. Bohm's model integrates the ordinary quantum theory by introducing particle coordinates as hidden variables. Therefore, particles are distinguishable and describe trajectories in space or in configuration space that are causally determinate. In this context it is possible to explain double slit experiments and interference phenomena in terms of particle trajectories. Quantum probabilities become epistemic: the probabilistic nature of physical predictions is not an intrinsic characteristic of nature, but depends on our ignorance of the exact value of the hidden variables. Since Bohm's interpretation is, both epistemologically and ontologically, a natural extension of classical mechanics to the quantum domain, the visualization of physical processes is still possible, and the corresponding picture of reality is more intuitive. Bohm's interpretation clearly also presents limits and weaknesses: a Lorentz invariant formulation of the model is still lacking, and all the observables result to be dependent on the global context (contextuality), with the only exception of position observables.

Conference on the Foundations of Quantum Mechanics: Historical Analysis and Open Questions•Jun 1, 2006•0 citations

The preferred basis problem in the many-worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics: why decoherence does not solve it

Meir Hemmo, Orly Shenker

Synthese•Jun 1, 2022•11 citations

Postulates of Quantum Mechanics

Ram Yatan Prasad Pranita

A postulate is an idea that is suggested as, or assumed to be, the basis for a theory, argument or calculation. In quantum mechanics, the postulates concern the atomic and molecular properties, which are quite far removed from everyday experience. Consequently, in this regard, these may be difficult to understand. The important point is that the postulates are justified by their ability to predict. They should also have the ability to correlate experimental facts by their general applicability. Before discussing the postulates of quantum mechanics, it will be useful to understand the meaning of two important terms: (a) dynamical variable and (b) observable. First of all, we should know about the dynamical variable. Any property of a system of interest is known as the dynamical variable. Examples are the position r, the energy E , the x -component of linear momentum px , and so on. Generally, any quantity of interest in classical mechanics is a dynamical variable. A very useful dynamical variable, which will be used later, comprise three components of the momentum vectors, which a particle in a system has when it remains at a fixed point. Now, we shall know about observable. An observable is defined as any dynamical variable that can be measured. It should be kept in mind that in classical mechanics, all dynamical variables are observables, but it is not so in quantum mechanics. In quantum mechanics, certain fundamental restrictions are imposed on simultaneously measurable variable quantities. To measure the component of the momentum vector, it is essential to make a simultaneous measurement of the position and momentum of the particle. We are aware of the fact that there exists an uncertainty relation for such kind of simultaneous measurement on microscopic particle, and the dynamical variable ‘the momentum at a point’ is not an observable. With this background in mind, we are going to introduce the basic postulates of quantum mechanics. Postulate 1 The state of the quantum mechanical objects is described by a wave function. or A quantum mechanical system of n particles is described as fully as possible by a function, ψ ( x, y, z, t ) called the wave function, which determines all the measurable quantities of the system, where x, y, z, t are spatial co-ordinates.

Foundation Books•Jan 1, 2014•0 citations

Discussion of "Contextual Values of Observables in Quantum Measurements" by J. Dressel, S. Agarwal, and A. N. Jordan

Stephen Parrott

•Feb 22, 2011•0 citations

When can hidden variables be excluded in quantum mechanics?

Baidyanath Misra

Nuovo cimento della Società italiana di fisica. A, Nuclei, particles and fields•Feb 1, 1967•34 citations
This is a comment on J. A. Barrett's article The Preferred-Basis Problem and the Quantum Mechanics of Everything'' in Brit. J. Phil. Sci. 56 (2005), which concerns theories postulating that certain quantum observables have determinate values, corresponding to additional (often called hidden'') variables. I point out that it is far from clear, for most observables, what such a postulate is supposed to mean, unless the postulated additional variable is related to a clear ontology in space-time, such as particle world lines, string world sheets, or fields.
This is a comment on J. A. Barrett's article ‘The Preferred-Basis Problem and the Quantum Mechanics of Everything’ ([2005]), which concerns theories postulating that certain quantum observables have determinate values, corresponding to additional (often called ‘hidden’) variables. I point out that it is far from clear, for most observables, what such a postulate is supposed to mean, unless the postulated additional variable is related to a clear ontology in space-time, such as particle world lines, string world sheets, or fields.
The standard, or Copenhagen, formulation of quantum mechanics postulates that the complete specification of a quantum state is given by the corresponding state vector (completeness). A different approach is possible, assuming instead the incompleteness of the theory. Additional parameters, called “hidden variables” since they are not empirically known, would be needed to completely characterize the quantum state. The knowledge of these hidden variables would allow the precise determination of the values for the observables of the quantum system. In 1952 David Bohm, starting from such an assumption, has proposed a hidden variables formulation of quantum mechanics that is empirically equivalent to standard quantum mechanics, but offers a more rational and coherent picture of reality. Bohm's model integrates the ordinary quantum theory by introducing particle coordinates as hidden variables. Therefore, particles are distinguishable and describe trajectories in space or in configuration space that are causally determinate. In this context it is possible to explain double slit experiments and interference phenomena in terms of particle trajectories. Quantum probabilities become epistemic: the probabilistic nature of physical predictions is not an intrinsic characteristic of nature, but depends on our ignorance of the exact value of the hidden variables. Since Bohm's interpretation is, both epistemologically and ontologically, a natural extension of classical mechanics to the quantum domain, the visualization of physical processes is still possible, and the corresponding picture of reality is more intuitive. Bohm's interpretation clearly also presents limits and weaknesses: a Lorentz invariant formulation of the model is still lacking, and all the observables result to be dependent on the global context (contextuality), with the only exception of position observables.
A postulate is an idea that is suggested as, or assumed to be, the basis for a theory, argument or calculation. In quantum mechanics, the postulates concern the atomic and molecular properties, which are quite far removed from everyday experience. Consequently, in this regard, these may be difficult to understand. The important point is that the postulates are justified by their ability to predict. They should also have the ability to correlate experimental facts by their general applicability. Before discussing the postulates of quantum mechanics, it will be useful to understand the meaning of two important terms: (a) dynamical variable and (b) observable. First of all, we should know about the dynamical variable. Any property of a system of interest is known as the dynamical variable. Examples are the position r, the energy E , the x -component of linear momentum px , and so on. Generally, any quantity of interest in classical mechanics is a dynamical variable. A very useful dynamical variable, which will be used later, comprise three components of the momentum vectors, which a particle in a system has when it remains at a fixed point. Now, we shall know about observable. An observable is defined as any dynamical variable that can be measured. It should be kept in mind that in classical mechanics, all dynamical variables are observables, but it is not so in quantum mechanics. In quantum mechanics, certain fundamental restrictions are imposed on simultaneously measurable variable quantities. To measure the component of the momentum vector, it is essential to make a simultaneous measurement of the position and momentum of the particle. We are aware of the fact that there exists an uncertainty relation for such kind of simultaneous measurement on microscopic particle, and the dynamical variable ‘the momentum at a point’ is not an observable. With this background in mind, we are going to introduce the basic postulates of quantum mechanics. Postulate 1 The state of the quantum mechanical objects is described by a wave function. or A quantum mechanical system of n particles is described as fully as possible by a function, ψ ( x, y, z, t ) called the wave function, which determines all the measurable quantities of the system, where x, y, z, t are spatial co-ordinates.