Physics-Uspekhi

Wigner’s friend paradox: does objective reality not exist?

Aleksandr V. Belinsky

Published May 16, 2020• 12 citations

Abstract

Abstract It is shown that the lack of objective existence of the results of quantum measurements of the state of collapse of the state vector of a remote localized system cannot be proved by an experiment using the reality of violation of Bell’s inequality in the Clauser–Horne–Shimony–Holt form. Arguments of a general nature and a specific calculation example confirming this conclusion are also given.

DOI: 10.3367/ufne.2020.05.038767

Related papers

Objective Reality and the Paradox of Wigner Friends

Aleksandr V. Belinsky

Abstract Using the experiment described at https://arxiv.org/pdf/1902.05080.pdf as an example, it has been shown that the absence of the objective existence of the results of quantum measurements cannot be rigorously proved based on the registration of the violation of the Bell inequality in the form of Clauser–Horne–Shimony–Holt. Universal arguments are also presented to generalize this inference.

Optics and SpectroscopySep 1, 20202 citations

Wigner's friend paradox: objective reality does not exist?

Belinsky, Alexander

It is shown that the absence of an objective existence of the results of quantum measurements cannot be proved by known experiments. There are also general arguments confirming this conclusion.

arXiv:1905.10563May 25, 20191 citation

Объективная реальность и парадокс друзей Вигнера

А. В. Белинский

Using the example of the experiment https://arxiv.org/pdf/1902.05080.pdf, it is shown that the absence of an objective existence of quantum measurement results cannot be rigorously proved based on the recording of the violation of Bell's inequality in the form of Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt. There are also general arguments summarizing this conclusion.

Журнал технической физикиJan 1, 20201 citation

Is a nondemolition measurement of the quantum state vector collapse of a remote localised system possible?

Aleksandr V. Belinsky

Abstract By the example of an experiment that implements, according to its authors, Wigner friends’ paradox, the impossibility of measuring the state vector collapse of a remote localised system is shown. It is also found that the objectivity of the results of quantum measurements is not violated in this case.

Quantum ElectronicsMay 1, 20203 citations

The original Wigner’s friend paradox within a realist toy model

Matteo Lostaglio, Joseph Bowles

The original Wigner’s friend paradox is a gedankenexperiment involving an observer described by an external agent. The paradox highlights the tension between unitary evolution and collapse in quantum theory, and is sometimes taken as requiring a reassessment of the notion of objective reality. In this note, however, we present a classical toy model in which (i) the contradicting predictions at the heart of the thought experiment are reproduced (ii) every system is in a well-defined state at all times. The toy model shows how puzzles such as Wigner’s friend’s experience of being in a superposition, conflicts between different agents’ descriptions of the experiment, the positioning of the Heisenberg’s cut and the apparent lack of objectivity of measurement outcomes can be explained within a classical model where there exists an objective state of affairs about every physical system at all times. Within the model, the debate surrounding the original Wigner’s friend thought experiment and its resolution have striking similarities with arguments concerning the nature of the second law of thermodynamics. The same conclusion however does not apply to more recent extensions of the gedankenexperiment featuring multiple encapsulated observers, and shows that such extensions are indeed necessary avoid simple classical explanations.

arXiv:2101.11032Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering SciencesOct 1, 202141 citations

Classical Information and Collapse in Wigner’s Friend Setups

Veronika Baumann

The famous Wigner's friend experiment considers an observer-the friend-and a superobserver-Wigner-who treats the friend as a quantum system and her interaction with other quantum systems as unitary dynamics. This is at odds with the friend describing this interaction via collapse dynamics, if she interacts with the quantum system in a way that she would consider a measurement. These different descriptions constitute the Wigner's friend paradox. Extended Wigner's friend experiments combine the original thought experiment with non-locality setups. This allows for deriving local friendliness inequalities, similar to Bell's theorem, which can be violated for certain extended Wigner's friend scenarios. A Wigner's friend paradox and the violation of local friendliness inequalities require that no classical record exists, which reveals the result the friend observed during her measurement. Otherwise, Wigner agrees with his friend's description and no local friendliness inequality can be violated. In this article, I introduce classical communication between Wigner and his friend and discuss its effects on the simple as well as extended Wigner's friend experiments. By controlling the properties of a (quasi) classical communication channel between Wigner and the friend, one can regulate how much outcome information about the friend's measurement is revealed. This gives a smooth transition between the paradoxical description and the possibility of violating local friendliness inequalities, on the one hand, and the effectively collapsed case, on the other hand.

arXiv:2308.08260EntropyOct 6, 20235 citations