Proof-of-principle test of coherent-state continuous variable quantum key distribution through turbulent atmosphere (Conference Presentation)
Ivan D. Derkach, Christian Peuntinger, László Ruppert, Bettina Heim, Kevin Günthner, Vladyslav C. Usenko, Dominique Elser, Christoph Marquardt, Radim Filip, Gerd Leuchs
Continuous-variable quantum key distribution is a practical application of quantum information theory that is aimed at generation of secret cryptographic key between two remote trusted parties and that uses multi-photon quantum states as carriers of key bits. Remote parties share the secret key via a quantum channel, that presumably is under control of of an eavesdropper, and which properties must be taken into account in the security analysis. Well-studied fiber-optical quantum channels commonly possess stable transmittance and low noise levels, while free-space channels represent a simpler, less demanding and more flexible alternative, but suffer from atmospheric effects such as turbulence that in particular causes a non-uniform transmittance distribution referred to as fading. Nonetheless free-space channels, providing an unobstructed line-of-sight, are more apt for short, mid-range and potentially long-range (using satellites) communication and will play an important role in the future development and implementation of QKD networks. It was previously theoretically shown that coherent-state CV QKD should be in principle possible to implement over a free-space fading channel, but strong transmittance fluctuations result in the significant modulation-dependent channel excess noise. In this regime the post-selection of highly transmitting sub-channels may be needed, which can even restore the security of the protocol in the strongly turbulent channels. We now report the first proof-of-principle experimental test of coherent state CV QKD protocol using different levels Gaussian modulation over a mid-range (1.6-kilometer long) free-space atmospheric quantum channel. The transmittance of the link was characterized using intensity measurements for the reference but channel estimation using the modulated coherent states was also studied. We consider security against Gaussian collective attacks, that were shown to be optimal against CV QKD protocols . We assumed a general entangling cloner collective attack (modeled using data obtained from the state measurement results on both trusted sides of the protocol), that allows to purify the noise added in the quantum channel . Our security analysis of coherent-state protocol also took into account the effect of imperfect channel estimation, limited post-processing efficiency and finite data ensemble size on the performance of the protocol. In this regime we observe the positive key rate even without the need of applying post-selection. We show the positive improvement of the key rate with increase of the modulation variance, still remaining low enough to tolerate the transmittance fluctuations. The obtained results show that coherent-state CV QKD protocol that uses real free-space atmospheric channel can withstand negative influence of transmittance fluctuations, limited post-processing efficiency, imperfect channel estimation and other finite-size effects, and be successfully implemented. Our result paves the way to the full-scale implementation of the CV QKD in real free-space channels at mid-range distances.
Continuous-variable quantum key distribution is a practical application of quantum information theory that is aimed at generation of secret cryptographic key between two remote trusted parties and that uses multi-photon quantum states as carriers of key bits. Remote parties share the secret key via a quantum channel, that presumably is under control of of an eavesdropper, and which properties must be taken into account in the security analysis. Well-studied fiber-optical quantum channels commonly possess stable transmittance and low noise levels, while free-space channels represent a simpler, less demanding and more flexible alternative, but suffer from atmospheric effects such as turbulence that in particular causes a non-uniform transmittance distribution referred to as fading. Nonetheless free-space channels, providing an unobstructed line-of-sight, are more apt for short, mid-range and potentially long-range (using satellites) communication and will play an important role in the future development and implementation of QKD networks. It was previously theoretically shown that coherent-state CV QKD should be in principle possible to implement over a free-space fading channel, but strong transmittance fluctuations result in the significant modulation-dependent channel excess noise. In this regime the post-selection of highly transmitting sub-channels may be needed, which can even restore the security of the protocol in the strongly turbulent channels. We now report the first proof-of-principle experimental test of coherent state CV QKD protocol using different levels Gaussian modulation over a mid-range (1.6-kilometer long) free-space atmospheric quantum channel. The transmittance of the link was characterized using intensity measurements for the reference but channel estimation using the modulated coherent states was also studied. We consider security against Gaussian collective attacks, that were shown to be optimal against CV QKD protocols . We assumed a general entangling cloner collective attack (modeled using data obtained from the state measurement results on both trusted sides of the protocol), that allows to purify the noise added in the quantum channel . Our security analysis of coherent-state protocol also took into account the effect of imperfect channel estimation, limited post-processing efficiency and finite data ensemble size on the performance of the protocol. In this regime we observe the positive key rate even without the need of applying post-selection. We show the positive improvement of the key rate with increase of the modulation variance, still remaining low enough to tolerate the transmittance fluctuations. The obtained results show that coherent-state CV QKD protocol that uses real free-space atmospheric channel can withstand negative influence of transmittance fluctuations, limited post-processing efficiency, imperfect channel estimation and other finite-size effects, and be successfully implemented. Our result paves the way to the full-scale implementation of the CV QKD in real free-space channels at mid-range distances.
Continuous-variable (CV) quantum key distribution (QKD) allows for quantum secure communication with the benefit of being close to classical coherent communication. In recent years, CV QKD protocols using a discrete number of displaced coherent states have been studied intensively as the modulation can be directly implemented with real devices with finite resolution. Until now, experiments only calculated key rates in the asymptotic regime. Here, we present a CV QKD system using discrete modulation that is especially designed for atmospheric channels. We use polarization encoding to exploit the nonbirefringent nature of the turbulent atmosphere. This allows to expand CV QKD networks beyond the existing fiber backbone. In a laboratory demonstration with a static 3-decibel loss channel, we implemented a recently developed security proof allowing to calculate composable finite-size key rates against independently and identically distributed collective attacks. We applied the full QKD protocol including a quantum random number generator, error correction, and privacy amplification to extract secret keys.
Quantum information processing uses the laws of quantum physics to perform tasks that are infeasible or impossible classically. Within this broader programme, quantum communication has emerged as one of the most practically mature sub-fields of quantum information science, with several proposed protocols having already been demonstrated over deployed optical fibre and free-space links. Of the various platforms available for encoding quantum information for communication, the continuous-variable (CV) framework encodes information in the quadratures of the electromagnetic field and is therefore directly compatible with the existing machinery of classical coherent optical communications. The most prominent CV protocol is continuous-variable quantum key distribution (CV-QKD), which establishes an information-theoretically secure cryptographic key between two spatially separated parties. Because CV-QKD reuses much of the hardware of classical coherent telecommunications, including off-the-shelf lasers, modulators, and balanced detectors, it is a leading candidate for the deployment of quantum-secured communication over standard optical fibre networks. The development of CV-QKD has typically proceeded with the underlying physics dictating the engineering. Security proofs, often relying on the Gaussian optimality of collective attacks, set the structure of the protocol, and the practical system is then built to satisfy the assumptions on which those proofs depend. Contributions of this thesis adopt the opposite view, taking the practical engineering of high-rate CV-QKD systems as the starting point and developing the theoretical machinery required to support it. The first contribution is the formalisation of one-round sliced reconciliation with guard-band post-selection as a key distillation scheme designed for real-time, high-throughput operation. Originally introduced experimentally as a means to stabilise bit error rates and enable the use of fixed-rate error correction codes at high symbol rates, guard-band post-selection is shown here to identify the guard-band span as a free parameter that can be tuned to hold the quantum bit error rate approximately constant across a range of channel conditions. However, conditioning on accepted data produces non-Gaussian post-selected statistics that lie outside the reach of standard Gaussian-optimality security arguments, which motivates the remaining two contributions. The second contribution is an asymptotic security analysis of guard-band post-selected CV-QKD against arbitrary collective attacks, no longer restricted to Gaussian adversaries. By using a quantum channel estimate as side information and by lifting reduced-state distances to purification distances via entropic continuity bounds, security is certified against the class of channels lying close to a Gaussian thermal-loss reference, with a key-rate penalty that scales with the energy-constrained diamond distance to that reference. The third contribution is the experimental basis required to apply this framework in practice. A lightweight three-stage protocol for quantum channel estimation is proposed and demonstrated, which repurposes the Gaussian probe constellation already present in the CV-QKD signal and requires no additional hardware or modifications to the underlying protocol. Over single-mode optical fibre at distances from 10 km to 50 km, the protocol produces physically valid process tensor estimates whose energy-constrained diamond distances to a Gaussian reference channel remain on the order of 10^(-3) throughout. Together, these three contributions provide a treatment of post-selected Gaussian-modulated CV-QKD in which the engineering, the security theory, and the channel characterisation are designed to operate together within a deployable system.
Entanglement properties of Gaussian states of light as well as the security of continuous variable quantum key distribution with Gaussian states in free-space fading channels are studied. These qualities are shown to be sensitive to the statistical properties of the transmittance distribution in the cases when entanglement is strong or when channel excess noise is present. Fading, i.e. transmission fluctuations, caused by beam wandering due to atmospheric turbulence, is a frequent challenge in free-space communication. We introduce a method of fading discrimination and subsequent post-selection of the corresponding sub-states and show that it can improve the entanglement resource and restore the security of the key distribution over a realistic fading link. Furthermore, the optimal post-selection strategy in combination with an optimized entangled resource is shown to drastically increase the protocol's robustness to excess noise, which is confirmed for experimentally measured fading channel characteristics. The stability of the result against finite data ensemble size and imperfect channel estimation is also addressed.
Entanglement properties of Gaussian states of light as well as the security of continuous variable quantum key distribution with Gaussian states in free-space fading channels are studied. These qualities are shown to be sensitive to the statistical properties of the transmittance distribution in the cases when entanglement is strong or when channel excess noise is present. Fading, i.e. transmission fluctuations, caused by beam wandering due to atmospheric turbulence, is a frequent challenge in free-space communication. We introduce a method of fading discrimination and subsequent post-selection of the corresponding sub-states and show that it can improve the entanglement resource and restore the security of the key distribution over a realistic fading link. Furthermore, the optimal post-selection strategy in combination with an optimized entangled resource is shown to drastically increase the protocol's robustness to excess noise, which is confirmed for experimentally measured fading channel characteristics. The stability of the result against finite data ensemble size and imperfect channel estimation is also addressed.
The survival of Gaussian quantum states in a turbulent atmospheric channel is of crucial importance in free-space continuous-variable (CV) quantum key distribution (QKD), in which the transmission coefficient will fluctuate in time, thus resulting in non-Gaussian quantum states. Different from quantum hacking of the imperfections of practical devices, here we propose a different type of attack by exploiting the security loopholes that occur in a real lossy channel. Under a turbulent atmospheric environment, the Gaussian states are inevitably afflicted by decoherence, which would cause a degradation of the transmitted entanglement. Therefore, an eavesdropper can perform an intercept-resend attack by applying an entanglement-distillation operation on the transmitted non-Gaussian mixed states, which allows the eavesdropper to bias the estimation of the parameters and renders the final keys shared between the legitimate parties insecure. Our proposal highlights the practical CV QKD vulnerabilities with free-space quantum channels, including the satellite-to-earth links, ground-to-ground links, and a link from moving objects to ground stations.
We address the applicability of quantum key distribution (QKD) with continuous-variable (CV) coherent and squeezed signal states of light over long-distance satellite-based links, considering low Earth orbits in the advantageous downlink scenario and taking into account strong varying channel attenuation (referred to as fading), atmospheric turbulence and finite data ensemble size effects.The study is motivated by the possibility to use highly efficient homodyne detection for CV protocols, which can serve as filter of background radiation due to matching of the quantum signal to a narrowband intense local oscillator beam.Considering feasible Gaussian modulation, compatible with the most advanced security proofs, we obtain tight security bounds on the untrusted excess noise at the channel output, which suggest that the protocols are very sensitive to the channel noise at the respective loss levels.In this regime, either a set-up stabilization resulting in drastic decrease of noise or relaxation of security assumptions to individual or passive collective attacks is required for implementation over the low Earth orbit satellites.Relaxation of security assumptions can be particularly motivated by the possibility of line-of-sight control of the absence of equipment capable of active collective eavesdropping attacks using quantum memories.Furthermore, splitting the satellite pass into discrete segments and extracting the keys from each rather than from the overall single pass allows one to effectively improve robustness against the untrusted channel noise and establish a secure key even under active collective attacks.Such satellite pass segmentation provides another viable option to reduce channel fading thus improving the secure key rate and allowing to establish the secure link with satellites at higher altitudes.We show that the use of signal squeezing can make the protocols more applicable in the satellite links, allowing for higher attenuation and levels of noise at the given security assumptions, and it has to be optimized in the collective attacks scenario.On the other hand, in the case of trusted noise assumption and at high repetition rates, squeezed-state CV QKD can tolerate attenuation levels up to 42 dB, allowing for higher orbit altitudes or smaller receiving telescope apertures.The obtained results are promising for satellite-based QKD, potentially applicable in daylight conditions.