arXiv:2510.06971 · Physical Review Research

Realistic threat models for fiber and free-space continuous variable quantum key distribution

Zhiyue Zuo, Masoud Ghalaii, Stefano Pirandola

Published Jan 21, 2026• 2 citations

Abstract

Future global quantum communication networks, or quantum internet, will realize high-rate secure communication and entanglement distribution for large-scale users over long distances. Continuous variable (CV) quantum key distribution (QKD) provides a powerful setting for secure quantum communications, thanks to the use of room-temperature off-the-shelf optical devices and the potential to reach high rates. However, the achievable performance of CV-QKD protocols is fundamentally limited by the fact that they appear to be fragile to both loss and noise. In this study, we provide a general framework for analyzing the composable finite-size security of CV-QKD with Gaussian-modulated coherent-state (GMCS) protocol under various levels of trust for the loss and noise experienced by the users of the protocol. Our work is comprehensive of several practical scenarios, encompassing both active and passive eavesdropping configurations, with both wired (i.e., fiber-based) and wireless (i.e., free-space and satellite-based) quantum communication channels. Our numerical results evaluate the robustness of the GMCS protocol under varying levels of trust and demonstrate that it is difficult for a practical protocol to remain robust against untrusted loss at the transmitter. In the wireless case, we analyze a scenario with a sun-synchronous satellite, showing that its key distribution rate, even with the worst level of trust, can outperform a ground chain of ideal quantum repeaters. Our results indicate that—when it comes to engineering and optimizing quantum-safe networks—it is essential to mitigate the shortcomings caused by critical trade-offs between rate performance, trust level, system noise, and communication distance.

DOI: 10.1103/hq32-x7gt

Related papers

Composable security for continuous variable quantum key distribution: Trust levels and practical key rates in wired and wireless networks

Stefano Pirandola

Continuous variable (CV) quantum key distribution (QKD) provides a powerful setting for secure quantum communications, thanks to the use of room-temperature off-the-shelf optical devices and the potential to reach much higher rates than the standard discrete-variable counterpart. In this paper, we provide a general framework for studying the composable finite-size security of CV-QKD with Gaussian-modulated coherent-state protocols under various levels of trust for the loss and noise experienced by the parties. Our paper considers both wired (i.e., fiber-based) and wireless (i.e., free-space) quantum communications. In the latter case, we show that high key rates are achievable for short-range optical wireless (LiFi) in secure quantum networks with both fixed and mobile devices. Finally, we extend our investigation to microwave wireless (WiFi) discussing security and feasibility of CV-QKD for very short-range applications.

arXiv:2203.00706Physical Review ResearchOct 7, 202194 citations

Security of Satellite-Based CV-QKD under Realistic Assumptions

Ziwen Pan, Ivan B. Djordjević

With the vastly growing need for secure communication, quantum key distribution (QKD) has been developed to provide high security for communications against potential attacks from the fast-developing quantum computers. Among different QKD protocols, continuous variable (CV-) QKD employing Gaussian modulated coherent states has been promising for its complete security proof and its compatibility with current communication systems in implementation with homodyne or heterodyne detection. Since satellite communication has been more and more important in developing global communication networks, there have been concerns about the security in satellite communication and how we should evaluate the security of CV-QKD in such scenarios. To better analyse the secure key rate (SKR) in this case, in this invited paper we investigate the CV-QKD SKR lower bounds under realistic assumptions over a satellite-to-satellite channel. We also investigate the eavesdropper's best strategy to apply in these scenarios. We demonstrate that for these channel conditions with well-chosen carrier centre frequency and receiver aperture size, based on channel parameters, we can optimize SKR correspondingly. The proposed satellite-based QKD system provides high security level for the coming 5G and beyond networks, the Internet of things, self-driving cars, and other fast-developing applications.

International Conference on Transparent Optical NetworksJul 1, 202013 citations

Continuous Variable Quantum Key Distribution over Long Distances

Masoud Ghalaii

Quantum key distribution (QKD) is fundamentally different from most classical key distribution schemes, such as Diffie-Hellman key exchange, in the sense that no computational complexity assumption is required on the power of adversaries to prove its security. QKD relies on basic laws of quantum physics and it is proven that it can enable highly secure data communication. Such achievements, however, are facing technological problems that have to be resolved in order to provide a viable solution to a large group of customers. While there are discrete-variable QKD schemes, which rely on encoding data in discrete degrees of freedom, such as polarization of single photons, in this thesis, we focus on the continuous-variable QKD (CV-QKD) protocols, in which data is encoded on the quadratures of light. Currently, one of the major drawbacks of CV-QKD is its poor performance at long distances. Nevertheless, such a limitation in CV-QKD can be overcome with the assistance of quantum repeaters that rely on entanglement distillation via noiseless linear amplifiers (NLAs). Such systems can, in principle, offer large secret key rates over long distances. In this thesis, we aim to provide a realistic analysis of a CV-QKD protocol running over quantum scissors (QSs) as realistic NLAs. We will report the obstacles that one could face in realizing CV-QKD in such a scenario. A review of CV-QKD and QS-based NLAs will be given, based on which QS-assisted CV-QKD is proposed. We, particularly, focus on the modelling of the QSs' structure and their effect on the secret key rate aiming to find operational regimes where the performance of the QKD scheme is enhanced. This study paves the way for implementing long-distance CV-QKD protocols that rely on QS/NLA devices over CV quantum repeaters. \n \nIn this thesis, we also consider and account for a realistic analysis of a CV-QKD protocol with non-Gaussian modulation, which is assisted by the means of QSs. We will show that, while we have to deal with similar obstacles as in the Gaussian modulation, we can potentially improve performance of the non-Gaussian modulation protocol. \n \nAs an alternative approach to extend the secure distance of CV-QKD protocols, the last part of this thesis is devoted to presenting realistic threat models for satellite QKD, wherein we consider several eavesdropping scenarios by limiting eavesdroppers' access to the trusted ground and/or satellite stations. In such scenarios, the eavesdropper has only limited access to the sender and/or receiver stations. \nFor example, we will explore the case where an eavesdropper can only receive an attenuated version of the transmitted signals. As well, we will focus on the case where Eve's signals would reach the receiver via a lossy channel inaccessible to the eavesdropper. We show that, in the case of both Gaussian and non-Gaussian protocols, this limitation would allow trusted parties to achieve higher key rates than what can be achieved when unrestricted eavesdropping is possible.

Sep 30, 20190 citations

Microwave continuous-variable quantum key distribution in the open air

Y. Feng, Gang Xu, Xiu‐Bo Chen +1 more

Continuous-variable quantum key distribution (CV-QKD) enables the efficient distribution of unconditionally secure keys for both communicating parties. Despite significant advancements in optical-based CV-QKD, a persistent challenge is the limited resilience of optical quantum signals to atmospheric noise in free-space channels. This susceptibility leads to considerable degradation in the performance of optical CV-QKD systems, particularly under adverse climatic conditions. Meanwhile, recent advancements in superconducting quantum computing have driven the demand for quantum communication between spatially separated superconducting processors operating at microwave frequencies. To solve the problems, we propose a Gaussian-modulated coherent-state protocol operating at microwave frequencies, utilizing traveling-wave parametric amplifiers to generate entangled states. Our numerical analysis demonstrates that CV-QKD at microwave frequencies enables secure communication in a free-space channel at room temperature. Furthermore, we show that this protocol outperforms the THz frequency protocol over a distance of 20 m and exhibits stronger immunity to interference. Finally, we consider the impact of microwave antenna gain on the protocol's performance, highlighting the decisive role of antenna gain in determining the maximum transmission distance in practical application scenarios.

Physical Review AApr 30, 20250 citations

Free-space continuous-variable quantum key distribution under high background noise

Xue-Tao Zheng, Qi-Fa Zhang, Jie Ling +2 more

Abstract One of the difficulties in the application of quantum communication is the fragility of its encoded quantum states. Conventional quantum key distribution (QKD) requires strict filtering operations at the receiver. Any ambient light entering the system can significantly increase the bit error rate and even render the system inoperable. We present a continuous-variable quantum key distribution (CV-QKD) system that can function effectively during the day or even on rainy days without complex filtering operations. The Gaussian modulated coherent state continuous-variable quantum key distribution (GMCS CV-QKD) system demonstrates robustness, maintaining a secure key rate (SKR) of more than 100 kbps when operating at a frequency of 10 MHz, which lays the foundation for low-cost, highly robust free-space quantum communication.

npj Quantum InformationMar 27, 202526 citations

Experimental Demonstration of Free-Space Unidimensional Continuous-Variable Quantum Key Distribution Under High Detector Noise

Rachita Nandan, Jayanth Ramakrishnan, Shashi Prabhakar +1 more

Continuous-variable quantum key distribution (CV-QKD), which uses quadratures of the electromagnetic field, enables practical quantum communication using standard telecommunication technologies. Unidimensional CV-QKD (UD-CVQKD) simplifies the implementation by restricting modulation to a single quadrature. In this work, we experimentally demonstrate a free-space Gaussian-modulated UD-CVQKD system operating under a high detector electronic-noise regime (1.4 shot-noise units). The system employs polarized coherent states with signal and local oscillator co-propagating in the same spatial mode in orthogonal polarizations, ensuring stable interference. System security is analyzed under both untrusted (UTD) and trusted (TD) detector noise models. While no positive secret key rate is obtained under the UTD model, the TD model enables secure key generation over a finite range of modulation variances, highlighting the critical role of detector trust in high-noise conditions. A maximum secret key rate of 270 kbps is achieved at an optimal modulation variance of 11.57. Furthermore, secure operation requires high-transmittance (low-loss) channels under such noise conditions. This study demonstrates the practical feasibility of free-space UD-CVQKD in realistic high electronic-noise detection constraints and highlights detector electronic noise as a key limiting factor in practical systems.

quant-pharXiv:2606.07206Jun 8, 20260 citations