Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Entanglement-distillation attack on continuous-variable quantum key distribution in a turbulent atmospheric channel

Ying Guo, Cailang Xie, Qin Liao, Wei Zhao, Guihua Zeng, Duan Huang

Published Aug 21, 2017• 52 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The survival of Gaussian quantum states in a turbulent atmospheric channel is of crucial importance in free-space continuous-variable (CV) quantum key distribution (QKD), in which the transmission coefficient will fluctuate in time, thus resulting in non-Gaussian quantum states. Different from quantum hacking of the imperfections of practical devices, here we propose a different type of attack by exploiting the security loopholes that occur in a real lossy channel. Under a turbulent atmospheric environment, the Gaussian states are inevitably afflicted by decoherence, which would cause a degradation of the transmitted entanglement. Therefore, an eavesdropper can perform an intercept-resend attack by applying an entanglement-distillation operation on the transmitted non-Gaussian mixed states, which allows the eavesdropper to bias the estimation of the parameters and renders the final keys shared between the legitimate parties insecure. Our proposal highlights the practical CV QKD vulnerabilities with free-space quantum channels, including the satellite-to-earth links, ground-to-ground links, and a link from moving objects to ground stations.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.96.022320

Related papers

Quantum hacking of free-space continuous-variable quantum key distribution by using a machine-learning technique

Wenti Huang, Yiyu Mao, Cailang Xie +1 more

The transmission coefficient of the free-space channel is fluctuating due to the occurrence of random fluctuations of the refractive index and noise. The Gaussian-modulated quantum states of light may degrade into a non-Gaussian mixture at a certain probability after being transmitted through the free-space channel. In such a situation, Eve can apply an entanglement-distillation attack to steal secret information without it being revealed if Alice and Bob regard the practical fluctuation losses as constant. However, the entanglement-distillation attack is available only when the transmitting states are a non-Gaussian mixture; otherwise, Eve will expose herself. Exploiting this loophole and considering the limitations of the attack, we enhance Eve's eavesdropping ability by integrating a machine-learning technique with the entanglement-distillation attack. With the help of convolutional neural network (CNN, one of the most popular machine leaning tools), Eve can choose the best opportunity to launch the entanglement-distillation attack. Therefore, Eve has a chance to bias the estimation of the parameters by improving the entanglement resource of the mixed states, which allows Eve to render the final keys shared between the legitimate parties insecure. Our proposed CNN-based entanglement-distillation attack does not require additional resources and can be implemented using simple means based on the present technologies.

Physical Review A•Jul 15, 2019•11 citations

Parameter estimation of atmospheric continuous-variable quantum key distribution

Geng Chai, Zhengwen Cao, Weiqi Liu +3 more

Atmospheric effects are the chief threats to the quantum properties of propagating quantum signals and may degrade the performance of quantum key distribution seriously. As one of the most important parts of continuous-variable quantum key distribution (CVQKD), a parameter estimation method has not been specially proposed in an atmospheric channel, and usually the security analysis is based on the assumption that the relevant parameters, especially the excess noise, have been previously obtained. Here we propose a parameter estimation method for Gaussian modulated coherent state continuous-variable quantum key distribution over the atmospheric link, and we investigate the impact of the atmospheric channel on the estimated values of the parameters. Based on this method, we study theoretically the effect of link fluctuations on the achievable secret key rate of CVQKD under different practical transmitted conditions. The results show that this method is unified with the physical model and can effectively resist entanglement-distillation attack. The proposed method fills in the blank of parameter estimation for implementation of practical atmospheric CVQKD.

Physical Review A•Mar 18, 2019•40 citations

Proof-of-principle test of coherent-state continuous variable quantum key distribution through turbulent atmosphere (Conference Presentation)

Ivan D. Derkach, Christian Peuntinger, László Ruppert +7 more

Continuous-variable quantum key distribution is a practical application of quantum information theory that is aimed at generation of secret cryptographic key between two remote trusted parties and that uses multi-photon quantum states as carriers of key bits. Remote parties share the secret key via a quantum channel, that presumably is under control of of an eavesdropper, and which properties must be taken into account in the security analysis. Well-studied fiber-optical quantum channels commonly possess stable transmittance and low noise levels, while free-space channels represent a simpler, less demanding and more flexible alternative, but suffer from atmospheric effects such as turbulence that in particular causes a non-uniform transmittance distribution referred to as fading. Nonetheless free-space channels, providing an unobstructed line-of-sight, are more apt for short, mid-range and potentially long-range (using satellites) communication and will play an important role in the future development and implementation of QKD networks. It was previously theoretically shown that coherent-state CV QKD should be in principle possible to implement over a free-space fading channel, but strong transmittance fluctuations result in the significant modulation-dependent channel excess noise. In this regime the post-selection of highly transmitting sub-channels may be needed, which can even restore the security of the protocol in the strongly turbulent channels. We now report the first proof-of-principle experimental test of coherent state CV QKD protocol using different levels Gaussian modulation over a mid-range (1.6-kilometer long) free-space atmospheric quantum channel. The transmittance of the link was characterized using intensity measurements for the reference but channel estimation using the modulated coherent states was also studied. We consider security against Gaussian collective attacks, that were shown to be optimal against CV QKD protocols . We assumed a general entangling cloner collective attack (modeled using data obtained from the state measurement results on both trusted sides of the protocol), that allows to purify the noise added in the quantum channel . Our security analysis of coherent-state protocol also took into account the effect of imperfect channel estimation, limited post-processing efficiency and finite data ensemble size on the performance of the protocol. In this regime we observe the positive key rate even without the need of applying post-selection. We show the positive improvement of the key rate with increase of the modulation variance, still remaining low enough to tolerate the transmittance fluctuations. The obtained results show that coherent-state CV QKD protocol that uses real free-space atmospheric channel can withstand negative influence of transmittance fluctuations, limited post-processing efficiency, imperfect channel estimation and other finite-size effects, and be successfully implemented. Our result paves the way to the full-scale implementation of the CV QKD in real free-space channels at mid-range distances.

•Dec 7, 2016•2 citations

Composable free-space continuous-variable quantum key distribution using discrete modulation

Kevin Jaksch, Thomas Dirmeier, Yannick Weiser +16 more

Continuous-variable (CV) quantum key distribution (QKD) allows for quantum secure communication with the benefit of being close to classical coherent communication. In recent years, CV QKD protocols using a discrete number of displaced coherent states have been studied intensively as the modulation can be directly implemented with real devices with finite resolution. Until now, experiments only calculated key rates in the asymptotic regime. Here, we present a CV QKD system using discrete modulation that is especially designed for atmospheric channels. We use polarization encoding to exploit the nonbirefringent nature of the turbulent atmosphere. This allows to expand CV QKD networks beyond the existing fiber backbone. In a laboratory demonstration with a static 3-decibel loss channel, we implemented a recently developed security proof allowing to calculate composable finite-size key rates against independently and identically distributed collective attacks. We applied the full QKD protocol including a quantum random number generator, error correction, and privacy amplification to extract secret keys.

arXiv:2410.12915•Science Advances•Jun 12, 2026•3 citations

CV-QKD with Gaussian and Non-Gaussian Entangled States over Satellite-Based Channels

Nedasadat Hosseinidehaj, Robert Malaney

In this work we investigate the effectiveness of continuous-variable (CV) entangled states, transferred through high-loss atmospheric channels, as a means of viable quantum key distribution (QKD) between terrestrial stations and low-Earth orbit (LEO) satellites. In particular, we investigate the role played by the Gaussian CV states as compared to non-Gaussian states. We find that beam-wandering induced atmospheric losses results in QKD performance levels that are in general quite different from those found in fixed-attenuation channels. For example, circumstances can be found where no QKD is viable at some fixed loss in fiber but is viable at the same mean loss in fading channels. We also find that, in some circumstances, the QKD relative performance of Gaussian and non-Gaussian states can in atmospheric channels be the reverse of that found in fixed-attenuation channels. These findings show that the nature of the atmospheric channel can have a large impact on the QKD performance. Our results should prove useful for emerging global quantum communications that use LEO satellites as communication relays.

arXiv:1605.01808•Globecom•Dec 1, 2016•18 citations

Free-space Continuous-Variable Quantum Key Distribution in moderate and strong atmospheric turbulence

Hailong Zhang, Xingran Chen, Jianhong Shi

Abstract Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) has been widely applied due to its theoretical one-time pad encryption. Typically employing laser beam as carrier, quantum states are transmitted through optical fibers or free-space channels, with the latter being more commonly adopted. However, compared to optical fibers, free-space links are more susceptible to external environmental factors, particularly atmospheric conditions. Beam propagation through the atmosphere experiences diffraction, refraction, and intensity attenuation, which can degrade key distribution efficiency and even prevent key generation at the receiver. The atmospheric turbulence poses the most significant challenge in all influencing factors, especially for the commonly encountered moderate-to-strong turbulence regimes. Therefore, in this work, we develop a phase screen model and turbulence-dominated transmittance model to comprehensively investigate the impact of various key parameters on optical beam propagation through turbulent atmospheres. Furthermore, we derive the key rate for the CV-QKD protocol using a TMSV (two-mode squeezed vacuum) state and perform numerical simulations.

Chinese Physics B•May 11, 2026•0 citations
The survival of Gaussian quantum states in a turbulent atmospheric channel is of crucial importance in free-space continuous-variable (CV) quantum key distribution (QKD), in which the transmission coefficient will fluctuate in time, thus resulting in non-Gaussian quantum states. Different from quantum hacking of the imperfections of practical devices, here we propose a different type of attack by exploiting the security loopholes that occur in a real lossy channel. Under a turbulent atmospheric environment, the Gaussian states are inevitably afflicted by decoherence, which would cause a degradation of the transmitted entanglement. Therefore, an eavesdropper can perform an intercept-resend attack by applying an entanglement-distillation operation on the transmitted non-Gaussian mixed states, which allows the eavesdropper to bias the estimation of the parameters and renders the final keys shared between the legitimate parties insecure. Our proposal highlights the practical CV QKD vulnerabilities with free-space quantum channels, including the satellite-to-earth links, ground-to-ground links, and a link from moving objects to ground stations.
The transmission coefficient of the free-space channel is fluctuating due to the occurrence of random fluctuations of the refractive index and noise. The Gaussian-modulated quantum states of light may degrade into a non-Gaussian mixture at a certain probability after being transmitted through the free-space channel. In such a situation, Eve can apply an entanglement-distillation attack to steal secret information without it being revealed if Alice and Bob regard the practical fluctuation losses as constant. However, the entanglement-distillation attack is available only when the transmitting states are a non-Gaussian mixture; otherwise, Eve will expose herself. Exploiting this loophole and considering the limitations of the attack, we enhance Eve's eavesdropping ability by integrating a machine-learning technique with the entanglement-distillation attack. With the help of convolutional neural network (CNN, one of the most popular machine leaning tools), Eve can choose the best opportunity to launch the entanglement-distillation attack. Therefore, Eve has a chance to bias the estimation of the parameters by improving the entanglement resource of the mixed states, which allows Eve to render the final keys shared between the legitimate parties insecure. Our proposed CNN-based entanglement-distillation attack does not require additional resources and can be implemented using simple means based on the present technologies.
Atmospheric effects are the chief threats to the quantum properties of propagating quantum signals and may degrade the performance of quantum key distribution seriously. As one of the most important parts of continuous-variable quantum key distribution (CVQKD), a parameter estimation method has not been specially proposed in an atmospheric channel, and usually the security analysis is based on the assumption that the relevant parameters, especially the excess noise, have been previously obtained. Here we propose a parameter estimation method for Gaussian modulated coherent state continuous-variable quantum key distribution over the atmospheric link, and we investigate the impact of the atmospheric channel on the estimated values of the parameters. Based on this method, we study theoretically the effect of link fluctuations on the achievable secret key rate of CVQKD under different practical transmitted conditions. The results show that this method is unified with the physical model and can effectively resist entanglement-distillation attack. The proposed method fills in the blank of parameter estimation for implementation of practical atmospheric CVQKD.
Continuous-variable quantum key distribution is a practical application of quantum information theory that is aimed at generation of secret cryptographic key between two remote trusted parties and that uses multi-photon quantum states as carriers of key bits. Remote parties share the secret key via a quantum channel, that presumably is under control of of an eavesdropper, and which properties must be taken into account in the security analysis. Well-studied fiber-optical quantum channels commonly possess stable transmittance and low noise levels, while free-space channels represent a simpler, less demanding and more flexible alternative, but suffer from atmospheric effects such as turbulence that in particular causes a non-uniform transmittance distribution referred to as fading. Nonetheless free-space channels, providing an unobstructed line-of-sight, are more apt for short, mid-range and potentially long-range (using satellites) communication and will play an important role in the future development and implementation of QKD networks. It was previously theoretically shown that coherent-state CV QKD should be in principle possible to implement over a free-space fading channel, but strong transmittance fluctuations result in the significant modulation-dependent channel excess noise. In this regime the post-selection of highly transmitting sub-channels may be needed, which can even restore the security of the protocol in the strongly turbulent channels. We now report the first proof-of-principle experimental test of coherent state CV QKD protocol using different levels Gaussian modulation over a mid-range (1.6-kilometer long) free-space atmospheric quantum channel. The transmittance of the link was characterized using intensity measurements for the reference but channel estimation using the modulated coherent states was also studied. We consider security against Gaussian collective attacks, that were shown to be optimal against CV QKD protocols . We assumed a general entangling cloner collective attack (modeled using data obtained from the state measurement results on both trusted sides of the protocol), that allows to purify the noise added in the quantum channel . Our security analysis of coherent-state protocol also took into account the effect of imperfect channel estimation, limited post-processing efficiency and finite data ensemble size on the performance of the protocol. In this regime we observe the positive key rate even without the need of applying post-selection. We show the positive improvement of the key rate with increase of the modulation variance, still remaining low enough to tolerate the transmittance fluctuations. The obtained results show that coherent-state CV QKD protocol that uses real free-space atmospheric channel can withstand negative influence of transmittance fluctuations, limited post-processing efficiency, imperfect channel estimation and other finite-size effects, and be successfully implemented. Our result paves the way to the full-scale implementation of the CV QKD in real free-space channels at mid-range distances.
Continuous-variable (CV) quantum key distribution (QKD) allows for quantum secure communication with the benefit of being close to classical coherent communication. In recent years, CV QKD protocols using a discrete number of displaced coherent states have been studied intensively as the modulation can be directly implemented with real devices with finite resolution. Until now, experiments only calculated key rates in the asymptotic regime. Here, we present a CV QKD system using discrete modulation that is especially designed for atmospheric channels. We use polarization encoding to exploit the nonbirefringent nature of the turbulent atmosphere. This allows to expand CV QKD networks beyond the existing fiber backbone. In a laboratory demonstration with a static 3-decibel loss channel, we implemented a recently developed security proof allowing to calculate composable finite-size key rates against independently and identically distributed collective attacks. We applied the full QKD protocol including a quantum random number generator, error correction, and privacy amplification to extract secret keys.
In this work we investigate the effectiveness of continuous-variable (CV) entangled states, transferred through high-loss atmospheric channels, as a means of viable quantum key distribution (QKD) between terrestrial stations and low-Earth orbit (LEO) satellites. In particular, we investigate the role played by the Gaussian CV states as compared to non-Gaussian states. We find that beam-wandering induced atmospheric losses results in QKD performance levels that are in general quite different from those found in fixed-attenuation channels. For example, circumstances can be found where no QKD is viable at some fixed loss in fiber but is viable at the same mean loss in fading channels. We also find that, in some circumstances, the QKD relative performance of Gaussian and non-Gaussian states can in atmospheric channels be the reverse of that found in fixed-attenuation channels. These findings show that the nature of the atmospheric channel can have a large impact on the QKD performance. Our results should prove useful for emerging global quantum communications that use LEO satellites as communication relays.
Abstract Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) has been widely applied due to its theoretical one-time pad encryption. Typically employing laser beam as carrier, quantum states are transmitted through optical fibers or free-space channels, with the latter being more commonly adopted. However, compared to optical fibers, free-space links are more susceptible to external environmental factors, particularly atmospheric conditions. Beam propagation through the atmosphere experiences diffraction, refraction, and intensity attenuation, which can degrade key distribution efficiency and even prevent key generation at the receiver. The atmospheric turbulence poses the most significant challenge in all influencing factors, especially for the commonly encountered moderate-to-strong turbulence regimes. Therefore, in this work, we develop a phase screen model and turbulence-dominated transmittance model to comprehensively investigate the impact of various key parameters on optical beam propagation through turbulent atmospheres. Furthermore, we derive the key rate for the CV-QKD protocol using a TMSV (two-mode squeezed vacuum) state and perform numerical simulations.