Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Realization of a single-atom-like macroscopic system to test the foundations of quantum mechanics

S. A. Emelyanov, Anthony J. Leggett

Published Sep 22, 2014• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Since the discovery of superconductivity there is an idea to test the foundations of quantum mechanics by using of low-temperature systems which demonstrate quantum behaviour on a macroscopic level. However, as it was shown by Anthony Leggett, the idea is unrealizable if such system contains indistinguishable particles obeying quantum statistics. In this work, we report on realization of a lowtemperature system comprising a great number of macroscopic orbit-like quantum states where electrons are distinguishable insofar as they are spatially separated. As a result, their macroscopic quantum behaviour becomes observable on a non-statistical level so that an experimental test becomes realizable where the foundations of quantum and relativity theories clash on the deepest level ever achieved.

Related papers

Quantum communication based on the fundamental indivisibility of macroscopic orbit-like quantum states

S. A. Emelyanov

We perform an experimental test where we directly observe light-induced electron transitions with a macroscopic spatial discontinuity. The effect is related to the fundamental indivisibility of macroscopic orbit-like quantum states reminiscent of so-called extended states in the integer quantum Hall system. The test has become realizable due to the discovering of a quantum phase with spontaneous pervasive quantum ordering reminiscent of that of a single atom. The observed transitions may be regarded as a peculiar quantum dynamics beyond relativity, which implies that the current relativistic model of universe should be replaced by a deeper quantum model. It is the Bohm's model of undivided universe, which now should involve a deeper-than-classical concept of absolute simultaneity and a deeper-than-relativistic concept of space and time. Ultimately, our test thus establishes a new hierarchy of fundamental physical theories where the de Broglie-Bohm realistic quantum theory is the deepest theory which does not contradict either classical physics or relativity but rather is beyond both. This is because the fact that quantum theory is dealing with a deeper reality where physical objects are not self-sufficient entities and therefore their discontinuous transitions are possible within an overall quantum system which may well be macroscopic.

•Sep 22, 2014•0 citations

From Relativistic to Quantum Universe: Observation of a Spatially-Discontinuous Particle Dynamics beyond Relativity

S. A. Emelyanov

We perform an experimental test where we directly observe light-induced electron transitions with a macroscopic spatial discontinuity. The effect is related to the fundamental indivisibility of macroscopic orbit-like quantum states reminiscent of so-called extended states in the integer quantum Hall system. The test has become realizable due to the discovering of a quantum phase with spontaneous pervasive quantum ordering reminiscent of that of a single atom. The observed transitions may be regarded as a peculiar quantum dynamics beyond relativity, which implies that the current relativistic model of universe should be replaced by a deeper quantum model. It is the Bohm’s model of undivided universe which now should involve a deeper-than-classical concept of absolute simultaneity and a deeper-than-relativistic concept of space and time. Ultimately, our test thus establishes a new hierarchy of fundamental physical theories where the de Broglie-Bohm realistic quantum theory is the deepest theory which does not contradict either classical physics or relativity but rather is beyond both. This is because the fact that quantum theory is dealing with a deeper reality where physical objects are not self-sufficient entities and therefore they can transit discontinuously within an overall quantum system determined by their wavefunctions.

arXiv:1409.6746•Universe•Jun 25, 2018•3 citations

Quantum mechanics and Leggett's principles of macroscopic realism

Nikolay Leonidovich Chuprikov

On the basis of our recent model of a one-dimensional (1D) completed scattering we argue that Leggett's principles of macroscopic realism must and can be extended onto the level of single electrons and atoms. These principles need three quite feasible innovations in quantum mechanics (QM): (1) at the conceptual level, QM must treat a pure time-dependent one-particle state to involve two or more macroscopically distinct alternatives for a particle as a pure {\it combined} one - the intermediate link between a pure {\it elementary} state (indecomposable into macroscopically distinct parts) and statistical mixture; (2) at the mathematical level, QM must provide the presentation of the pure time-dependent combined state as a coherent superposition of macroscopically distinct elementary states (MDESs); (3) at the experimental level, QM must provide for such states two types of measurements - those for observing the interference pattern resulting from the joint action of MDESs, and non-demolishing 'which-way' measurements for scanning the individual properties of MDESs.

arXiv:quant-ph/0610033•Oct 5, 2006•0 citations

Quantum nonlocality observable on a non-statistical level: idea, experimental evidence, fundamental consequences

S. A. Emelyanov

Today quantum nonlocality is discussed only in the context of EPR situation where we face a macroscopic system which is fundamentally indivisible insofar as it consists of entangled distant particles. But quantum formalism implies a one more type of indivisibility. It is the indivisibility of a quantum state per se regardless of its configuration in the real space. In this work, we propose an idea of how this type of indivisibility may also be relevant to macrocosm giving rise to an alternative type of quantum nonlocality which, in contrast to EPR nonlocality, is observable on a non-statistical level. It is light-induced electron transitions with macroscopic spatial discontinuity. We provide strong evidence for these transitions in a modification of low-temperature quantum Hall state of matter, which is characterized by a great number of macroscopic orbit-like quantum states. We thereby demonstrate a deeper-than-relativistic spatial dynamics requiring a deeper kinematics beyond the Minkowski model of spacetime. Such kinematics was proposed by Karl Popper as well as by John Bell through the idea of a deeper non-Lorentz-invariant spatial level identified as precisely the aether in the Lorentz-Poincare’s version of relativity. We argue that this idea may be integrated into the Bohm-Hiley’s model of undividable Universe which thus appears to be precisely the deeper-than-relativistic model relevant at any lengthscale. Ultimately, this approach opens the door to the solution of such fundamental problems as the problem of interpretation of quantum formalism as well as the problem of unification of quantum and relativity theories.

•Sep 22, 2014•0 citations

Macroscopic quantum phenomena

William J. Munro

This thesis consists of two parts. Although both are concerned with macroscopic quantum phenomena, I choose to present the two parts quite separately. Macroscopic Quantum Phenomena: Tests of Quantum Mechanics The correctness of quantum mechanics has been verified in numerous situations. A particularly strong test of quantum mechanics was suggested by Bell, who showed that the predictions of all classical theories, based as they are on the assumptions of local realism, contradict those of quantum mechanics. Later work by Greenberger, Horne, and Zeilinger showed that the GHZ phenomena also contradicts all classical theories. Experimental tests of Bells inequality performed to date support quantum mechanics (No experimental test of the GHZ phenomenon has yet been attempted). However, such tests have been so far restricted to microscopic systems in the sense that one particle is at a detector at a time. Our interest here in the first part of this thesis is in tests of quantum mechanics against local realistic theories in macroscopic or mesoscopic systems where there is a significant number of particles incident on each analyser. The states considered in the first two chapters are not simple quantum superpositions of macroscopically distinct states, but we nevertheless show how one can obtain tests of quantum mechanics in situations involving large numbers of particles. A more elementary macroscopic quantum state, and one in which the deviation from classical interpretations is striking, is the Schrodinger Cat state considered by Schrodinger in his famous "Schrodinger Cat" paradox. In Chapter Three we consider a scheme for generating such a state. The Quantum Brownian Motion Master Equation The second section of this thesis involves an examination of various aspects of the Quantum Brownian Motion Master Equation. We begin with a discussion of the recent problem occurring from the study of the quantum Brownian motion (QBM) master equation, which can occur because the QBM master equation is not of the Lindblad form. We examine two specific examples, namely the damped free particle and the two level atom. More specifically, in the case of the evolution of a free particle, we show that the equation of motion for the Wigner function (which is exactly the same as the Fokker-Planck equation for classical Brownian motion) gives unphysical results if the initial position distribution is well localised. In the case of the two level atom we show that unphysical results can also occur even in the steady state. The last chapter of the thesis involves using the quantum Brownian motion master equation to estimate the rate of diagonalisation of the off diagonal elements of a Fermion system. These elements contain the "quantum information" and hence knowledge of how long they exist can determine the type of model required to describe the semiconductor medium. Using a very simplistic approach we can show that there are two main time scales present and for normal parameters one of these is very small. If we neglect electron-electron scattering we can show that the the many electron system solution is simply a product of the one electron solutions.

•Jan 1, 1994•2 citations

Testing Einstein's objection of 1927 to quantum mechanics opens the door to purely quantum communication

S. A. Emelyanov

Single electron may have wavefunction of a macroscopic lengthscale but cannot be detected in two places. At the Solvay Conference of 1927, Einstein argued that in a combination with Bohr's postulate about wavefunction as an exhaustive characteristics of electron, this fact implies nonlocality related to the collapse of a macroscopic wavefunction of single electron. This was his objection to Bohr's quantum mechanics (QM) in favor of de Broglie's quantum theory. We perform an experimental test in low-temperature state of matter where electrons have macroscopic orbit-like wavefunctions and surprisingly observe nonlocality of that type. This nonlocality differs in principle from the well-known Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) nonlocality because the former does not imply quantum entanglement and hence is beyond the no-communication theorem. Our observation is the first empirical justification of the choice in favor of QM in compare with de Broglie's theory. Moreover, now we can expand the current concept of reality and thus open the door to a realistic interpretation of quantum formalism. Ultimately, we thus come to a quantum model of Universe based on the standard QM.

arXiv:2302.10783•Feb 10, 2023•0 citations
Since the discovery of superconductivity there is an idea to test the foundations of quantum mechanics by using of low-temperature systems which demonstrate quantum behaviour on a macroscopic level. However, as it was shown by Anthony Leggett, the idea is unrealizable if such system contains indistinguishable particles obeying quantum statistics. In this work, we report on realization of a lowtemperature system comprising a great number of macroscopic orbit-like quantum states where electrons are distinguishable insofar as they are spatially separated. As a result, their macroscopic quantum behaviour becomes observable on a non-statistical level so that an experimental test becomes realizable where the foundations of quantum and relativity theories clash on the deepest level ever achieved.
We perform an experimental test where we directly observe light-induced electron transitions with a macroscopic spatial discontinuity. The effect is related to the fundamental indivisibility of macroscopic orbit-like quantum states reminiscent of so-called extended states in the integer quantum Hall system. The test has become realizable due to the discovering of a quantum phase with spontaneous pervasive quantum ordering reminiscent of that of a single atom. The observed transitions may be regarded as a peculiar quantum dynamics beyond relativity, which implies that the current relativistic model of universe should be replaced by a deeper quantum model. It is the Bohm's model of undivided universe, which now should involve a deeper-than-classical concept of absolute simultaneity and a deeper-than-relativistic concept of space and time. Ultimately, our test thus establishes a new hierarchy of fundamental physical theories where the de Broglie-Bohm realistic quantum theory is the deepest theory which does not contradict either classical physics or relativity but rather is beyond both. This is because the fact that quantum theory is dealing with a deeper reality where physical objects are not self-sufficient entities and therefore their discontinuous transitions are possible within an overall quantum system which may well be macroscopic.
We perform an experimental test where we directly observe light-induced electron transitions with a macroscopic spatial discontinuity. The effect is related to the fundamental indivisibility of macroscopic orbit-like quantum states reminiscent of so-called extended states in the integer quantum Hall system. The test has become realizable due to the discovering of a quantum phase with spontaneous pervasive quantum ordering reminiscent of that of a single atom. The observed transitions may be regarded as a peculiar quantum dynamics beyond relativity, which implies that the current relativistic model of universe should be replaced by a deeper quantum model. It is the Bohm’s model of undivided universe which now should involve a deeper-than-classical concept of absolute simultaneity and a deeper-than-relativistic concept of space and time. Ultimately, our test thus establishes a new hierarchy of fundamental physical theories where the de Broglie-Bohm realistic quantum theory is the deepest theory which does not contradict either classical physics or relativity but rather is beyond both. This is because the fact that quantum theory is dealing with a deeper reality where physical objects are not self-sufficient entities and therefore they can transit discontinuously within an overall quantum system determined by their wavefunctions.
On the basis of our recent model of a one-dimensional (1D) completed scattering we argue that Leggett's principles of macroscopic realism must and can be extended onto the level of single electrons and atoms. These principles need three quite feasible innovations in quantum mechanics (QM): (1) at the conceptual level, QM must treat a pure time-dependent one-particle state to involve two or more macroscopically distinct alternatives for a particle as a pure {\it combined} one - the intermediate link between a pure {\it elementary} state (indecomposable into macroscopically distinct parts) and statistical mixture; (2) at the mathematical level, QM must provide the presentation of the pure time-dependent combined state as a coherent superposition of macroscopically distinct elementary states (MDESs); (3) at the experimental level, QM must provide for such states two types of measurements - those for observing the interference pattern resulting from the joint action of MDESs, and non-demolishing 'which-way' measurements for scanning the individual properties of MDESs.
Today quantum nonlocality is discussed only in the context of EPR situation where we face a macroscopic system which is fundamentally indivisible insofar as it consists of entangled distant particles. But quantum formalism implies a one more type of indivisibility. It is the indivisibility of a quantum state per se regardless of its configuration in the real space. In this work, we propose an idea of how this type of indivisibility may also be relevant to macrocosm giving rise to an alternative type of quantum nonlocality which, in contrast to EPR nonlocality, is observable on a non-statistical level. It is light-induced electron transitions with macroscopic spatial discontinuity. We provide strong evidence for these transitions in a modification of low-temperature quantum Hall state of matter, which is characterized by a great number of macroscopic orbit-like quantum states. We thereby demonstrate a deeper-than-relativistic spatial dynamics requiring a deeper kinematics beyond the Minkowski model of spacetime. Such kinematics was proposed by Karl Popper as well as by John Bell through the idea of a deeper non-Lorentz-invariant spatial level identified as precisely the aether in the Lorentz-Poincare’s version of relativity. We argue that this idea may be integrated into the Bohm-Hiley’s model of undividable Universe which thus appears to be precisely the deeper-than-relativistic model relevant at any lengthscale. Ultimately, this approach opens the door to the solution of such fundamental problems as the problem of interpretation of quantum formalism as well as the problem of unification of quantum and relativity theories.
This thesis consists of two parts. Although both are concerned with macroscopic quantum phenomena, I choose to present the two parts quite separately. Macroscopic Quantum Phenomena: Tests of Quantum Mechanics The correctness of quantum mechanics has been verified in numerous situations. A particularly strong test of quantum mechanics was suggested by Bell, who showed that the predictions of all classical theories, based as they are on the assumptions of local realism, contradict those of quantum mechanics. Later work by Greenberger, Horne, and Zeilinger showed that the GHZ phenomena also contradicts all classical theories. Experimental tests of Bells inequality performed to date support quantum mechanics (No experimental test of the GHZ phenomenon has yet been attempted). However, such tests have been so far restricted to microscopic systems in the sense that one particle is at a detector at a time. Our interest here in the first part of this thesis is in tests of quantum mechanics against local realistic theories in macroscopic or mesoscopic systems where there is a significant number of particles incident on each analyser. The states considered in the first two chapters are not simple quantum superpositions of macroscopically distinct states, but we nevertheless show how one can obtain tests of quantum mechanics in situations involving large numbers of particles. A more elementary macroscopic quantum state, and one in which the deviation from classical interpretations is striking, is the Schrodinger Cat state considered by Schrodinger in his famous "Schrodinger Cat" paradox. In Chapter Three we consider a scheme for generating such a state. The Quantum Brownian Motion Master Equation The second section of this thesis involves an examination of various aspects of the Quantum Brownian Motion Master Equation. We begin with a discussion of the recent problem occurring from the study of the quantum Brownian motion (QBM) master equation, which can occur because the QBM master equation is not of the Lindblad form. We examine two specific examples, namely the damped free particle and the two level atom. More specifically, in the case of the evolution of a free particle, we show that the equation of motion for the Wigner function (which is exactly the same as the Fokker-Planck equation for classical Brownian motion) gives unphysical results if the initial position distribution is well localised. In the case of the two level atom we show that unphysical results can also occur even in the steady state. The last chapter of the thesis involves using the quantum Brownian motion master equation to estimate the rate of diagonalisation of the off diagonal elements of a Fermion system. These elements contain the "quantum information" and hence knowledge of how long they exist can determine the type of model required to describe the semiconductor medium. Using a very simplistic approach we can show that there are two main time scales present and for normal parameters one of these is very small. If we neglect electron-electron scattering we can show that the the many electron system solution is simply a product of the one electron solutions.
Single electron may have wavefunction of a macroscopic lengthscale but cannot be detected in two places. At the Solvay Conference of 1927, Einstein argued that in a combination with Bohr's postulate about wavefunction as an exhaustive characteristics of electron, this fact implies nonlocality related to the collapse of a macroscopic wavefunction of single electron. This was his objection to Bohr's quantum mechanics (QM) in favor of de Broglie's quantum theory. We perform an experimental test in low-temperature state of matter where electrons have macroscopic orbit-like wavefunctions and surprisingly observe nonlocality of that type. This nonlocality differs in principle from the well-known Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) nonlocality because the former does not imply quantum entanglement and hence is beyond the no-communication theorem. Our observation is the first empirical justification of the choice in favor of QM in compare with de Broglie's theory. Moreover, now we can expand the current concept of reality and thus open the door to a realistic interpretation of quantum formalism. Ultimately, we thus come to a quantum model of Universe based on the standard QM.