Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Problem of the Calculations of the Mean Value in Quantum Meohanics

Fan Xi

Published Jan 1, 2001• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

This article aims to analyze and compare two equations of the mechanieal quantity Q of mean value in a certain quantum state ψ(ArU) in quantum mechanics. Finaly, it presents the equation (2) is general while the equation (1) is used under certain conditions.

Related papers

On a paradox in quantum mechanics and its resolution

Padtarapan Banyadsin, Salvatore De Vincenzo

Abstract Consider a free Schrödinger particle inside an interval with walls characterized by the Dirichlet boundary condition. Choose a parabola as the normalized state of the particle that satisfies this boundary condition. To calculate the variance of the Hamiltonian in that state, one needs to calculate the mean value of the Hamiltonian and that of its square. If one uses the standard formula to calculate these mean values, one obtains both results without difficulty, but the variance unexpectedly takes an imaginary value. If one uses the same expression to calculate these mean values but first writes the Hamiltonian and its square in terms of their respective eigenfunctions and eigenvalues, one obtains the same result as above for the mean value of the Hamiltonian but a different value for its square (in fact, it is not zero); hence, the variance takes an acceptable value. From whence do these contradictory results arise? The latter paradox has been presented in the literature as an example of a problem that can only be properly solved by making use of certain fundamental concepts within the general theory of linear operators in Hilbert spaces. Here, we carefully review those concepts and apply them in a detailed way to resolve the paradox. Our results are formulated within the natural framework of wave mechanics, and to avoid inconveniences that the use of Dirac’s symbolic formalism could bring, we avoid the use of that formalism throughout the article. In addition, we obtain a resolution of the paradox in an entirely formal way without addressing the restrictions imposed by the domains of the operators involved. We think that the content of this paper will be useful to undergraduate and graduate students as well as to their instructors.

arXiv:2305.08556•European Journal of Physics•May 31, 2023•0 citations

MÉTODO DE OPERADORES EM MECÂNICA QUÂNTICA

Lucas Henrique Elias Vieira, Petrus Henrique Ribeiro dos Anjos

This paper will introduce and discuss the method of Operators in Quantum Mechanics. This presentation will be mathematically rigorous, but also physically motivate the definitions and propositions established.

•Aug 1, 2015•0 citations

On randomness in quantum mechanics

Alberto C. de la Torre

The quantum mechanical probability densities are compared with the probability densities treated by the theory of random variables. The relevance of their difference for the interpretation of quantum mechanics is commented.

arXiv:0707.2954•European Journal of Physics•Apr 25, 2008•5 citations

Quantization problem and variational principle in the phase-space formulation of quantum mechanics

Leon W. Cohen

The problem of quantization in the phase-space formulation of quantum mechanics is considered. An integral equation for the phase-space eigenfunctions is derived which is equivalent to the standard eigenvalue equation for a quantum mechanical operator. A differential form is also given. A variational principle is derived for quasiprobability distributions. It is shown that the expected value of the classical Hamiltonian calculated with a trial quasiprobability distribution will be greater than the ground state energy only if the distribution is chosen from a certain class of functions. The notion of ψ-representability is introduced to classify these functions. They represent distributions which correspond to possible quantum mechanical states. Also, a general relation is given between different distribution functions.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Oct 1, 1976•70 citations

Error Limits of Expectation Values in Quantum Mechanical Calculations

Joseph F. Mucci, Peter J. Haskins

We present a general treatment of error limits of expectation values in quantum-mechanical calculations. Important expressions and their derivations are included along with an indication of the state of research in this area.

American Journal of Physics•Aug 1, 1973•2 citations

Statistical Inverse Problem: Root Approach

Yu. I. Bogdanov

Multiparametric statistical model providing stable reconstruction of parameters by observations is considered. The only general method of this kind is the root model based on the representation of the probability density as a squared absolute value of a certain function, which is referred to as a psi-function in analogy with quantum mechanics. The psi-function is represented by an expansion in terms of an orthonormal set of functions. It is shown that the introduction of the psi-function allows one to represent the Fisher information matrix as well as statistical properties of the estimator of the state vector (state estimator) in simple analytical forms. The chi-square test is considered to test the hypotheses that the estimated vector converges to the state vector of a general population. The method proposed may be applied to its full extent to solve the statistical inverse problem of quantum mechanics (root estimator of quantum states). In order to provide statistical completeness of the analysis, it is necessary to perform measurements in mutually complementing experiments (according to the Bohr terminology). The maximum likelihood technique and likelihood equation are generalized in order to analyze quantum mechanical experiments. It is shown that the requirement for the expansion to be of a root kind can be considered as a quantization condition making it possible to choose systems described by quantum mechanics from all statistical models consistent, on average, with the laws of classical mechanics.

arXiv:quant-ph/0312042•Dec 4, 2003•11 citations
Abstract Consider a free Schrödinger particle inside an interval with walls characterized by the Dirichlet boundary condition. Choose a parabola as the normalized state of the particle that satisfies this boundary condition. To calculate the variance of the Hamiltonian in that state, one needs to calculate the mean value of the Hamiltonian and that of its square. If one uses the standard formula to calculate these mean values, one obtains both results without difficulty, but the variance unexpectedly takes an imaginary value. If one uses the same expression to calculate these mean values but first writes the Hamiltonian and its square in terms of their respective eigenfunctions and eigenvalues, one obtains the same result as above for the mean value of the Hamiltonian but a different value for its square (in fact, it is not zero); hence, the variance takes an acceptable value. From whence do these contradictory results arise? The latter paradox has been presented in the literature as an example of a problem that can only be properly solved by making use of certain fundamental concepts within the general theory of linear operators in Hilbert spaces. Here, we carefully review those concepts and apply them in a detailed way to resolve the paradox. Our results are formulated within the natural framework of wave mechanics, and to avoid inconveniences that the use of Dirac’s symbolic formalism could bring, we avoid the use of that formalism throughout the article. In addition, we obtain a resolution of the paradox in an entirely formal way without addressing the restrictions imposed by the domains of the operators involved. We think that the content of this paper will be useful to undergraduate and graduate students as well as to their instructors.
The problem of quantization in the phase-space formulation of quantum mechanics is considered. An integral equation for the phase-space eigenfunctions is derived which is equivalent to the standard eigenvalue equation for a quantum mechanical operator. A differential form is also given. A variational principle is derived for quasiprobability distributions. It is shown that the expected value of the classical Hamiltonian calculated with a trial quasiprobability distribution will be greater than the ground state energy only if the distribution is chosen from a certain class of functions. The notion of ψ-representability is introduced to classify these functions. They represent distributions which correspond to possible quantum mechanical states. Also, a general relation is given between different distribution functions.
Multiparametric statistical model providing stable reconstruction of parameters by observations is considered. The only general method of this kind is the root model based on the representation of the probability density as a squared absolute value of a certain function, which is referred to as a psi-function in analogy with quantum mechanics. The psi-function is represented by an expansion in terms of an orthonormal set of functions. It is shown that the introduction of the psi-function allows one to represent the Fisher information matrix as well as statistical properties of the estimator of the state vector (state estimator) in simple analytical forms. The chi-square test is considered to test the hypotheses that the estimated vector converges to the state vector of a general population. The method proposed may be applied to its full extent to solve the statistical inverse problem of quantum mechanics (root estimator of quantum states). In order to provide statistical completeness of the analysis, it is necessary to perform measurements in mutually complementing experiments (according to the Bohr terminology). The maximum likelihood technique and likelihood equation are generalized in order to analyze quantum mechanical experiments. It is shown that the requirement for the expansion to be of a root kind can be considered as a quantization condition making it possible to choose systems described by quantum mechanics from all statistical models consistent, on average, with the laws of classical mechanics.