Controlling Photons in Superconducting Electrical Circuits Blake Robert Johnson 2011 Circuit quantum electrodynamics (circuit QED) is a system that allows for strong coupling between microwave photons in transmission line cavities and superconducting qubits or artificial atoms. While circuit QED is often studied in the context of quantum information processing, it also provides an attractive platform for performing quantum optics experiments on-a-chip, because the level of control and coupling strengths available in circuit QED opens a vast array of possibilities for the creation, manipulation, and detection of quantum states of light. In this thesis, the extension of circuit QED to two cavities is examined, including design issues for cavities with very different Q-factors, and a new qubit design is proposed that couples to both cavities. The qubit-cavity interaction, while providing much of the utility of circuit QED, also introduces additional qubit relaxation. A powerful formalism for calculating this energy decay due to the classical admittance of the electromagnetic environment is presented in the context of circuit QED. Measurements of a wide range of samples validate this theory as providing an effective model for relaxation. A new circuit element, called the ‘Purcell filter’, is introduced and demonstrated to decouple the relationship between cavity Q and qubit relaxation. Finally, a new method for performing quantum nondemolition measurements of microwave photons is demonstrated. Controlling Photons in Superconducting Electrical Circuits A Dissertation Presented to the Faculty of the Graduate School of Yale University in Candidacy for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy by Blake Robert Johnson Dissertation Director: Professor Robert J. Schoelkopf
Controlling Photons in Superconducting Electrical Circuits Blake Robert Johnson 2011 Circuit quantum electrodynamics (circuit QED) is a system that allows for strong coupling between microwave photons in transmission line cavities and superconducting qubits or artificial atoms. While circuit QED is often studied in the context of quantum information processing, it also provides an attractive platform for performing quantum optics experiments on-a-chip, because the level of control and coupling strengths available in circuit QED opens a vast array of possibilities for the creation, manipulation, and detection of quantum states of light. In this thesis, the extension of circuit QED to two cavities is examined, including design issues for cavities with very different Q-factors, and a new qubit design is proposed that couples to both cavities. The qubit-cavity interaction, while providing much of the utility of circuit QED, also introduces additional qubit relaxation. A powerful formalism for calculating this energy decay due to the classical admittance of the electromagnetic environment is presented in the context of circuit QED. Measurements of a wide range of samples validate this theory as providing an effective model for relaxation. A new circuit element, called the ‘Purcell filter’, is introduced and demonstrated to decouple the relationship between cavity Q and qubit relaxation. Finally, a new method for performing quantum nondemolition measurements of microwave photons is demonstrated. Controlling Photons in Superconducting Electrical Circuits A Dissertation Presented to the Faculty of the Graduate School of Yale University in Candidacy for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy by Blake Robert Johnson Dissertation Director: Professor Robert J. Schoelkopf
PhD Thesis: Superconducting circuit quantum electrodynamics (QED) has developed into a powerful platform for studying the interaction between matter and different states of light. In this context, superconducting quantum bits (qubits) act as artificial atoms interacting with quantized modes of the electromagnetic field. The field can be trapped in superconducting microwave resonators or propagating in transmission lines. In this thesis, we particularly study circuit QED systems where microwave fields are coupled with superconducting flux and transmon qubits. We optimize the coherence properties of the resonators, by analyzing loss mechanisms at excitation powers of approximately one photon on average. We find that two-level fluctuators associated with oxide layers at substrate and metal surfaces and metal-metal interfaces represent the predominant loss channel. Furthermore, we show how broadband thermal photon fields influence the relaxation and dephasing properties of a superconducting transmon qubit. To this end, we study several second-order loss channels of the transmon qubit and find that the broadband fields introduce a larger decay rate than expected from the Purcell filter defined by the resonator. Additionally, we show that qubit dephasing at the flux-insensitive point as well as low-frequency parameter fluctuations can be enhanced by thermal fields. Finally, we study how artificial atoms react to changes in inherent properties of the light fields. We perform a detailed analysis of the photon statistics of thermal fields using their relation to the qubits coherence properties. We quantitatively recover the expected n2+n-law for the photon number variance and confirm this result by direct correlation measurements. We then show a novel technique for the in-situ conversion of the interaction parity in light-matter interaction. To this end, we couple spatially controlled microwave fields to a flux qubit with two degrees of freedom.
Circuit Quantum Electrodynamics (cQED), the study of the interaction between superconducting circuits behaving as artificial atoms and 1-dimensional transmission-line resonators, has shown much promise for quantum information processing tasks.For the purposes of quantum computing it is usual to approximate the artificial atoms as 2-level qubits, and much effort has been expended on attempts to isolate these qubits from the environment and to invent ever more sophisticated control and measurement schemes.Rather than focussing on these technological aspects of the field, this thesis investigates the opportunities for using these carefully engineered systems for answering questions of fundamental physics.The low dissipation and small mode volume of the circuits allows easy access to the strong-coupling regime of quantum optics, where one can investigate the interaction of light and matter at the level of single atoms and photons.A signature of strong coupling is the splitting of the cavity transmission peak into a pair of resolvable peaks when a single resonant atom is placed inside the cavity-an effect known as vacuum Rabi splitting.The cQED architecture is ideally suited for going beyond this linear response effect.This thesis shows that increasing the drive power results in two unique nonlinear features in the transmitted heterodyne signal: the supersplitting of each vacuum Rabi peak into a doublet, and the appearance of additional peaks with the characteristic √ n spacing of the Jaynes-Cummings ladder.These constitute direct evidence for the coupling between the quantized microwave field and the anharmonic spectrum of a superconducting qubit acting as an artificial atom.This thesis also addresses the idea of Bell tests, which are experiments that aim to disprove certain types of classical theories, presenting a proposed method for preparing maximally entangled 3-qubit states via a 'preparation by measurement' scheme using an optimized filter on the time-dependent signal obtained via homodyne monitoring of the transmitted microwave field.
A revolution is underway in the construction of ‘artificial atoms’ out of superconducting electrical circuits. ‘Circuit QED’ permits strong-coupling non-linear optics at the single-photon level and gives an architecture for novel quantum information processing. The dispersive coupling between a qubit and a microwave cavity can be orders of magnitude larger than the line widths of both qubit and cavity. This yields a new ‘quantum toolbox’ which permits arbitrary control of the entangled quantum state of the system. For example one can flip the state of the qubit conditioned on there being exactly n photons in the cavity or one can displace the cavity oscillation amplitude conditioned on the state of the qubit. Using these tools it is now possible to create large ‘Schrödinger cat’ states containing more than 100 photons. An introduction to circuit QED and a review of recent experimental results will be presented.
In the last decade, the field of Quantum Optics has been enriched with a completely new platform: superconducting quantum circuits, also known as circuit-QED. This platform builds on the original designs of superconducting qubits, that is few-level systems made of superconducting islands and Josephson junctions, but adds to it a new ingredient, microwave photons. In this talk I will review circuit-QED with a focus on two complementary lines of research: ultrastrong light-matter coupling and strongly correlated propagating photons. The first topic deals with novel designs of superconducting qubits, engineering their coupling to the microwave radiation field to reach Rabi frequencies that approach the qubit and photon frequencies. In this regime, known as ”ultrastrong coupling”, the rotating wave approximation from Quantum Optics is no longer valid, the vacuum may spontaneously polarize, producing photons that get bound to the qubit, and novel physics is expected to emerge. I will review recent experiments on this topic, together with various theoretical proposals to tame this ultrastrong coupling. The second topic revolves around the notion of ”propagating” photons in these circuits. Most experiments in circuit-QED so far adopted the typical configuration of artificial atoms (qubits) interacting with artificial cavities (LC resonators). This proved useful in order to reach the strong coupling regime, demonstrating Rabi oscillations and developing a variety of protocols for quantum information, tomograhy, entanglement, etc. However, recent experiments have shown that it is possible to also work with propagating photons, replacing the LC resonators with open transmission lines, and studying the scattering properties of those artificial atoms. In this context we have worked on developing new technology to detect and control these photons, engineering single-photon detectors, quantum metamaterials and photonic crystals, or even new nonlinear media based on coupled cavities.
In this thesis, experimentally relevant aspects and open questions of quantum information processing and measurement in circuit quantum electrodynamics have been investigated theoretically. Circuit quantum electrodynamics is a relatively young field combining superconducting transmission line resonators on-chip with superconducting quantum bits which serve as artificial atoms. Remarkable experiments have underlined the prospects of circuit QED as a possible architecture for quantum information processing as well as a framework within which quantum optics experiments can be performed. In contrast to their optical counterparts, these experiments reach the ultra-strong coupling limit and allow e.g. the generation of Fock states, the study of decoherence and the observation of quantum jumps. We present the physics of superconducting circuits based on the Josephson junction as a non-linear circuit element. We discuss the various types of quantum bits (qubits) before turning to an introduction on cavity QED and conclude the introduction with a brief presentation of the most relevant experiments and a short introduction to the principles and prospects of quantum information processing. Building on the pioneering theoretical and experimental work in which up to three qubits have been integrated on a chip and successfully coupled via a cavity mode, we propose a scheme to overcome the natural limits concerning scalability in these systems. Usually, scalability is severely limited by the resonance width of the qubit transitions and the attainable frequency range for both qubit transition and cavity resonance frequencies. This limits the present setups to at most ten qubits. As a possible solution, we propose and investigate a cross-bar grid layout of cavities with qubits at the intersections. It turns out that this setup, allowing for up to about 1000 qubits, offers significant advantages over e.g. nearest-neighbor coupling schemes. In addition, it can serve as a building block for a truly scalable scheme for fault-tolerant quantum information processing with superconducting circuits by combining 7x7 arrays in a staircase manner. Furthermore, we discuss and simulate different possibilities to improve upon the suggested scheme by e.g. using resonant gates and optimal control theory. Another focus of the present thesis is measurement physics. In order to investigate e.g. the possibilities of using a circuit QED system to dispersively detect single microwave photons or to generate multi-qubit entangled states, we introduce in a pedagogical manner the basics of stochastic master equations which generate quantum trajectories before turning to concrete applications. Quantum trajectories have proven to be a state-of-the-art tool to analyze measurement situations in a very realistic manner by giving access to both the measurement record as well as the internal quantum dynamics conditioned on this record. Using the method of quantum trajectories as generated by stochastic master equations, we discuss a scheme to efficiently generate multi-qubit entangled states in a very flexible way. The method is based on a collective, dispersive qubit readout. By this measurement, a suitable product state of N qubits can be reliably converted into e.g. an N-qubit Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger or W state. We propose and discuss the scheme and investigate the effects of decoherence and parameter spread as they would be encountered in experiment. Last but not least, we propose and fully analyze a scheme to dispersively detect single itinerant microwave photons. While experiments to generate single microwave photons have already been successfully performed, their single-shot quantum non-demolition detection has not been possible so far. The scheme presented in this thesis closes this gap in the circuit QED toolbox and reaches detection efficiencies of 30% only limited by fundamental quantum mechanics in this case the Quantum Zeno effect. This detection scheme could be used in quantum communication or quantum cryptography applications.
Waveguide circuit quantum electrodynamics (waveguide circuit QED) studies light-matter interaction with superconducting circuits in one dimension. In circuit QED, natural atoms are replaced by superconducting qubits consisting of a non-linear Josephson junction, resulting in an anharmonic energy spectrum just like real atoms. With superconducting qubits, it is possible to study quantum optical phenomena and reach new regimes hard to achieve with real atoms due to weak coupling to the electromagnetic field. The reduction to one dimension in waveguide QED increases the electromagnetic field's directionality, which results in reduced losses. In this thesis, we first introduce circuit quantisation, giving the basis for the next part, where we investigate a transmon, a charge-insensitive artificial atom, coupled to a semi-infinite transmission line. An atom coupled to a semi-infinite waveguide is referred to as an atom in front of a mirror and is the subject of all appended papers. We proceed by summarising Paper I and III's main results: in Paper I, we investigate the spontaneous emission of a transmon coupled to a semi-infinite transmission line, where we take time-delay effects into account. We find that the system dynamics strongly depend on the coupling strength to the transmission line and the atom's position with respect to the electromagnetic field, leading to the Purcell effect or the convergence to a dark state with finite excitation probability. In the high-impedance regime, which we investigate in Paper III, the properties of the transmon coupled to the high-impedance transmission line change drastically. It becomes highly reflective and creates its own cavity with the mirror, resulting in the emergence of cavity modes and vacuum Rabi oscillations in the spontaneous emission dynamics. In the next chapter of the thesis, we demonstrate how to quantise an electromagnetic field and derive a light-matter interaction Hamiltonian within dipole approximation. We then give an introduction to open quantum systems and derive the quantum-optical master equation in Lindblad form. Furthermore, we introduce the dressed state picture, where the interaction of light and matter is so strong that the individual energy levels of light and matter are no longer separable. Both the quantum optical master equation and the dressed state picture are relevant in Paper II and IV. In Paper II, an experimental collaboration, we perform several experiments to characterise and discriminate different decay rates of a superconducting qubit coupled to the end of a transmission line. One experiment measured the atomic fluorescence spectral density, which shows an asymmetry for off-resonant driving, resulting from pure dephasing: an effect that we explain in more detail in this thesis and Paper II. In Paper IV, we theoretically investigate amplification mechanisms realised by different set-ups of an atom coupled to a semi-infinite waveguide. In the considered systems, the amplification of a probe field happens either due to population inversion between the pure states or dressed states or multi-photon processes. We find that compared to an open waveguide, we can achieve a higher gain in the amplification with a semi-infinite waveguide.