Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

American Journal of Physics

The principle of identicality and the foundations of quantum theory. II. The role of identicality in the formation of quantum theory

Peter D. Pešić

Published Nov 1, 1991• 7 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The place of the concept of indistinguishability in the formation of quantum theory is examined, including particularly Planck’s earliest formulations of the quantum hypothesis, as well as the use of this concept in the developments surrounding the new quantum theory.
DOI
10.1119/1.16654

Related papers

The principle of identicality and the foundations of quantum theory. I. The Gibbs paradox

Peter D. Pešić

The development of the concept of indistinguishability in the writings of Gibbs is traced, leading from the ‘‘Gibbs paradox’’ to his definition of generic phase.

American Journal of Physics•Nov 1, 1991•16 citations

The Concept 'Indistinguishable'

Saunders, Simon

The concept of indistinguishable particles in quantum theory is fundamental to questions of ontology. All ordinary matter is made of electrons, protons, neutrons, and photons and they are all indistinguishable particles. Yet the concept itself has proved elusive, in part because of the interpretational difficulties that afflict quantum theory quite generally, and in part because the concept was so central to the discovery of the quantum itself, by Planck in 1900; it came encumbered with revolution. I offer a deflationary reading of the concept ‘indistinguishable’ that is identical to Gibbs’ concept ‘generic phase’, save that it is defined for state spaces with only finitely-many states of bounded volume and energy (finitely-many orthogonal states, in quantum mechanics). That, and that alone, makes for the difference between the quantum and Gibbs concepts of indistinguishability. This claim is heretical on several counts, but here we consider only the content of the claim itself, and its bearing on the early history of quantum theory rather than in relation to contemporary debates about particle indistinguishability and permutation symmetry. It powerfully illuminates that history.

•Jul 28, 2020•12 citations

Descriptions in quantum mechanics

Décio Krause

Russell’s theory of descriptions depends essentially on the concept of identity, in particular to eliminate definite descriptions by contextual definitions. But quantum objects, according to a possible metaphysical interpretation I shall assume without discussion here, seem not to satisfy the standard theory of identity, and do not have individuality in a sense. Even so, physicists refer informally to both ‘a quantum so-and-so’ and, worst, to ‘the quantum so-and-so’, as if these expressions were something like descriptions. In this article, we sketch a possible theory of ‘quantum (definite) descriptions’ using a weaker concept of indiscernibility (or indistinguishability), and advance some consequences such a theory may have for the discussions on the logical foundations of quantum theory.

Logic Journal of IGPL•Apr 28, 2017•1 citation

From identity to indistinguishability

Enric Pérez Canals

It is widely accepted that the papers by Bose in 1924 and by Einstein in 1924-1925 definitely opened the path to the quantum concept of ‘indistinguishability’. Since then, distinction in physics between ‘identity’ and ‘indistinguishability’ of particles has come to be required. However, even before the rise of quantum physics, Maxwell, Boltzmann and Gibbs, among others, had to tackle the difficulties and paradoxes that appear when counting identical particles. Later, after Sackur’s and Tetrode’s first quantum derivation of the canonical partition function of an ideal gas, much confusion arose around its dependence on the number of molecules in the system. Many other physicists, such as Planck, Lorentz or Schrodinger took part in those debates. In 1921, Ehrenfest and Trkal devoted a whole paper to this subject. Clearly, in the days before Bose’s seminal work, embroiling and misunderstanding were commonplace. In considering the emergence of the distinction between ‘identical’ and ‘indistinguishable’ particles, we will go through the so-called statistical route to quantum mechanics. The first developments in statistical mechanics became immediately confused and entangled with the irruption of quantum physics. In the first quarter of the twentieth century the mutual influence between both disciplines was profuse. We will pay special attention to the story of the so-called ‘Gibbs Paradox.’ We will argue that what is now often known by this name in some textbooks of statistical mechanics did not exist as such in those foundational days.

•Jan 1, 2012•0 citations

Quantum Information Constraints From Early Quantum Postulates: The Planck-Einstein Perspective on No-Cloning and Quantum Security

Shweta Dour, Ankit Chouhan

The chapter presents the fundamental theoretical history of the field between the first quantum investigations of Max Planck and Albert Einstein and one of the foundations of the modern quantum information science the Quantum No-Cloning Theorem. Starting with the concept of energy quantization by Planck and the hypothesis of photons by Einstein, the chapter chronologically follows the development of these concepts into the discrete, probabilistic version of quantum mechanics. The chapter shows that the quantization of energy and the discreteness of photons automatically result in the non-duplicability of information, and establishes the logical and mathematical foundations of the no-cloning constraint. The discussion also extends to its implications on quantum communication, cryptography and quantum computing architectures in that fundamental quantum postulates determine the ultimate boundaries of secure information transfer and replication. The proposed chapter lies in between classical quantum theory and current quantum technologies providing the historical view together with analytical modeling that emphasizes the role of early 20th-century physics in the formation of the principles of the current quantum information systems.

IGI Global eBooks•Apr 16, 2026•0 citations

The rise of quantum theory

Tian Yu Cao

The origin of the relativity theories was closely bound up with the development of electromagnetic concepts, a development that approached a coherent fieldtheoretical formulation, according to which all actions may vary in a continuous manner. In contrast, quantum theory arose out of the development of atomic concepts, a development that was characterized by the acknowledgment of a fundamental limitation to classical physical ideas when applied to atomic phenomena. This restriction was expressed in the so-called quantum postulate, which attributed to any atomic process an essential discontinuity that was symbolized by Planck's quantum of action.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 13, 1997•0 citations
The concept of indistinguishable particles in quantum theory is fundamental to questions of ontology. All ordinary matter is made of electrons, protons, neutrons, and photons and they are all indistinguishable particles. Yet the concept itself has proved elusive, in part because of the interpretational difficulties that afflict quantum theory quite generally, and in part because the concept was so central to the discovery of the quantum itself, by Planck in 1900; it came encumbered with revolution. I offer a deflationary reading of the concept ‘indistinguishable’ that is identical to Gibbs’ concept ‘generic phase’, save that it is defined for state spaces with only finitely-many states of bounded volume and energy (finitely-many orthogonal states, in quantum mechanics). That, and that alone, makes for the difference between the quantum and Gibbs concepts of indistinguishability. This claim is heretical on several counts, but here we consider only the content of the claim itself, and its bearing on the early history of quantum theory rather than in relation to contemporary debates about particle indistinguishability and permutation symmetry. It powerfully illuminates that history.
Russell’s theory of descriptions depends essentially on the concept of identity, in particular to eliminate definite descriptions by contextual definitions. But quantum objects, according to a possible metaphysical interpretation I shall assume without discussion here, seem not to satisfy the standard theory of identity, and do not have individuality in a sense. Even so, physicists refer informally to both ‘a quantum so-and-so’ and, worst, to ‘the quantum so-and-so’, as if these expressions were something like descriptions. In this article, we sketch a possible theory of ‘quantum (definite) descriptions’ using a weaker concept of indiscernibility (or indistinguishability), and advance some consequences such a theory may have for the discussions on the logical foundations of quantum theory.
It is widely accepted that the papers by Bose in 1924 and by Einstein in 1924-1925 definitely opened the path to the quantum concept of ‘indistinguishability’. Since then, distinction in physics between ‘identity’ and ‘indistinguishability’ of particles has come to be required. However, even before the rise of quantum physics, Maxwell, Boltzmann and Gibbs, among others, had to tackle the difficulties and paradoxes that appear when counting identical particles. Later, after Sackur’s and Tetrode’s first quantum derivation of the canonical partition function of an ideal gas, much confusion arose around its dependence on the number of molecules in the system. Many other physicists, such as Planck, Lorentz or Schrodinger took part in those debates. In 1921, Ehrenfest and Trkal devoted a whole paper to this subject. Clearly, in the days before Bose’s seminal work, embroiling and misunderstanding were commonplace. In considering the emergence of the distinction between ‘identical’ and ‘indistinguishable’ particles, we will go through the so-called statistical route to quantum mechanics. The first developments in statistical mechanics became immediately confused and entangled with the irruption of quantum physics. In the first quarter of the twentieth century the mutual influence between both disciplines was profuse. We will pay special attention to the story of the so-called ‘Gibbs Paradox.’ We will argue that what is now often known by this name in some textbooks of statistical mechanics did not exist as such in those foundational days.
The chapter presents the fundamental theoretical history of the field between the first quantum investigations of Max Planck and Albert Einstein and one of the foundations of the modern quantum information science the Quantum No-Cloning Theorem. Starting with the concept of energy quantization by Planck and the hypothesis of photons by Einstein, the chapter chronologically follows the development of these concepts into the discrete, probabilistic version of quantum mechanics. The chapter shows that the quantization of energy and the discreteness of photons automatically result in the non-duplicability of information, and establishes the logical and mathematical foundations of the no-cloning constraint. The discussion also extends to its implications on quantum communication, cryptography and quantum computing architectures in that fundamental quantum postulates determine the ultimate boundaries of secure information transfer and replication. The proposed chapter lies in between classical quantum theory and current quantum technologies providing the historical view together with analytical modeling that emphasizes the role of early 20th-century physics in the formation of the principles of the current quantum information systems.
The origin of the relativity theories was closely bound up with the development of electromagnetic concepts, a development that approached a coherent fieldtheoretical formulation, according to which all actions may vary in a continuous manner. In contrast, quantum theory arose out of the development of atomic concepts, a development that was characterized by the acknowledgment of a fundamental limitation to classical physical ideas when applied to atomic phenomena. This restriction was expressed in the so-called quantum postulate, which attributed to any atomic process an essential discontinuity that was symbolized by Planck's quantum of action.