Journal of Mathematical Physics

A comment on the paper ``Lower Bounds on the Energy Eigenvalues of Systems Containing Identical Particles''

Francesco Calogero, Carlo Marchioro

Published Jan 1, 1974• 3 citations

Abstract

It is pointed out that the extension by Yeh [J. Math. Phys. 13, 227 (1972)] of the result by Calogero and Marchioro [J. Math. Phys. 10, 562 (1969)] is invalid. Counterexamples are indicated; the fault hidden in the proof of the extended result is spotted.

DOI: 10.1063/1.1666492

Related papers

Lower Bounds of the Energy Eigenvalues of Systems Containing Identical Particles

Robert H. T. Yeh

Lower bounds of the energy eigenvalues of systems containing identical particles were obtained by a generalization of the method of Calogero and Marchioro [J. Math. Phys. 10, 562 (1969)].

Journal of Mathematical PhysicsFeb 1, 19720 citations

Lower Bounds to the Ground-State Energy of Systems Containing Identical Particles

Francesco Calogero, Carlo Marchioro

Lower bounds to the ground-state energy of a system composed of N identical particles interacting by two-body forces (and possibly also with an external potential) are derived. They are expressed in terms of the ground-state energies of (simpler) systems composed of a smaller number of particles having masses and/or interactions different from the original ones. This reduction process may be continued all the way down to systems involving one and two particles only. The generalization to systems containing some identical and some distinguishable particles is also discussed.

Journal of Mathematical PhysicsApr 1, 196930 citations

A lower energy bound for N-particles quantum systems

Kilić, S., Perši, T., Sunarić, S.

It has been shown that the ground state energy E₀ of a quantum system of N identical fermi particles satisfies inequality E₀ ≥ (1 / (N − n)) Σᵢⁿ⁻ⁿ εᵢ , (1) where n = 1, 2, …, N − 1 and εᵢ are the eigenvalues of “n + 1-body Hamiltonian”. The summation is performed over the first N − n states.

Jan 1, 19890 citations

Reply to Comment on ‘Critical points of Potts and O( N ) models from eigenvalue identities in periodic Temperley–Lieb algebras’

Jesper Lykke Jacobsen

Abstract The authors replies to the comment made by Yang and Zhou (2024 J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. ) on his 2015 paper entitled ‘Critical points of Potts and O( N ) models from eigenvalue identities in periodic Temperley–Lieb algebras’ (Jacobsen 2015 J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 48 454003).

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and TheoreticalJun 6, 20240 citations

Comment on ‘‘One-body and two-body operators on systems of identical particles,’’ by N. I. Greenberg and S. Raboy [Am. J. Phys. 5 0, 148–155 (1982)]

W. N. Mathews

American Journal of PhysicsJul 1, 19900 citations

Comment on “Quasi-coherent states for the Hermite oscillator” [J. Math. Phys. 59, 062104 (2018)]

Kevin Zelaya, Oscar Rosas-Ortiz

The paper of Ünal [J. Math. Phys. 59, 062104 (2018)], though worthy of attention, contains a conclusion that is in error and may mislead the efforts to extend his results. The aim of the present note is twofold: we provide a correction to such a conclusion and then we emphasize some missing points that are necessary to clarify the content of the paper.

arXiv:1810.03662Journal of Mathematical PhysicsMay 1, 20194 citations