Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Journal of Chemical Physics

On the classical limit of quantum thermodynamics in finite time

Eitan Geva, Ronnie Kosloff

Published Sep 15, 1992• 208 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The finite time performance of quantum heat engines has been examined with emphasis on the classical, high temperature, limit. Two basic engine models were studied, differing by their consistency of working fluid: the harmonic engine, consisting of noninteracting harmonic oscillators, and the spin-j engine, consisting of noninteracting spin-j subsystems. The two models represent two distinct types of engines, with bounded vs unbounded Hamiltonians, and with creation and annihilation operators of the Fermionic vs the Bosonic type. The analysis is based on the time derivatives of the first and second laws of thermodynamics. Explicit relations linking quantum observables to thermodynamic quantities are utilized. The dynamics of the engines was modeled by the semigroup approach. The engines were optimized with respect to various target functions: power, entropy production, and efficiency, while subject to finite cycle duration. The main strategy of optimization was based on the Euler–Lagrange equation, and is similar to that previously applied by Salamon and Nitzan for the investigation of Newtonian engines [J. Chem. Phys. 74, 3546 (1981)]. The optimal cycles obtained at the classical limit are not of the Curzon–Ahlborn type, i.e., the internal temperature along the thermal branches is not constant. This result is in conflict with Newtonian thermodynamics, where the optimal cycles are of the Curzon–Ahlborn type. Nonetheless, some of the main features of Newtonian thermodynamics, such as the Curzon–Ahlborn efficiency at maximum power, are reproduced at the classical limit. This makes it possible to establish a ‘‘thermodynamic correspondence principle.’’ This principle asserts that the phenomenological Newtonian thermodynamic approach provides an asymptote of a theory based upon the more fundamental semigroup quantum approach. It is argued that the asymptotic nature of Newtonian thermodynamics is twofold since its validity is restricted by two demands: that of high temperatures and that of proximity to equilibrium.

DOI
10.1063/1.463909

Related papers

A quantum-mechanical heat engine operating in finite time. A model consisting of spin-1/2 systems as the working fluid

Eitan Geva, Ronnie Kosloff

The finite-time operation of a quantum-mechanical heat engine with a working fluid consisting of many noninteracting spin-1/2 systems is considered. The engine is driven by an external, time-dependent and nonrotating magnetic field. The cycle of operation consists of two adiabats and two isotherms. The analysis is based on the time derivatives of the first and second laws of thermodynamics. Explicit relations linking quantum observables to thermodynamic quantities are developed. The irreversible operation of this engine is studied in three cases: (1) The sudden limit, where the performance is found to be the same as that of the spin analog of the Otto cycle. This case provides the lower bound of efficiency. (2) The step-cycle operation scheme. Here, the optimization of power is carried out in the high-temperature limit (the ‘‘classical’’ limit). The results obtained are similar to those of Andresen et al. [Phys. Rev. A 15, 2086 (1977)]. (3) The Curzon–Ahlborn operation scheme. The semigroup approach is used to model the dynamics. Then the power production is optimized. All the results obtained for Newtonian engines operating by the same scheme, such as the Curzon–Ahlborn efficiency, apply in the high-temperature limit. These results are obtained without the additional assumption of proximity to thermal equilibrium, implicitly implied by the use of Newtonian heat conduction in the original derivation. It seems that the results of the Curzon–Ahlborn analysis are always obtained in the high-temperature limit, irrespective of the details of the model. The performance beyond the classical limit is optimized numerically. The classical approximation is found to be valid for most of the spin-polarization range. The deviations from the classical limit depend heavily upon the specific nature of both the working fluid and the heat baths and exhibit great diversity and complexity.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Feb 15, 1992•334 citations

The Quantum Harmonic Otto Cycle

Ronnie Kosloff, Yair Rezek

The quantum Otto cycle serves as a bridge between the macroscopic world of heat engines and the quantum regime of thermal devices composed from a single element. We compile recent studies of the quantum Otto cycle with a harmonic oscillator as a working medium. This model has the advantage that it is analytically trackable. In addition, an experimental realization has been achieved, employing a single ion in a harmonic trap. The review is embedded in the field of quantum thermodynamics and quantum open systems. The basic principles of the theory are explained by a specific example illuminating the basic definitions of work and heat. The relation between quantum observables and the state of the system is emphasized. The dynamical description of the cycle is based on a completely positive map formulated as a propagator for each stroke of the engine. Explicit solutions for these propagators are described on a vector space of quantum thermodynamical observables. These solutions which employ different assumptions and techniques are compared. The tradeoff between power and efficiency is the focal point of finite-time-thermodynamics. The dynamical model enables the study of finite time cycles limiting time on the adiabatic and the thermalization times. Explicit finite time solutions are found which are frictionless (meaning that no coherence is generated), and are also known as shortcuts to adiabaticity.The transition from frictionless to sudden adiabats is characterized by a non-hermitian degeneracy in the propagator. In addition, the influence of noise on the control is illustrated. These results are used to close the cycles either as engines or as refrigerators. The properties of the limit cycle are described. Methods to optimize the power by controlling the thermalization time are also introduced. At high temperatures, the Novikov–Curzon–Ahlborn efficiency at maximum power is obtained. The sudden limit of the engine which allows finite power at zero cycle time is shown. The refrigerator cycle is described within the frictionless limit, with emphasis on the cooling rate when the cold bath temperature approaches zero.

arXiv:1612.03582•Entropy•Mar 23, 2017•373 citations

Finite-power performance of quantum heat engines in linear response

Qin Liu, Jizhou He, Yong-li Ma +1 more

We investigate the finite-power performance of quantum heat engines working in the linear response regime where the temperature gradient is small. The engine cycles with working substances of ideal harmonic systems consist of two heat transfer and two adiabatic processes, such as the Carnot cycle, Otto cycle, and Brayton cycle. By analyzing the optimal protocol under maximum power we derive the explicitly analytic expression for the irreversible entropy production, which becomes the low dissipation form in the long duration limit. Assuming the engine to be endoreversible, we derive the universal expression for the efficiency at maximum power, which agrees well with that obtained from the phenomenological heat transfer laws holding in the classical thermodynamics. Through appropriate identification of the thermodynamic fluxes and forces that a linear relation connects, we find that the quantum engines under consideration are tightly coupled, and the universality of efficiency at maximum power is confirmed at the linear order in the temperature gradient.

Physical review. E•Jul 8, 2019•10 citations

Thermodynamical analysis of a quantum heat engine based on harmonic oscillators

Andrea Roberto Insinga, Bjarne Andresen, Peter Salamon

Many models of heat engines have been studied with the tools of finite-time thermodynamics and an ensemble of independent quantum systems as the working fluid. Because of their convenient analytical properties, harmonic oscillators are the most frequently used example of a quantum system. We analyze different thermodynamical aspects with the final aim of the optimization of the performance of the engine in terms of the mechanical power provided during a finite-time Otto cycle. The heat exchange mechanism between the working fluid and the thermal reservoirs is provided by the Lindblad formalism. We describe an analytical method to find the limit cycle and give conditions for a stable limit cycle to exist. We explore the power production landscape as the duration of the four branches of the cycle are varied for short times, intermediate times, and special frictionless times. For short times we find a periodic structure with atolls of purely dissipative operation surrounding islands of divergent behavior where, rather than tending to a limit cycle, the working fluid accumulates more and more energy. For frictionless times the periodic structure is gone and we come very close to the global optimal operation. The global optimum is found and interestingly comes with a particular value of the cycle time.

Physical review. E•Jul 15, 2016•51 citations

Work extremum principle: Structure and function of quantum heat engines

ARMEN E. ALLAHVERDYAN, Ramandeep S. Johal, G. Mahler

We consider a class of quantum heat engines consisting of two subsystems interacting with a work-source and coupled to two separate baths at different temperatures Th>Tc. The purpose of the engine is to extract work due to the temperature difference. Its dynamics is not restricted to the near equilibrium regime. The engine structure is determined by maximizing the extracted work under various constraints. When this maximization is carried out at finite power, the engine dynamics is described by well-defined temperatures and satisfies the local version of the second law. In addition, its efficiency is bounded from below by the Curzon-Ahlborn value 1-radical Tc/Th and from above by the Carnot value 1-(Tc/Th). The latter is reached-at finite power--for a macroscopic engine, while the former is achieved in the equilibrium limit Th-->Tc . The efficiency that maximizes the power is strictly larger than the Curzon-Ahloborn value. When the work is maximized at a zero power, even a small (few-level) engine extracts work right at the Carnot efficiency.

arXiv:0709.4125•Physical Review E•Apr 18, 2008•149 citations

Irreversible Performance of a Quantum Harmonic Heat Engine

Rezek, Y, Kosloff, R

The unavoidable irreversible losses of power in a heat engine are found to be of quantum origin. Following thermodynamic tradition a model quantum heat engine operating by the Otto cycle is analyzed. The working medium of the model is composed of an ensemble of harmonic oscillators. A link is established between the quantum observables and thermodynamical variables based on the concept of canonical invariance. These quantum variables are sufficient to determine the state of the system and with it all thermodynamical variables. Conditions for optimal work, power and entropy production show that maximum power is a compromise between the quasistatic limit of adiabatic following on the compression and expansion branches and a sudden limit of very short time allocation to these branches. At high temperatures and quasistatic operating conditions the efficiency at maximum power coincides with the endoreversible result. The optimal compression ratio varies from the square root of the temperature ratio in the quasistatic limit where their reversibility is dominated by heat conductance to the temperature ratio to the power of 1/4 in the sudden limit when the irreversibility is dominated by friction. When the engine deviates from adiabatic conditions the performance is subject to friction. The origin of this friction can be traced to the noncommutability of the kinetic and potential energy of the working medium.

•Jan 2, 2006•172 citations
The finite time performance of quantum heat engines has been examined with emphasis on the classical, high temperature, limit. Two basic engine models were studied, differing by their consistency of working fluid: the harmonic engine, consisting of noninteracting harmonic oscillators, and the spin-j engine, consisting of noninteracting spin-j subsystems. The two models represent two distinct types of engines, with bounded vs unbounded Hamiltonians, and with creation and annihilation operators of the Fermionic vs the Bosonic type. The analysis is based on the time derivatives of the first and second laws of thermodynamics. Explicit relations linking quantum observables to thermodynamic quantities are utilized. The dynamics of the engines was modeled by the semigroup approach. The engines were optimized with respect to various target functions: power, entropy production, and efficiency, while subject to finite cycle duration. The main strategy of optimization was based on the Euler–Lagrange equation, and is similar to that previously applied by Salamon and Nitzan for the investigation of Newtonian engines [J. Chem. Phys. 74, 3546 (1981)]. The optimal cycles obtained at the classical limit are not of the Curzon–Ahlborn type, i.e., the internal temperature along the thermal branches is not constant. This result is in conflict with Newtonian thermodynamics, where the optimal cycles are of the Curzon–Ahlborn type. Nonetheless, some of the main features of Newtonian thermodynamics, such as the Curzon–Ahlborn efficiency at maximum power, are reproduced at the classical limit. This makes it possible to establish a ‘‘thermodynamic correspondence principle.’’ This principle asserts that the phenomenological Newtonian thermodynamic approach provides an asymptote of a theory based upon the more fundamental semigroup quantum approach. It is argued that the asymptotic nature of Newtonian thermodynamics is twofold since its validity is restricted by two demands: that of high temperatures and that of proximity to equilibrium.
The finite-time operation of a quantum-mechanical heat engine with a working fluid consisting of many noninteracting spin-1/2 systems is considered. The engine is driven by an external, time-dependent and nonrotating magnetic field. The cycle of operation consists of two adiabats and two isotherms. The analysis is based on the time derivatives of the first and second laws of thermodynamics. Explicit relations linking quantum observables to thermodynamic quantities are developed. The irreversible operation of this engine is studied in three cases: (1) The sudden limit, where the performance is found to be the same as that of the spin analog of the Otto cycle. This case provides the lower bound of efficiency. (2) The step-cycle operation scheme. Here, the optimization of power is carried out in the high-temperature limit (the ‘‘classical’’ limit). The results obtained are similar to those of Andresen et al. [Phys. Rev. A 15, 2086 (1977)]. (3) The Curzon–Ahlborn operation scheme. The semigroup approach is used to model the dynamics. Then the power production is optimized. All the results obtained for Newtonian engines operating by the same scheme, such as the Curzon–Ahlborn efficiency, apply in the high-temperature limit. These results are obtained without the additional assumption of proximity to thermal equilibrium, implicitly implied by the use of Newtonian heat conduction in the original derivation. It seems that the results of the Curzon–Ahlborn analysis are always obtained in the high-temperature limit, irrespective of the details of the model. The performance beyond the classical limit is optimized numerically. The classical approximation is found to be valid for most of the spin-polarization range. The deviations from the classical limit depend heavily upon the specific nature of both the working fluid and the heat baths and exhibit great diversity and complexity.
The quantum Otto cycle serves as a bridge between the macroscopic world of heat engines and the quantum regime of thermal devices composed from a single element. We compile recent studies of the quantum Otto cycle with a harmonic oscillator as a working medium. This model has the advantage that it is analytically trackable. In addition, an experimental realization has been achieved, employing a single ion in a harmonic trap. The review is embedded in the field of quantum thermodynamics and quantum open systems. The basic principles of the theory are explained by a specific example illuminating the basic definitions of work and heat. The relation between quantum observables and the state of the system is emphasized. The dynamical description of the cycle is based on a completely positive map formulated as a propagator for each stroke of the engine. Explicit solutions for these propagators are described on a vector space of quantum thermodynamical observables. These solutions which employ different assumptions and techniques are compared. The tradeoff between power and efficiency is the focal point of finite-time-thermodynamics. The dynamical model enables the study of finite time cycles limiting time on the adiabatic and the thermalization times. Explicit finite time solutions are found which are frictionless (meaning that no coherence is generated), and are also known as shortcuts to adiabaticity.The transition from frictionless to sudden adiabats is characterized by a non-hermitian degeneracy in the propagator. In addition, the influence of noise on the control is illustrated. These results are used to close the cycles either as engines or as refrigerators. The properties of the limit cycle are described. Methods to optimize the power by controlling the thermalization time are also introduced. At high temperatures, the Novikov–Curzon–Ahlborn efficiency at maximum power is obtained. The sudden limit of the engine which allows finite power at zero cycle time is shown. The refrigerator cycle is described within the frictionless limit, with emphasis on the cooling rate when the cold bath temperature approaches zero.
We investigate the finite-power performance of quantum heat engines working in the linear response regime where the temperature gradient is small. The engine cycles with working substances of ideal harmonic systems consist of two heat transfer and two adiabatic processes, such as the Carnot cycle, Otto cycle, and Brayton cycle. By analyzing the optimal protocol under maximum power we derive the explicitly analytic expression for the irreversible entropy production, which becomes the low dissipation form in the long duration limit. Assuming the engine to be endoreversible, we derive the universal expression for the efficiency at maximum power, which agrees well with that obtained from the phenomenological heat transfer laws holding in the classical thermodynamics. Through appropriate identification of the thermodynamic fluxes and forces that a linear relation connects, we find that the quantum engines under consideration are tightly coupled, and the universality of efficiency at maximum power is confirmed at the linear order in the temperature gradient.
Many models of heat engines have been studied with the tools of finite-time thermodynamics and an ensemble of independent quantum systems as the working fluid. Because of their convenient analytical properties, harmonic oscillators are the most frequently used example of a quantum system. We analyze different thermodynamical aspects with the final aim of the optimization of the performance of the engine in terms of the mechanical power provided during a finite-time Otto cycle. The heat exchange mechanism between the working fluid and the thermal reservoirs is provided by the Lindblad formalism. We describe an analytical method to find the limit cycle and give conditions for a stable limit cycle to exist. We explore the power production landscape as the duration of the four branches of the cycle are varied for short times, intermediate times, and special frictionless times. For short times we find a periodic structure with atolls of purely dissipative operation surrounding islands of divergent behavior where, rather than tending to a limit cycle, the working fluid accumulates more and more energy. For frictionless times the periodic structure is gone and we come very close to the global optimal operation. The global optimum is found and interestingly comes with a particular value of the cycle time.
We consider a class of quantum heat engines consisting of two subsystems interacting with a work-source and coupled to two separate baths at different temperatures Th>Tc. The purpose of the engine is to extract work due to the temperature difference. Its dynamics is not restricted to the near equilibrium regime. The engine structure is determined by maximizing the extracted work under various constraints. When this maximization is carried out at finite power, the engine dynamics is described by well-defined temperatures and satisfies the local version of the second law. In addition, its efficiency is bounded from below by the Curzon-Ahlborn value 1-radical Tc/Th and from above by the Carnot value 1-(Tc/Th). The latter is reached-at finite power--for a macroscopic engine, while the former is achieved in the equilibrium limit Th-->Tc . The efficiency that maximizes the power is strictly larger than the Curzon-Ahloborn value. When the work is maximized at a zero power, even a small (few-level) engine extracts work right at the Carnot efficiency.
The unavoidable irreversible losses of power in a heat engine are found to be of quantum origin. Following thermodynamic tradition a model quantum heat engine operating by the Otto cycle is analyzed. The working medium of the model is composed of an ensemble of harmonic oscillators. A link is established between the quantum observables and thermodynamical variables based on the concept of canonical invariance. These quantum variables are sufficient to determine the state of the system and with it all thermodynamical variables. Conditions for optimal work, power and entropy production show that maximum power is a compromise between the quasistatic limit of adiabatic following on the compression and expansion branches and a sudden limit of very short time allocation to these branches. At high temperatures and quasistatic operating conditions the efficiency at maximum power coincides with the endoreversible result. The optimal compression ratio varies from the square root of the temperature ratio in the quasistatic limit where their reversibility is dominated by heat conductance to the temperature ratio to the power of 1/4 in the sudden limit when the irreversibility is dominated by friction. When the engine deviates from adiabatic conditions the performance is subject to friction. The origin of this friction can be traced to the noncommutability of the kinetic and potential energy of the working medium.