Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical review. B, Solid state

Relations among theories of excitation transfer

V. M. Kenkre

Published Feb 15, 1975• 76 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A study of the formal relations existing among three recent theories of excitation transfer is made and exact results concerning the two-molecule system are presented. An equivalence is established between the Haken-Reineker-Strobl (HRS) and the Grover-Silbey (GS) formalisms (before the partial Markoffian approximation) on one hand and the Kenkre-Knox (KK) formalism on the other. This equivalence takes the form of a simple relation between the KK memory $\mathcal{W}(t)$ and a function [$g(t)\ensuremath{-}1$] appearing in the GS theory. It is shown that the two-term nature of the GSHRS diffusion constant can be understood clearly in terms of this relation, and the ranges of validity of the various theories, including that of the "GSHRS equation," are discussed.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.11.1741

Related papers

On stochastic theories of quantum mechanics

James G. Gilson

Introduction. There exists a very comprehensive theory concerning the time development of probabilistic systems. This is the Theory of Stochastic processes (1). Quantum mechanics as described by the Schrödinger equation rests very heavily on probabilistic interpretation, and yet, after forty years of remarkably rapid advances and successes, it is not clear how it is related to stochastic theory. The formal similarity of certain aspects of, and equations used in these two theories are well known. The diffusion equation corresponds to the Schrödinger equation, a correspondence only marred by a square root of minus unity appearing with the time derivative in the latter equation. The Kolmogoroff–Chapman relation for probabilities in Brownian motion has an analogue (2) in quantum mechanics, not for probabilities though, but for the complex probability amplitudes. The uncertainty relation also has a stochastic analogue (3). Some of these analogous characteristics are actually symptomatic of the gulf which separates these two theories. There are solutions to the diffusion equation which have a very clear physical probabilistic meaning. This is not the case with the corresponding and formally similar solutions to the Schrödinger equation and is partly due to the √ − 1 mentioned earlier. The probabilistic interpretation of the solutions to the diffusion equation is direct and immediate. On the other hand, the probabilistic interpretation of the solutions, ψ of the Schrödinger equation involve the introduction of the probability density, p = ψ*ψ. One great difference between these two theories lies in their each having distinct principles of linear superposition. In Stochastic Theory probabilities are superposed and in quantum mechanics amplitudes or wave functions are superposed.

Mathematical Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society•Oct 1, 1968•34 citations

Two-atom interaction energies with one atom in an excited state: van der Waals potentials versus level shifts

M. Donaire

I revisit the problem of the interaction between two dissimilar atoms with one atom in an excited state, recently addressed by Berman [Phys. Rev. A 91, 042127 (2015)], Donaire et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 033201 (2015)], and Milonni and Rafsanjani [Phys. Rev. A 92, 062711 (2015)], for which precedent approaches have given conflicting results. In the first place, I discuss to what extent these works provide equivalent results. I show that the phase-shift rate of the two-atom wave function computed by Berman, the van der Waals potential of the excited atom by Donaire et al., and the level shift of the excited atom by Milonni and Rafsanjani possess equivalent expressions in the quasistationary approximation. In addition, I show that the level shift of the ground-state atom computed by Milonni and Rafsanjani is equivalent to its van der Waals potential. A diagrammatic representation of all those quantities is provided. The equivalences among them are, however, not generic. In particular, it is found that for the case of the interaction between two identical atoms excited, the phase-shift rate and the van der Waals potentials differ. Concerning the conflicting results of previous approaches in regards to the spatial oscillation of the interactions, I conclude, in agreement with Berman and with Milonni and Rafsanjani, that they refer to different physical quantities. The impacts of free-space dissipation and finite excitation rates on the dynamics of the potentials are analyzed. In contrast with Milonni and Rafsanjani, the oscillatory versus monotonic spatial forms of the potentials of each atom are found not to be related to the reversible versus irreversible nature of the excitation transfer involved.

arXiv:1603.08195•Physical Review A•May 16, 2016•19 citations

Equivalence of two alternative approaches to Schrödinger equations

B. Gönül, Koray Köksal

Recently developed simple approach for the exact/approximate solution of Schrodinger equations with constant/position-dependent mass, in which the potential is considered as in the perturbation theory, is shown to be equivalent to the one leading to the construction of exactly solvable potentials via the solution of second-order differential equations in terms of known special functions. The formalism in the former solves difficulties encountered in the latter in revealing the corrections explicitly to the unperturbed piece of the solutions whereas the other obviate cumbersome procedures used in the calculations of the former.

arXiv:quant-ph/0512216•Physica Scripta•May 15, 2006•5 citations

Effect of trapping on transport coherence. II. Continuous-time random-walk treatment

Pavel Heřman, Ivan Barvík

Our recent investigation led to the conclusion that there is much agreement among theories of the excitation transfer: the generalized master equation (GME), the Haken-Strobl-Reineker stochastic-Liouville-equation theory, and the Grover-Silbey microscopic theory. Trapping effects influence memory functions entering the GME. Decoupling of the rest of the system from the sink in the nearly coherent regime for large trapping rates changes the form of the pausing-time-distribution functions and probability densities in the continuous-time random-walk method.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Aug 1, 1993•6 citations

Theory of Fast and Slow Excitation Transfer Rates

V. M. Kenkre, Robert S. Knox

The two limiting cases of dipole-allowed excitation transfer rates between molecules, $w\ensuremath{\sim}\frac{1}{{R}^{3}}$ (Perrin) and $w\ensuremath{\sim}\frac{1}{{R}^{6}}$ (F\"orster), where $R$ is the separation, may be obtained as well-defined limits of a single function $w(R)$. The demonstration is based on a model which allows the interaction strengths and relaxation rates to be compared explicitly and which has a generalization describing the situation in real molecules.

Physical Review Letters•Sep 30, 1974•149 citations

Using the Haken–Strobl–Reineker Model to Determine the Temperature Dependence of the Diffusion Coefficient

William Barford

High Resolution Image Download MS PowerPoint Slide Stochastic quantum Liouville equations (SQLE) are widely used to model energy and charge dynamics in molecular systems. The Haken–Strobl–Reineker (HSR) SQLE is a particular paradigm in which the dynamical noise that destroys quantum coherences arises from a white noise (i.e., constant-frequency) spectrum. A system subject to the HSR SQLE thus evolves to its “high-temperature” limit, whereby all the eigenstates are equally populated. This result would seem to imply that the predictions of the HSR model, e.g., the temperature dependence of the diffusion coefficient, have no validity for temperatures lower than the particle bandwidth. The purpose of this paper is to show that this assumption is incorrect for translationally invariant systems. In particular, provided that the diffusion coefficient is determined via the mean-squared-displacement, considerations about detailed-balance are irrelevant. Consequently, the high-temperature prediction for the temperature dependence of the diffusion coefficient may be extrapolated to lower temperatures, provided that the bath remains classical. Thus, for diagonal dynamical disorder the long-time diffusion coefficient, D ∞ ( T ) = c 1 / T, while for both diagonal and off-diagonal disorder, D ∞ ( T ) = c 1 / T + c 2 T, where c 2 ≪ c 1 . An appendix discusses an alternative interpretation from the HSR model of the “quantum to classical” dynamics transition, whereby the dynamics is described as stochastically punctuated coherent motion.

arXiv:2406.12750•Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation•Jul 17, 2024•4 citations
A study of the formal relations existing among three recent theories of excitation transfer is made and exact results concerning the two-molecule system are presented. An equivalence is established between the Haken-Reineker-Strobl (HRS) and the Grover-Silbey (GS) formalisms (before the partial Markoffian approximation) on one hand and the Kenkre-Knox (KK) formalism on the other. This equivalence takes the form of a simple relation between the KK memory W(t)\mathcal{W}(t)W(t) and a function [g(t)\ensuremath−1g(t)\ensuremath{-}1g(t)\ensuremath−1] appearing in the GS theory. It is shown that the two-term nature of the GSHRS diffusion constant can be understood clearly in terms of this relation, and the ranges of validity of the various theories, including that of the "GSHRS equation," are discussed.
Introduction. There exists a very comprehensive theory concerning the time development of probabilistic systems. This is the Theory of Stochastic processes (1). Quantum mechanics as described by the Schrödinger equation rests very heavily on probabilistic interpretation, and yet, after forty years of remarkably rapid advances and successes, it is not clear how it is related to stochastic theory. The formal similarity of certain aspects of, and equations used in these two theories are well known. The diffusion equation corresponds to the Schrödinger equation, a correspondence only marred by a square root of minus unity appearing with the time derivative in the latter equation. The Kolmogoroff–Chapman relation for probabilities in Brownian motion has an analogue (2) in quantum mechanics, not for probabilities though, but for the complex probability amplitudes. The uncertainty relation also has a stochastic analogue (3). Some of these analogous characteristics are actually symptomatic of the gulf which separates these two theories. There are solutions to the diffusion equation which have a very clear physical probabilistic meaning. This is not the case with the corresponding and formally similar solutions to the Schrödinger equation and is partly due to the √ − 1 mentioned earlier. The probabilistic interpretation of the solutions to the diffusion equation is direct and immediate. On the other hand, the probabilistic interpretation of the solutions, ψ of the Schrödinger equation involve the introduction of the probability density, p = ψ*ψ. One great difference between these two theories lies in their each having distinct principles of linear superposition. In Stochastic Theory probabilities are superposed and in quantum mechanics amplitudes or wave functions are superposed.
I revisit the problem of the interaction between two dissimilar atoms with one atom in an excited state, recently addressed by Berman [Phys. Rev. A 91, 042127 (2015)], Donaire et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 033201 (2015)], and Milonni and Rafsanjani [Phys. Rev. A 92, 062711 (2015)], for which precedent approaches have given conflicting results. In the first place, I discuss to what extent these works provide equivalent results. I show that the phase-shift rate of the two-atom wave function computed by Berman, the van der Waals potential of the excited atom by Donaire et al., and the level shift of the excited atom by Milonni and Rafsanjani possess equivalent expressions in the quasistationary approximation. In addition, I show that the level shift of the ground-state atom computed by Milonni and Rafsanjani is equivalent to its van der Waals potential. A diagrammatic representation of all those quantities is provided. The equivalences among them are, however, not generic. In particular, it is found that for the case of the interaction between two identical atoms excited, the phase-shift rate and the van der Waals potentials differ. Concerning the conflicting results of previous approaches in regards to the spatial oscillation of the interactions, I conclude, in agreement with Berman and with Milonni and Rafsanjani, that they refer to different physical quantities. The impacts of free-space dissipation and finite excitation rates on the dynamics of the potentials are analyzed. In contrast with Milonni and Rafsanjani, the oscillatory versus monotonic spatial forms of the potentials of each atom are found not to be related to the reversible versus irreversible nature of the excitation transfer involved.
Recently developed simple approach for the exact/approximate solution of Schrodinger equations with constant/position-dependent mass, in which the potential is considered as in the perturbation theory, is shown to be equivalent to the one leading to the construction of exactly solvable potentials via the solution of second-order differential equations in terms of known special functions. The formalism in the former solves difficulties encountered in the latter in revealing the corrections explicitly to the unperturbed piece of the solutions whereas the other obviate cumbersome procedures used in the calculations of the former.
Our recent investigation led to the conclusion that there is much agreement among theories of the excitation transfer: the generalized master equation (GME), the Haken-Strobl-Reineker stochastic-Liouville-equation theory, and the Grover-Silbey microscopic theory. Trapping effects influence memory functions entering the GME. Decoupling of the rest of the system from the sink in the nearly coherent regime for large trapping rates changes the form of the pausing-time-distribution functions and probability densities in the continuous-time random-walk method.
The two limiting cases of dipole-allowed excitation transfer rates between molecules, $w\ensuremath{\sim}\frac{1}{{R}^{3}}$ (Perrin) and $w\ensuremath{\sim}\frac{1}{{R}^{6}}$ (F\"orster), where RRR is the separation, may be obtained as well-defined limits of a single function w(R)w(R)w(R). The demonstration is based on a model which allows the interaction strengths and relaxation rates to be compared explicitly and which has a generalization describing the situation in real molecules.
High Resolution Image Download MS PowerPoint Slide Stochastic quantum Liouville equations (SQLE) are widely used to model energy and charge dynamics in molecular systems. The Haken–Strobl–Reineker (HSR) SQLE is a particular paradigm in which the dynamical noise that destroys quantum coherences arises from a white noise (i.e., constant-frequency) spectrum. A system subject to the HSR SQLE thus evolves to its “high-temperature” limit, whereby all the eigenstates are equally populated. This result would seem to imply that the predictions of the HSR model, e.g., the temperature dependence of the diffusion coefficient, have no validity for temperatures lower than the particle bandwidth. The purpose of this paper is to show that this assumption is incorrect for translationally invariant systems. In particular, provided that the diffusion coefficient is determined via the mean-squared-displacement, considerations about detailed-balance are irrelevant. Consequently, the high-temperature prediction for the temperature dependence of the diffusion coefficient may be extrapolated to lower temperatures, provided that the bath remains classical. Thus, for diagonal dynamical disorder the long-time diffusion coefficient, D ∞ ( T ) = c 1 / T, while for both diagonal and off-diagonal disorder, D ∞ ( T ) = c 1 / T + c 2 T, where c 2 ≪ c 1 . An appendix discusses an alternative interpretation from the HSR model of the “quantum to classical” dynamics transition, whereby the dynamics is described as stochastically punctuated coherent motion.