Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2406.12750 · Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation

Using the Haken–Strobl–Reineker Model to Determine the Temperature Dependence of the Diffusion Coefficient

William Barford

Published Jul 17, 2024• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

High Resolution Image Download MS PowerPoint Slide Stochastic quantum Liouville equations (SQLE) are widely used to model energy and charge dynamics in molecular systems. The Haken–Strobl–Reineker (HSR) SQLE is a particular paradigm in which the dynamical noise that destroys quantum coherences arises from a white noise (i.e., constant-frequency) spectrum. A system subject to the HSR SQLE thus evolves to its “high-temperature” limit, whereby all the eigenstates are equally populated. This result would seem to imply that the predictions of the HSR model, e.g., the temperature dependence of the diffusion coefficient, have no validity for temperatures lower than the particle bandwidth. The purpose of this paper is to show that this assumption is incorrect for translationally invariant systems. In particular, provided that the diffusion coefficient is determined via the mean-squared-displacement, considerations about detailed-balance are irrelevant. Consequently, the high-temperature prediction for the temperature dependence of the diffusion coefficient may be extrapolated to lower temperatures, provided that the bath remains classical. Thus, for diagonal dynamical disorder the long-time diffusion coefficient, D ∞ ( T ) = c 1 / T, while for both diagonal and off-diagonal disorder, D ∞ ( T ) = c 1 / T + c 2 T, where c 2 ≪ c 1 . An appendix discusses an alternative interpretation from the HSR model of the “quantum to classical” dynamics transition, whereby the dynamics is described as stochastically punctuated coherent motion.

DOI
10.1021/acs.jctc.4c00568

Related papers

Stochastic description of quantum Brownian dynamics

Yun‐An Yan, Jiushu Shao

Classical Brownian motion has well been investigated since the pioneering work of Einstein, which inspired mathematicians to lay the theoretical foundation of stochastic processes. A stochastic formulation for quantum dynamics of dissipative systems described by the system-plus-bath model has been developed and found many applications in chemical dynamics, spectroscopy, quantum transport, and other fields. This article provides a tutorial review of the stochastic formulation for quantum dissipative dynamics. The key idea is to decouple the interaction between the system and the bath by virtue of the Hubbard-Stratonovich transformation or Itô calculus so that the system and the bath are not directly entangled during evolution, rather they are correlated due to the complex white noises introduced. The influence of the bath on the system is thereby defined by an induced stochastic field, which leads to the stochastic Liouville equation for the system. The exact reduced density matrix can be calculated as the stochastic average in the presence of bath-induced fields. In general, the plain implementation of the stochastic formulation is only useful for short-time dynamics, but not efficient for long-time dynamics as the statistical errors go very fast. For linear and other specific systems, the stochastic Liouville equation is a good starting point to derive the master equation. For general systems with decomposable bath-induced processes, the hierarchical approach in the form of a set of deterministic equations of motion is derived based on the stochastic formulation and provides an effective means for simulating the dissipative dynamics. A combination of the stochastic simulation and the hierarchical approach is suggested to solve the zero-temperature dynamics of the spin-boson model. This scheme correctly describes the coherent-incoherent transition (Toulouse limit) at moderate dissipation and predicts a rate dynamics in the overdamped regime. Challenging problems such as the dynamical description of quantum phase transition (local- ization) and the numerical stability of the trace-conserving, nonlinear stochastic Liouville equation are outlined.

Frontiers of Physics•May 1, 2016•50 citations

Localization, dynamical correlations, and the effect of colored noise on coherence

Doron Cohen

Localization in the quantum-kicked-rotator problem leads to nontrivial dynamical correlations that are absent in the classical limit. Consequently, both coherence and diffusion in the presence of colored noise depend on its long-range autocorrelations. This implies that a Markovian treatment of the dynamics for a system that is coupled to a low-temperature heat bath is not valid even if the system is classically chaotic.

Physical Review Letters•Oct 7, 1991•24 citations

Stochastic Liouville, Langevin, Fokker–Planck, and Master Equation Approaches to Quantum Dissipative Systems

Yoshitaka Tanimura

Half century has past since the pioneering works of Anderson and Kubo on the stochastic theory of spectral line shape were published in J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 9 (1954) 316 and 935, respectively. In this review, we give an overview and extension of the stochastic Liouville equation focusing on its theoretical background and applications to help further the development of their works. With the aid of path integral formalism, we derive the stochastic Liouville equation for density matrices of a system. We then cast the equation into the hierarchy of equations which can be solved analytically or computationally in a nonperturbative manner including the effect of a colored noise. We elucidate the applications of the stochastic theory from the unified theoretical basis to analyze the dynamics of a system as probed by experiments. We illustrate this as a review of several experimental examples including NMR, dielectric relaxation, Mössbauer spectroscopy, neutron scattering, and linear and nonlinear laser spectroscopies. Following the summary of the advantage and limitation of the stochastic theory, we then derive a quantum Fokker–Planck equation and a quantum master equation from a system–bath Hamiltonian with a suitable spectral distribution producing a nearly Markovian random perturbation. By introducing auxiliary parameters that play a role as stochastic variables in an expression for reduced density matrix, we obtain the stochastic Liouville equation including temperature correction terms. The auxiliary parameters may also be interpreted as a random noise that allows us to derive a quantum Langevin equation for non-Markovian noise at any temperature. The results afford a basis for clarifying the relationship between the stochastic and dynamical approaches. Analytical as well as numerical calculations are given as examples and discussed.

Journal of the Physical Society of Japan•Aug 10, 2006•891 citations

Dynamics of quantum–classical systems in nonequilibrium environments

Jeremy Schofield, Raymond Kapral

The dynamics of a quantum system coupled to a classical environment and subject to constraints that drive it out of equilibrium are described. The evolution of the system is governed by the quantum-classical Liouville equation. Rather than evaluating the evolution of the mixed quantum-classical density operator, we derive exact equations of motion for the nonequilibrium average values of a set of operators or variables, along with correlation function expressions for the dissipative coefficients that enter these equations. These equations are obtained by requiring that the exact nonequilibrium averages are equal to local nonequilibrium averages that depend on auxiliary fields whose values satisfy evolution equations obtained using projection operator methods. The results are illustrated by deriving reaction-diffusion equations coupled to fluid hydrodynamic equations for a solution of quantum particles that can exist in two metastable states. Nonequilibrium steady states are discussed along with the reaction rate and diffusion correlation functions that characterize such states.

arXiv:2411.18713•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Feb 24, 2025•0 citations

Unified model for the study of diffusion localization and dissipation

Doron Cohen

A model that generalizes the study of quantum Brownian motion (BM) is constructed. We consider disordered environment that may be either static (quenched), noisy or dynamical. The Zwanzig-Caldeira-Leggett BM model formally constitutes a special case where the disorder autocorrelation length is taken to be infinite. Alternatively, a localization problem is obtained if the noise autocorrelation time is taken to be infinite. Also the general case of weak nonlinear coupling to a thermal, possibly chaotic bath is handled by the same formalism. A general, Feynman-Vernon type path-integral expression for the propagator is introduced. A Wigner transformed version of this expression is utilized in order to facilitate comparison with the classical limit. It is demonstrated that nonstochastic genuine quantal manifestations are associated with the model. It is clarified that such effects are absent in the standard BM model, either the disorder or the chaotic nature of the bath are essential. Quantal correction to the classical diffusive behavior is found even in the limit of high temperatures. The suppression of interference due to dephasing is discussed, leading to the observation that due to the disorder the decay of coherence is exponential in time, and no longer depends on geometrical considerations. Fascinating non-Markovian effects due to time-correlated (colored) noise are explored. For this, a strategy is developed in order to handle the integration over paths. This strategy is extended in order to demonstrate how localization comes out from the path-integral expression.

arXiv:chao-dyn/9611013•Physical review. E, Statistical physics, plasmas, fluids, and related interdisciplinary topics•Feb 1, 1997•42 citations

Quantum chaos, dynamical correlations, and the effect of noise on localization

Doron Cohen

Localization in the quantum kicked rotator (QKR) problem leads to nontrivial dynamical correlations that are absent in the classical limit. These correlations are related to the spectral properties of the model. The effect of noise on coherence is studied. Also, its effect on the dynamical correlations is investigated, and thus one is able to determine analytically the diffusion that is induced. If the noise is white, then coherence time is the same as that for the undriven system. For colored noise it is essential to take into account the nature of the dynamical correlations. It follows that a Markovian treatment of the dynamics for a system that is coupled to a low-temperature heat bath is not valid even if the system is classically chaotic. The formalism applies also to the problem of QKR with kicks that are not strictly periodic in time, and also to the quantum kicked particle problem, where a nonperturbative mechanism for destruction of coherence has been found.

Physical Review A•Aug 1, 1991•91 citations
High Resolution Image Download MS PowerPoint Slide Stochastic quantum Liouville equations (SQLE) are widely used to model energy and charge dynamics in molecular systems. The Haken–Strobl–Reineker (HSR) SQLE is a particular paradigm in which the dynamical noise that destroys quantum coherences arises from a white noise (i.e., constant-frequency) spectrum. A system subject to the HSR SQLE thus evolves to its “high-temperature” limit, whereby all the eigenstates are equally populated. This result would seem to imply that the predictions of the HSR model, e.g., the temperature dependence of the diffusion coefficient, have no validity for temperatures lower than the particle bandwidth. The purpose of this paper is to show that this assumption is incorrect for translationally invariant systems. In particular, provided that the diffusion coefficient is determined via the mean-squared-displacement, considerations about detailed-balance are irrelevant. Consequently, the high-temperature prediction for the temperature dependence of the diffusion coefficient may be extrapolated to lower temperatures, provided that the bath remains classical. Thus, for diagonal dynamical disorder the long-time diffusion coefficient, D ∞ ( T ) = c 1 / T, while for both diagonal and off-diagonal disorder, D ∞ ( T ) = c 1 / T + c 2 T, where c 2 ≪ c 1 . An appendix discusses an alternative interpretation from the HSR model of the “quantum to classical” dynamics transition, whereby the dynamics is described as stochastically punctuated coherent motion.
Classical Brownian motion has well been investigated since the pioneering work of Einstein, which inspired mathematicians to lay the theoretical foundation of stochastic processes. A stochastic formulation for quantum dynamics of dissipative systems described by the system-plus-bath model has been developed and found many applications in chemical dynamics, spectroscopy, quantum transport, and other fields. This article provides a tutorial review of the stochastic formulation for quantum dissipative dynamics. The key idea is to decouple the interaction between the system and the bath by virtue of the Hubbard-Stratonovich transformation or Itô calculus so that the system and the bath are not directly entangled during evolution, rather they are correlated due to the complex white noises introduced. The influence of the bath on the system is thereby defined by an induced stochastic field, which leads to the stochastic Liouville equation for the system. The exact reduced density matrix can be calculated as the stochastic average in the presence of bath-induced fields. In general, the plain implementation of the stochastic formulation is only useful for short-time dynamics, but not efficient for long-time dynamics as the statistical errors go very fast. For linear and other specific systems, the stochastic Liouville equation is a good starting point to derive the master equation. For general systems with decomposable bath-induced processes, the hierarchical approach in the form of a set of deterministic equations of motion is derived based on the stochastic formulation and provides an effective means for simulating the dissipative dynamics. A combination of the stochastic simulation and the hierarchical approach is suggested to solve the zero-temperature dynamics of the spin-boson model. This scheme correctly describes the coherent-incoherent transition (Toulouse limit) at moderate dissipation and predicts a rate dynamics in the overdamped regime. Challenging problems such as the dynamical description of quantum phase transition (local- ization) and the numerical stability of the trace-conserving, nonlinear stochastic Liouville equation are outlined.
Half century has past since the pioneering works of Anderson and Kubo on the stochastic theory of spectral line shape were published in J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 9 (1954) 316 and 935, respectively. In this review, we give an overview and extension of the stochastic Liouville equation focusing on its theoretical background and applications to help further the development of their works. With the aid of path integral formalism, we derive the stochastic Liouville equation for density matrices of a system. We then cast the equation into the hierarchy of equations which can be solved analytically or computationally in a nonperturbative manner including the effect of a colored noise. We elucidate the applications of the stochastic theory from the unified theoretical basis to analyze the dynamics of a system as probed by experiments. We illustrate this as a review of several experimental examples including NMR, dielectric relaxation, Mössbauer spectroscopy, neutron scattering, and linear and nonlinear laser spectroscopies. Following the summary of the advantage and limitation of the stochastic theory, we then derive a quantum Fokker–Planck equation and a quantum master equation from a system–bath Hamiltonian with a suitable spectral distribution producing a nearly Markovian random perturbation. By introducing auxiliary parameters that play a role as stochastic variables in an expression for reduced density matrix, we obtain the stochastic Liouville equation including temperature correction terms. The auxiliary parameters may also be interpreted as a random noise that allows us to derive a quantum Langevin equation for non-Markovian noise at any temperature. The results afford a basis for clarifying the relationship between the stochastic and dynamical approaches. Analytical as well as numerical calculations are given as examples and discussed.
The dynamics of a quantum system coupled to a classical environment and subject to constraints that drive it out of equilibrium are described. The evolution of the system is governed by the quantum-classical Liouville equation. Rather than evaluating the evolution of the mixed quantum-classical density operator, we derive exact equations of motion for the nonequilibrium average values of a set of operators or variables, along with correlation function expressions for the dissipative coefficients that enter these equations. These equations are obtained by requiring that the exact nonequilibrium averages are equal to local nonequilibrium averages that depend on auxiliary fields whose values satisfy evolution equations obtained using projection operator methods. The results are illustrated by deriving reaction-diffusion equations coupled to fluid hydrodynamic equations for a solution of quantum particles that can exist in two metastable states. Nonequilibrium steady states are discussed along with the reaction rate and diffusion correlation functions that characterize such states.
A model that generalizes the study of quantum Brownian motion (BM) is constructed. We consider disordered environment that may be either static (quenched), noisy or dynamical. The Zwanzig-Caldeira-Leggett BM model formally constitutes a special case where the disorder autocorrelation length is taken to be infinite. Alternatively, a localization problem is obtained if the noise autocorrelation time is taken to be infinite. Also the general case of weak nonlinear coupling to a thermal, possibly chaotic bath is handled by the same formalism. A general, Feynman-Vernon type path-integral expression for the propagator is introduced. A Wigner transformed version of this expression is utilized in order to facilitate comparison with the classical limit. It is demonstrated that nonstochastic genuine quantal manifestations are associated with the model. It is clarified that such effects are absent in the standard BM model, either the disorder or the chaotic nature of the bath are essential. Quantal correction to the classical diffusive behavior is found even in the limit of high temperatures. The suppression of interference due to dephasing is discussed, leading to the observation that due to the disorder the decay of coherence is exponential in time, and no longer depends on geometrical considerations. Fascinating non-Markovian effects due to time-correlated (colored) noise are explored. For this, a strategy is developed in order to handle the integration over paths. This strategy is extended in order to demonstrate how localization comes out from the path-integral expression.
Localization in the quantum kicked rotator (QKR) problem leads to nontrivial dynamical correlations that are absent in the classical limit. These correlations are related to the spectral properties of the model. The effect of noise on coherence is studied. Also, its effect on the dynamical correlations is investigated, and thus one is able to determine analytically the diffusion that is induced. If the noise is white, then coherence time is the same as that for the undriven system. For colored noise it is essential to take into account the nature of the dynamical correlations. It follows that a Markovian treatment of the dynamics for a system that is coupled to a low-temperature heat bath is not valid even if the system is classically chaotic. The formalism applies also to the problem of QKR with kicks that are not strictly periodic in time, and also to the quantum kicked particle problem, where a nonperturbative mechanism for destruction of coherence has been found.