Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Cooperative Phenomena in Resonant Electromagnetic Propagation

F. T. Arecchi, E. Courtens

Published Nov 1, 1970• 297 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Phenomena of coherent resonant propagation can be considered as resulting from the cooperative interaction of a certain number of excited two-level systems. It is shown that these phenomena can be characterized by a specific "maximum cooperation number" and by the associated "cooperation time." These are defined for the superradiant state, but their meaning and usefulness can be extended to other situations. The alternative description of of superradiance as a spontaneous or as a stimulated effect is also discussed and it is shown that with the help of the new concepts, the Dicke quantum perturbative treatment can be reconciled with the semiclassical theories.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.2.1730

Related papers

Cooperative effects in radiation processes (multilevel particles and second-order perturbation theory)

Махвиладзе Тариэль Михайлович, Leonid A. Shelepin

The Dicke theory of coherent spontaneous emission is generalized by means of group-theoretical methods. Effects of superradiation and the structure of coherent responses of an equilibrium medium to pulsed excitation are considered. A method of calculating cooperative effects in second-order perturbation theory is developed. The role of collective properties of a system of radiators in experiments with high power exciting radiation is discussed. Some "anomalous" features of stimulated Raman scattering are accounted for.

Physical Review A•Jan 1, 1974•32 citations

Superradiance Revisited

Joseph H. Eberly

The basic features of coherent spontaneous emission, including its dependence on the square of the number of participating emitters, are reviewed. Analogies with magnetic resonance phenomena are exploited, and we explain the need to go beyond such analogies in order to treat optical emission. Some recent results in the theory of optical superradiance are discussed. The radiative decay process is treated as a quantum-classical interpolation problem, and explicit solutions are given. In addition to its time dependence, we give the angular distribution of radiated power and the expected intensity fluctuations, and we estimate the maximum number of emitters which can cooperate in a superradiant event. Dicke's “coherence brightening” criterion is discussed from the point of view of the present paper. A “failure” of the criterion is exhibited and explained. Two of the purely quantum aspects of superradiance are isolated and discussed briefly.

American Journal of Physics•Oct 1, 1972•47 citations

Collective spontaneous emission (Dicke superradiance)

Anatolii V Andreev, Vladimir I Emel'yanov, Yu A Il'inskiĭ

The present state of theoretical and experimental research on collective spontaneous emission (superradiance) in a system of radiators (atoms, molecules, or nuclei) is reviewed. The distinction between superradiance and the amplification of spontaneous emission is discussed. There is also a discussion of conditions under which the effect can be observed and of various theoretical methods for describing superradiance: the quantum single-mode and multimode models and the semiclassical approach. Theoretical papers on superradiance in systems with dimensions smaller than the wavelength of the radiation and also in extended systems are reviewed. It is shown that superradiance may occur in weakly amplifying media. A situation in which the superradiance is oscillatory is described. The possible use of superradiance to generate coherent emission in the x-ray and ? ranges is discussed. The superradiance accompanying Raman scattering of light in atomic and molecular media is studied. The theoretical results are compared with experimental observations of superradiance in the optical range. In an appendix, the nature of the phase transition in a system of radiators interacting through an electromagnetic field is discussed.

Soviet Physics Uspekhi•Aug 31, 1980•143 citations

Coupled Superradiance Master Equations

Richard H. Picard, C. R. Willis

In this paper we attempt to unify the theoretical treatment of a variety of cooperative interaction phenomena occurring in resonantly interacting radiation-matter systems. The system consists of a multimode optical field interacting with $N$ resonant atoms in a region of large spatial extent. The field and atoms may or may not be coupled to reservoirs. We derive a set of coupled master equations for the reduced matter and radiation density operators of the composite system in the first Born approximation, using a method due to Bogoliubov. These equations describe within a single framework phenomena involving superradiant emission and coherent propagation. In the first place, our theory generalizes existing formulations of the superradiance problem by treating the radiation field as part of the dynamical system rather than as a reservoir. Hence, our equations describe stimulated interaction effects, which are entirely absent in the usual superradiance master equations. Moreover, our equations contain terms describing the self-consistent interaction of an average field with a set of polarizable atoms, as in the coupled Bloch and Maxwell equations of the theory of coherent pulse propagation, and enable us to describe fluctuations, arising from incoherent emission, about the average behavior described by the Bloch-Maxwell theory. We solve formally the dynamical equation for the radiation density operator and obtain a displaced multivariate Gaussian distribution centered on the solution of the Maxwell wave equation, which has as parameters the first and second moments of the matter density operator. Then we derive and discuss the field and atomic-moment equations, both in the wave-number and position representations. The moment equations enable us to show the relationship between descriptions of superradiant damping based on the Bloch equations and those based on the existence of correlated atomic states, including both as special cases. We introduce reduced matter moments, which allow us to separate incoherent- and coherent-emission effects and enable us to discuss the question of the closure of the moment equations. Then we consider cases where the behavior of the atomic system is dominated by a strong coherent pump wave or where the atoms are in a symmetric correlated state and show how the slowly-varying-envelope approximation simplifies the radiation-moment equations in these two cases. In the former case, we obtain an approximate theory which consists, in lowest order, of the Bloch-Maxwell equations with radiative-damping terms, plus an equation describing the time development of the correlation function for field fluctuations. Returning to our general formalism, we relate the usual parameters of the theory of radiative decay and of resonant interactions to the more general quantities appearing in our spatial analysis. Finally, we discuss the importance of the stimulated-emission terms appearing in our theory and describe several extensions, including the introduction of inhomogeneous broadening.

Physical Review A•Sep 1, 1973•20 citations

Quantum theory for superradiance

Elisabeth Ressayre, Andree A. Tallet

In order to study the cooperative emission of radiation from an extended system of $N$ two-level atoms, we use the master-equation approach within the Born and Markov approximations. All the properties of the emission of radiation can be deduced from the diagonalization of the coupling matrix $\ensuremath{\Gamma}$, where an element ${\ensuremath{\Gamma}}_{\mathrm{jk}}$ gives the coupling between the atoms labeled $j$ and $k$ via the electromagnetic field. We choose a pencil-shaped volume and study analytically the coupling matrix in the limit for small and large Fresnel numbers. For Fresnel numbers of order unity numerical methods are used. Thus we prove that, for the pencil-shaped geometry, any elaborated model must take into account the interaction of the atoms with the infinity of electromagnetic field modes lying inside two small solid angles about the axis of the largest linear dimension, which we label the $z$ axis. In other words, the intensity of radiation emitted by any atom of the system depends on its position with respect to the others and this "propagation effect" cannot be neglected when interpreting superradiance experiments. For small Fresnel numbers the $z$ dependence predominates, in the opposite case the ($x, y$) dependence does, while for Fresnel numbers of order unity the dependence of all three components must be taken into account. Preliminary calculations are given for which only the $z$ dependence is considered; for Fresnel numbers of magnitude of order unity or smaller, the effect of propagation along the $z$ axis displays large delays for the appearance of superradiance with respect to the time at which the superradiant pulse is maximum when the "propagation effects" are neglected (one-mode model).

Physical Review A•Jun 1, 1977•51 citations

Superradiance of non-interacting atoms

M. Bojer, Joachim von Zanthier

Fully-excited two-level atoms separated by less than the transition wavelength cooperatively emit light in a short burst, a phenomenon called superradiance by R. Dicke in 1954. The burst is characterized by a maximum intensity scaling with the square of the number of atoms $N$ and a temporal width reduced by $N$ compared to the single atom spontaneous decay time. Both effects are usually attributed to a synchronization of the electric dipole moments of the atoms occurring during the process of light emission. Contrary to this explanation, it was recently shown by use of a quantum path description that the peak intensity results from the quantum correlations among the atoms when occupying symmetric Dicke states. Here we investigate from this perspective the temporal evolution of the ensemble, starting in the small sample limit, i.e., when the atoms have mutual separations much smaller than the transition wavelength $λ$ and pass down the ladder of symmetric Dicke states. In addition, we explore the temporal evolution for the case of non-interacting atoms with mutual separations much larger than $λ$. We show that in this case a similar superradiant burst of the emitted radiation is observed if the quantum correlations of the atoms are generated by conditional photon measurements retaining the atomic ensemble within or close to the symmetric subspace.

arXiv:2206.14646•Jun 29, 2022•1 citation
Phenomena of coherent resonant propagation can be considered as resulting from the cooperative interaction of a certain number of excited two-level systems. It is shown that these phenomena can be characterized by a specific "maximum cooperation number" and by the associated "cooperation time." These are defined for the superradiant state, but their meaning and usefulness can be extended to other situations. The alternative description of of superradiance as a spontaneous or as a stimulated effect is also discussed and it is shown that with the help of the new concepts, the Dicke quantum perturbative treatment can be reconciled with the semiclassical theories.
The Dicke theory of coherent spontaneous emission is generalized by means of group-theoretical methods. Effects of superradiation and the structure of coherent responses of an equilibrium medium to pulsed excitation are considered. A method of calculating cooperative effects in second-order perturbation theory is developed. The role of collective properties of a system of radiators in experiments with high power exciting radiation is discussed. Some "anomalous" features of stimulated Raman scattering are accounted for.
The basic features of coherent spontaneous emission, including its dependence on the square of the number of participating emitters, are reviewed. Analogies with magnetic resonance phenomena are exploited, and we explain the need to go beyond such analogies in order to treat optical emission. Some recent results in the theory of optical superradiance are discussed. The radiative decay process is treated as a quantum-classical interpolation problem, and explicit solutions are given. In addition to its time dependence, we give the angular distribution of radiated power and the expected intensity fluctuations, and we estimate the maximum number of emitters which can cooperate in a superradiant event. Dicke's “coherence brightening” criterion is discussed from the point of view of the present paper. A “failure” of the criterion is exhibited and explained. Two of the purely quantum aspects of superradiance are isolated and discussed briefly.
The present state of theoretical and experimental research on collective spontaneous emission (superradiance) in a system of radiators (atoms, molecules, or nuclei) is reviewed. The distinction between superradiance and the amplification of spontaneous emission is discussed. There is also a discussion of conditions under which the effect can be observed and of various theoretical methods for describing superradiance: the quantum single-mode and multimode models and the semiclassical approach. Theoretical papers on superradiance in systems with dimensions smaller than the wavelength of the radiation and also in extended systems are reviewed. It is shown that superradiance may occur in weakly amplifying media. A situation in which the superradiance is oscillatory is described. The possible use of superradiance to generate coherent emission in the x-ray and ? ranges is discussed. The superradiance accompanying Raman scattering of light in atomic and molecular media is studied. The theoretical results are compared with experimental observations of superradiance in the optical range. In an appendix, the nature of the phase transition in a system of radiators interacting through an electromagnetic field is discussed.
In this paper we attempt to unify the theoretical treatment of a variety of cooperative interaction phenomena occurring in resonantly interacting radiation-matter systems. The system consists of a multimode optical field interacting with NNN resonant atoms in a region of large spatial extent. The field and atoms may or may not be coupled to reservoirs. We derive a set of coupled master equations for the reduced matter and radiation density operators of the composite system in the first Born approximation, using a method due to Bogoliubov. These equations describe within a single framework phenomena involving superradiant emission and coherent propagation. In the first place, our theory generalizes existing formulations of the superradiance problem by treating the radiation field as part of the dynamical system rather than as a reservoir. Hence, our equations describe stimulated interaction effects, which are entirely absent in the usual superradiance master equations. Moreover, our equations contain terms describing the self-consistent interaction of an average field with a set of polarizable atoms, as in the coupled Bloch and Maxwell equations of the theory of coherent pulse propagation, and enable us to describe fluctuations, arising from incoherent emission, about the average behavior described by the Bloch-Maxwell theory. We solve formally the dynamical equation for the radiation density operator and obtain a displaced multivariate Gaussian distribution centered on the solution of the Maxwell wave equation, which has as parameters the first and second moments of the matter density operator. Then we derive and discuss the field and atomic-moment equations, both in the wave-number and position representations. The moment equations enable us to show the relationship between descriptions of superradiant damping based on the Bloch equations and those based on the existence of correlated atomic states, including both as special cases. We introduce reduced matter moments, which allow us to separate incoherent- and coherent-emission effects and enable us to discuss the question of the closure of the moment equations. Then we consider cases where the behavior of the atomic system is dominated by a strong coherent pump wave or where the atoms are in a symmetric correlated state and show how the slowly-varying-envelope approximation simplifies the radiation-moment equations in these two cases. In the former case, we obtain an approximate theory which consists, in lowest order, of the Bloch-Maxwell equations with radiative-damping terms, plus an equation describing the time development of the correlation function for field fluctuations. Returning to our general formalism, we relate the usual parameters of the theory of radiative decay and of resonant interactions to the more general quantities appearing in our spatial analysis. Finally, we discuss the importance of the stimulated-emission terms appearing in our theory and describe several extensions, including the introduction of inhomogeneous broadening.
In order to study the cooperative emission of radiation from an extended system of NNN two-level atoms, we use the master-equation approach within the Born and Markov approximations. All the properties of the emission of radiation can be deduced from the diagonalization of the coupling matrix $\ensuremath{\Gamma}$, where an element ${\ensuremath{\Gamma}}_{\mathrm{jk}}$ gives the coupling between the atoms labeled jjj and kkk via the electromagnetic field. We choose a pencil-shaped volume and study analytically the coupling matrix in the limit for small and large Fresnel numbers. For Fresnel numbers of order unity numerical methods are used. Thus we prove that, for the pencil-shaped geometry, any elaborated model must take into account the interaction of the atoms with the infinity of electromagnetic field modes lying inside two small solid angles about the axis of the largest linear dimension, which we label the zzz axis. In other words, the intensity of radiation emitted by any atom of the system depends on its position with respect to the others and this "propagation effect" cannot be neglected when interpreting superradiance experiments. For small Fresnel numbers the zzz dependence predominates, in the opposite case the (x,yx, yx,y) dependence does, while for Fresnel numbers of order unity the dependence of all three components must be taken into account. Preliminary calculations are given for which only the zzz dependence is considered; for Fresnel numbers of magnitude of order unity or smaller, the effect of propagation along the zzz axis displays large delays for the appearance of superradiance with respect to the time at which the superradiant pulse is maximum when the "propagation effects" are neglected (one-mode model).
Fully-excited two-level atoms separated by less than the transition wavelength cooperatively emit light in a short burst, a phenomenon called superradiance by R. Dicke in 1954. The burst is characterized by a maximum intensity scaling with the square of the number of atoms NNN and a temporal width reduced by NNN compared to the single atom spontaneous decay time. Both effects are usually attributed to a synchronization of the electric dipole moments of the atoms occurring during the process of light emission. Contrary to this explanation, it was recently shown by use of a quantum path description that the peak intensity results from the quantum correlations among the atoms when occupying symmetric Dicke states. Here we investigate from this perspective the temporal evolution of the ensemble, starting in the small sample limit, i.e., when the atoms have mutual separations much smaller than the transition wavelength λλλ and pass down the ladder of symmetric Dicke states. In addition, we explore the temporal evolution for the case of non-interacting atoms with mutual separations much larger than λλλ. We show that in this case a similar superradiant burst of the emitted radiation is observed if the quantum correlations of the atoms are generated by conditional photon measurements retaining the atomic ensemble within or close to the symmetric subspace.