Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General

States of minimal joint uncertainty for complementary observables in three-dimensional Hilbert space

Jorge Sánchez-Ruiz

Published Nov 7, 1994• 10 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The entropic uncertainty relation for sets of N+1 complementary observables (A r ) existing in N-dimensional Hilbert space, Sigma r H(A r )>or=(N+1)ln((N+1)/2), is shown to be optimal in the case N=3 by explicit construction of the states for which equality holds. We prove that the lower bound cannot be attained when N is even, and, on the basis of numerical calculations, this is conjectured to also be the case for odd N>3.

DOI
10.1088/0305-4470/27/21/010

Related papers

Complementary observables and uncertainty relations

K. Kraus

Two observables A and B of an n-level system (i.e., a quantum system with n-dimensional state space) are called complementary, if knowledge of the measured value of A implies maximal uncertainty of the measured value of B, and vice versa. Such observables exist for all n, but no classification (up to equivalence) of all possible pairs of complementary observables is known except for n\ensuremath{\le}4. Complementary observables are conjectured to satisfy an ``entropic'' uncertainty relation of the strongest possible form. This relation has been verified for n\ensuremath{\le}4 by explicit calculations. A recent attempt of substantiating the widespread interpretation of uncertainty relations in terms of mutual disturbances between measurements is criticized.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•May 15, 1987•543 citations

Bounds on the entropic uncertainty in successive measurements of non-commuting observables

Mojtaba Jafarpour, Abbass Sabour

We obtain the exact entropic uncertainty and its upper and lower bound in successive measurements of N non-commuting observables, in a D-dimensional Hilbert space. The specific cases of complementary observables and the associated unbiased bases are also discussed. Spin measurements are considered as examples.

Il Nuovo Cimento B•Feb 1, 2003•0 citations

Optimality of entropic uncertainty relations

Kais Abdelkhalek, René Schwonnek, Hans Maassen +5 more

The entropic uncertainty relation proven by Maassen and Uffink for arbitrary pairs of two observables is known to be nonoptimal. Here, we call an uncertainty relation optimal, if the lower bound can be attained for any value of either of the corresponding uncertainties. In this work, we establish optimal uncertainty relations by characterizing the optimal lower bound in scenarios similar to the Maassen–Uffink type. We disprove a conjecture by Englert et al. and generalize various previous results. However, we are still far from a complete understanding and, based on numerical investigation and analytical results in small dimension, we present a number of conjectures.

arXiv:1509.00398•International Journal of Quantum Information•Sep 1, 2015•22 citations

Asymptotic entropic uncertainty relations

Radosław Adamczak, Rafał Latała, Zbigniew Puchała +1 more

We analyze entropic uncertainty relations for two orthogonal measurements on a N-dimensional Hilbert space, performed in two generic bases. It is assumed that the unitary matrix U relating both bases is distributed according to the Haar measure on the unitary group. We provide lower bounds on the average Shannon entropy of probability distributions related to both measurements. The bounds are stronger than those obtained with use of the entropic uncertainty relation by Maassen and Uffink, and they are optimal up to additive constants. We also analyze the case of a large number of measurements and obtain strong entropic uncertainty relations, which hold with high probability with respect to the random choice of bases. The lower bounds we obtain are optimal up to additive constants and allow us to prove a conjecture by Wehner and Winter on the asymptotic behavior of constants in entropic uncertainty relations as the dimension tends to infinity. As a tool we develop estimates on the maximum operator norm of a submatrix of a fixed size of a random unitary matrix distributed according to the Haar measure, which are of independent interest.

arXiv:1412.7065•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Mar 1, 2016•21 citations

Improved lower bound on the entropic uncertainty relation

Mojtaba Jafarpour, Abbass Sabour

We present a lower bound on the entropic uncertainty relation for the distinguished measurements of two observables in a d-dimensional Hilbert space for d up to 5. This bound provides an improvement over the best one yet available. The feasibility of the obtained bound presenting an improvement for higher dimensions is also discussed.

Physical Review A•Sep 8, 2011•5 citations

Generalized entropic uncertainty relations

Hans Maassen, Jos Uffink

A new class of uncertainty relations is derived for pairs of observables in a finite-dimensional Hilbert space which do not have any common eigenvector. This class contains an ``entropic'' uncertainty relation which improves a previous result of Deutsch and confirms a recent conjecture by Kraus. Some comments are made on the extension of these relations to the case where the Hilbert space is infinite dimensional.

Physical Review Letters•Mar 21, 1988•1,232 citations
The entropic uncertainty relation for sets of N+1 complementary observables (A r ) existing in N-dimensional Hilbert space, Sigma r H(A r )>or=(N+1)ln((N+1)/2), is shown to be optimal in the case N=3 by explicit construction of the states for which equality holds. We prove that the lower bound cannot be attained when N is even, and, on the basis of numerical calculations, this is conjectured to also be the case for odd N>3.
Two observables A and B of an n-level system (i.e., a quantum system with n-dimensional state space) are called complementary, if knowledge of the measured value of A implies maximal uncertainty of the measured value of B, and vice versa. Such observables exist for all n, but no classification (up to equivalence) of all possible pairs of complementary observables is known except for n\ensuremath{\le}4. Complementary observables are conjectured to satisfy an ``entropic'' uncertainty relation of the strongest possible form. This relation has been verified for n\ensuremath{\le}4 by explicit calculations. A recent attempt of substantiating the widespread interpretation of uncertainty relations in terms of mutual disturbances between measurements is criticized.
The entropic uncertainty relation proven by Maassen and Uffink for arbitrary pairs of two observables is known to be nonoptimal. Here, we call an uncertainty relation optimal, if the lower bound can be attained for any value of either of the corresponding uncertainties. In this work, we establish optimal uncertainty relations by characterizing the optimal lower bound in scenarios similar to the Maassen–Uffink type. We disprove a conjecture by Englert et al. and generalize various previous results. However, we are still far from a complete understanding and, based on numerical investigation and analytical results in small dimension, we present a number of conjectures.
We analyze entropic uncertainty relations for two orthogonal measurements on a N-dimensional Hilbert space, performed in two generic bases. It is assumed that the unitary matrix U relating both bases is distributed according to the Haar measure on the unitary group. We provide lower bounds on the average Shannon entropy of probability distributions related to both measurements. The bounds are stronger than those obtained with use of the entropic uncertainty relation by Maassen and Uffink, and they are optimal up to additive constants. We also analyze the case of a large number of measurements and obtain strong entropic uncertainty relations, which hold with high probability with respect to the random choice of bases. The lower bounds we obtain are optimal up to additive constants and allow us to prove a conjecture by Wehner and Winter on the asymptotic behavior of constants in entropic uncertainty relations as the dimension tends to infinity. As a tool we develop estimates on the maximum operator norm of a submatrix of a fixed size of a random unitary matrix distributed according to the Haar measure, which are of independent interest.