Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Physics B Atomic and Molecular Physics

Some asymptotic (n → ∞) properties of hydrogen-like states | n l m > and on the use of the correspondence principle

E. de Prunelé

Published Oct 28, 1980• 10 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Some results obtained with the quantal wavefunctions are compared, as n to infinity , with those obtained from the Bohr-Sommerfeld picture. In particular, it is shown that the probability to find the electron in the classically forbidden domain may not be negligible even when all the quantum numbers go to infinity, a fact which leads one to analyse the conditions for using the correspondence principle.

DOI
10.1088/0022-3700/13/20/006

Related papers

Quantum-Classical Connection for Hydrogen atom-like systems

Debapriyo Syam, Arup Roy

The Bohr-Sommerfeld quantum theory specifies the rules of quantization for circular and elliptical orbits for a one-electron hydrogen atom-like system. This article illustrates how a formula connecting the principal quantum number 'n' and the length of the major axis of an elliptical orbit may be arrived at starting from the quantum mechanical description and how, in the limit when 'n' is large, one gets the expected classical result.

European Journal Of Physics Education•Jan 1, 2011•0 citations

Synthesis of the Planck and Bohr formulations of the correspondence principle

Ghazi Q. Hassoun, Donald H. Kobe

Planck formulated the correspondence principle between quantum and classical mechanics as the limit in which the Planck constant h goes to zero. Bohr formulated the correspondence principle to be the limit of large quantum numbers. For three common quantum mechanical systems it is shown that in order for eigenvalues of quantum mechanical observables to have meaningful classical limits, it is necessary to take the double limit as both the Planck constant goes to zero and the quantum number goes to infinity, subject to the constraint that their product is equal to an appropriate classical action. This synthesis of the Bohr and Planck formulations of the correspondence principle is also used to show that the quantum mechanical transition frequency between adjacent levels approaches the corresponding classical frequency. The features these systems have in common in their classical limit are explained by general considerations of the classical limit of the Schrödinger equation.

American Journal of Physics•Jul 1, 1989•25 citations

Deduceing of the quantization energy and the quantization electron orbits of hydrogen atom and Bohr's quantization condition of the steady orbits with the correspondence principle

Wang Wen-ze

The quantization energy and the quantization electron orbits of hydrogen atom and Bohr's quantization condition of the steady orbits (or the quantization condition of angular momentum) are educed with the correspondence principle.

Chinese journal of atomic and molecular physics•Jan 1, 2002•0 citations

Low energy levels and matrix elements in the large-N (small-h(cross)) asymptotic region

S. Giler

The asymptotic form of the Froman and Froman solutions (1977) to the Schrodinger equation has been used to calculate the low energy spectra and corresponding matrix elements for many-well potentials. It has been proved that the Bohr-Sommerfeld quantisation condition is also valid in the low energy region, independently for each well. It has also been shown that the corresponding matrix elements are dominated by the energy levels belonging to the same well. The general results have then been used to show that, in N dimensions, with spherically symmetric Hamiltonians, quantum systems approach their classical configurations with constraints when N to infinity .

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Aug 7, 1989•7 citations

Breakdown of Bohr's Correspondence Principle

Bo Gao

Bohr's correspondence principle, i.e., the expectation that the semiclassical approximation works better for states with greater quantum numbers, is shown to break down in all quantum systems in which the asymptotic interaction between the fragments behaves as ${\ensuremath{-}C}_{n}/{r}^{n}$ with $n>2$.

Physical Review Letters•Nov 22, 1999•51 citations

What happened to the Bohr-Sommerfeld elliptic orbits in Schrodinger's wave mechanics?

Michael Nauenberg

According to Heisenberg and Pauli, two of the great pioneers of quantum mechanics, in the domain of atoms and molecules the Bohr-Sommerfeld elliptic orbits disappear. But Bohr's correspondence principle requires that for large quantum numbers, quantum mechanics corresponds to classical mechanics. It is shown here how this correspondence, generally ignored in physics textbooks, takes place.

•Jan 1, 2015•0 citations
Some results obtained with the quantal wavefunctions are compared, as n to infinity , with those obtained from the Bohr-Sommerfeld picture. In particular, it is shown that the probability to find the electron in the classically forbidden domain may not be negligible even when all the quantum numbers go to infinity, a fact which leads one to analyse the conditions for using the correspondence principle.
Planck formulated the correspondence principle between quantum and classical mechanics as the limit in which the Planck constant h goes to zero. Bohr formulated the correspondence principle to be the limit of large quantum numbers. For three common quantum mechanical systems it is shown that in order for eigenvalues of quantum mechanical observables to have meaningful classical limits, it is necessary to take the double limit as both the Planck constant goes to zero and the quantum number goes to infinity, subject to the constraint that their product is equal to an appropriate classical action. This synthesis of the Bohr and Planck formulations of the correspondence principle is also used to show that the quantum mechanical transition frequency between adjacent levels approaches the corresponding classical frequency. The features these systems have in common in their classical limit are explained by general considerations of the classical limit of the Schrödinger equation.
The asymptotic form of the Froman and Froman solutions (1977) to the Schrodinger equation has been used to calculate the low energy spectra and corresponding matrix elements for many-well potentials. It has been proved that the Bohr-Sommerfeld quantisation condition is also valid in the low energy region, independently for each well. It has also been shown that the corresponding matrix elements are dominated by the energy levels belonging to the same well. The general results have then been used to show that, in N dimensions, with spherically symmetric Hamiltonians, quantum systems approach their classical configurations with constraints when N to infinity .
Bohr's correspondence principle, i.e., the expectation that the semiclassical approximation works better for states with greater quantum numbers, is shown to break down in all quantum systems in which the asymptotic interaction between the fragments behaves as ${\ensuremath{-}C}_{n}/{r}^{n}$ with n>2n>2n>2.